
1. Introduction, Financial Terms and Concepts
What this covers
This opening lecture of MIT's 18.S096 finance course is a survey of terms and ideas rather than a single argument. It is led mainly by Jake Shaw, a former trader, with Vasily Estrella taking over for the technical applications. It begins with the economic role of financial markets, which bridge investors seeking returns and borrowers (companies, governments, individuals) who need capital. From there it moves to the people who work in them: market makers and dealers who earn the bid-offer spread rather than predicting direction, and traders who rely on discipline and loss rules more than on sophisticated models.
The range is wide. On the product side, the lecture covers derivatives pricing through differential equations, the risk sensitivities known as the Greeks, and dynamic hedge management. A running anecdote about how Salomon traders misnamed vega while Morgan Stanley called it "kappa" shows how recently the terminology settled. Strategy examples include the carry trade and its currency risk, arbitrage when relationships like spot-forward parity break down, and why trend-following loses its edge once many traders adopt it. Estrella's technical examples are a Kalman filter applied to noisy broker exchange-rate data and the tradeoff between precision and computational cost when Monte Carlo simulation is used to estimate derivatives.
The lecture is most contentious when it turns to judgment and history. Shaw argues that whether to hold or cut a losing position depends on whether the original thesis still holds, not on expected value alone, and he links this to the human tendency to take profits early and hold losses. He questions how far the efficient market hypothesis applies, and he separates deterministic relationships from statistical ones. He also covers the 1933 Glass-Steagall separation of commercial and investment banking, its 1999 repeal, and the roughly 40-times leverage at banks before 2008. He notes that analysts disagree about how much the repeal contributed to the crisis.
Mathematical finance emerged as a distinct field only in the last 30 years, transforming finance from an art practiced by undereducated traders into a quantitative discipline requiring advanced mathematics, and understanding this recent evolution is essential to critically evaluating both the power and limitations of mathematical models in modern finance.
- The Black-Scholes option pricing model (1970s) and subsequent mathematical frameworks are recent innovations that fundamentally changed how traders operate and communicate
- Finance requires both rigorous mathematics AND human judgment; it is more art than science, so models must be questioned, not blindly applied
- Mathematics enables three key financial activities: pricing complex instruments, quantifying and managing risk, and developing systematic trading strategies, but none eliminates the need for critical thinking about market structure and human behavior
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Mathematical and quantitative finance is a relatively new field that emerged primarily in the last 30 years, following the introduction of the Black-Scholes option pricing model in the 1970s, transforming finance from a profession dominated by undereducated traders to one requiring advanced mathematical and computer science training.
“mathematical or quantitative finance is that rather new field a lot of these terms were newly introduced and the pricing model of options as you know right was introduced in at the black shows in the 70s”
The optimal response to a losing position depends on whether the fundamental thesis behind the position has changed, not on whether you've already locked in a loss: if fundamentals are intact, you should evaluate it as if you don't have a position; if fundamentals have changed, you should exit regardless of loss magnitude.
“if you can let's say you think the market i mean i'll give you the stock example again if you're not purely following the discipline of stop loss but you just think you know the fundamental picture has changed you really don't think the stock is should go up anymore obviously at whatever level you should get out right regardless how much loss you're locking and uh but if you if you think the fundamental story is still very sound you should think about as if you don't have a position what do you want to do next”
Risk aversion causes investors to take different actions when facing losses versus gains with the same mathematical expected value: when facing losses, people often hold positions hoping for recovery (avoiding locking in losses), while when facing gains, people tend to take profits early, contrary to what expected value maximization would suggest.
“when you go to the market you buy a stock when the stock goes up makes big money the natural tendency for especially someone is new to the market is to let's take take profit let's sell oh i made a thousand dollars i made five hundred dollars let's go you know have a nice meal or you know whatever i buy a ipad but when the stock loses money what's the natural tendency that's i think natural tendency a lot of people will keep it”
People often oversimplify complex phenomena by focusing on one important parameter while ignoring others, leading to models that miss critical dynamics.
