causal

Radical order produced rebellion and poor learning

The 'no excuses' radical-order approach backfired over time: students who seemed positively affected and happy with structure in 5th grade were, by 8th grade, rebelling, resentful, dropping out, and had learned little, acting out as soon as they left the structured environment—suggesting heavily structured students never learned to be independent decision-makers and couldn't cope with unstructured reality.

causalpending

Speaker

Elizabeth Green

Evidence Quote

“Were they learning to be independent decision makers about their own behavior... or were they so heavily structured that when they faced unstructured reality of the real world and college and work, they didn't know what to do.”

Source

Elizabeth Green on Education and Building a Better Teacher— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:07:38 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...