289 | Cari Cesarotti on the Next Generation of Particle Experiments
What this covers
Sean Carroll talks with theoretical physicist Cari Cesarotti about how particle physics moves forward when the Standard Model works so well it frustrates discovery. The Standard Model successfully predicts and explains observed phenomena across precision measurements and the 2012 discovery of the Higgs boson, yet it omits quantum gravity, cannot explain dark matter or neutrino masses, and suffers from the hierarchy problem—the puzzling fact that the Higgs boson mass is about 10^32 times smaller than first-principles theory predicts. Cesarotti argues that experimental physics must now be experiment-driven and agnostic, prioritizing machines that maximize discovery potential per dollar and energy spent.
The conversation centers on the muon collider as the candidate for the next generation. A muon collider would combine the clean, fundamental-particle precision of electron machines with energies far beyond what electron colliders can achieve—a 10 TeV muon collider delivering physics comparable to a 70–80+ TeV proton machine. The technical obstacles are substantial: muons decay in about a microsecond, so all production, cooling, and acceleration must happen within that window; the dominant showstopper is likely 6D cooling, a cycle requiring over a hundred iterations of momentum removal and restoration via magnets before the muons decay. The conversation also touches on neutrino radiation concerns, the expense and constraints of tunneling, and why preserving the institutional knowledge of collider design matters. Cesarotti discusses how the field has shifted from the era of raw unexplained phenomena toward more subtle questions about why particles have their properties, and why supersymmetry in its simplest form no longer survives as an attractive unified solution.
Cesarotti argues that despite the Standard Model's frustrating success, deep unsolved puzzles (the hierarchy problem, dark matter, neutrino masses) demand new experiments, and that a muon collider—though technologically risky—is the fastest, most energy-efficient route to the energy frontier and thus the best bet for the next generation of particle physics.
- The Standard Model fits all data but cannot explain why the Higgs mass is ~10^32 times smaller than theory predicts (hierarchy problem), nor dark matter or neutrino masses.
- A muon collider combines the clean, fundamental-particle precision of electron machines with energies far beyond electron colliders, reaching effective energies comparable to much larger proton machines.
- With theory no longer offering a single beautiful prediction, physics should now be experiment-driven and agnostic, prioritizing machines that maximize new-physics discovery per dollar and energy.
A muon collider uniquely delivers high-energy precision physics by accelerating fundamental particles to energies far exceeding electron machines while maintaining clean collision environments unavailable to proton colliders.
- A muon collider is uniquely suited to directly producing new physics above a couple hundred GeV with fundamental particles—something no electron collider can reach and no proton machine can match in cleanliness—and because muons are fundamental, a 10 TeV muon collider delivers physics comparable to a 70-80+ TeV proton machine, with a 14 TeV muon collider rivaling a 100 TeV proton machine.
“a 10 TEV muon collider would be comparable to the physics for the average collision that you can get out of something like a 70 or 80 TEV if not more proton proton machine. So that 100 TEV number... would be comparable to a 14 TEV muon collider.”
- A muon collider is uniquely promising because muons are fundamental clean particles (like electrons, giving precision) yet heavy enough to be accelerated to far higher energies than electrons in a circular machine, since electron circular colliders cannot practically surpass a few hundred GeV—so the muon collider uniquely breaks the energy frontier with a clean environment.
“because a muon is heavier, we can accelerate it to much higher energies than electrons. So an electron circular collider really can't surpass more than a couple hundred GeV”
- A muon collider can study the Higgs boson in ways the LHC cannot and in a cleaner environment, with a ~10 TeV muon collider capable of producing 10 million Higgs bosons—enough to flesh out how the Higgs couples to itself and other particles and how electroweak symmetry is restored at high energies—making it a complementary or overlapping Higgs factory alongside e+e- machines.
“attend to EV muon collider, given the physics program that we hope to run, you can produce 10 million Higgs bosons. And with 10 million Higgs bosons, you can study a lot.”
- Electron colliders collide fundamental point particles so the full collision energy is known and reconstructable, making them clean precision machines; proton colliders collide composite 'bags' of quarks and gluons (partons) sharing the proton's energy unpredictably, so no collision reaches the full beam energy but a wide variety of parton interactions makes them versatile discovery machines.
“electrons are the precision machine. Because everything's very clean... Versus for protons, it's like smashing cars together. There's debris everywhere. You don't know exactly what collided into what.”
