172 | David Goyer on Televising the Fall of the Galactic Empire
What this covers
David Goyer, the screenwriter behind the Dark Knight trilogy and now showrunner for the Foundation adaptation on Apple TV, sits down with physicist Sean Carroll to discuss the collision between Isaac Asimov's idea-driven source material and the demands of television storytelling. The core problem is stark: Asimov's Foundation books are dry, anthological, and structurally unfilmable—the galactic empire itself falls offscreen, and the central character is a mathematician whose greatest power is predicting history through psychohistory, a concept that resists dramatization. Goyer argues that the only path forward is to translate abstract themes into character conflict, embodying Asimov's interrogation of determinism, resistance to change, and the predictability of human societies through invented narrative elements like the genetic dynasty of Cleon I, who clones himself to rule across three generations simultaneously.
The conversation ranges across how serialized streaming television enables richer character arcs than film, why scientific accuracy sometimes must yield to watchability without sacrificing inspiration, and the specific craft of adaptation—how to earn a reveal through setup like the Mule, how to treat the script as data rather than defer blindly to science consultants, and how constraints as creative fuel often yield better storytelling than unconstrained scenarios. Goyer contends that inaccurate but stirring science fiction (Star Wars, Star Trek) has actually driven people into scientific careers more effectively than rigorous popularization. He also reflects on broader industry pressures: the consolidation of IP preference among studios, the outrage economy on social media that has turned adaptations into culture-war flashpoints, and why Foundation could only be made now, in an age of novelistic streaming shows, when it could not have been squeezed into theatrical films.
Goyer argues that adapting idea-driven, undramatic science fiction like Foundation requires translating abstract themes (psychohistory, resistance to change, determinism) into character conflict and embracing scientific constraints as creative fuel, even at the cost of strict accuracy.
- Asimov's source is dry, anthological, conflict-free and unfilmable as written, so themes must be embodied in characters (e.g., the genetic dynasty).
- Scientific accuracy must be balanced against watchability via an 'uncanny valley of adapting science'; constraints from science advisors lead to more interesting storytelling.
- The goal is to inspire audiences toward science and reason while keeping the show emotionally compelling.
Source material demands significant change: the books are dry with offscreen action, static characters, and were written haphazardly without unified planning.
- Asimov wrote the early Foundation stories ad hoc as a young writer breaking into the field, throwing ideas against the wall without planning a unified series, and only by the third novel was the work actually written as a deliberate novel; he himself said he would have constructed a different story had he planned it from the start.
“he didn't go into it planning it as if it were going to be some kind of unified series. Perhaps if someone had said, "Here's a contract to write a novel," at the beginning, he might have... Well, in fact, Asimov said he would have constructed a different story.”
- The core adaptation problems are that the Foundation books, while fascinating, are dry with almost all action happening off-screen (the Empire even falls off-screen), and the characters in the first two books have no real arcs and do not grow or change.
“the books are fascinating, but they're dry. Almost all the action happens off-screen, the Empire falls off screen. There aren't any character arcs, certainly in the first two books, that the characters don't grow and change.”
- Unlike the books, which introduce the Second Foundation as a late-stage deus ex machina that already exists, the show will not have that liberty, so Goyer is interested in depicting how the Second Foundation formed and how the Mule became the Mule, dramatizing origins rather than presenting fully-formed reveals.
“in our show, we don't have the liberty of just introducing the second Foundation as a deus ex machina... in our show, I'm interested in showing how the second Foundation formed, I'm interested in depicting how the Mule became the Mule.”
- Foundation's premise is that one mathematician, Hari Seldon, develops psychohistory, a predictive model based on the law of mass action and statistics that, given a large enough sample size, can predict the broad movements of history and society but cannot predict any individual person's lifeline or actions.
“one mathematician, a man named Hari Seldon has come up with a predictive model called psychohistory, which does just that, it predicts the broad movements of history. Can't predict the individual person's lifeline or action, but it can predict the broad movements of history.”
- In Foundation's premise, psychohistory predicts the Empire's fall is inevitable and unstoppable, and that doing nothing leads to 35,000 years of chaos, but following Seldon's plan can shorten the coming age of darkness to a thousand years.
“if we do nothing, humanity will fall into 35,000 years of chaos. However, if we follow his plan, we can shorten the age of darkness to a thousand years.”
Accurate adaptation requires identifying core themes and expressing them through character rather than depicting abstraction directly.
- Goyer's core adaptation method is to identify the core elements or concepts that make a property unique, validate them with the original creator or estate so both parties accept the same model of the work, and then take abstract themes and express them through character rather than depicting the abstraction directly.
“how do I take as amongst themes and express them through character?”
- Beyond visual beauty, the way to dramatize psychohistory is not to depict the dryness of the predictions but to show how the predictions relate to people—who is fearful, who is hopeful, who thinks the math is being misused—and to explore the existential questions of determinism, free will, and individual agency that the predictions raise.
“my other way of approaching it... was to not talk about the dryness of the predictions, but talk about how the predictions relate to the people in the story.”
