
What this covers
This is a long one-on-one conversation between Shane Parrish and Howard Marks, co-founder of Oaktree Capital. It starts with investing and then moves into economics, politics, and family life. Marks's core investing ideas come up repeatedly. Second-Level Thinking holds that beating the market means diverging from consensus and being right. That requires a Willingness to Look Stupid. He also argues that being average is easy: an S&P 500 index fund guarantees you won't fall below average, and it also guarantees you won't rise above it. If everyone already expects a good event, such as a strong new Mustang, the price has absorbed it, so the company does well while investors don't.
On risk, Marks rejects the academic equation of risk with volatility. He says volatility is used only because it can be measured, and that risk is really the probability of bad outcomes. Managing it means forming a view of the probability distribution of what might happen. He adds that expected value alone isn't enough, because some outcomes can't be survived. He also separates decision quality from outcome quality, since improbable things happen often. On cycles, he says investor psychology swings between "perfect" and "no chance of survival," while real conditions only move between "pretty good" and "not so hot." The 2008 crisis, which ended with Lehman Brothers failing on September 15, is presented as an episode of excess credulity about mortgages.
The conversation then moves into more contested ground. Marks explains who actually pays a tariff and describes the unintended harm of steel tariffs to manufacturers that use steel. He argues that automation has cost far more manufacturing jobs than trade with China, and he forecasts that self-driving cars will cut jobs well beyond driving. He also claims that governments redistribute wealth rather than create it, so "fair share" is a philosophical question, and that politicians promise what economics says can't be had without trade-offs. The last stretch covers parenting: letting children make real choices, teaching them that money is finite, letting them make small mistakes early, and the family values Marks wants to pass on.
Marks argues that superior investment returns and sound decision-making require thinking differently from the crowd while being right, managing emotions through process and culture, and understanding that cycles driven by human psychology—not deterministic laws—create both risks and opportunities.
- Markets are driven by people's emotions and psychology, not rational actors; cycles result from excesses and corrections that are inherent to human behavior
- Superior investing requires second-level thinking that diverges from consensus while being correct, which demands emotional discipline, contrarian conviction, and willingness to look wrong
- Understanding risk as the probability of bad outcomes—not volatility—and recognizing the difference between decision quality and outcome quality is essential to long-term success
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The quality of a decision cannot be determined from its outcome because improbable things happen frequently and probable things fail to happen regularly, so a good decision can produce a bad outcome and a bad decision can produce a good outcome due to luck.
“I started Wharton 55 years ago last month and the first thing I remember learning there is that you can't tell the quality of a decision from the outcome... you need some crazy number to win and you get it that doesn't mean you're a good player means you were lucky and he always says that improbable things happen all the time and probable things fail to happen all the time because the world is in uncertain place you know if the things that were probable happened all the time there were in theory there would be no risk”
Investment decisions should be based on expected value (probability-weighted outcomes), but some possible outcomes under high expected value strategies may be unsurvivable, so expected value alone is an insufficient decision criterion without considering risk tolerance.
“in economics we make decisions based on what's called the expected value which is you enumerate the possibilities you assign probabilities you figure out which course of action has the highest probability weighting weighted value but some may be the action which has the high expected value includes some possible outcomes which are unsurvivable you know probably the the the activity which could produce the highest expected level of elation for me might be Clift I think I don't like the bad outcomes so I'm not going to engage in cliff diving and similarly the highest returning investment activity might be venture capital investing and somewhere in the probability distribution for any venture capital fund investment is the possibility that all the investments turn out to be valueless so if I'm a conservative investor I'm not going to do that”
Teaching children about money requires discussing responsible financial decisions rather than treating money as taboo, teaching that money is finite and resources must be allocated through choices, and giving children tools (like paying their own credit card bills) to experience real financial consequences.
