What this covers

Netta Engelhardt and Sean Carroll discuss the black hole information paradox—whether information genuinely vanishes when a black hole evaporates, as Steven Hawking's calculations seemed to suggest. The conversation traces the decades-long puzzle from its origins through recent breakthroughs, centering on two conceptual layers: the indirect argument that information must be conserved (derived from AdS/CFT correspondence), and the direct gravitational calculations that now demonstrate this conservation explicitly. Engelhardt explains why the paradox matters not for its own sake but as a window into quantum gravity's deep structure, and how recent work suggests that progress is possible without a complete theory of quantum gravity in hand.

The discussion ranges across what the gravitational path integral mysteriously "knows" about quantum information—computing the correct entropy and reproducing the Page Curve without being given the fundamental equations of quantum gravity. Engelhardt distinguishes between the indirect CFT argument for information conservation and the new direct calculations (2019 work by Geoff Penington and others) that show the radiation's entropy behaves correctly. The conversation also examines how wormholes appear in the gravitational path integral in ways that encode information conservation, and addresses the conceptual puzzle of how information escapes an event horizon while apparently respecting causality. Key ground includes Hawking radiation, the Holographic Principle, the status of spacetime as emergent, and whether resolving the paradox requires counting the microstates of black holes.

Sharpest takeaway

Engelhardt argues that recent calculations of the Page curve via the gravitational path integral show black hole evaporation conserves information without requiring a complete theory of quantum gravity, and that the path integral 'knows' more than it should—pointing the way toward understanding quantum gravity itself.

  • AdS/CFT shows information must be conserved because the boundary CFT never loses information, but this is an indirect argument
  • Direct gravitational calculations (Engelhardt-Wall entropy formula, Penington and Almheiri et al. 2019) reproduce the Page curve, the litmus test for information conservation
  • The gravitational path integral, even in semiclassical approximation including Euclidean wormholes, mysteriously computes information conservation, suggesting deep undiscovered structure in quantum gravity

The argument · threads9 threads · 40 claims
0.80

Black hole information loss would violate quantum mechanics' determinism and reversibility in a way burning books does not.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Throwing a book into a bonfire preserves information in principle—a sufficiently powerful computer tracking every particle could reconstruct the book from the light, heat, and ash—but black holes appear to be fundamentally different, which is why the information paradox is genuinely puzzling rather than merely a practical limitation.

    “you would be able, at the end of the day, to say, okay, well, the information about the book was somehow encoded in everything that came out of the fire. But black holes appear to be different.”

  • Information loss is catastrophic because physics is a predictive and postdictive science; if information is lost after a black hole evaporates, it becomes impossible to reverse-engineer the past state of the system, introducing a fundamental weakness into physics never observed before.

    “after the black hole has evaporated, it is impossible for us to reverse engineer what was happening some time ago. And so physics is no longer postdictive, as we call it, able to predict or postdict the past, which is truly catastrophic”

  • Quantum mechanics did not abandon determinism; although it gave up the idea that systems have definite states before measurement (as in the Schrodinger cat), a given quantum state still evolves deterministically into another quantum state, and this determinism is a unifying feature of all constructed theories to date.

    “we have not given up on determinism in the sense that a given quantum state evolves into some other quantum state by a process which we can describe. And so I would say that determinism is a unifying feature of everything that we have seen”

  • If you take Hawking's prediction that black holes evaporate seriously and follow the calculations, information (quantum bits/qubits) is lost from the universe altogether when the black hole disappears, which contradicts the basic laws of quantum mechanics that require information always be conserved.

    “classical general relativity can't be the right answer if black holes evaporate. If black holes didn't evaporate, it would be fine, right?”

  • Information loss is acceptable and reasonable when describing a subsystem of the universe (like particles escaping a tabletop experiment), but it is deeply troubling when the wave function describes the entire universe and information is still lost, because then there is nowhere for it to go.

    “The information loss is reasonable when you're looking at a sub-system, a subset, a wave function that describes some part of the universe rather than all of it. But it's more troubling when you are literally describing everything in the known universe”

0.75

Recent 2019 papers derived Page curve entropy directly from quantum gravity, confirming information conservation without assuming AdS/CFT.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Follow-up papers (the 'East Coast' and 'West Coast' groups) derived the radiation entropy formula in toy models without assuming the AdS/CFT correspondence, using only access to quantum gravity, which makes the result much more robust than being special to AdS/CFT and suggests physicists are on the right track to finding the actual mechanism by which information escapes.

