What this covers
Indre Viskontas, a neuroscientist and opera singer, speaks with Sean Carroll about how music reshapes the brain rather than merely playing through it. The conversation moves from the neurobiology of musical perception to music's role in human society, anchored in the idea that sound becomes music only through higher brain processing. Viskontas traces how the brain's architecture—particularly its drive to predict what comes next—generates the emotional force of music: tension builds in the caudate nucleus as the brain anticipates release, which arrives as a dopamine surge in the nucleus accumbens. This same predictive machinery explains why great musicians extend the wait for resolution as long as listeners can bear, maximizing the pleasure when it finally comes.
The discussion ranges across critical periods in development, where early musical training leaves a lasting signature on the auditory cortex even decades after someone stops playing. Viskontas dismantles the "Mozart effect" myth—tracing it to a single 1993 study of 30 undergraduates whose gains came from arousal, not genius—while defending music's genuine value in at-risk youth, brain plasticity, and language development. She addresses music's darker aspects: neuroplasticity gone wrong in focal dystonia, or how cochlear implants, despite restoring speech, often fail to restore musical enjoyment. The core argument pivots toward the social: oxytocin released during synchronized movement builds in-group bonds, and music functions as a window into human meaning-making that language alone cannot reach. Viskontas argues that science should follow artists' centuries of intuition rather than reduce music to measurable cognitive gains.
Viskontas argues that music is not merely processed by the brain but actively reshapes it, harnessing the brain's predictive machinery and reward circuitry, and that its deepest value is as a social glue and a window into what it means to be human rather than as a tool to make us 'smarter.'
- How sound becomes music depends on higher brain processing, not just the ear, so musical taste reflects how the brain extracts meaning and predicts patterns
- Music exploits the brain's drive to predict the future through tension and release, engaging the caudate (wanting) and nucleus accumbens (liking)
- Music functions as social glue via oxytocin-mediated synchronization, bonding in-groups and antagonizing out-groups
Music engages visceral brain systems beyond language by provoking extreme emotional and behavioral responses despite being physically just air vibrations.
- Music is a powerful way of looking at what it means to be human because it provokes extreme behaviors—people can fall in love over it or incite hatred and violence—even though physically it is just rarefactions and compressions of air, suggesting it engages something visceral that language does not.
“music to me is a really powerful way of looking at what it means to be human, because it's so bizarre, like why is it that we... We can fall in love over music, we can incite hate over music.”
- Film and TV soundtracks are powerfully manipulative because the brain wants to predict things, so music's pacing and instrumentation dictate what expectations viewers form—an ominous theme over a foggy lake makes you anticipate danger while calming music makes the same image feel safe—and physiological studies (galvanic skin response, heart rate, respiration) now let researchers track this emotional manipulation in real time.
“you can look at different aspects of music pacing, the types of instrumentation used, etcetera, that can dictate what kinds of expectations people will start to have... you have an ominous theme and what you see is a rowboat on a lake and it's foggy”
- The caudate nucleus is the brain's 'wanting' system, showing dopamine activity in anticipation of pleasure (or aversive events) and tracking what matters emotionally, while the nucleus accumbens is the 'liking' system that delivers the actual sense of pleasure—so in music the caudate is active during the build-up of tension and a dopamine spike in the nucleus accumbens accompanies the release, such as the chills.
“the caudate is the wanting part of the brain... we see it active during the building up of tension part of a musical phrase. And then once you get the release of tension, if you get the chills... we see a big spike in dopamine in the nucleus accumbens, which is the liking part of the brain.”
- Great musicians intuitively delay the release of tension as long as possible because the longer the desire for pleasure is extended the greater the pleasure when it finally comes—since pleasure is the death of desire—though it cannot be extended so long that the audience becomes frustrated.
“in order to have a great piece of music, you need to delay the release of tension as long as possible. The longer you extend the desire for the pleasure, the greater the pleasure when it comes and pleasure is the death of desire.”
- Music harnesses the brain's fundamental trait of wanting to predict the future—memory exists not for the past but to simulate possible futures—so musicians create tension for an ultimate release, and within a genre's established rules listeners can anticipate where music is going, letting skilled musicians push and pull against expectation to convey something truthful.
“it harnesses what I think of as the brain's fundamental trait, which is it wants to predict the future. Our memory is not about the past. It's about giving us the ability to create a potential future”
Musical training physically rewires the developing brain in childhood, producing lasting changes in auditory processing and cognitive ability that persist into adulthood.