- For the next round of experiments the US chose to invest in neutrino physics via Fermilab's DUNE experiment rather than a next-generation collider, while China (CEPC) and CERN (FCC/FCC-ee) present the most concrete circular electron-collider proposals, leaving the US unlikely to host the next e+e- circular collider.
“the thing that the US has chosen to invest in right now is neutrino physics. So Fermilab... is committed to doing a big experiment called DUNE”
- Different national physics cultures—the US tending toward wacky, dreamer, 'get weird with it' theories and experiments versus Europe's precision focus on tracking factors of two and pi—are complementary rather than one being better, so the ideal outcome is precision-oriented countries building precision machines while the US pulls resources for a high-risk muon collider, since diversity of approaches is the most robust path to discovery when the answer is unknown.
“in the US, for better or for worse, we tend to be sort of the people that always wanna make sort of wacky theories... the fact that that then opens up the possibility of like, oh, let's get weird with it in science”
The hierarchy problem—Higgs mass calculations vastly overpredicting observed values—reveals unexplained physics requiring deeper first-principles explanation beyond the Standard Model's empirical categorization.
- The hierarchy problem is that theoretical first-principles calculation predicts the Higgs boson mass-squared should be about 10^32 times larger than the value observed (the Higgs mass itself being ~10^18 times smaller than the natural scale), and the fact that such enormous numbers cancel to such tiny accuracy with no known reason is fundamentally puzzling.
“we think that the Higgs boson should have a mass 10 to the 18 times bigger than it does... The fact that something can be off by 32 orders of magnitude from our theoretical predictions, where did that come from?”
- A model like the Standard Model is empirical—it categorizes and accounts for observed phenomena without explaining why they exist—whereas a framework or first-principles theory (like a grand unified theory) would explain why the phenomena arise the way they do; this is why the Standard Model is beautiful in its patterns but ugly in lacking a fundamental origin.
“a model is something that we use to account for phenomena that we observe. So it's very empirical in nature... versus something like grand unified theory would be a way of explaining sort of why everything comes together in the way they do.”
- The expectation of what the Higgs mass 'should be' comes not from the empirical model but from the theoretical framework: once the Higgs is hypothesized to have the properties that let it give mass to other particles, those theoretical tools let physicists calculate the mass it should have had under the simplest assumptions—and the mismatch reveals something unexplained is happening.
“given the properties that we hypothesized of the Higgs that make it a particle that could, in fact, give mass to other particles, then we have the theoretical tools to make a prediction of what the mass should be.”
- Supersymmetry was attractive because adding a symmetry that pairs every fermion with a boson super-partner provides a natural mechanism to cancel the enormous contributions to the Higgs mass, explaining why it sits near 100 GeV rather than 10^18 GeV—solving the hierarchy problem through symmetry-enforced cancellation of two large numbers.
“if you want to understand why you have a very, very big number as a prediction, but you see a very, very small number experimentally measured, the easiest answer is there's a symmetry that cancels something.”
- The Standard Model exhibits patterns including three generations of many particles, gauge bosons grouping together, and particles getting heavier as they couple more strongly to the Higgs.
“there are three generations of a lot of things. We see that the gauge bosons kind of fit nicely in one bucket.”
Theory-driven supersymmetry and grand unified frameworks have failed empirical tests, leaving physicists without a compelling unified theory and requiring experiment-led exploration of energy frontier.
- Particle physics has undergone a phase transition: where the 1950s-80s bubble-chamber era was full of 'what the heck is this' surprises that drove rapid theoretical progress, the field now faces more subtle and fundamental questions—why particles have the properties they do, what we are failing to see—rather than unexplained raw phenomena.
“now I think we're in a much more subtle phase of particle physics where the questions are not so much what the heck is this, but where does this come from? Why does this look like this? What are the things that we're not seeing?”
- A theory is marked as healthy in physics when it can address many problems simultaneously rather than picking one and patching it; supersymmetric grand unified theories were attractive precisely because they could solve the hierarchy problem, supply dark matter, and explain neutrino masses all at once.
“it is definitely something that really is a marker of a very healthy theory in physics, I think is when it can sort of address many problems at once versus just picking one problem and trying to, like I said, patchwork it.”
- Because the LHC turned on and did not find the predicted super-partners, supersymmetry in its purest maximally symmetric form is likely not realizable; surviving versions must break the symmetry by adding new particles or interactions, which turns it from a global solution into an unattractive patchwork that no longer cleanly answers the fundamental question it was invented for.
