What this covers

Elizabeth Green, author of Building a Better Teacher, discusses with economist Russ Roberts how teaching can be understood and improved as a learnable craft rather than an innate gift. The conversation moves through the history of American teacher training, the structural barriers that prevent improvement, and the rare examples where systematic practice has produced measurable results. Green argues that universities inherited teacher training without developing it as a genuine science, that schools lack the vocabulary and mechanisms for teachers to diagnose and refine their work, and that a handful of charter networks have succeeded by providing the conditions—shared curriculum, collaboration time, subject-specific mentorship—that traditional public schools structurally deny. Roberts pushes back with economic critiques of system design and the perverse incentives baked into education's institutional arrangements.

The exchange covers several interconnected failures. The Expert Blind Spot—the phenomenon that mastery renders skills invisible and automatic—means expert teachers cannot easily teach others what they do without first unpacking it into visible steps through Decomposition of Skills. Education schools, historically staffed by scholars indifferent to Teaching as a Craft, left trainers with weak science to work from and gave teachers no Professional Language of Practice to describe what they observe in effective classrooms. Research on teacher quality reveals no personality traits predict effectiveness; what matters is what teachers know and do—learnable knowledge. Doug Lemov discovered he could not recruit his way to excellence and instead pioneered methods using Approximations of Practice to train teachers systematically. Uncommon Schools demonstrate that structural changes—organized planning time, common curriculum, expert mentorship aligned to subject matter—enable ordinary teachers to improve. The discussion also surfaces tensions: the no excuses movement's early success gave way to student resentment and rebellion by middle school, and Pam Grossman's proven training program cannot scale because expert mentors are scarce and no method yet exists to replicate their knowledge at mass. Roberts and Green disagree on whether the core problem is a lack of knowledge about how to teach or the economic incentives that prevent schools from caring whether teachers improve at all.

Sharpest takeaway

Green argues that great teaching is not an innate trait but a learnable craft, and that American education fails because its training institutions, professional language, and school structures are designed in ways that prevent teachers from systematically practicing and improving that craft.

  • Research finds no personality or character traits predict teacher effectiveness; what teachers do and know matters instead
  • Universities took over teacher training but staffed education schools with scholars uninterested in teaching as a craft, leaving an impoverished science
  • Charter networks like Uncommon Schools succeed by providing common curriculum, organized work time, and subject-specific mentorship that traditional public schools lack

The argument · threads4 threads · 26 claims
0.71

Effective teaching and learning depend on granular, decomposed skill instruction and peer observation, which isolated classrooms and generic advice cannot provide.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Generic coaching advice like 'try harder' or 'keep your eye on the ball' is useless because it doesn't decompose the skill into steps; in hitting, the head must turn one direction while the hips pivot the other, but most kids' heads follow their hips and spin out of the strike zone, so a coach who only says 'keep your eye on the ball' without teaching how to do it cannot help—the same granularity problem applies to teaching.

    “we don't teach, most coaches don't teach their kids how to keep their eye on the ball.”

  • Education is about feedback—helping students understand what they know and don't know—but the same principle applies to teachers, who mostly work in the isolated island of their own classroom and get feedback only from students, lacking the richer feedback they would gain from sharing ideas with and being observed by mentors and peers.

    “Arnold Kling, on EconTalk has said that education is about feedback. It's about helping your students understand what they know and don't know. But that works for teachers, too.”

0.70

Education systems lack feedback mechanisms that push excellence, because money and decisions flow through disconnected intermediaries rather than direct consumers.

1 pointcentrality 5/5
  • The largest underlying problem in education is that the system isn't designed to let better-informed people make decisions: people spend other people's money, students are not the consumer and parents are not really the consumer, so the whole system has a terrible design flaw that fails to incentivize excellence—and reforms like Common Core and No Child Left Behind are desperate end-around attempts to deal with that flaw.

    “students are not really the consumer; the parents aren't the consumers. And the whole system has got this terrible design flaw that fails to incentivize excellence.”

0.56

Market pressure and customer focus drive schools toward practical, realistic training, as business schools proved when ranked on student satisfaction.

1 pointcentrality 4/5
  • Business and law schools historically pushed away from being seen as trade schools to appear scholarly, teaching theories rather than practice, but business schools changed when they began getting ranked partly on student satisfaction, forcing them to treat MBA students as customers who wanted realistic, practical skills—a customer-focus pressure that education schools are largely immune to.

    “what has changed is that business schools started getting ranked. And some of the rankings had to do with how happy their students were. So it actually forced business schools to see their MBA (Master of Business Administration) students as customers.”

0.43

Decentralized, diverse education emerging through trial and error like the broader economy would succeed because central design is unnecessary.

1 pointcentrality 3/5
  • Roberts advocates a non-public education system that would emerge through diversity, flavor, and trial and error like the rest of the economy, likely nonprofit and charitable as private schools already are, and argues that not having to specify the design centrally is the strength of the approach—because nothing needs to be decided centrally if it's not centrally designed.

    “I want an un public system to emerge, with all of its diversity and flavor and trial and error and everything else in our economy does so much better.”