Jenny Johnson - Seven Decades of Investing Expertise - [Invest Like the Best, EP. 256]
What this covers
Patrick interviews Jenny Johnson, who joined Franklin Templeton in 1988 and became its CEO in 2020. The conversation starts with management and then widens to the industry. She lays out her Four P's of Leadership, a 40-30-30 Time Allocation across clients, day-to-day disputes, and disruption, and a Talent Venn Diagram that separates people you enjoy from people you should work with. She also discusses what makes a good board, why deals fail on culture integration rather than price, and Jack Welch's admission that he was slow to make personnel changes.
The middle of the episode is about costs and active versus passive investing. Patrick notes that Bogle's argument was mostly about cost, and Johnson says cost should be judged by what comes back per dollar paid. She traces the apparent cheapness of ETFs to post-crisis fee transparency, which stripped out distribution fees. She also argues that passive's recent run reflects momentum and concentration, citing Tesla's S&P 500 inclusion. She respects Cathie Wood while flagging the concentration risk in her portfolio. Franklin's acquisition of Random Force, which finds micro-signals that predict charge-off risk, anchors her claim that managers without data scientists will struggle.
The most contested material concerns what comes next. Johnson expects private assets to be opened to 401k savers, who now miss early company growth, and she says the illiquidity premium gets less attention than fees. She also expects a move from pooled funds toward individually held accounts that reflect personal values. On blockchain she describes smart contract collateral calls, a single source of truth, and fractional ownership of buildings like the Empire State Building, and she puts the disruption roughly ten years out, though that window is shrinking.
Johnson argues that large asset managers must combine disciplined people, purpose, and long-horizon investment in disruption with a clear view of costs and client outcomes, while the industry's shift toward private assets, customized accounts, and blockchain infrastructure will democratize access and reduce friction.
- Leadership depends on getting the right people in the right seats, protecting disruptive experiments from short-term pressure, and having a CEO who breaks ties after open debate
- Cost should be judged by net return per dollar invested, and fee-based reforms exposed hidden distribution costs
- Private markets capture early growth that retail 401k investors cannot access, so vehicles must be built to democratize alternatives
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
John Bogle's active-passive argument was mainly about cost reduction, including compounding fees, taxes, and turnover, rather than market efficiency as most people assume.
“he was talking more about cost reduction than market efficiency”
Franklin acquired Random Force, which uses AI on unique data sources; it found micro-signals such as failing to capitalize an employer's name or applying late at night that predict higher charge-off risk, showing that investors without such data face adverse selection and larger losses.
“they found micro signals like you didn't capitalize the name of your employer... or if you applied for the loan after a certain time at night, you are a higher risk”
Post-financial-crisis transparency rules on distribution fees led to the fee-based model, and the apparent cheapness of ETFs over mutual funds came largely from stripping out embedded service and distribution fees rather than from the vehicle itself.
“it was because there was service fees and distribution fees embedded in mutual funds that weren't in an ETF”
Investing 5,000 dollars a year from age 25 to 35 and then stopping at a 7 percent return yields more money by 65 than investing the same amount from age 35 to 65 at the same return, so the industry should get young people investing earlier.
“from age 25 to 35, those 10 years put away, let's say $5,000 a year... you will have more money than the person who puts away for 30 years from age 35 to 65”
As companies and industries change, jobs grow beyond some people's capabilities, so CEOs must keep people in the right seats and make tough changes; Jack Welch saw being slow to make changes as one of his Achilles' heels.
“the job grows out of their capabilities in that role. And then you got to make tough decisions. And I think it was Jack Welsh, who always said he was slower to make changes”
Deals succeed or fail mainly based on culture integration, not on strategic fit or price, which investment bankers emphasize; Franklin has passed on many strategically sensible deals because the cultures would not mesh.
“deals are successful or not depending on whether there's a culture class or culture integration. We have passed on many deals that we think were strategically made a lot of sense”
Investors should judge costs by the net number, asking what they got back for each dollar invested, since paying 5 cents to receive 10 cents is better than paying 1 cent to receive 2 cents.
“I invested a dollar. What did I get back? If I paid 5 cents and you gave me 10 cents back”
A great board needs diversity of views, external industry experience, and a willingness to challenge and support the CEO, and the board's number one job is picking the CEO, which requires no surprises and valuing the board's advice.
