gravitational path integral
An approach to quantum gravity in which you compute amplitudes by summing over all possible spacetime geometries connecting an initial and final configuration, weighted appropriately; in gravity it mysteriously 'knows' things like black hole entropy that the state-counting approach cannot reproduce.
As defined in 349 | Daniel Harlow on What Quantum Gravity Teaches Us About Quantum Mechanics
Where it comes up · 2
- 115 | Netta Engelhardt on Black Hole Information, Wormholes, and Quantum Gravity6 claims
- 349 | Daniel Harlow on What Quantum Gravity Teaches Us About Quantum Mechanics3 claims
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “gravitational path integral” →
- Unlike ordinary quantum mechanics where the path integral and canonical (matrix) approaches are equivalent, in gravity the path integral is stronger: by summing over geometries (as Gibbons and Hawking showed in the late 1970s) it correctly knows the number of degrees of freedom and entropy of a black hole without ever counting states, something the canonical formalism cannot reproduce.349 | Daniel Harlow on What Quantum Gravity Teaches Us About Quantum Mechanics
- The gravitational path integral generalizes Feynman's idea by summing over all possible spacetime geometries with a fixed boundary—including shapes that don't solve Einstein's equations—where solutions to the Einstein equation give the large dominant 'classical' contributions.115 | Netta Engelhardt on Black Hole Information, Wormholes, and Quantum Gravity
- Applying black hole methods (path integral counting and holography) to count the degrees of freedom of a whole closed universe gives the answer zero — equivalently, a one-dimensional Hilbert space — because holography says fundamental degrees of freedom live on the spatial boundary, and a closed universe has no spatial boundary; multiple independent calculations developed for black holes quantitatively confirm this.349 | Daniel Harlow on What Quantum Gravity Teaches Us About Quantum Mechanics
- Follow-up papers (the 'East Coast' and 'West Coast' groups) derived the radiation entropy formula in toy models without assuming the AdS/CFT correspondence, using only access to quantum gravity, which makes the result much more robust than being special to AdS/CFT and suggests physicists are on the right track to finding the actual mechanism by which information escapes.115 | Netta Engelhardt on Black Hole Information, Wormholes, and Quantum Gravity
- The gravitational path integral mysteriously 'knows' information it has no apparent right to: without inputting the fundamental equations or states of quantum gravity, it correctly computes a black hole's entropy and number of microstates, and the new result is that it also encodes information conservation when computing the radiation entropy—yet why and how it knows this is not understood.115 | Netta Engelhardt on Black Hole Information, Wormholes, and Quantum Gravity
- Hartle and Hawking's wave function of the universe employed the trick of computing the gravitational path integral over all Euclidean (purely spatial, time-removed) geometries rather than all spacetimes to obtain finite answers; though originally a poorly-justified mathematical trick in quantum gravity, physicists have become more comfortable using the Euclidean path integral, and it is the framework in which the recent entropy wormholes appear.115 | Netta Engelhardt on Black Hole Information, Wormholes, and Quantum Gravity
- The wormholes relevant to the recent results are spacetime (Euclidean) wormholes that appear in the calculation of the entropy of Hawking radiation, not as the physical spacetime on which radiation propagates; Engelhardt is therefore hesitant to claim these wormholes provide the mechanism by which information escapes, though she acknowledges others disagree.115 | Netta Engelhardt on Black Hole Information, Wormholes, and Quantum Gravity
- The gravitational path integral should be treated like the Oracle at Delphi: it gives you correct answers when consulted, but you do not always understand what those answers mean, and misinterpreting them can be fatal — so one should seek a more fundamental framework from which the path integral's consequences can be derived rather than treating it as the end of the story.349 | Daniel Harlow on What Quantum Gravity Teaches Us About Quantum Mechanics
- The key next step is to understand why the gravitational path integral knows the right answer and what it is actually computing behind the scenes—asking it the right questions and finding a way to reproduce information conservation directly from the physics of quantum gravity without relying on the path integral—in order to give a complete description of how an outside observer with mirrors and beam splitters would see information escape.115 | Netta Engelhardt on Black Hole Information, Wormholes, and Quantum Gravity