“we turned on the LHC and we did not see the super partners. So super symmetry as theorized in its most beautiful, pure form of having the maximal symmetry is not something that's probably realizable at this point.”
- Far from particle physics being dead, this is an exciting era of first-order change in which young physicists have the privilege of shaping how the field unsticks itself—deciding the next generation of experiments and how to search for new physics—after a decade that saw the Higgs discovered, supersymmetry not found, and the Tevatron shut down as the LHC turned on.
“what amazing privilege I have as a young person in this field is that I get to be part of the conversation of how we unstick ourselves, right? Is how we decide what the next generation of experiments gets to be.”
- Before the LHC, theory had a firm promise that something new had to appear around 100 GeV because predictions were breaking down, but now physicists only know the Standard Model is incomplete without knowing where the answer lies, so it is time to let experiment drive and hope data re-inspires theorists.
“now we just don't have that theoretical promise, right? Is that we just know things are broken. And we haven't yet been able to debug the standard model... now it's the time to let experiment drive a little bit and see what's up there”
- Physics suffers in public engagement compared to astronomy or biology because understanding why a physics result is surprising or exciting requires extensive conceptual lead-up.
“physics requires so much lead up to understanding sort of why it's surprising or exciting or interesting or puzzling.”
Muon collider development is technically feasible with no fundamental showstoppers, though 6D cooling and microsecond-scale operations present severe engineering challenges requiring novel solutions.
- A primary justification for a muon collider is that no fundamental physical showstopper rules it out, so demonstrating that muons can be collided is itself a worthwhile scientific achievement that would open an entirely new generation of colliders functioning as microscopes for fundamental interactions.
“there's no fundamental showstopper that would suggest that this is a deeply impossible task to do. So the fact that this is just a scientific challenge to see if you can collide muons, and this could open up... an entire new generation of colliders, which are really effectively microscopes”
- The biggest open technological problem for a muon collider is 6D cooling—simultaneously localizing muons in three momentum and three spatial dimensions—achieved by repeatedly removing then restoring momentum (since squeezing in one direction expands another) and using magnets to recompress, a cycle that must run over a hundred times before the muon decays; failure here, not acceleration, is the most likely showstopper.
“this is called 6D cooling... the sixth dimension is three dimensions for momentum and three dimensions for physical space, because you need all these muons to be traveling not only at the same momentum, but also localized to a very small bunch.”
- The fundamental challenge of a muon collider is that muons decay in about 10^-6 seconds into neutrinos and electrons, so the entire process—producing enough muons, cooling them into a dense bunch, and accelerating them around a ring—must occur within a microsecond, something never attempted at this scale before.
“muons, like you say, live for 10 to the minus six seconds and then they decay away to neutrinos and electrons. So one of the most fundamental challenges... would be to accelerate particles that decay, which we have never even tried to do on this kind of scale before.”
- Muons are produced as tertiary particles: low-energy protons (a few GeV) are dumped into a metal target where they scatter and produce mesons (quark-antiquark pairs), which being unstable decay almost entirely into muons and muon neutrinos, yielding a large diffuse cloud of muons that, because the protons and mesons are slow, is far from the tight bunch needed for collisions.
“we accelerate protons to a couple of GeV and then we just dump it into some chunk of metal... they scatter around and they produce mesons... a big way that mesons tend to decay is into muons.”
- A muon collider's high-energy neutrinos pose a radiation concern because, unlike low-energy neutrinos, TeV neutrinos can interact with atoms in the ground and excite them, but this can be mitigated by burying the ring sufficiently deep and by 'wiggling' the beam to diffuse the dose over a wide area, keeping radiation well below legal and dangerous limits.
“all of these neutrinos that are coming off from your muon being circulated is they'll just travel in a straight line. They'll escape the experiment and they'll travel through dirt... they might interact with some atom in the dirt and they could excite the atom, and then that could decay.”
Multiple open fundamental puzzles—Higgs origin, dark matter, neutrino mass, fourth-generation particles—lack a single beautiful unified solution, demanding diverse experimental approaches to discovery.
- Cesarotti believes new physics must exist between currently accessible energies and the Planck scale because she cannot reconcile 16 orders of magnitude of empty energy range as an accident or as fine-tuning by a supreme power—a deeper explanation must exist—with the first plausible hints affecting the electroweak sector around four pi times the Higgs vacuum expectation value, roughly three TeV.