- Myelination of the prefrontal cortex—the fatty sheath that speeds axonal transmission via saltatory conduction—occurs in the late teens and early twenties, which is when emotional regulation and rational control mature; the failure of this myelination process may explain why people who develop schizophrenia typically have their first psychotic breaks during this same window.
“myelination of the prefrontal cortex seems to be what is happening during these late teenage years”
- Early childhood, when the auditory cortex develops, is a critical period for musical processing: kids trained as musicians early have brains that react to sound differently and retain a 'musician's signature' even decades after stopping, while children exposed to constant unfilterable noise (often low-income urban environments) can develop trouble parsing speech from noise and later language difficulties—damage that musical training can partly undo.
“kids who are trained as musicians early on, their brains literally react to sound differently, even if they stop playing piano... many years later, we can still see the kind of musician's signature.”
- There is a relationship between the extent of musical training and academic success or IQ—kids with three or more years of individual music lessons show higher IQs and academic achievement—but socioeconomic status is a confound; controlled studies like one in Boston public schools showed brain changes after 15 months of instrumental training, though not yet IQ changes, likely because the study period was too short.
“kids who have three years or more of individual music lessons, tend to show higher IQs or a higher academic achievement... Now, you've got a compound here potentially of socio-economic status”
- There is a sensitive period for acquiring language and absolute (perfect) pitch: the brain maps a second language learned at 55 differently than one learned at 5, and a Japanese study found that 100% of children aged 2-4 who completed a training protocol acquired absolute pitch, because young brains in the sensitive period extract regularities differently as the auditory cortex matures.
“there's a study that came out of Japan that looked at kids who were between the ages of 2 and 4, and 100% of them that finished this training protocol had absolute or perfect pitch.”
Music's transformative value is social—making music together and synchronizing with others increases bonding and empathy far more than isolated or passive consumption.
- Creating music alone with a computer in your basement is ultimately not as powerful or motivating as playing in a garage band, because music's value is social, and humans are adaptive enough that if isolated digital music-making leaves us unsatisfied, the pendulum will swing back toward making music together in person.
“Sitting in your basement and creating music with a computer, I think is just not ultimately as powerful or motivating as playing a garage band.”
- Almost all music is fundamentally social—even a solo composer imagines a listener—and music makes the world better primarily by engendering empathy, letting us experience another person's humanity and feel connected to or merciful toward them in a way other media cannot, as illustrated by hip-hop emerging from 1970s New York turntable culture as a communal outlet.
“I think it engenders empathy. I think it allows us to put ourselves in someone else's shoes to experience someone else's humanity in a way that maybe we wouldn't have in another medium.”
- Bouncing in sync with someone to music raises oxytocin (an attachment hormone) in both brains and increases prosocial bonding—demonstrated by experiments where people, and even toddlers, who were bounced in sync were more likely to help by picking up a dropped object, but only for the person they synced with, not a neutral stranger.
“when you bounce in sync with someone else to music, you actually raise levels of an attachment hormone called oxytocin in both of your brains, and that makes you feel more bonded”
- We are at a pivotal point where we risk losing the amateur musician, which would be tragic because we gain the most from participating in music-making rather than just consuming it—evidenced by babies as young as six months and people as old as 95 coming alive when they make music—and society has overcorrected toward the view that you must be a professional or not bother, unlike most of human history.
“I think that we are in danger of losing the amateur musician, which I think would be really tragic, because I think we gain the most out of actually participating in music making.”
Music works by exploiting the brain's drive to search for meaning and predict the future within repeated patterns, preventing habituation through layered discovery.
- The brain habituates to repeated stimuli that carry no new information—as a sea slug stops withdrawing its tail after repeated pokes, or as people stop hearing their refrigerator hum—so music works by giving the brain layered meanings to keep discovering within a repeated pattern, satisfying our drive to search for meaning.
“you poke a California Aplysia, a sea slug, on its tail a bunch of times, eventually it stops withdrawing its tail. That's habituation”
- Repetition is the one universal feature of virtually all known music (except music that explicitly avoids it as a reaction against it), and experiments show that adding repetition to non-repetitive music makes listeners rate it as more interesting, more enjoyable, and more likely to have been composed by a human.
“repetition is the one universal feature of virtually every music that we know of, except the music that explicitly avoids it”
The brain's dopamine reward system—anticipation in the caudate and pleasure release in the nucleus accumbens—underlies both music's emotional power and pathological conditions like anorexia.