- Rather than depicting math like the Arabic-numeral equations of A Beautiful Mind, the show depicts psychohistory's math as a swirling, spiraling, godlike visual inspired by the murmuration of birds, meant to look like 'the language of angels' because math is the code the universe is based on.
“I want our depiction of the math to be very beautiful, and I want it to look like the language of angels.”
Modern adaptation must reframe Foundation's social allegory to address contemporary concerns like nationalism, climate change, and gender equity.
- Asimov used Foundation as social allegory, basing it on Gibbon's decline and fall of the Roman Empire but actually interrogating the post-World War II realignment of empires, the ascension of America and the Soviets, so a modern adaptation must reframe the falling empires in terms of today's concerns like nationalism, climate change, and the Me Too movement.
“he was using science fiction as kind of social allegory... the empire that he was interrogating with his metaphors was a post-World War II environment. It was the empires that were falling with the realignment of Europe, with the ascension of America, the ascension of the Soviets”
- Because the original Foundation audience and writers were largely white men and the books had virtually no female characters, and because the show depicts a galaxy 25,000 years in the future for a far more varied modern audience, the show's characters should not be limited to reflecting the original demographic.
“there were virtually no female characters whatsoever in the first Foundation book. I'm not even sure that there were any speaking female characters.”
- To embody the theme of an empire resistant to change, Goyer invented the genetic dynasty: Cleon I clones himself repeatedly so three versions reign simultaneously (Brother Dawn at 30, Brother Day at 60 ruling, Brother Dusk at 90 advising), expressing resistance to change by imposing one man's ego across the galaxy, while also enabling castable recurring characters and stories about nature versus nurture.
“that led me to the idea of the genetic dynasty, which is a concept that's not in the books. And it's the idea that this one character, Cleon 1, about 400 years prior to the pilot, decides to keep cloning himself over and over again.”
Artistic liberties serve Foundation's core argument that reason and science enable human survival and inspire real scientific careers.
- By analogy to the uncanny valley in animation, where 99% realistic somehow feels worse than 70% realistic, there is an uncanny valley of adapting science: the exactly accurate depiction is often boring on screen, so creators must dumb it down even though they know it is inaccurate, accepting some distortion for the sake of watchability.
“when dealing with science and math and things like that in a show, I call it almost the uncanny valley of adapting science”
- Artistic liberties in Foundation are worth taking because the show is fundamentally about faith in reason and science in this era, arguing that it is only through science and reason that the human race will survive, and because it may inspire people to go into science.
“Is it worth it if we're telling a show that's fundamentally about faith in reason, and faith in science in this era? I would say yes, it's incredibly worth it. We need our scientists right now, and this is a show that says it's only through science and reason that the human race is going to survive.”
- At Science & Entertainment Exchange mixers, scientists overwhelmingly reported they got into science because of Star Wars or Star Trek, even though those works were not remotely scientifically accurate, suggesting that inaccurate but inspiring science fiction can drive people into real scientific careers.
“to a person, one of the things that they said was, "Because the reason I got into science was because of Star Wars or Star Trek."”
Serialized streaming enabled Foundation adaptation by providing hours for character development impossible in condensed film form.
- Long-form serialized streaming shows allow richer storytelling than film because a movie can usually only show a character change once over two or three hours, whereas a 50-to-70-hour serialized show lets characters grow, fail, and reverse course multiple times—good people becoming bad and vice versa—which makes that storytelling more interesting.
“In a movie, you can usually have a character change once, and it happens fairly quickly... But in a 50 or 60-hour or 70-hour serialised show, characters can grow and change and fail, good people can become bad people, bad people can become good people, they can screw up multiple times.”
- Adapting Foundation only became viable with the advent of big novelistic streaming shows like Game of Thrones, because it cannot be condensed into three three-hour films without cutting too much, but it can be adapted over 50 or 60 or more hours of serialized television.
“It wasn't until the advent of these big novelistic streaming shows like Game of Thrones that I thought, "Oh, maybe this could work."... maybe I can figure out how to adapt it over the course of 50 hours or 60 hours or more.”
Social media toxicity and outrage-driven discourse make honest audience engagement difficult and turn adaptations into culture-war flashpoints.
- One of the things both great and terrible about the internet is that every voice has an equal megaphone, which surfaces a toxic and virulent underbelly—as seen in the misogynistic and racist reactions to some Foundation casting—making it unappealing to engage with audience reactions too closely.
“one of the things that's great about the internet, one of the things that's terrible about the internet, is every voice has an equal megaphone.”
- The Mule, a mutant that psychohistory cannot predict, is so effective in the books because Asimov first established the expectation that Seldon crises would always be solved and psychohistory would work; introducing the Mule too early (in season one) would blunt its impact, so like the Red Wedding in Game of Thrones, the reveal must be earned through prior setup.
“I think the reason why the Mule is so effective is because Asimov did that storytelling set up where there was this expectation that the Seldon crisis would be solved in a certain way, and that psychohistory would work, and then this spoiler came in.”
