hierarchy problem
The puzzle of why the Higgs/electroweak scale is so much smaller than the Planck scale despite large quantum corrections.
As defined in ms_ama_february_2024
Other definitions
The puzzle of why gravity is so much weaker than the other forces, given that quantum corrections would naively push the Higgs mass and related scales up to the Planck scale.
Aak Me Anything | November 2026
Where it comes up · 14
- 245 | Solo: The Crisis in Physics5 claims
- 183 | Michael Dine on Supersymmetry, Anthropics, and the Future of Particle Physics4 claims
- 289 | Cari Cesarotti on the Next Generation of Particle Experiments3 claims
- 331 | Solo: Fine-Tuning, God, and the Multiverse2 claims
- AMA | February 20232 claims
- 130 | Frank Wilczek on the Present and Future of Fundamental Physics1 claim
- 321 | David Tong on Open Questions in Quantum Field Theory1 claim
- 359 | Solo: Theories of Dark Energy1 claim
and 6 more
Most important claims · 10 of 25Search all claims for “hierarchy problem” →
- When a feature of the universe (like dark energy's coincidence problem, the cosmological constant problem, the hierarchy problem, or inflation) seems unnatural or preposterous, it is never a criticism of the universe but a reminder that our expectations—set by some subset of what we observe—are wrong, signaling something we don't yet understand.AMA | February 2023
- The WIMP miracle is the observation that if you work backwards from the required relic abundance of cold dark matter, the interaction strength needed is roughly that of the known weak interactions of particle physics; combined with the hierarchy problem motivating new weak-scale particles, this made weakly interacting massive particles a compelling and favored dark matter candidate.245 | Solo: The Crisis in Physics
- There was a strong, well-motivated expectation that the LHC would find new physics at the electroweak scale (supersymmetric particles, extra dimensions, etc.) to solve the hierarchy problem, but the LHC has found no new particles beyond the Higgs boson; this absence is really concerning for the future of particle physics, though it is not the physicists' fault.245 | Solo: The Crisis in Physics
- Supersymmetry and extra-dimension theories were favored partly because they could naturally explain the hierarchy between the electroweak and Planck scales, and they predicted new particles near the Higgs mass; the LHC, built partly to find these, has discovered none, which is a cautionary tale that plausible solutions to a fine-tuning can simply turn out to be wrong.331 | Solo: Fine-Tuning, God, and the Multiverse
- Inflationary models are not strongly contingent on supersymmetry; while the inflaton potential must be fine-tuned (shallow slope, ~60 e-folds), supersymmetry can be broken at a high scale and still help, so the failure to find supersymmetry at the LHC affects the hierarchy problem (which needs SUSY broken near the electroweak scale) but not inflation.AMA | February 2023
- A naturalness problem arises when a theory contains a dimensionless number that is extremely tiny (or huge) for no good reason, when it should be of order unity; the hierarchy problem is the ~10^-15 ratio of the electroweak scale to the Planck scale, with no reason quantum corrections shouldn't push the electroweak scale up to the Planck scale, and the cosmological constant problem is the analogous ~10^-30 (or 10^-120 in energy density) discrepancy for vacuum energy.245 | Solo: The Crisis in Physics
- The ratio of the Higgs expectation value to the Planck mass is about 10⁻¹⁶, and unlike the cosmological constant this hierarchy problem is 'down to earth' particle physics: effective field theory leads us to expect masses to be driven up to large scales, so the smallness of the electroweak scale is a genuine puzzle.331 | Solo: Fine-Tuning, God, and the Multiverse
- The naturalness argument (hierarchy problem) led most of the community, including Tong, to expect the LHC would find new particles accompanying the Higgs boson as a portal to the next layer of reality, but despite the LHC working beyond expectations and finding the Higgs, those particles are not there—so nature is telling us the well-motivated naturalness argument is wrong and the hierarchy problem has no solution.321 | David Tong on Open Questions in Quantum Field Theory
- The hierarchy problem (the huge mismatch between the Higgs/weak scale and the Planck/grand-unification scale) is a real but very broad motivation; for Wilczek it has been superseded by the unification of couplings, which is far more quantitative and a stronger, more positive guiding principle.130 | Frank Wilczek on the Present and Future of Fundamental Physics
- Supersymmetry was a very natural, highly constrained, phenomenologically interesting idea that could have been detected at the LHC by now but wasn't; the rational response is to decrease one's credence in supersymmetry from what it was in 2005 via Bayesian reasoning, but not to zero, since it could still be true if the supersymmetry breaking scale is higher (sacrificing it as a hierarchy solution) or just above LHC reach.245 | Solo: The Crisis in Physics