“Then what's the board's number one job? It's picking the CEO. So you got to stay, make sure you're communicating well with the board”
After a decade of smooth markets, investors risk complacency with passive strategies, because market beta has become riskier as a few giant companies concentrate the index, and the Tesla inclusion in the S&P 500 is an example of rising concentration risk.
“While market beta is market beta, beta got a lot riskier... when Tesla was put in, if you measure beta by volatility”
Investment portfolios will shift away from pooled vehicles toward individually held, tax-efficient accounts that reflect personal values, with ESG data letting investors measure whether values-based choices add alpha or subtract returns granularly.
“customization of people's investment portfolios are going to have a lot less pooled vehicles and a lot more individually held accounts that are tax efficient”
Blockchain creates a single immutable source of truth that all parties, including tax authorities, agree on, which removes the costly reconciliation between systems and compresses back-office costs and settlement time across asset management.
“if it's imprinted on the chain, it's there, you don't have to reconcile. There's no worry about what the source of truth is. That's going to compress a lot of costs”
Smart contracts can automate collateral calls on foreign exchange and derivative contracts, replacing spreadsheet-driven checks of covenants and balances and eliminating disputes because the terms are programmed in.
“all that can be programmed into the smart contract so it actually automates the process. And there's no disagreement about it”
Robo-advisors will not eliminate financial advisors; as with TurboTax and CPAs, who remain the main TurboTax users, tools will make advisors more effective wealth managers handling education, planning, and estates.
“people think that ROBO is going to get rid of financial advisors but I'd say remember TurboTax was going to get rid of all the CPAs and who's the number one user of TurboTax? CPAs”
The early high-growth years of companies increasingly occur in private markets, so average 401k savers miss that growth cycle that the IPO and mutual fund channel once delivered, creating pressure to democratize private assets.
“what's happening is that real growth projectory in those early years is captured in the private markets, which, right now, is not really accessible to the average 401K guy”
Passive investing wins share in momentum markets, and the recent extreme was driven by technology concentration, with six S&P 500 companies accounting for about 50 percent of earnings, plus massive government intervention that pushed savers into equities at low interest rates.
“I think there's six companies in the S and P 500 that have accounted for like 50% of the earnings... Passive's going to win”
Johnson believes blockchain and infrastructure investments are about a 10-year-out massively disruptive opportunity, and she thinks that window is getting shorter than when she first considered it.
“our focus on blockchain and infrastructure investments, I honestly think they're kind of a 10 year out massively disruptive”
The traditional spreadsheet-based investment model of P and L and assumed sales is insufficient; active managers without data scientists and broad proprietary data sources will struggle to keep up.
“the kind of business school model of you build a spreadsheet with P and L and you assume sales and things, I think it's going to be all about leveraging AI and data”
Blockchain-based tokenization can fractionalize historically illiquid assets such as the Empire State Building and sell them to a million people without title-company frictions, opening such assets to the masses.
“imagine if you could sell the Empire State Building to a million people, and they got 1000000th of their rent in their token”
The asset management industry holds a view that 49 percent of revenues will come from alternatives, which is why Franklin needed to be bigger in alternatives through Lexington Partners, Clarion real estate, and Benefit Street Partners private credit.
“there's a view that 49% of revenues will come from the alt space. So we need it to be bigger in that space”
Cathie Wood built ARK by hitting the timing of momentum and growth opportunities and by capturing trends such as social media, but her portfolio carries significant risk from concentration in large momentum stocks, which Johnson respects even though she does not agree with everything.
“She's hit the timing exactly right as far as the momentum growth opportunities, but there's a lot of people with similar growth and haven't been as successful”
The under-discussed issue in asset management is the excess illiquidity premium in private markets, which democratization requires, yet the conversation is dominated by fees, creating a disconnect since investment committees face less blame for choosing low-fee passive funds than for choosing higher-fee products that underperform.
“you do get in trouble if you go with a higher fee product, because you genuinely believe you're going to get higher returns”
Periods of strong returns in a benign industry let firms avoid hard efficiency work, because when the business turns, firms must face managing out loyal employees and admit they were in a great industry rather than being unusually smart; in the 1980s asset managers averaged a 26 percent return on equity.