“sometimes people tend to oversimplify right just say oh i can model this you know this is one important parameter i just take that”
If many market participants simultaneously execute the same profitable trade (such as the carry trade example), they collectively move the market and create adverse pricing impact, forcing each participant to decide whether to hedge their exposure to exit the crowded position.
“further if everybody plays the same game then and when you try to exit you you have the adverse impact of your trade so let's say you you think that's the right time to do it but then at one time you wake up you said huh i think too many people are doing this i want to hedge myself”
The primary economic function of financial markets is to bridge the gap between lenders and borrowers: investors with capital seek better yields and returns, while borrowers (companies, governments, individuals) need access to capital, and this fundamental relationship drives the essential purpose of financial markets.
“why do we need financial markets right i mean this this comes back to what i described before because something existed actually there's a need for it it's really the need to bridge between the lenders and the borrowers that's really coming down to the essential relationship so investors who have money need have better yield or better return better interest in the current environment when you have a savings account you know you don't really earn much at all and so you would have to take more risk to generate more return or you have a longer horizon cds or other type of products or trade stocks right”
Carry trade strategies (borrowing at low interest rates in one currency and investing at higher rates in another) are profitable due to interest rate differentials, but participants face currency risk if the currency in which they're investing appreciates relative to the borrowing currency, potentially wiping out gains.
“interest rate in australia is higher than in japan so typically people like to borrow money in japan because you pay smaller interest and you invest it in australia you earn higher interest rate so let me ask you a question who can tell me why don't people just do that all day long just borrow from japan and invest in australia then that interest rate i'm giving you an example of a difference is about three and a half percent for the ten year roughly you know ten years uh swap rates why don't yeah go ahead right because you invest in the australia aussie right australian dollar the australian dollar may become weaker to the yen you may lose all your profit or even more right”
Trend-following and momentum strategies were historically effective but become less effective as more traders adopt the same strategy, since when everyone follows the same trend signal, market impacts and crowding eliminate the edge.
“systematic trader builds computer models one example is train the following right so just follow the price trend i mean that used to be a effective uh strategy for some time but when a lot of people doing the same thing that becomes much less effective”
Kalman filters can be applied to noisy, irregularly-timed broker exchange rate data to improve price predictions for electronic trading systems, and using this approach can result in smoother, more reliable predictions than ad hoc methods.
“basically what we had we had the noisy observation of broker data uh and they it it was not it was coming on a different non uh on uniform times basically at random times so uh we decided to use kalman filter and um to uh and uh to study how it can predict and yeah that's one of uh of the nice graphs dusan produced which which again uh will be we will use this the strategy and this the column filters which he constructed in our in our e-trading platform in moscow”
Market makers and dealers profit primarily from the bid-offer spread (the difference between the price at which they buy and the price at which they sell) rather than from directional market predictions, and they manage residual principal risk by balancing portfolio exposures.
“market maker also takes principle risk but the main source of profit is really to earn the bid offer i gave you the example of 90 cents a bit 95 cents offer so that's what the market maker is trying to profit from but obviously they have residual risks sitting on the book not every trade is matched so how to optimize those group of trades that's what market maker is doing”
Pricing models for complex financial instruments (beyond simple stocks) require solving differential equations to derive model prices, which are then adjusted to match market observations and calibrated to the specific assumptions and risk parameters of the trading context.
“when you your bank your or your corporate you want to buy some financial instruments you have to know where is the price it's easy to observe a stock in the market but when it comes to more complex products they just take one step full or forward on the complexity which is option you have to know how to press an option so that's where the math comes in right you actually have to be able to solve differential equations to get a you know model price then you obviously adjust to the your assumptions to fit into the market”
Arbitrage opportunities exist because deterministic mathematical relationships (like spot-forward parity in foreign exchange) sometimes break down due to trading constraints, liquidity issues, or transaction costs, creating profitable misalignment opportunities for traders who understand the relationship.
