loyal opposition
The modern concept that political opponents of government policy are legitimate participants in government, not enemies of the state; requires secularization of politics and social contract theory to develop
As defined in Burke and the Birth of Enlightened Conservatism
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “loyal opposition” →
- The idea of legitimate political parties, of a loyal opposition, of legitimate dissent, is a peculiarly modern idea, and Burke helps to legitimize this idea by recognizing that in representative legislatures it is necessary to organize both those who support government policy and those opposed to it so that we can effectively legislate or obstruct legislation within the legislature itself.Burke and the Birth of Enlightened Conservatism
- The rise of representative legislatures and human-centered political theory necessitates both the rise of legitimate dissent and loyal opposition, and also the rise of legitimate political parties, which are not seen as threats to the state but as the natural condition of human beings who intrinsically have different perspectives on the world.Burke and the Birth of Enlightened Conservatism
- When we move into the modern world and adopt social contractarianism—the idea that government legitimacy derives from the consent of the people who form the social contract—it becomes necessary to make possible the idea of legitimate dissent and loyal opposition because people with differing opinions about governmental policy are not children of the devil but simply have different opinions.Burke and the Birth of Enlightened Conservatism
- Legitimate dissent and loyal opposition cannot happen until the secularization of politics, which cannot happen until the Enlightenment, meaning the idea of loyal opposition is an immensely sophisticated and peculiarly modern thought requiring certain adjustments in political theory.Burke and the Birth of Enlightened Conservatism
- In the ancient political tradition and medieval age, the idea of legitimate dissent never comes up because the government is backed by God; dissent is by definition evil, so the idea of loyal opposition cannot exist.Burke and the Birth of Enlightened Conservatism