“we always talked about money not in some not like it's you know the altar of money on which we have to lay ourselves down but we talked about responsible financial decision... one of the most important things to have kids who function well around money is for them to have a feeling of finiteness and this goes back really to economic reality... they should understand that money is finite no matter how much money you have you can get in trouble if you spend too much of it and and but since it's finite you shouldn't waste it you should make good decisions... when our daughter went off to college we said here's your credit card... when the bill comes in you pay the credit card bill”
Tariffs on steel and aluminum create unintended consequences: while protecting American steel makers, they harm American manufacturers who use steel (like motorcycle makers) by raising their input costs, putting them at a disadvantage relative to foreign competitors and other American manufacturers using cheaper foreign steel.
“you put a tariff on imports of steel and aluminum to protect American manufacturers of steel aluminum but that means that American manufacturers of motorcycles are added who use foreign steel are at a disadvantage relative to American manufacturers of motorcycles who use domestic steel you want to disadvantage some American country companies relative to others and they're at a disadvantage relative to foreign motorcycle manufacturers”
Risk exists because the future is uncertain and is a range of possibilities; sometimes we know what's in that range and sometimes we don't; managing risk requires developing a view of the probability distribution of future events.
“risk exists because the future is a range of possibilities... risk means more things can happen than will which is a brilliant summation but risk exists because the future is uncertain there's a range of possibilities... sometimes we don't even know what's in the range in answer to your question and sometimes we think we do sometimes we're right about that sometimes we're wrong but I think clearly the upshot is that in order to manage risk you have to have a view of what the probability distribution of future events looks like”
If everyone knows a positive development will occur (like Ford launching a great new Mustang), then that knowledge is already incorporated into the stock price, so the actual event will be favorable for the company but not profitable for investors.
“my son and when he was training as a young investor... he would say well you know we should buy the stock afford because they're bringing out this new Mustang it's gonna be terrific and I always for pedagogical purposes answered him the same way who doesn't know that see let's say Ford is going to bring out of a Mustang and it's going to be fabulous but if everybody knows it then the expectation of the success of that car is already reflected in the price of that stock and the event will not be a profitable it'll be favorable for Ford but it will not be profitable for investors”
Parents should resist the urge to give children everything their friends have because it removes the child's motivation to do better, sets a bad tone based on peer comparison rather than values, and builds character through learning to make constrained choices.
“some people think that a good parent gives all they can but it's bad to have the what the what the kid who has the most it's bad to let that kid set the tone for what your kids should have and it builds character to have some to say no in our family we don't do that or in our family we don't spend our money that way or our family decided to take a trip to Paris rather than buy one of those these are these are good letting kids make responsible decisions and choices and stuff like that and insulating kids from choices is not doing them a favor”
Parents should let children make consequential choices (like school selection) without parental interference and should trust children to decide, which develops decision-making capability and builds confidence through parental trust.
“I would buys young parents if there are if it is a choice to be made and the two choices let's say are both non-lethal let the child make the choice you know when our daughter our daughter got into two schools for high school we wanted to go to one but we never said a word she chose the other one she went she did fine and number one maybe the child can make a good decision and number two experience in making decisions is important and number three having your parents tell you we trust you to make that decision is really very positive for a child's development”
Being wrong is inevitable in any activity whose outcome depends on unknown futures; baseball players don't bat a thousand and investors shouldn't expect 100% success; the focus should be on having a good process, not on eliminating mistakes.
“being wrong is inevitable and normal not some terrible tragedy not some awful failing and reasoning not even bad luck in most instances being wrong comes with the franchise of an activity whose outcome depends on an unknown future no baseball player expects to bat a thousand investors shouldn't which means they shouldn't get down on themselves if they make a mistake as long as they Rhian their process and it was good”
Automation and job displacement driven by productivity increases have reduced manufacturing employment from 19 million to 12 million while output has doubled over 40 years, meaning 24 million jobs have been lost to productivity gains (not trade), which dwarfs the 3 million lost to China.
“our manufacturing output in this country has doubled and we don't think ourselves as being great manufacturers... we sell in measured in dollar terms... we sell twice as much today as we did 40 years ago and 40 years ago I think we had about 19 million people working in manufacturing today we have 12 so we have twice the outcome output with 1/3 less workers which means that the output per worker has tripled... if the output per worker hadn't tripled we'd have three times as many workers right making the same amount of goods rather than twelve we'd have 36 million employed in manufacturing... I wrote if you want to solve the problem all you have to do is ban gay in productivity but of course that would be silly... we have probably lost 24 million jobs to increasing productivity over the last 40 years compared to 3 million that went to China”
Self-driving cars will eliminate not just driving jobs (truckers, taxi drivers, bus drivers) but also downstream jobs in body shops, paint shops, steel production, and insurance adjusting because autonomous vehicles will have no accidents, requiring less maintenance and replacement.