- Seeing the dopamine tracking from caudate to nucleus accumbens explained why a singing teacher's advice was right: it is not the high note that matters but all the notes leading up to it, because a high note that comes out of nowhere is technically harder, not anticipated by the audience, and therefore sounds weird and unrewarding.
“it's not the high note that matters, it's all the notes leading up to the high note... if the high note comes out of nowhere... the audiences doesn't expect it and they don't care about it, it just sounds weird.”
- Anorexia may be partly driven not just by a desire to be thin but by a habit that makes eating aversive, reflected in an overactive caudate nucleus, which is why force-feeding is the worst intervention—it associates even more misery with eating.
“people who have anorexia we think now it might be partly to do with a habit of not eating, so that they find eating aversive, and we see an overactive caudate... So it's not just the desire to be thin, it's just that eating is unpleasant.”
- Earworms persist because certain melodies—like Baby Shark or Wheels on the Bus—never end or never release their tension, so the brain keeps looping them; one remedy is to volitionally compose a big ending in your head so the brain registers it as finished, and severe earworms can be treated with OCD medications because they involve an overactive caudate nucleus.
“things like Baby Shark or Wheels on the Bus have this problem where they're never ending, so there isn't an ultimate release... And then it just keeps looping”
- Focal dystonia is the dark side of neuroplasticity: when a musician repeatedly trains two body parts to move in sync, the somatosensory cortex can remap them as a single unit, making it very hard to decouple and move them independently and producing painful conditions like musician's cramp.
“this is the dark side of neuroplasticity, it's called focal dystonia... your brain actually remaps your somatosensory cortex as that being... one finger rather than two fingers. And so, now it's very hard for you to decouple them”
Singing and musical skill development depend primarily on deliberate practice and training rather than innate talent, though emotional self-consciousness can impede learning.
- Singing well is more a matter of training and practice than innate talent—the brains of trained singers show measurable changes—but progress is hindered because awkward singing is emotionally embarrassing, and that emotional reaction makes the brain focus on the emotion rather than the corrective information, since our voice is so tied to our identity.
“we see the differences in the brains of singers... So, you gotta wire it up differently, but that takes time.”
- Motor skill learning proceeds through Fitts's three stages—the clumsy cognitive stage where you consciously think through each movement, the associative stage where parts automatize but still require thought, and the automatic (implicit) stage where conscious attention can actually interfere; experts can then re-introduce conscious control to a largely automatic skill, like Tiger Woods checking his golf swing mid-swing.
“there's this three-stage model by a guy named Fitz that I like, where things start clumsy and cognitive... that's called the associative stage... and then eventually you get to the automatic stage, where it's now implicit, and in fact, if you start thinking about it too much you can actually interfere with your ability to do the task”
- The belief that we get much worse at learning music as we age is largely an unreasonable expectation about speed: while young adults do learn motor tasks faster than children, serious musical gains require years of deliberate practice with feedback, so older learners who devote the same time and effort can achieve exceptional results.
“I think it's an unreasonable expectation that we can learn something very quickly as we get older without putting in the same kind of time.”
Brain plasticity enables cochlear implant users and older learners to achieve remarkable results, but music appreciation after hearing loss often remains impaired despite excellent speech comprehension.
- Transcranial direct current stimulation devices like Halo Neuroscience's headset claim to put the motor cortex into a 'hyperplastic' mode more open to change, potentially increasing the efficacy of practicing an instrument or athletic skill, though whether this actually works and what protocols are most effective remains under investigation.
“it's transcranial direct stimulation and it's supposed to essentially stimulate the motor cortex, put it into what they call a hyperplastic mode... that's supposed to increase the efficacy with which you can train.”
- People who are well-educated tend to be more likely to have been exposed to opera and therefore like it, which is why Pasadena—with its intellectual community and history of arts focus—was chosen as a place to start an accessible opera company.
“there's a big intellectual community there, and generally people who are well-educated tend to be more likely to have been exposed to opera and therefore like it.”
- How we interpret sound as music depends on higher-level brain processing, so disliking a widely loved genre often means one's brain is not processing it or finding meaning in it the same way others do—rather than the music being objectively bad.
“ultimately how we interpret sound as music depends on our brains. And it's high up in there.”