“a spot price versus forward price that's a deterministic relationship it's a mathematical relationship if that relationship breaks down you can also profit so there are many examples of mathematical relationship which gives you the arbitrage opportunity”
Estimating derivatives using Monte Carlo simulation introduces numerical noise around the true derivative value, and there is a tradeoff between computational cost (number of simulation paths) and precision (confidence interval width) that can be optimized by choosing an appropriate perturbation size.
“so it is statistical methods so obviously there there is a noise to to your answer every time so if you want to to differentiate this function and get the derivative uh then this derivative will be quite noisy and so instead of getting the the true derivative you might obtain something quite different from two derivative just because there is a confidence interval around any any point and obviously there is a trade-off here as well because you can run more paths throw more computational power and which will reduce your confidence interval you you will know uh better where where you are more precise uh or the other uh solution could be if you know that your your function is not too concave and reasonably flat you might move uh the uh do the numerical differentiation on wider interval basically reducing the significance of the error right”
The efficient market hypothesis is not universally applicable; whether and what parts of markets are actually efficient is an important empirical question that affects how traders should build models and manage risk.
“is the market really efficient right i mean what is really what part is efficient you know how do you really apply those theories in your day-to-day uh risk management or training activities”
Risk management in trading requires quantifying portfolio exposure across multiple dimensions (delta, gamma, theta, vega, value-at-risk), and these Greeks allow traders to understand how their positions respond to different market factors, enabling dynamic hedging and capital optimization.
“so if it's not transparent so what do you do so if i instead of asking you where apple is probably you're going to tell me 4.95 today okay yeah but if i ask you instead what is the call option on apple stock in the you know two months time i'll give you a strike let's say 500. right so you're probably less transparent so that market maker comes in to provide that liquidity and then takes the risk they manage the book by balancing those greeks which i mentioned earlier delta which describes the kind of the linear relationship of this whole book to the underlying stock”
Glass-Steagall legislation (1933) separated commercial banking (taking deposits and lending) from investment banking (capital markets and trading), but this separation was repealed in 1999, and some analysts blame this deregulation for amplifying the severity of the 2008 financial crisis.
“there are essentially after 1933 uh glass-steagall uh legislation there were two main types of banks one is called commercial bank the other is investment bank commercial bank is supposedly you're taking deposits and lend out the money and doing you know more commercial services investment bank supposed to focus on the capital markets raising capital trading and asset management but obviously after 1999 there's a you know the glass-steagall was repealed right there's no longer that some people blame that and probably for a very good reason for the cause of 2008 financial crisis”
Government policy decisions (interest rates, quantitative easing, regulatory changes) have enormous impact on financial markets because policy shapes economic outlook and profitability across all sectors, making policy analysis a critical component of fundamental trading analysis.
“governments obviously have a huge impact on the market so we know in the financial crisis government intervened and not only that at the normal market condition government always have a very large impact on the market because they are the policy makers they decide the interest rate and interest rate curve and the different policies they push out obviously will generate different outlook for the future markets therefore profitability then the corporate hedges and the liabilities”
Whether to accept a certain loss versus risking an uncertain larger loss or gain depends on individual context (bank account size, risk tolerance, and fundamental assessment of the underlying investment), not purely on expected value calculations, meaning mathematical analysis alone cannot determine the 'right' choice in financial decisions.
“i think we can talk a bit more along in the class i mean the last day of the class hopefully we have much deeper discussion on this it's not unique the answer okay i think it can go either way i mean as as you said if your bank account balance is let's say you're a freshman student your bank account is uh uh eight hundred dollars your choice will be very different from someone has a hundred thousand dollars in his bank account okay and uh also your risk tolerance right how much you can you can tolerate”
People tend to learn ineffectively from financial market experiences because market cycles are long, memories are short, and there is a natural tendency to extrapolate from very recent experience rather than integrating longer-term patterns or understanding underlying mechanisms.