“not only will they put I mean this is a utopian world that may be decades away but not only will they put all the taxi drivers bus drivers truck drivers limo drivers out of business but think about the body shops because computer car self-driven cars won't have any accidents and the paint shops and the steel because they'll require less so tonight and the insurance companies because you know you won't need insurance adjustor since there won't be any accidents to inspect”
In the investment world, investor psychology swings from thinking things are 'perfect' to 'no chance of survival,' whereas in the real world conditions fluctuate only between 'pretty good' and 'not so hot'—this psychological exaggeration is what drives market cycles.
“in the real world things fluctuate by between pretty good and not so hot but in there in the investment world investors go from you know perfect to no chance of survival in their psychology”
Globalization and specialization maximize world production because each country/entity produces what it's best at, creating mutual advantage, but trade tariffs that attempt to protect domestic industries reduce overall efficiency by preventing specialization and creating unintended consequences for other industries.
“the greatest contributor to global economic maximization is globalization you know I mean let's say you have two countries mine and yours and we're really good at raising sheep and you're really good at turning leather into shoes and so we braised the sheep and when they're ready we send the hides to you and you make the leather into shoes and we and this system produces a hundred pairs of shoes a year and then some politician a Rexha wall no more trade in sheep leather or shoes now I have to I'm good at raising sheep but I have to try to learn how to make shoes friend and you are good at making shoes but you have to learn how to raise sheep to get the leather yeah and so in this new world I can only produce 40 pairs of shoes and you can only produce 40 pairs of shoes”
Moral values that guide family culture should include respecting others, caring for others, wanting good for others, being part of team efforts, following the Golden Rule (do unto others), and being liked and respected for good reasons.
“in our family we we respect others and we care for others and we want good for others in our family it's not about getting to the front of the line and it's not about succeeding at the expense of others we want to be part of a team effort... we want to be part of a team effort which brings success to everybody and it's not about it getting ahead of the others and you know if you go out and do a great job you'll be successful and kindness and you know the Golden Rule do unto others as you would have them do unto you is is very relevant and you know the importance of being good people and being liked and for good reasons and respected”
Very few Americans understand basic economics like what tariffs are, who bears the cost of tariffs, or how they create unintended consequences, suggesting that economic literacy is prerequisite for informed political discourse but is largely absent.
“what percent of let's say Americans understand economics I mean it's economics is really convoluted and what percentage of people all right now we have tariffs been they've been tariffs in the headlines for the last six nine months how many people understand what a tariff is how many people understand that the Chinese don't pay the tariffs Americans pay the tariffs”
Nations cannot unilaterally set tax rates without reference to the tax rates of other countries, because high tax rates incentivize capital and businesses to move elsewhere, as demonstrated by the U.S. corporate tax rate reduction and wealthy individuals relocating from high-tax jurisdictions like France and New Jersey.
“a nation cannot or shouldn't set its tax rates without reference to the tax rates in the rest of the world one of the reasons we had to reduce our corporate tax rate is that our corporate tax rate was high relative to rest the world which meant which gave businesses and an incentive to establish themselves elsewhere or move elsewhere to escape u.s. taxation... I think was Hollande put a seventy five percent tax rate on the wealthiest Frenchman they move away this is economic reality in action”
Tariffs are paid by consumers of imported goods through higher prices, not by foreign countries, so American tariffs on Chinese goods mean U.S. consumers pay higher prices at retailers like Walmart, not Chinese manufacturers losing revenue.
“Chinese don't pay tariffs tariffs are paid by consumers of goods we have collected billions in tariffs from US consumers of Chinese goods paying higher price... everything in Walmart just went up”
Being average in investing is easy and low-risk; you can achieve S&P 500 returns with an index fund at low cost, and this guarantees you won't be below average but prevents being above average.
