psychohistory
Asimov's fictional science of statistically predicting the behavior of large human populations; here used as an aspiration for what economics might be.
As defined in Paul Krugman
Where it comes up · 5
- 172 | David Goyer on Televising the Fall of the Galactic Empire3 claims
- Paul Krugman1 claim
- 17 | Annalee Newitz on Science, Fiction, Economics, and Neurosis1 claim
- AMA | Feb 20261 claim
- AMA | July 20221 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “psychohistory” →
- Foundation's premise is that one mathematician, Hari Seldon, develops psychohistory, a predictive model based on the law of mass action and statistics that, given a large enough sample size, can predict the broad movements of history and society but cannot predict any individual person's lifeline or actions.172 | David Goyer on Televising the Fall of the Galactic Empire
- The reason economics can get as far as it does (the dream of psychohistory) is that it concerns the simplest, crudest aspects of human motivation—getting and spending—where we at least have a good idea of what people are trying to do; beyond that, modeling human behavior gets dramatically harder.Paul Krugman
- Unlike Asimov's psychohistory which assumes individual idiosyncrasies average out, human societies cannot be predicted deterministically because the individual people are themselves complex systems, so averaging over them does not yield simple macroscopic behavior the way averaging over atoms yields predictable gas dynamics.AMA | July 2022
- Carroll holds that psychohistory is entirely bogus and there will never be a real predictive science of large-scale human history, a position he is defending in a book on the physics of democracy explaining why Asimov was mistaken, though he considers the conceit perfectly fine for the purposes of the story.172 | David Goyer on Televising the Fall of the Galactic Empire
- Asimov's psychohistory—extrapolating statistical-mechanics-style laws from large groups of people the way thermodynamics works for gas atoms—fails because, unlike atoms that bump into each other linearly and have fluctuations cancel out, humans interact strongly and nonlinearly, so tiny fluctuations can be amplified, allowing individuals to strongly influence the whole.17 | Annalee Newitz on Science, Fiction, Economics, and Neurosis
- Beyond visual beauty, the way to dramatize psychohistory is not to depict the dryness of the predictions but to show how the predictions relate to people—who is fearful, who is hopeful, who thinks the math is being misused—and to explore the existential questions of determinism, free will, and individual agency that the predictions raise.172 | David Goyer on Televising the Fall of the Galactic Empire
- Asimov's psychohistory combines history, sociology, and statistics (akin to statistical physics for societies) to model and predict the behavior of vast groups while faltering with unpredictable individuals, inviting comparison with Carroll's ideas for a physics of democracy.AMA | Feb 2026