- School music programs make at-risk kids more likely to attend school because they want to play in the band, and keeping kids in school keeps them off the streets and less likely to commit crimes—so turning one child away from jail can pay for ten years of a music teacher's salary, making music a societal good even if it doesn't directly raise IQ.
“If you put a school music program in, they're more likely to show up... 'Cause they want to play in the band... you take one child and you turn them around, so they don't end up going to jail, that pays for 10 years of a music teacher salary”
- Cochlear implants can restore the ability to understand speech remarkably well, but in most cases they do not restore the love or appreciation of music—even for former music aficionados who lost their hearing—with music often described as sounding like 'broken keys' or noise.
“They don't really learn to appreciate music. Music still is something that... Sometimes they give descriptions like it sounds like broken keys or it just sounds like noise.”
- Drug overdoses often happen in novel environments like hotel rooms because the brain, expecting a drug at the usual place and time, counteracts it to maintain homeostasis; in a new environment lacking those cues the caudate is unprepared, so the same dose that was tolerated can become fatal.
“a lot of people who overdose tend to do so in novel environments, like hotel rooms, because your brain... expects a drug if you take it in the same place at the same time... it swings in the other direction.”
- Cochlear implants deliver only 10-20 leads versus the cochlea's roughly 10,000 hair cells, yet patients learn to understand speech because the brain figures out how to interpret the impoverished signal if the person is motivated to keep trying—demonstrating the brain's flexibility rather than a fixed module.
“the problem is, it's only going to have maybe 10 to 20 leads as opposed to 10,000 hair cells. And also then how are you going to teach the brain to interpret this signal?”
- Administering oxytocin via nasal spray makes people keep rhythm better and become more in sync, suggesting a link between the attachment hormone and the capacity to synchronize with others.
“if you spray people with this or you give them this oxytocin nasal spray, they actually keep the rhythm better... it makes them more in sync”
- We retain a special attachment to the music we loved as teenagers because it helped us find ourselves and our tribe during an emotionally formative period, so even when we recognize it is not objectively great music it still produces a rush of nostalgia—though we may also tire of it more quickly than we did then.
“it still gives you this rush of nostalgia... 'cause it helped you find yourself in your tribe. But you're exactly right that we can recognize that it is actually not objectively good music and still have this good effect.”
- Oxytocin is more accurately the 'attachment hormone' than the 'love hormone,' because it is also the 'hate hormone': elevated oxytocin increases aggression toward people deemed to threaten or fall outside one's tribe, meaning the same molecule that bonds in-groups antagonizes out-groups.
“it's much more accurate to say, it's the attachment hormone, because it's also the hate hormone. So, you actually feel more aggression towards people you deem as threatening your tribe or outside of your tribe when you're high on oxytocin.”
- Opera is uniquely difficult because, traditionally, nothing should separate the human voice from the audience—no amplification—so singers train for years to use bone structure, resonance, diaphragm, and lungs to project sound across a large space while still sounding beautiful.
“there shouldn't be any, in my opinion, amplification. So there should be nothing separating the human voice from the audience... we train for so many years to do, to use our bone structure, our resonance, our diaphragm, our lungs to be able to project sound as far as it can possibly go, but still sound beautiful.”
Artists and musicians understand human behavior through centuries of intuitive study, so art should guide neuroscience rather than science reducing music to mechanism.
- Artists and musicians often understand aspects of human behavior—what gives music soul, what makes a great track—long before neuroscientists formalize it, so rather than using science to reduce and demystify music, art should help direct neuroscience, since artists have studied these human phenomena for centuries.
“this is actually why I sort of turned the whole for Cadence... turned the idea on its head. I don't want to use science to reduce music... I want to use music to help me understand the brain, humanity.”
The Mozart effect was overstated; music's cognitive benefits come from arousal and engagement, not from music's special properties, debunking the infant-music-enhances-intelligence industry.
- The original Mozart effect came from a single 1993 one-page paper on about 30 undergraduates who scored slightly better on spatial reasoning after hearing Mozart versus silence or relaxation tapes, but the effect was due to arousal (being more awake and engaged), since espresso, a Stephen King chapter, or Blur produced the same boost—debunking the Baby Einstein 'music makes babies smarter' industry.
“it was literally a one-page paper from 1993... of like 30 undergraduates... they performed better slightly on these tests. If you had given them a shot of espresso or in subsequent replications... reading a Stephen King chapter was just as arousing, Blur was just as arousing.”