“do people always learn from the experiences you think you know in science right we collect evidence we build models we first understand the physics we build mathematic models then we verify in physics doing experiments but is that the same investigation process process in finance i mean market cycles are typically very long but people tend to have show the memories is so how do people really learn from the experience it's a very interesting question and the very natural tendency is to extrapolate historical experience what happened in 2008 people still remember what happened in 1970s maybe some people still remember what happened 100 years ago right so people tend to extrapolate join conclusions from very recent experience”
Pre-2008 financial crisis, many banks leveraged 40 times (having only $1 in equity backing $40 in asset exposure), making them extremely fragile so that even small market moves could wipe them out, and this extreme leverage was a primary amplifier of the crisis.
“and i think peter will uh or tumor would probably peter will teach uh then capital right uh how much capital you're using it becomes a very important issue nowadays and balance sheet again you have asset your liability how how do you leverage how much leverage you have before the crisis for example a lot of the banks leverage up 40 times meaning when you have one dollar you have a 40 exposure so when the market moves a little you get wiped out that's that's really what amplified in the 2008 financial crisis”
Discipline, loss management, and following predetermined risk rules (like stop-loss orders) are more critical to trading success than mathematical models, because most losses come from failure to manage downside rather than from sophisticated pricing errors.
“that's really all about how where do you how do you risk manage you know have a discipline and how to manage your losses right the natural tendency a lot of people say well i think there's a chance 20 chance to come back i'm going to make 500 more right why do i want to lock in to stop myself out at 280 right”
In the context of quantitative finance, it is more important to ask how concepts are established, defined, and verified than whether they are mathematically 'right or wrong' in an absolute sense, because this is a young field where products, models, and methodology are changing very rapidly.
“before you dive into any details of mathematics or any concept in finance in this class just bear in mind this is a field developed in the last mostly 30 years or even shorter and what you really need to ask questions is it's not really is the right or wrong in mathematics is it right or wrong in physics so how the concepts are established or defined and verified because this is a field the transformation about the participants products models methodology everything are changing very rapidly even nowadays still changing”
Financial markets involve both deterministic mathematical relationships and statistical relationships, and conflating the two (oversimplifying models by ignoring statistical noise or misidentifying which relationships are deterministic) is a common error in model-building and risk management.
“deterministic relationship versus statistical relationship is very interesting as well when you try to trade on those how do you really build models i mean is the market really efficient right i mean what is really what part is efficient you know how do you really apply those theories in your day-to-day uh risk management or training activities”
In the vega/kappa terminology incident, traders from Solomon Brothers (including Jake Shaw) used 'vega' incorrectly as the name for volatility sensitivity, mistakenly treating it as a Greek letter after 'gambling at Vegas', while Morgan Stanley correctly called it 'kappa', illustrating how recently standardized the terminology in derivatives pricing is.
“so the footnote about why it's called kappa at the at morgan stanley kappa is also called vega by some uneducated traders at the solomon brothers that's where i came from i just joined they have mistaken vega as a greek letter after gambling at vegas”
The optimal numerical differentiation method discovered by the student was implemented in Morgan Stanley's actual trading systems and is planned for use in practice.
“we actually are implementing it in our systems and plan uh plan to use it in in practice”
Building a perpetual 'robo trader' that generates consistent profits indefinitely without adjustment is not feasible because markets evolve rapidly and strategic edges degrade as conditions change, requiring constant research and strategy updates.
“i mean a lot of people with mass background or in general people are looking for the so-called holy grail trading strategies just almost like perpetual motion machines right people looking for 100 years ago you just turn it on it makes money by itself you go to sleep you go on vacation you come back you have more in your bank account obviously that's not going to happen the robe the robo trader a robotic trader is the dream it has its place or its use but it's a fast evolving market you have to constantly you know upgrade your research and uh adjust your strategies there's no such thing you can build and leave it alone it runs for itself forever”
Stock indices aggregate multiple stocks (often with market-capitalization weighting) to provide a benchmark of broad market performance, and traders can invest in index funds as a low-cost way to gain diversified exposure instead of picking individual stocks.
