coincidence problem
The puzzle that dark energy density is the same order of magnitude as matter density today, despite their very different scaling over cosmic time.
As defined in 118 | Adam Riess on the Expansion of the Universe and a Crisis in Cosmology
Where it comes up · 6
- 358 | Solo: Vacuum Energy and the Cosmological Constant2 claims
- 359 | Solo: Theories of Dark Energy2 claims
- 118 | Adam Riess on the Expansion of the Universe and a Crisis in Cosmology1 claim
- 331 | Solo: Fine-Tuning, God, and the Multiverse1 claim
- AMA | February 20231 claim
- Mindscape Ask Me Anything, Sean Carroll | August 20261 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “coincidence problem” →
- The dark energy puzzle has two deep aspects: the cosmological constant is inexplicably small relative to natural expectations from gravity, and it is suspiciously the same order of magnitude as today's matter density (the coincidence problem), which leads some to invoke the anthropic principle and multiverse and others to conclude we simply lack a good current explanation—even though the idea fits a huge amount of data.118 | Adam Riess on the Expansion of the Universe and a Crisis in Cosmology
- When a feature of the universe (like dark energy's coincidence problem, the cosmological constant problem, the hierarchy problem, or inflation) seems unnatural or preposterous, it is never a criticism of the universe but a reminder that our expectations—set by some subset of what we observe—are wrong, signaling something we don't yet understand.AMA | February 2023
- The coincidence problem asks why the vacuum energy density is only three to five times the matter density today, when matter density dilutes with expansion while vacuum energy stays constant, so earlier matter dominated and later vacuum energy will dominate; this near-equality at the present era is suspicious and suggests an anthropic explanation unless a new physical mechanism is found.359 | Solo: Theories of Dark Energy
- Carroll argues that the anthropic principle is currently the best available solution to the cosmological constant and coincidence problems, even though it is messy, involves speculative physics, and is not known to be right.358 | Solo: Vacuum Energy and the Cosmological Constant
- In 1987 Steven Weinberg used anthropic reasoning—assuming a flat probability distribution over the tiny allowed window, using galaxy counts as a proxy for observers, and assuming we are typical observers—to predict the cosmological constant should be nonzero but comparable to the matter density (ratio between 0 and ~10); the eventually observed ratio of about 3 confirmed this a decade before measurement, showing anthropic reasoning can be genuinely predictive.331 | Solo: Fine-Tuning, God, and the Multiverse
- Matter density falls as the universe expands while vacuum energy density stays fixed, so vacuum energy would be invisible early and dominant late; that we live in the brief era when the two are comparable is the coincidence problem, which Carroll found very convincing.358 | Solo: Vacuum Energy and the Cosmological Constant
- It is intuitive that the most interesting dynamics occur near transitions, so life might plausibly have appeared between a regime where cosmic events wipe out fledgling life and one where sparsity makes life-sustaining confluences unlikely.Mindscape Ask Me Anything, Sean Carroll | August 2026
- Tracker models, in which the dark energy scalar field tracks the matter density over time, were proposed to explain the coincidence problem, but they did not become convincing and appear to be ruled out by data because the aspiration to explain more constrains models too severely.359 | Solo: Theories of Dark Energy