Sheela
Sheela
Home
Add
Questions
Thinkers
Claims
People
Concepts
Jargon
Sources
Health
Predictions
Collections
Domain Landscape
Contribute
Review
Dedup
Topic requests
Settings
Help

← Jargon

Jargonphilosophy· 2 claims· 1 episode

dialogical

Charles Taylor's term meaning that identities are formed and changed through dialogue with others, not unilaterally; their meaning is a shared social possession requiring negotiation.

As defined in 83 | Kwame Anthony Appiah on Identity, Stories, and Cosmopolitanism


Where it comes up · 1
  • 83 | Kwame Anthony Appiah on Identity, Stories, and Cosmopolitanism2 claims

Most important claims · 2 of 2Search all claims for “dialogical” →
  • Identities are dialogical: their meaning is a common possession like the meaning of words, so you cannot unilaterally redefine an identity any more than Humpty Dumpty can make a word mean whatever he wants; changing one identity affects others in the system, so everyone has a stake and change requires negotiation and consent.83 | Kwame Anthony Appiah on Identity, Stories, and Cosmopolitanism
  • Because the cis-trans system is shared, changing it to allow trans people better lives requires bringing cis people along through argument and explanation rather than mere declaration; cis people have a genuine stake and right to participate in understanding the change, even when resistance is unreasonable.83 | Kwame Anthony Appiah on Identity, Stories, and Cosmopolitanism