    “they actually derive this formula, this calculation, not assuming the AdS/CFT correspondence. Which means that it is much more robust than just being special to AdS/CFT... suggests that we are on the right track to figuring out what is the exact mechanism”

  • In two simultaneous 2019 papers (one by Penington; one by Almheiri, Engelhardt, Maxfield, and Marolf), physicists computed the entropy of an evaporating black hole or its radiation directly in the quantum gravity theory and found it behaves consistent with information conservation—an explicit, non-trivial result that was not put in by hand, providing direct gravitational evidence rather than the indirect CFT argument.

    “we did a calculation in the quantum gravity theory in the box... that in fact, showed, we calculated the entropy and this calculation showed that the entropy actually behaves in a way that is consistent with information conservation”

  • For a long time physicists believed resolving any aspect of the information paradox required a complete first-principles theory of quantum gravity, but the miraculous aspect of the past year-and-a-half of developments is that tremendous progress has been made without needing access to the deep mysterious regime of quantum gravity.

    “we actually have not needed that kind of access to this deep mysterious regime of quantum gravity in order to be able to make tremendous progress on the black hole information paradox. And that's what's been causing so much excitement”

  • The Page curve, attributed to Don Page, is the behavior where the entropy of the radiation first increases and then decreases back to zero as the black hole fully evaporates—reflecting ignorance growing then vanishing as all information escapes—and serves as the litmus test for information conservation, in contrast to Hawking's calculation where entropy monotonically increases and stays high.

    “this type of behavior where the entropy first increases and then decreases is something called the... It's attributed to Don Page, it's something called the Page Curve, which is what we think of it as a litmus test for information conservation.”

0.75

The gravitational path integral mysteriously produces the correct entropy and information-conservation results despite lacking apparent access to fundamental quantum gravity equations.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • The gravitational path integral mysteriously 'knows' information it has no apparent right to: without inputting the fundamental equations or states of quantum gravity, it correctly computes a black hole's entropy and number of microstates, and the new result is that it also encodes information conservation when computing the radiation entropy—yet why and how it knows this is not understood.

    “it knows a lot more than it has any right to. We don't know why it knows all of this... you didn't put in the underlying fundamental equations of quantum gravity into it... it just kind of knows. It knows what the entropy of a black hole is. It knows the number of microstates.”

  • The gravitational path integral generalizes Feynman's idea by summing over all possible spacetime geometries with a fixed boundary—including shapes that don't solve Einstein's equations—where solutions to the Einstein equation give the large dominant 'classical' contributions.

    “In the gravitational theory, we're talking about all possible geometries, all possible spacetime shapes that have a fixed boundary... we sum over all of these possible contributions without worrying about whether this spacetime solves the equations of Einstein's theory of general relativity or not.”

  • The required inclusion of Euclidean wormholes in the gravitational path integral is mysterious and has prompted suggestions that gravity may be described not by a single quantum theory but by a collection of theories—an ensemble—with some kind of averaging happening to obtain gravity; these hypotheses are under active development and reflect a fundamental insight into quantum gravity arising from the information paradox work.

    “there's a possibility that, really, gravity is described by a collection of quantum theories, what we call an ensemble, rather than a single theory. There have been suggestions of some kind of... That there is some kind of an averaging that is happening in order to obtain gravity”

  • The key next step is to understand why the gravitational path integral knows the right answer and what it is actually computing behind the scenes—asking it the right questions and finding a way to reproduce information conservation directly from the physics of quantum gravity without relying on the path integral—in order to give a complete description of how an outside observer with mirrors and beam splitters would see information escape.

    “we have ascertained the path integral knows the answer... and we need to ask ourselves why. What is it actually calculating?... How do we compute that without using the gravitational path integral? How do we see it directly from the physics of quantum gravity?”

0.71

AdS/CFT correspondence shows information is conserved in the boundary field theory, implying it is also conserved in the equivalent bulk gravity theory.

6 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The AdS/CFT correspondence states that quantum gravity in a box (Anti-de Sitter space) with a given number of dimensions is exactly equivalent to a conformal field theory with no gravity living in one fewer dimension on the boundary, with a dictionary relating processes in each—so a four-dimensional gravitational theory and a three-dimensional non-gravitational quantum field theory are secretly the same theory.

    “it also admits a completely different description in terms of a theory that lives in one fewer dimension and has no gravity at all. It's just a quantum field theory... there is a dictionary that relates processes and object in this quantum field theory to processes and constructs in the quantum gravity theory”

  • Knowing from AdS/CFT that information is conserved is not enough to resolve the paradox—physicists could just as well have declared it conserved by fiat; a genuine resolution requires an explicit calculation showing the mechanism, in particular showing the entropy of the radiation starts at some value and returns to it, which is the hallmark of information conservation.

    “we could just as easily have all sat down in some secret cabal meeting and decided we all say information is conserved, so be it. But in order to have a resolution to this problem, we need to actually say how, how it happens.”