“I just fundamentally can't reconcile a world where there's just 16 orders of magnitude that are empty and I don't think that this is an accident... I think there has to be some deeper explanation.”
- Neutrino mass constitutes new physics because, unlike all other fermions, there is no single fundamental interaction term that can be written to give neutrinos mass via the Higgs the standard way—they only have a left-handed component, so generating mass requires either a yet-undiscovered right-handed neutrino (Dirac) or a different two-neutrino/two-Higgs Majorana mechanism, both departing from the Standard Model pattern.
“because there does not exist a fundamental interaction term that we can write down for neutrinos that give them mass because they can't, it won't work the same way as the other particles with the Higgs boson... I think that is an example of new physics.”
- Because there is no single beautiful theory explaining all open puzzles (Higgs origin, dark matter, neutrino mass, possible fourth-generation particles), physicists should be agnostic explorers prioritizing experiments that give the most return—reaching the energy frontier in a clean, high-luminosity environment—which is how the field gets unstuck, and the muon collider is the fastest, cleanest, most novel route.
“no one beautiful theory like we had for super symmetry sort of explains them all, to me means that we should just be explorers. And we should be kind of agnostic and just do experiments in which we can sort of get the most return on our money in terms of just seeing new things.”
- Cesarotti's favorite model to hope for is a new spin-1 vector boson—a heavy 'dark photon' or Z prime—because any spin-1 vector particle couples to something else, so its existence would open a portal into dark matter or an entirely new sector of physics, potentially mixing with the electroweak sector.
“I really hope that there's a new Z prime or vector boson out there. So I want some new spin-1 particle that looks like a massive photon... It could be the portal to dark matter.”
Practical collider construction faces real constraints of land, tunneling costs, and energy supply, requiring physicists to be responsible stewards of public resources while maintaining institutional knowledge.
- Collider design is constrained by mundane realities: a machine cannot be built bigger than the land you own (running into mountains, rivers, state borders, and property law), tunnels are extremely expensive so smaller is cheaper, and energy supply is a real limit—the LHC has run at reduced capacity due to Europe's energy shortage from the Russia-Ukraine war—so physicists must be responsible stewards of public money, space, and energy.
“you just can't build an arbitrarily big machine, expect that yeah, you as a scientist are immune to property law... Tunnels are so expensive.”
- Because particle colliders are built so rarely, there is a real danger that the largely implicit, undocumented knowledge of how to build them—passed down by training individuals rather than via any textbook or manual—ages out, so preserving the field is necessary to keep the very possibility of building future colliders alive.
“There's no textbook that you can buy. There's no IKEA manual to how to build a particle collider. And so much of what's taught is just passed down between groups and training individuals”
Precision and discovery machines serve complementary roles; electron colliders reveal new physics through Standard Model discrepancies while proton machines achieve versatile discovery through parton variety.
- Precision (electron) colliders are also discovery machines in a roundabout way: by measuring Standard Model predictions to high precision, any discrepancy between data and prediction becomes a hint of new physics or new phenomena, even though the machine cannot directly produce and point to a new particle.
“if you were to discover something that is not matching the standard model prediction, that's a hint of a discovery, right? So you don't get to actually physically make the particle and point to it... But you get to say, OK, there's a discrepancy in our data.”
- The LHC is not a Boolean new-physics detector; many subtleties in choosing, analyzing, and interpreting events can introduce bias and obscure signals, so the machine still has discovery potential—it is even possible it has already produced new physics that has not yet been analyzed correctly to notice it.
“there's just so many subtleties that occur between colliding the particles and a physicist understanding what's going on... there's so many things in which you could introduce a bias that would skew you away from understanding fundamentally what physics could be going on.”
Neutrino mass constitutes new physics because its generation mechanism departs from standard Higgs interactions, requiring either undiscovered right-handed neutrinos or exotic Majorana mechanisms.
- Massive particles need both left- and right-handed degrees of freedom because, being slower than light, an observer can boost into a frame that flips the apparent spin direction, whereas a massless particle travels at light speed with no valid boost frame to flip its spin, so it needs only one handedness.
“if something is massive, then you as an observer can boost yourself either in front or behind of that object. And if you are in front, you see it turning one way, and if you're behind, you see it turning a different way.”