“the average asset manager had a 26% return on equity. It was just a great business to be in. You just had to be pretty good, you didn't have to be great”
Talent in business is a Venn diagram of people you love to hang out with and people you should work with; the overlap is ideal, but leaders must not confuse the two circles.
“talent in the business world is a bit of a Venn diagram. These are the people I love to hang out with, these are the people I should work with”
Franklin's hybrid structure rests on a single capability, investing for risk-adjusted returns across the risk spectrum, packaged in whatever way clients want, while each investment team stays independent in its operating choices but shares risk and compliance infrastructure.
“we have one capability which is investing people's money to get risk adjusted returns... And then we package it in whatever way our clients want to receive it”
Running a small auto-loan division taught Johnson that lending is different from investing because the lender takes on people's obligations, and early lending that was too lenient led to regulatory trouble and sleepless stress before she learned to manage credit.
“when you're lending people money, it's a different decision than when you're investing and they're handing you money. We probably, right out of the gate, were too lenient”
Johnson allocates about 40 percent of her time to clients, prospects, and external industry speaking, about 30 percent to day-to-day decisions where teams disagree, and about 30 percent to disruption; if day-to-day time consistently exceeds 30 percent, she concludes she has the wrong people.
“I think 40% of my time should be spent on clients, prospects, industry speaking, external facing... 30% should be on day to day... And if that number edges up more than 30% consistently, I probably have the wrong people”
Disruptors are often hard to engage because they talk in ideas that lack words yet, so leaders should create a protected subgroup with budget and resources, give them latitude to present business cases, and treat them like R&D to prevent them being squashed and leaving.
“if you don't protect them, they get squashed within an organization. Eventually they're frustrated and they leave”
As a third-generation leader, Johnson spends about 30 percent of time on disruptive areas outside the industry, because decisions made today are seeds for the fourth and fifth generations.
“since I'm a third generation running this company, I focus on making sure it's here for the fourth and fifth generation. So that means decisions today are probably seeds planted today”
Disruptive thinkers often talk in esoteric terms because the vocabulary for their idea does not yet exist, so their colleagues focused on today's problems dismiss them as irrelevant noise.
“one of the biggest problems with disruption is people can talk about it, but the words don't exist. So they don't exist, so they can't explain it that well”
Leaders should gather team feedback and let everyone be heard, since perspectives often change the CEO's view, but when the executive team is tied or in real disagreement, the CEO must step up and make the call.
“It really ends up being the CEO happened to make a decision when there's kind of a tie internally”
Acquiring private equity managers requires assessing why the sellers are selling and whether they will stay engaged after a payout, because asset management is a people business and buyers are really buying a team.
“you're buying a team when you buy a company and so can you keep that team really engaged”
An effective meeting starts with a clear objective, excludes people who only listen and should just get an update later, requires everyone present to contribute, and has no meetings after the meeting, meaning disagreements must be aired in the room.
“everybody in the room who is just listening, probably shouldn't be in the room. They should just get an update later”
Mutual funds were created in the 1920s because only wealthy people could access equity markets, and Johnson sees private equity and real estate, restricted to qualified or credited investors, as following a similar pattern that calls for new retail vehicles.
“why did mutual funds get created? Because there was a period in the '20s where only the rich people could go to the equity markets”
When it is unclear which initiatives will win, leaders should spread small bets as seeds, concentrate larger bets only where they are confident, and never fully close other options.
“In some cases, you just give a little bit, it's spreading seeds and just seeing kind of what grows. In other cases, you're saying, 'I'm going to really focus on this'”
Johnson believes 401k plans are a good way to deliver private assets via managed accounts that allocate a percentage to professional managers and include demographic-based allocation and a built-in lending facility for hardship.
“I am a big believer that the 401K plan is a great way to do that in kind of managed accounts”
A senior leadership team should be built like a sports team with complementary skill sets rowing in the same direction; senior executives must speak up honestly in the meeting and then fully support the decision made.
“You're building a team... They're rowing the boat in the same direction, and their complementary to each other. So the skill sets are going to be different”
Public-company CEOs get roughly a three-year window before investments must show success, but family concentrated ownership lets a third-generation CEO make multi-year bets like blockchain and infrastructure even at a possible short-term earnings cost.