“the goal in investing investing is a funny activity it's really incredibly easy to be average and an average is usually not too bad and if you're willing to settle for average you can do it with very little risk and very little very choosy very little risk of being below average and very little cost you buy what's called an index fund... it's really easy to be average... you're not investing time either right but no same time cost and you're absolutely guaranteed against falling short at the expense of not being able to exceed”
As one ages, self-perception becomes more important than how others perceive you; unhappiness at life's end comes from regret about how one led one's life, which represents a 'terrible tragedy' that could have been prevented through deliberate choices.
“when you get to be my age you Eric Erickson the psychologist wrote about the stages of man and you you think in terms of how are you thought of it's very important to you but when you get to be my age it's too late to change how your thought of and then ultimately how do you think of yourself and you know you when I think of people who get close to the end and are unhappy with how they led their lives I think it's a terrible tragedy”
Governments don't create wealth; they only redistribute it by making taxation and spending decisions, so questions about 'fair share' for the rich are fundamentally philosophical rather than economic because there is no objective definition of fairness in taxation.
“governments don't make anything all they do is redistribute all they do you know we have these millions of people working in Washington and all these senators in Congress all they really do is they collect money and they spend it they don't make it... and there are people who say that we have too much inequality and it should be fixed and there are people who say that the way to fix it is to get the rich to pay their share now I kind of bridle at that because it seems like a religious or philosophical statement it's not an economic statement there is no such thing as a fair share and and the only question is who determines the fair share”
Political reality differs fundamentally from economic reality: politicians promise solutions without cost ('you can have it all'), but economics is the science of choices and constraints, requiring trade-offs that politicians can promise without legal consequence.
“political reality is totally different from economic reality the politician says I can get you everything you want without any sacrifice it's not gonna cost you anything vote for me and you can have you can have it all you don't have to choose economics if you think about it is really the science of choices and clearly it's not true but people can say anything on the stump they want and you can't sue a politician for for making a promise that he didn't come through with”
Risk in academic investment theory is defined as volatility of prices/returns, but risk should really be defined as the probability of bad outcomes; volatility is used only because it's measurable historically, not because it's correct.
“in academic investment theory they say it's volatility the volatility of prices the volatility of returns now I believe and that was a view basically developed in the new theory of investing... they there are all these processes in equations which concern risk and return... you need to plug something in for risk and they plug the in volatility now I don't think volatility is risk I think but I think risk is the probability of bad outcomes but why did they use volatility because it exists you can say how volatile was this asset or asset class in the past and we'll extrapolate to the future and if if you don't use volatility there's no other number available”
The financial crisis grew out of excesses in credulous belief in mortgages and mortgage-backed securities, which were invested too heavily and riskily by financial institutions, creating systemic precariousness that culminated in the bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers on September 15, 2008.
“the excesses were basically you know a willing suspension of disbelief an excess of credulous 'no stand you know there was too much faith in mortgages and mortgage-backed securities and they were invested too heavily and to riskily by essential financial institutions which then became precarious and you know you had Bear Stearns and Merrill Lynch in Wachovia Bank and what Washington Mutual all disappear or require rescues and it culminated in the bankruptcy of Lehman Brothers on September 15 2008”
Children should make their first mistakes early (at age 5 rather than 35) with low-stakes consequences so they learn that mistakes don't kill you and develop resilience; insulating children from mistakes fails to prepare them for adulthood.
“your kids will make mistakes hopefully not lethal ones and insulating them from making mistakes is not doing them a favor because if they make their first mistake at five and they improve their decision-making process and they learn that mistakes don't kill you that's a good thing and if they make their first mistake at thirty five and it crushes them because they're not prepared for that then that's a bad outcome and too close on the Soviet I'd like to read you a paragraph from the book it yeah I'm gonna I'm gonna go get it just become for now my favorite paragraph in the book it's also the next-to-last as Peter Bernstein said the future is not ours to know but it helps to know that being wrong is inevitable and normal not some terrible tragedy”
Unlike previous technological displacements (agriculture to autos to information), current automation appears fundamentally different because the jobs being eliminated will be replaced by machines, not by new human-intensive industries, raising the question of what displaced workers will do.