- Since the Milky Way galaxy is thousands of light years across and the Foundation 'slow ship' is supposed to take only five years to travel from the galaxy's center to its edge, the slow ship must necessarily be traveling faster than the speed of light.
“it's supposed to take five years to get from the center of the galaxy to the edge of the galaxy, and the only way that the slow ship could get from the center of the galaxy to the edge of the galaxy, is to travel faster than the speed of light.”
- Foundation was an influence on George Lucas's Star Wars and Frank Herbert's Dune, so its core ideas like the Galactic Empire have already been strip-mined, meaning the adaptation had to find ways to make familiar concepts feel fresh again.
“Foundation was an influence, obviously, on Lucas for Star Wars, it was an influence on Herbert for Dune. And so some of these ideas have already been strip mined, and so the idea of a Galactic Empire is not something new”
- The preference for pre-existing IP can reach absurd extremes, where a comic book that sold only a few thousand copies gets pursued as a hot property because Hollywood believes a billion-dollar feature can be made from it.
“you could have a tiny, tiny comic book that might have sold literally 3000 copies, but because it's a pre-existing IP, "Well, gosh darn it, this is a hot property."”
- Industry consolidation and vertical integration among streamers has made it much harder to sell and set up original projects, especially expensive ones, because companies believe pre-existing IP with prior association gives them a better chance at profit, even when this is essentially circular reasoning.
“increasingly, as everyone's fighting for a slice of the pie, they're interested in pre-existing IP, so it's harder to sell and set up original projects, particularly expensive ones, because they believe that some kind of pre-association means that they have a better chance at making a profit”
- Game of Thrones, now a benchmark, itself defied conventional storytelling when it premiered—too many characters, a slow burn, major characters dying—and audiences were freaked out, so Foundation similarly experimenting with form may be polarizing before it sets its own terms.
“People were freaked out when Game of Thrones came out, because it defied conventional storytelling. There were too many characters, it was a slow burn.”
- Sandman has long been considered unfilmable because, unlike most properties, it does not adhere to any one genre—skipping between horror, philosophy, fantasy, historical fiction, comedy, and DC mythology—making it a 'feathered fish' that is not easily categorizable.
“The biggest challenge with Sandman is that it doesn't adhere to any one genre, it skips around. It's a horror episode, it's a philosophical episode, it's a fantasy episode, it's a largely historical fiction episode”
- Apple chose to release Foundation on a weekly cadence rather than all at once because they believe a weekly schedule creates more water-cooler conversation, which infuriates binge-accustomed audiences but does get them talking about the show.
“they decided that they felt that they can create more water cooler moments if the show comes out on a weekly cadence. On one hand, that's infuriating to the audience, who are used to... Who are used to binging things... But they're talking about it.”
- We now know that on Twitter and Facebook negative posts gain more traction, so social media stokes an era of outrage in which outrage becomes the coin of the realm, and adaptations become a tool in the culture wars rather than occasions for honest reaction.
“we live in a time of outrage culture. That's everything that social media is stoking. It's, outrage the coin of the realm. We know now, with Twitter and Facebook, that negative posts gain more traction.”
Storytelling drama requires conflict, doubt, and character failure; audiences reject self-satisfied exposition regardless of source accuracy.
- A storytelling rule of thumb is that coincidences working in favor of the protagonist are bad storytelling, but coincidences that work in favor of the antagonist and make things worse for the protagonist are permissible, because you always want to make things as difficult as possible for your protagonist.
“I hate coincidences that work in the favour of the protagonists. That's just bad storytelling. However... coincidences that work in favour of the antagonist and that make it worse for the protagonist, I think are okay, because you always wanna make it as difficult for your protagonists as possible”
- Characters like Walter White and Saul Goodman frequently self-harm and trip over themselves, and this works dramatically because human beings work against their own self-interest all the time, making self-defeating behavior realistic rather than the lazy character-stupidity Carroll dislikes.
“the fact of the matter is that human beings work against their own self-interest all the time.”
- Filmed entertainment is fundamentally based on conflict; audiences want to see characters doubt themselves, fail, fall in and out of love, and betray one another, so a show that simply depicted self-satisfied men presenting answers without any dark nights of the soul would never have been made, even if a tiny sliver of the audience might have loved it.
“filmed entertainment, it's based on conflict. We wanna see people doubt themselves and overcome those challenges, we wanna see them fail.”
Creator partnership and estate approval establishes shared model of the work and secures imprimatur necessary for successful adaptation.
- For Sandman, Goyer insisted that Neil Gaiman be made a producer and co-write the first episode—something no prior attempt had considered—to secure the creator's imprimatur and stamp of approval on the adaptation.
“I insisted that that be the case and said I wouldn't do it unless Neil was a producer, and then I said I want Neil to co-write the first episode with me. So we have that imprimatur, we have that stamp of approval.”
- David Goyer sold his first screenplay at 21, had it made into a film at 22, is over 50 with more than 30 years in the industry, and passed on Foundation in both his 30s and 40s before feeling mature enough to take it on.
“I sold my first screenplay when I was 21 and it was made as a film when I was 22. I'm over 50 now, so I've been in the game over 30 years.”