“you sort of get about a three year run as a CEO to have investments show signs of being successful... sometimes our family still has a concentrated ownership in the business. So we're able to make that longer term”
Franklin's investment teams recognize that competition is outside the firm, so they leverage internal strengths; after COVID-era Treasury market freezes, the fixed income CIOs from Legg Mason, Brandywine, Franklin, and private credit began weekly calls that became quarterly CIO events.
“the competition is outside the wall. So actually leverage the strengths inside the wall”
Although apps like Robinhood may not be the right way to invest, they bring many young people into owning stocks, and the on-ramp matters, though the danger is that new investors lose savings in speculative bursts and exit permanently.
“It is a paradox for me that I don't think it's the right way to invest, but it's hard to argue with the on ramp”
Johnson's leadership framework has four pillars, people, passion, purpose, and persistence, and the CEO's number one job is getting the right team and the right people running things.
“my four P's of leadership... it's people, passion, purpose, and persistence. And I think people one is, what's the job of the CEO? The number one job is get the right team”
For Franklin, M&A filled immediate product and capability gaps, because buying is often better than building; corporate IT cannot easily innovate under compliance and testing, and building Canvas internally could have taken 18 months while the industry moved on.
“if you could buy it, it's often better than trying to build it yourself”
Financial firms accumulated many systems built piecemeal as technology improved, so they must reconcile one system to the next, creating large embedded costs that represent substantial tech debt.
“you piece them together over time... there's a lot of tech debt in financial services business because we built these things as the capability and technology computing improved”
After a decade of smooth, low-rate markets, investors will need active managers in turbulent conditions, as pilots take manual control in turbulence and drivers pay for safety features on snowy roads, so complacent passive allocation becomes riskier.
“We have been in a decade of a straight well paved road. And now we're going to move into this.”
Large corporate IT departments struggle to innovate because compliance, testing, and fear of failure accumulate until building new products becomes too expensive, which is why entrepreneurs who build and sell first are better positioned.
“It's hard within companies... You take a corporate IT department”
Johnson's father warned that a market crash would drive investors away permanently, citing the Nifty 50 pharmaceutical-led rally that later collapsed as the example of how late entrants lose trust.
“He had used the example of the Nifty 50, which was the pharmaceutical similar type of rocket ship of an equity market for pharmaceutical companies. Then they blew up.”
Johnson defines alternatives simply as private assets that are not traded in public form, and she sees buying alternative managers as hard because the sellers usually know far more about the holdings and the team is the real asset.
“To me it's more private assets, not traded in a more public form”
Universal tokenization is hard because systems must agree on common protocols, akin to many people speaking different languages, so friction will slow adoption even as large institutions and sovereign funds explore it.
“Again, this assumes everybody's talking to each other using the same protocols. This is really hard to do”
Franklin Templeton outperformed Berkshire Hathaway for 25 years in a row during a long stretch when it was one of the strongest performers in the market.
“we outperformed Berkshire Hathaway for 25 years in a row”
When developing an idea internally, a firm must monitor whether others are building the same thing, because it may be better to stop and acquire a competitor instead.
“when you do it internally, you have to make sure you're also staying aware of how others are also developing the same idea, because you may want to stop and just go acquire somebody else.”
A strong stock price is a currency for retaining employees, but during high growth leaders may band-aid issues and fail to fix underlying problems because they fear losing momentum.
“Your stock is a currency of your employees so when it's doing really, really well in itself, it helps you a lot in retention”
Hardship in a business crisis, such as the lending-regulation trouble of her auto loan business, produced the most leadership training and gave her confidence to lead in later difficult situations.
“those character building moments also gave me a lot of confident to be able to lead in other difficult situations.”
Franklin's purpose is to help people achieve the most important goals in their lives, such as retirement, college for children, providing for a special-needs child, covering medical emergencies, and buying a home, and this mission drives daily work.
“we are helping people solve the most important goals in their lives”
Franklin's client base has become roughly 50/50 retail and institutional after combining with Legg Mason, and retail investors now receive the same professional review through gatekeeper platforms as large sovereign wealth funds.