  • Although AdS/CFT was initially derived as a consequence of certain string theory constructions, the accumulated strong evidence now lets physicists treat it as a conjecture independent of string theory; it takes inspiration from string theory and is compatible with it, but does not rely on it.

    “today, we have seen so much strong evidence in favor of AdS/CFT that we take it to be a conjecture that's in some sense independent of string theory, although certainly they are compatible with one another... I would not say that AdS/CFT relies on string theory.”

  • The AdS/CFT correspondence has passed numerous highly non-trivial checks—where calculations can be done on both the gravity and CFT sides in the appropriate limits, they agree—but it has not been proven, partly because we do not fully know what quantum gravity in Anti-de Sitter space is independently of the CFT.

    “in cases where we can calculate things on both sides of the duality, they do agree... We have not proven it and we do need to be careful about that, but there is, in my mind... I feel fairly confident that AdS/CFT... by and large that the correspondence is genuine and correct.”

  • Because the boundary conformal field theory in AdS/CFT manifestly conserves information—its entropy never changes under time evolution—and it is equivalent to the bulk quantum gravity theory, it follows conclusively that information is not lost in quantum gravity (in AdS) even though we don't know how to fix Hawking's calculation directly.

    “if in this quantum field theory, information is not lost, then it is also not lost in the quantum gravity. No matter how much we may not understand how to fix Hawking's calculation, it nevertheless gives us the conclusive answer that information is not lost in quantum gravity”

  • Engelhardt is a proponent of the view that quantum gravity admits a description independent of the conformal field theory, and resists simply defining quantum gravity in Anti-de Sitter space as the CFT; she argues we should keep looking for an independent description in variables that more naturally give rise to general relativity in the appropriate limit, which would provide a genuine independent check.

    “there are some people who are simply saying quantum gravity should simply be... in Anti-de Sitter space, should simply be defined as this conformal field theory, and I think that I'm not ready to jump on that just yet... we should still be looking for an independent description of quantum gravity”

0.53

Classical black holes have no entropy by the no-hair theorem, yet quantum gravity assigns them entropy through mechanisms still not fully understood.

5 pointscentrality 3/5
  • In classical general relativity, black holes are completely described by a few simple quantities like mass, charge, and spin (the no-hair property), so there is no uncertainty about them and hence mathematically no entropy—making it puzzling how they can have entropy at all.

    “black holes don't... That they're completely described by certain simple quantities that you can measure, like their mass... there is no uncertainty about the black hole if you know, say, its mass... And there being no uncertainty in a mathematical way means that it has no entropy.”

  • Hawking originally set out to show that black holes do not actually have a temperature and that the entropy analogy was purely an analogy, but his calculation ended up showing the opposite—that black holes literally are thermal objects with a genuine temperature and entropy.

    “I believe that Hawking in fact set out to show that black holes do not actually have a temperature... And what he ended up showing was actually quite the opposite, that they literally are thermal objects with a temperature and an entropy.”

  • Jacob Bekenstein, as a graduate student under Wheeler, resolved the puzzle of how throwing a hot cup of tea into a black hole could decrease the universe's entropy (seemingly violating the second law) by proposing that black holes must themselves have entropy, even though classical general relativity says they have none, and that this entropy must arise from some deep quantum gravity mechanism.

    “eventually, he suggested that, actually, it must be the case that black holes have entropy. And even though general relativity doesn't seem to think so, that entropy must be a result of some deep quantum gravity mechanism”

  • While in certain cases physicists have been able to directly count black hole microstates (given agreement on the counting method and framework), for general dynamical black holes that change with time, what the microstates actually are remains unknown and is a problem that will have to be solved.

    “in general, dynamical black holes, meaning black holes that change with time, I don't know. I don't know the answer to that, and I think it's something that we are going to have to solve sooner or later.”

  • Entropy is best understood intuitively as a measure of ignorance about a system—you might know macroscopic quantities like temperature and volume but not the location and behavior of every molecule, and entropy quantifies that ignorance about the unknown aspects given what you do know.

    “I would like to think of entropy as a measure of ignorance of some system... ignorance about some aspect of the system you're interested in, given that you might know some other things.”

0.47

Spacetime is not fundamental but an emergent approximate description that breaks down microscopically, making information conservation non-obvious.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Because the event horizon is defined as a boundary from which nothing can escape, getting information from inside the black hole out into the radiation appears to require a process that does not respect causality, yet quantum gravity somehow manages to place the interior information outside the horizon despite this apparent violation.

    “There has to be some kind of a... It would appear to have to be some kind of a process that doesn't respect causality, in order for information that went into the black hole to end up in the radiation.”