“this is different about this one that the causes need to be the less optimistic see it's the march of technology and is it the share volume yes number of people displaced it's the well it's the volume of people displaced and the fact that their jobs will not be done by other people they'll be done by machines and who were doing the matter at equivalent or better level than they were and much faster”
Universal basic income would address physical needs (food, clothing) but wouldn't solve society's core problems because people derive substantial psychological and social benefits from work (team membership, accomplishment, dignity, purpose) that unconditional income cannot provide.
“we get a lot more from our work than just our income because we feel like we're part of something well we don't think we get self-satisfaction and we understand that we are able to do things we understand that we are producing our own subsistence and we have colleagues you know we have a team effort we work together with others on things and we accomplish them... universal basic income will not give those benefits it'll only feed the physical needs and you know so number one there was a big debate under Clinton about welfare and we reduced welfare because we thought it gave bad incentives and got people into bad habits and I think that's probably right and universal basic income probably would do so”
In a free enterprise system, there must be both winners and losers, and attempting to eliminate losing outcomes through policy creates worse problems than accepting that some people will lose while ensuring they don't suffer catastrophically.
“we don't want anybody to lose right I mean that's part of the issue well we don't know some don't want anybody to lose you know I had a stepmother who thought everybody should get a vacation in Las Vegas in a color TV or I would rather say we don't want anybody to any of the losers and of course it's hard to use that word but losers in this process to suffer right you have to have winners and losers”
Even if you know a probability distribution exactly (like with dice: 6 ways to roll a 7 out of 36 outcomes), you still don't know what will happen on any given roll; probability describes tendency, not prediction.
“I use the example of a craps table and ooh Bruce and I play backgammon all the time backgammon is is is run by dice so you throw two dice and there are 36 possible outcomes each die has six sides six times 6 36 and we know a hundred percent certainty what's possible you're gonna get one of those outcomes... there are six combinations that give seven... there are five combinations that give six and five that give eight... we still don't know what's going to happen right it's only what the tendency would be on a given role and probably if you do enough experiments in the long run that's what you'll get if you roll a thousand dice a thousand times 6:36 the the outcomes will be seven yeah but in one roll and you have no idea”
First-level thinking ('this is a great company, buy the stock') is simplistic and widely held, while second-level thinking ('this is a great company but it's priced for even more greatness than will occur, so sell it') is more complex and counterintuitive, which is why few investors engage in it.
“the first level thing then this is the this is the simplest and the clearest the first level thinker says this is a great company we should buy the stock the second level thinker says it's it's a great company but it's not as great as everybody thinks the the opinions which are incorporated in the price are too optimistic and when it turns out that the two out the mysticum when the truth comes out those hopes are going to be dashed the price is going to fall so we should sell the stock now clearly the first level thinker is simplistic good company buy the stock the second level thinking requires a more convoluted discussion many more words more time a lot of the concepts of second level thinking are by definition counterintuitive which by definition elude most people that's the definition of counterintuitive so it's not easy but it is a necessary condition for for being superior”
The Federal Reserve has been charged for more than 100 years with controlling inflation to keep the economy on an even keel, but in recent decades (30-40 years) was also given responsibility for supporting employment, creating a problematic situation where economic growth to support employment can cause inflation that has to be reined in.
“the feds central banks which is what the Fed is have for more than a hundred years basically been charged with controlling inflation that is the number one job keep the economy on an even keel so that it grows but not overheats causing inflation that has to be reined in in the more recent years maybe 30 40 years ago the Fed was given another responsibility which is to support employment now this is problematic because employment growth comes from economic growth that's good too much economic growth you get rising inflation that's bad so they they have two goals which are in opposition”
Oaktree invested at an average rate of $650 million per week for the last 15 weeks of 2008, totaling $10 billion, while the financial system did not melt down, which was described as the best possible environment for investing and a vindication of the decision-making framework.