“Franklin's history was much deeper on the retail side, Legg Mason was much deeper on the institutional side and so now we're 50/50”
Investment teams should be genuinely independent, defining their own technology, trading, and portfolio specialist setups, while the platform provides shared data, risk management, and compliance.
“If we're offering all these different independent investment teams, they really have to be independent.”
Franklin's incubator seriously evaluates at least 20 companies a month in areas of potential disruption, giving a front-row seat to how things are disrupting, and the firm is setting up incubators around the globe because disruption can happen anywhere.
“we look at least 20, seriously look at 20 companies a month to bring into our incubator”
As clients move toward solutions, distribution needs portfolio specialists who sit with investment teams and speak like portfolio managers, and a diverse set of capabilities gives the firm an advantage like a chef in a well-stocked kitchen.
“you almost need portfolio specialists who are helping on the distribution process”
As a CEO, Johnson receives many more outreach requests than she did as president, so she can no longer be as open-door and must prioritize.
“when you become CEO, suddenly reach out. I was always so good about being pretty open door”
Family members working together in a business must leave sibling and parent-child dynamics at the door and focus on what is right for the business, which is easier because they share a long-term stake in it.
“you have to put the company first, and you have to leave behind the natural dynamics that come in a relationship of older siblings, younger siblings, parent, child”
Client conversations are the top priority for a CEO because clients reveal the trends that should shape where the business goes, even though she relies on investment professionals for investment decisions.
“That's where you learn where the trends are. It's what's on the client's minds that's going to inform you where your business should be going”
Every employee carries the brand, and one bad interaction can define a company in a customer's mind, so the firm's culture of treating everyone as part of a people business matters.
“Every employee carries the brand on their shoulders”
Johnson's father taught that taking care of the client takes care of the business, and this top-down principle shaped Franklin's culture.
“Take care of the client, and the business takes care of itself.”
Asset management lacks market-clearing prices, with the top managers and many weaker ones both charging the same two-and-twenty fee model, which the speaker calls a strange feature of the industry.
“in asset management, there seems to be just a couple fee models. The very best are two and 20. Others are still two and 20, even if they're not nearly as good”
In crises, leaders sometimes must compartmentalize, turning on logic and turning off emotion, while still ensuring they do not do this in their personal lives, and staying focused on the tasks ahead.
“there are times where you have to compartmentalize as a leader, turn on the logic and turn out the emotion”
Johnson remains a strong believer in active management and risk-adjusted returns, seeing passive funds as useful only to complement exposures rather than as the whole portfolio.
“From on the investment side, I'm still a big believer in active management. I think passive has its place to complement exposures and things.”
The old model of leaders keeping distance and showing a stoic nature has given way to leading with empathy, since during COVID leaders had to recognize that people had very different situations.
“more successful leaders, I think lead with some empathy. Because in this period of COVID I had to understand that everybody had different situations”
The kindest thing anyone has done for Johnson is that long-time friends showed up for her during the hardest times in her life, and she hopes she provides the same support in return.
“During the hardest times in my life, when friends reached out and just knew that you needed them there for you”
Large sovereign funds and institutions do not necessarily need assets tokenized, though some are thinking about it, and tokenization is most relevant for government assets being privatized and as a more efficient back office.
“large institution, big sources of capital, big Sovereign funds and others, they don't necessarily need things to be tokenized”
Pooled, low-fee options dominated the past, but the move toward customized active accounts makes costs higher in absolute terms, so investors must judge them on net return per dollar rather than headline fee.
“when you move to more of these separates accounts, you're going to pay for the active management”
Meeting effectiveness depends on clarity about why each person is in the room, and CEOs should avoid meetings for meetings' sake, a concern Johnson shares with Daniel Ek who focuses on improving meeting quality.
“I don't like to have meetings for meetings.”
Turning a crisis into an opportunity builds character and confidence, and the most important lessons come during periods of crisis rather than calm.
“I probably learned the most lessons in my career during that window of crisis and I guess what I would say to people is the old never let a good crisis go by”
Johnson's father taught her persistence, invoking a Calvin Coolidge quote, and she describes his attitude of never giving up as the difference between success and failure.
“He's got the Calvin Coolidge quote about persistence and his attitude of never giving up is the difference between success and failure”