  • Spacetime is not fundamental but an approximate, convenient description that emerges when viewed from far away; if you zoom in enough it breaks down, and more radically, holography implies the same physical situation can have multiple very different spacetime descriptions, so spacetime cannot be the central or fundamental ingredient of physics.

    “the spacetime is not fundamental... it's an approximate notion that we see when we're looking at it from far away”

  • The holographic principle holds that all the information about gravity in a region of spacetime is encoded on the lower-dimensional boundary of that region—analogous to describing everything in a room just by examining its walls—an idea born from the fact that a black hole's entropy can be computed from quantities measured only on its event horizon boundary.

    “even though it seems very strange, all of the information about gravity in some part of the spacetime is encoded on the boundary of it... the entropy of a black hole... is something that you can compute knowing... Only by measuring only quantities that are on its boundary, on the event horizon.”

  • Ordinary quantum field theory allows an infinite number of degrees of freedom and hence infinite entanglement entropy in any box, but a black hole—the most you can fit in a region—has only finite entropy, suggesting that in regions where gravity matters there are only finitely many possible things that can happen because quantum gravity does not permit a continuum of space.

    “a black hole, which is supposed to be the most we can fit in a region, only has a finite entropy, and that suggests... that there's only a finite number of things that can happen in a region of space where black holes are possible”

0.34

Understanding the information paradox is valuable primarily for the broader insights it teaches about quantum gravity, not for its own sake.

4 pointscentrality 2/5
  • There is a theorem in quantum information that entanglement alone cannot be used to transmit information; sending information requires supplementing entanglement with classical communication that travels no faster than light, so the quantum non-locality of entanglement is insufficient to explain how information escapes a black hole.

    “there is a theorem in quantum information which tells you that you cannot use entanglement alone to send information... You have to supplement it with what is known as classical communication. Which is to say something that does not travel faster than light”

  • There is currently no empirical experiment that can determine whether information is conserved or lost in black hole evaporation, though recent theoretical developments point toward conservation, and many physicists prefer conservation because it keeps the principles of quantum mechanics intact.

    “classical general relativity can't be the right answer if black holes evaporate. If black holes didn't evaporate, it would be fine, right?”

  • The reason physicists care about the information paradox is that a paradox in quantum gravity is a signal that we are thinking about something wrong; resolving it is valuable not for its own sake but because it is expected to teach us much more about the nature of quantum gravity, and recent progress confirms this hope is starting to be realized.

    “having a paradox in quantum gravity is telling us that there's something we're thinking about wrong. So this is going to tell us a lot more about quantum gravity.”

  • Most working physicists do not worry much about the foundations of quantum mechanics; Engelhardt describes herself as occasionally worrying but mostly falling into the camp of not caring and just thinking about black holes.

    “most working physicists don't worry that much about the foundations of quantum mechanics... Sometimes, I worry, but most of the time, I don't worry... Most of the time, I fall into the latter category.”

0.24

Spacetime wormholes appearing in entropy calculations differ fundamentally from spatial ER=EPR wormholes; their role in information escape remains unclear.

2 pointscentrality 2/5
  • The wormholes relevant to the recent results are spacetime (Euclidean) wormholes that appear in the calculation of the entropy of Hawking radiation, not as the physical spacetime on which radiation propagates; Engelhardt is therefore hesitant to claim these wormholes provide the mechanism by which information escapes, though she acknowledges others disagree.

    “these wormholes, the way that they contribute is in a calculation of the entropy rather than as a description of the spacetime on which the information is propagating... I would be hesitant to say that these wormholes are giving us the mechanism via which information gets out.”

  • The Susskind-Maldacena ER=EPR wormholes connecting entangled particles are spatial wormholes existing in space at a single moment in time, whereas the wormholes in the recent entropy calculations are spacetime wormholes extended in time that appear only in the entropy computation; the two are qualitatively different phenomena with no clear, obvious relationship.

    “Lenny and Juan's wormholes are what we call spatial wormholes... The wormholes that are discussed in the context of the gravitational path integral... are not like that. These are what are called spacetime wormholes. These are wormholes that are extended in time”

0.05

The black hole information paradox historically progresses in episodic bursts of insight rather than sustained accumulation of work.

1 pointcentrality 1/5
  • Progress on the black hole information paradox historically comes in waves: long silent periods where it is merely kept in mind, punctuated by sudden insights that trigger frantic short bursts of activity as everyone hopes the paradox will finally be solved, before dying down again until the next insight.

    “I would describe progress on the black hole information paradox as something that comes in waves... someone will have some insight... And that'll result in some frantic activity for a short amount of time... And it sort of dies out for a while until it gets revised by some new insight.”