“and so we started to invest and sometimes we thought we were going too fast and sometimes we thought we were going too slow but for the last 15 weeks of '08 we invested in an average of 650 million a week for a total of 10 billion and the financial world did not meltdown isn't”
We have made substantial global progress in reducing extreme poverty, and people living in poverty today have better quality of life than most people had 200 years ago, though this doesn't eliminate the problem that work provides psychological and social benefits beyond income.
“the number has been coming down and and the other thing is that I think that people who live in what we describe as poverty poverty today it might be even better than most people lived 200 years ago terms of quality of life but the problem is that we get a lot more from our work than just our income”
The decision to invest during the financial crisis was based on the logic that (1) it is impossible to predict if the financial system will melt down, (2) if it does melt down, what you do doesn't matter, and (3) if it doesn't melt down and you fail to invest, you have abdicated your fiduciary responsibility, making investment the only rational choice.
“it's hard to predict the meltdown of the financial system that if it if you think it's gonna melt down it's impossible to know what to do that anything you might do to prepare for the meltdown the financial system would be a disaster under any other circumstances and most of the time the financial world doesn't end... well we can't plan on the end of the enterprise number two do we invest or not if we invest and the financial world melts down it doesn't matter what we did but if we don't invest and it doesn't melt down then we abdicated our responsibility we were hired by our clients to invest if there's a crisis that does not culminate in the meltdown as an analyst and that was the best of all possible environments to invest”
To achieve above-average results, you must think differently from the crowd, but the efficient market hypothesis suggests that most of the time the crowd is approximately right, creating a paradox where exceptional performance requires non-consensus thinking that is usually wrong.
“if you think the same as everybody else you'll take the same actions as everybody else if you take the same actions as everybody else you'll have the same performance of everybody else so and that by definition cannot result in above average results so you can't think the same as everybody else you have to diverge from the thinking of the herd at some point in time and if you do and you're right then you will probably do things which are different from what the herd does and you'll be have above-average performance... the efficient market hypothesis which says that the market does... the consensus of all investors does a good job of incorporating the availability is available information at a point in time which is to say that most of the time the consensus opinion is close to the truth... to be an above-average investor number one you have to think different from the crowd but number two you have to be right so second level thinking is thinking which is different and better”
Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan was excessively accommodating and created perception of the 'Greenspan Put'—the belief that the Fed would inject liquidity anytime economic problems appeared—which led investors to plan for only positive scenarios and become unprepared for actual crises.
“Greenspan was so accommodating of the need the economy to grow that and kind of a kind of a cheerleader that he permitted the perception of something called the Greenspan put which is anytime the economy looks like it might have a problem the Fed will squirt in some extra liquidity and cut rates maybe and that'll prevent the problem so ie there will never be a problem there will never be a slowdown we don't have to worry about negative scenarios in make in doing our planning it'll it'll always be okay and that's dangerous because if if you ask you planning for tough times then your planning will be overly biased to the upside and when the tough times come you're by definition not ready”
The inability to distinguish between bad decisions and bad outcomes creates organizational cultures prone to mistake-aversion, and cultures that do make this distinction are better able to make superior decisions because they don't punish errors that resulted from good reasoning.
“and I like the fact that you don't sort of assign blame but how do you learn from that how do you surface that... I think we have an above-average ability to detect risk and make investments that have upside potential what would the risks under control I think we had this ability you described to to understand the difference between bad decisions and bad outcomes... I think that all of these things start with the mindset”
Oaktree's primary motto is 'if we avoid the losers, the winners take care of themselves,' which signifies a risk-control-first mentality that is foundational to all investment approaches, from high-yield bonds to distressed debt to private equity.
“one of the reasons we're so good at controlling risk is that we put risk control first we have a motto if we avoid the losers the winners take care of themselves and that was fine when we invested in in high-yield bonds where high-yield bond if you buy it at par the work the best you're going to get is interest plus par back but there are lots of worse outcomes so we've concluded that if we secure against the worse outcomes we'll get our interest than our money back”
Cycles occur because people, not electrons, commit excesses to the upside out of enthusiasm, which then must be corrected and those corrections overshoot to the downside, creating cyclical oscillation in economic activity.