“when you think about i mean there are many other ways of trading aside from exchanges one of them which is called otc is over the counter meaning two counterparties agree to do a trade without really subject to the exchange rules or the underlying trading agreement does not have to be a securitize the product or standardized or you know whatever ways you defined it and the different regions have different exchanges and markets as well and they typically specialize in local products local company stocks local bonds and local currencies so there are many different forms so again what's in common that's the question you need to ask also you don't know the specifics and the currencies money itself also traded right so and that's where different the uh currencies issued by different countries so when we talk about trading stocks also people trade baskets of stocks trade groups of stocks together and that's stock index or indices”
Hedging is a risk management practice where parties with existing exposures (such as currency risk, interest rate risk, or commodity price risk) take offsetting positions in derivative instruments to lock in or reduce their downside exposure without directly eliminating the underlying business.
“the types of trading the first type is really just hedging that means you're not proactively adding risk to what you have you already have some exposure let's say just give you an example let's say you borrow money you bought a house you have mortgage and uh so let's say it's a you know uh floating rate mortgage payments and you're worried about the interest rate going higher right so you can lock that rate in into the fixed rate format or you can find ways to to hedge your exposure”
Primary market is when a company issues equity through IPO (initial public offering) for the first time, transitioning from private to public ownership, while secondary market is trading of already-issued securities between investors on exchanges.
“so when a company changes from private to public it goes through this ipo process it's called primary market primary listing and once the stock is listed on exchange and it becomes traded in the market we call it secondary trading”
OTC (over-the-counter) markets allow two counterparties to trade without exchange rules or standardization requirements, giving them flexibility in customizing products but at the cost of counterparty risk and reduced transparency compared to exchange-traded products.
“one of them which is called otc is over the counter meaning two counterparties agree to do a trade without really subject to the exchange rules or the underlying trading agreement does not have to be a securitize the product or standardized or you know whatever ways you defined it”
Beta measures how much a portfolio's returns move in correlation with a benchmark index (like S&P 500), while alpha measures the excess return above what beta would predict, and portfolio managers try to outperform the index by generating positive alpha while managing beta exposure.
“so you can say this actually somehow it came out it's supposed to be alpha and a beta but it turned out to be uh you know the the letters but so in the short description beta is really kind of you know just think as uh the correlated move with the the other asset alpha is really the the you know the difference in return uh it's a format you want to beat smp 500 so you want basically have certain tracking of this index but you want to return more on top of that”
Asset-backed securities securitize loan cash flows by issuing debt instruments backed by pools of assets (mortgages, car loans, credit card receivables), allowing banks to transfer credit risk and free up capital for new lending, though the quality and transparency of these products was severely compromised pre-2008.
“asset-backed securities is when you have an asset you basically issue a debt with the asset backing it and how how do you rate the assets risk level and what's the income stream cash flow and during before 2008 financial crisis as you heard large amount of cmbs commercial basically is a commercial real estate backed uh you know securities mortgage securities and the residential as well”
Trading strategies fall into several categories: directional (betting on price direction), arbitrage (exploiting deterministic mathematical mispricing), value/relative value (identifying long-term underpriced assets), systematic (using computer models to follow trends or statistical patterns), and fundamental (based on analysis of economic conditions, earnings, policy).
“that you can just simply doing directional trading strategies just go long or sure the stock right that's very simple you know they are the so-called gut traders gut feeling go with your gut you don't even think he said i'm eating i'm eating um you know uh curry today so i i go long i'm eating rice tomorrow so i go short so this arbitrage arbitrage is really to find the relationships between prices and try to profit from uh those relationship uh missed pricing”
Private equity firms invest in and take control of private companies, aiming to improve their profitability and then exit at a profit through IPO or secondary sale.
“private equity i mean different type of funds they basically look to take a pr invest in companies and uh you know either take them private or invest in the private uh equity forum to hopefully improve the company's profitability and then catch up”
Theta measures the time decay of a portfolio's value when nothing else in the market changes, representing the profit or loss a position experiences simply due to the passage of time.
