Silver Rule
The negative formulation of reciprocity—do not do to others what you would not want done to you—associated in the discussion with Hillel's Jewish version.
As defined in The Underrated Bruno Leoni (with Michael Munger)
Other definitions
An ethical principle stating 'don't do to others what you don't want done to you'—a more robust alternative to the Golden Rule that requires restraint rather than active imposition of values.
Nassim Taleb - 11 Rules For Life (How To Live a Resilient Life)
Where it comes up · 3
- Skin in the Game | Nassim Nicholas Taleb | Talks at Google3 claims
- Nassim Taleb - 11 Rules For Life (How To Live a Resilient Life)2 claims
- The Underrated Bruno Leoni (with Michael Munger)2 claims
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “Silver Rule” →
- The Leviticus injunction to love your neighbor as yourself, as interpreted by Rashi's borrowed-axe example, rules out tit-for-tat: one must lend one's axe even to a neighbor who refused you, because the rule is to treat others as you want to be treated, not empirically as they have treated you, and that equilibrium yields a far better world.The Underrated Bruno Leoni (with Michael Munger)
- Leoni's universality principle has two parts: law must apply to everyone equally, and—drawing on the Golden/Silver Rule traditions—one's rules for one's own behavior must be those one would want applied to oneself; Hayek and later Buchanan and Congleton narrowed this to mere equal application (ruling out taxing some to subsidize others), whereas Leoni's fuller version also forbids subjecting others to coercion you would not want for yourself.The Underrated Bruno Leoni (with Michael Munger)
- The Golden Rule ('do unto others as you would have done to you') is intrusive and problematic because it imposes your preferences on others; the Silver Rule ('do not do to others what you would not want done to you') is more robust because it is negative and respects diversity of preferences.Skin in the Game | Nassim Nicholas Taleb | Talks at Google
- Universalism is impractical because universalism kills the particular and is not fractal; effective ethical systems must be layered, respecting that rules differ appropriately at different scales and contexts.Skin in the Game | Nassim Nicholas Taleb | Talks at Google
- The Silver Rule extends to international relations: treat other countries the way you would like to be treated if you were weaker; it has a fractal property where the same principle applies at multiple scales (individual, family, tribe, community, nation).Skin in the Game | Nassim Nicholas Taleb | Talks at Google
- The Golden Rule ('do unto others as you'd have them do unto you') is intrusive because it imposes your preferences on others; the Silver Rule ('don't do to others what you don't want done to you') is more robust and is necessary for civilization.Nassim Taleb - 11 Rules For Life (How To Live a Resilient Life)
- The complete list of failures to avoid includes: muscles without strength, friendship without trust, opinion without risk, change without aesthetics, age without values, food without nourishment, power without fairness, facts without rigor, degrees without erudition, militarism without fortitude, progress without civilization, complication without depth, fluency without content, and religion without tolerance.Nassim Taleb - 11 Rules For Life (How To Live a Resilient Life)