“cycles happen because people not electrons but people commit excesses to the upside usually out of enthusiasm which then have to be corrected and those corrections overshoot to the downside and that's the investor psychology yes exactly but it's it's the way the world works”
Understanding what other investors think and how your perspective differs is a critical layer of analysis beyond simply analyzing what will happen; you must know what others think and why you differ.
“at some point look our the people who work here spend all their time time trying to figure out what it is and they try to know what is that is to say what is this company about what will it be worth down the road... but I think an important element in the process is you have to stop at some time and say what do other people think why do they think it why do they diverge for me what makes me think I'm right and they're wrong you have to you have to plumb those differences”
The December 2017 tax bill was over-stimulative because it cut corporate tax rates to 21% in a healthy economy that didn't need stimulus, which will likely lead to excesses that require correction through higher interest rates, increasing the probability of recession.
“in December the government passed a tax bill which is highly stimulative because it cut the rates on corporations... I would say that was over stimulative that that tax bill will cut government revenues and most people think that that will lead to an increase in the deficit and in the national debt and that was I I would say it was over still motive and my reaction at the time was it still is that doctors do not give adrenaline to healthy patients they give it to people who are having heart attacks and we had a healthy economy that tax bill stimulated it I would say over stimulated it unnecessarily that will lead to excesses which will then have to be corrected one of the ways we correct excesses in the in the economy preferably and hopefully less painfully is through interest rate increases”
The ability to act contrarian in a crisis while others are paralyzed by emotion comes from a combination of factors: (1) experience living through previous lesser crises, (2) naturally lower emotional reactivity, (3) the inherently contrarian nature of distressed debt investing, (4) a supportive partnership that doesn't blame for mistakes, and (5) an organizational culture that doesn't punish errors.
“we had lived through some lesser crises you know my partner Bruce kasha and I... we lived through a severe market downturn in 1991 and another one in a 102 so we had rehearsed I had at the time of the financial crisis I'd been working 40 years already... number two maybe Bruce and I are more unemotional than most number three our very activity of investing in distressed debt is inherently contrarian... and finally I think we are unusually supportive of each other and you know we've been doing we've been part for 31 years neither of us has ever said to the other one boy that worked out badly you did a stupid thing... if you have a partner or an organization which second-guesses your mistakes then you become mistake averse and we don't do that”
Trade deficits are natural outcomes when people prefer buying better and cheaper foreign goods to domestic goods, and running a trade deficit means consumers get cheap goods in exchange for money, which is beneficial to consumers even if it represents a 'deficit' in trade accounting.
“why do we have a trade deficit because we would rather buy their goods which are some combination of better and cheaper and they're not very motivated to buy our goods because number one we don't manufacture that much and what we manufacture by their standards isn't better and cheaper so we get cheap goods... when we run a trade deficit with China most people weren't unhappy why it's over let's say that let's say the number is 800 billion... it means we bought 800 million billion more of Chinese goods than they bought of American goods... why do we have a trade deficit because we would rather buy their goods which are some combination of better and cheaper”
Luck is a real and substantial factor in outcomes including success; people are born with advantages (IQ, health, location, family background) that they didn't earn, and acknowledging luck fosters gratitude which motivates sharing its fruits with others.
“I had a memo in January of 2014 which happens to be the memo that got the most response and it was called getting lucky and it was on the importance of luck... I think I've been the luckiest person on the planet... success is never accidental you make your own luck and I I don't agree I think luck is a real thing and it's unimportant and it's inherently unfair but that's life... how about your IQ what did you do to deserve develop or nurture your IQ you were born with the brain that works better than others yeah that's luck... the thankful heart is not only the greatest of all the virtues but it is the parent of all the other virtues... people who are lucky should thank their luck acknowledge it and revel in it I think it will also make them want to share the fruits of their luck right with with others”
Technological disruption will likely worsen income inequality because people with capital and technical skills will be highly valuable and concentrated geographically (Silicon Valley), while people without these skills will face severe income pressure, and current government appears incapable of addressing this problem due to partisan dysfunction.