“theta is really you know on nothing changes in the market nothing changes in your position how your trading book is carrying or bleeding away money”
Directional trading strategies involve simply taking long or short positions in assets based on the trader's view of price direction, representing the most basic form of proprietary trading without sophisticated analysis.
“you can just simply doing directional trading strategies just go long or sure the stock right that's very simple you know they are the so-called gut traders gut feeling go with your gut”
Commodities (metals, energy, agriculture) trade in both physical and futures format, with physical delivery requiring warehouses, ships, and storage infrastructure, while futures allow speculators to express price views without managing physical inventory.
“commodities actually you know metal energy agriculture uh products or traded right mostly in the futures format and some in physical format meaning you take deliveries when you actually buy and sell you build a warehouse to take them your you know ship tanks right to store above the ocean”
Bonds are securitized loans created when private loan agreements are formalized into tradeable debt instruments, and governments (U.S. Treasury), corporations, and local governments all issue bonds as a primary mechanism for raising capital.
“loans actually that products are more generic than equity products when you started thinking about what is really the what is really finance is about it's really about someone has money someone doesn't someone has money to land out someone needs to borrow money so that's loan loan is really a private agreement between two counterparties or multiple counterparties when you securitize them it becomes bonds and uh when you look at bonds every government right issue large sovereign debt the u.s government has large outstanding u.s treasury debt bonds notes bills and corporates have issued a lot of that product as well”
Value at Risk (VaR) is a risk measure that quantifies the potential tail risk and large losses that could occur in extreme market events beyond the Greeks' linear and quadratic approximations.
“on top of that what are the tail risks you know how do what other events can actually get you into big trouble right so people use value at risk so you will hear this var concept in some of the lectures”
Special situations or special opportunities strategies involve identifying companies facing particular difficulties or distress where assets are priced very cheaply, and firms like Bain Capital focus on private equity and special situation opportunities to profit from turnarounds or restructurings.
“special situations some companies are going through uh particular uh difficulties assets are priced very cheaply so there are firms out there i mean you probably heard you know bain capital and many others right they focus on these private equity and special situation opportunities”
Banks after Glass-Steagall repeal are typically organized internally by product line (fixed income, equity, investment banking division) and by client type (institutional clients vs asset management), and within each product area they trade, manage derivatives, and generate revenue from multiple sources (bid-offer spread, proprietary trading, advisory fees).
“so i mean vasily just mentioned he works in a fixed income right and so banks typically organized by you know institutional business and asset management so within the institutional client business it has typically three main parts fixed income which trade the debt and the derivative products equity trade stocks and the derivative products and ibd stands for investment banking division which really covers corporate finance raising capital listing a stock ipo and merger and acquisition and advisory”
Risk management has become a widespread responsibility across corporate functions (not just treasury departments), requiring even non-finance professionals working in corporate operations, importing/exporting, factory building, and M&A to understand and monitor their exposures to exchange rate and interest rate fluctuations.
“even you are not a finance guy you know you work in a corporate you just do input export or building a factory or you know you have to know actually what the exposure is so risk management nowadays becomes pretty widespread responsibility it's not just of you know the corporate treasury's responsibility”
The course has expanded from 6 units of credit meeting once weekly with primarily industry practitioners to 12 units of credit meeting twice weekly, with four main instructors and new mathematical foundations content added.
“this is the second time we are having this class we had it last year in a smaller version that was for six units of credit and we had it once a week and mostly practitioners from the industry from morgan stanley talking about examples how math is applied in modern finance okay is it okay yeah and uh so we got some good response last year so with the support of the math department we decided to expand this class to be 12 units of credit and have twice a week so we have every tuesday and thursday afternoon from 2 30 to 4 as you know in this classroom and so last year dr vasily estrella and i i'm by the way i'm jake shaw”
A large portion of the classroom consists of math majors, with most non-finance-major students, reflecting the course's intent to teach mathematically-trained students how to apply their skills to finance.
“how many of you are in math major most of you okay how many of you are engineering major okay”