“the people who can develop the personalist bookstore or the robot will be in great demand and people who can create artificial intelligence will be in great demand and very valuable and they'll all live in a small community just south of San Francisco and the people who can't do any of that stuff and get this place from their jobs will be will do very poorly and this is dystopian and I hate myself for thinking that way but I'm not optimistic about a solution”
A market is not a physical location or institution but rather a group of people who implement their views of value through transacting—all value judgments and price movements are ultimately driven by human emotion and behavior, not by inherent market mechanics.
“there's no such thing as a market there's only a bunch of people who trade talk to me about that well what why do we conceptualize it as a market then because you know if you think of them of a market most people flash to a photo of the New York Stock Exchange a building just as if most people well in my day if you talked about a stock people would think about a stock certificate but the building is not the market and the stock certificate is not ownership of a company it's these things are only signifiers but a market consists of a group of people who implement their views or in value by transacting and so it's all there is as people”
Marks has made money in asset classes that were unpopular when entered (high-yield bonds in 1978) by being willing to do what others wouldn't because it looked risky, and this requires willingness to look stupid and be wrong.
“I've made my money in asset classes that when I got there were unpopular like high-yield bonds in 1978... if you went up to a bunch of people in this in the straight world the straight investing world and you said you should buy this because nobody else is most of them will say what are you crazy if they're not buying it by definition it has no merit and and we can't do that and anyway we don't want to do something which is different from what everybody else is doing because if it turns out to be a mistake we'll look stupid”
Political tribalization and polarization are increasing, making bipartisan cooperation more difficult, but some hope exists through organizations supporting bipartisanship and eventually experiencing crises bad enough to force compromise.
“this is part of a natural cycle like we become more extreme and then we come back together or am I am I just trying to be optimistic ahead huh oh I'd like to hope so I'd like to hope so I'd like to hope that that it eventually you have experiences which are so bad that you say you know we can't run that way anymore but the thing you probably have to get pretty bad for it to happen... my greatest interest at the present time in the political world is in bipartisanship and I'm supporting an organization which exists no labels to support bipartisanship”
Marks is not optimistic about solutions to technology-driven job displacement because he can't imagine what new labor-intensive industries would absorb displaced workers, and current political dysfunction makes large-scale solutions unlikely.
“I'm not optimistic I'm four and I try to be an optimist but I try not to be a stupid optimist... what do they do if they don't drive cars do insurance adjusting fix cars buy build cars or make steel what do they do... I'm not optimistic about a solution... this government by a meet by which I mean the current state of affairs in Washington I'm not talking about a person or a political party this government can solve any problems because they can't agree on anything”
Reading broadly across subjects isn't primarily aimed at becoming a better investor, but at getting smarter and challenging thinking; the process of refining understanding (like reconceptualizing risk) is continuous.
“my reading is not so purposeful okay you know I'm not reading at this point to become a better investor I'm not making that many investment around the decisions around here I'm really just trying to lead the organization... I'm just trying to get smarter you know and know more and always challenged my thinking... about risk and I now have a slightly different way of explaining risk than I did three years ago we're always refining and busting right”
The U.S. has experienced a 10-year recovery and there has never been a recovery lasting more than 10 years historically, but this doesn't mean a recession is imminent because historical patterns are not hard rules and the slowness of this recovery (avoiding excess) suggests it could set a record for longest recovery.
“we're in the tenth year of a recovery there's never been a recovery of more than ten years so somebody who was an absolutist you know would say well then that means that in let's say October it's in nine months the economy will stop going up but of course there are no rules and twain said history does not repeat and that's one of the ways in which it doesn't repeat these limitations are not hard and fast this has also been the slowest recovery since World War two and that's a good thing because that slow recovery you see one of the things is that your listeners should note is that in the financial or investment world where cycle psychology is so important and there are no absolute laws of nature at work everything has two sides a good side every development has a positive side and a negative side so the the negative side of a slow recovery is that it's been slow the positive side is that it hasn't been marked by excesses and if it has been marked by excess then that means we don't have to have a correction to the downside which is called the recession anytime soon so my guess is that this recovery will set a record for the longest recovery in history because of the slowness and the absence of excesses”