What this covers

Cynthia Haven, a Stanford scholar of René Girard's work, joins Russ Roberts to map the French philosopher's sweeping theories of desire, violence, and religion. Girard upended three deeply held assumptions: that our desires are authentically our own, that conflict arises from our differences, and that religion causes violence rather than containing it. The conversation moves through Girard's core insight that mimetic desire—the human urge not merely to imitate but to become the other—creates rivalry precisely through sameness, not difference. Haven and Roberts explore how this mimetic competition builds social tension until communities discharge it through scapegoating: selecting a victim to blame and eliminate, which brings temporary relief but resets the cycle. The discussion then turns to Girard's claim that only forgiveness truly breaks this pattern—and that the Judeo-Christian tradition uniquely revealed the scapegoat's innocence, beginning in the Old Testament.

Haven emphasizes that recognizing oneself as a persecutor, and thus capable of perpetuating injustice, sits at the heart of Girard's moral vision. The speakers examine how Adam Smith's impartial spectator—the internal witness that lets us see ourselves as we truly are—parallels this call for self-recognition. They also address how external threats temporarily unite communities (9/11, October 7th) by functioning like a shared scapegoat, only to have internal divisions resurface once the crisis fades. Throughout, Haven notes that forgiveness is not a permanent achievement but a practice requiring continual renewal, and that Girard's solution to violence ultimately points beyond human mimesis entirely toward the Imitatio Christi. The conversation closes with Girard's counsel that genuine reform begins with personal sanctity rather than institutional overhaul.

Sharpest takeaway

Girard argued that human desire is mimetic (we want to be others, not just imitate them), that conflict springs from sameness rather than difference, and that religion historically functioned to contain violence through scapegoating—with forgiveness, revealed through the recognition of the scapegoat's innocence in the Judeo-Christian tradition, as the only true exit from the cycle of violence.

  • All desire is a desire for being: we crave to occupy and become the other, which puts us in competition
  • Scapegoating temporarily relieves social tension but resets the cycle; only forgiveness ends it
  • The Old Testament begins revealing the innocence of the scapegoat, undermining the sacrificial mechanism

The argument · threads4 threads · 22 claims
0.75

Mimesis drives both human learning and conflict because imitation creates sameness that generates rivalry over shared objects of desire.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Authentic, self-originated desire is an illusion; nothing about us can be completely authentic because everything we desire and become has to come from somewhere else through imitation, so the belief that we eventually create ourselves on a blank slate is self-deception.

    “I don't know how anything could be completely authentic because it's got to come from somewhere.”

  • Conflict arises because mimesis makes rivals so much alike that they reach for the same object; the irritation comes from noticing others copying us while we believe ourselves to be authentic, and each fights against being appropriated, so it is sameness rather than difference that generates rivalry.

    “it creates conflict because the other person fights to keep themselves from appropriation or what they may see as appropriation. Or where they both become so much alike--which is what typically happens, that two people reach for the same thing.”

  • Humans are fundamentally imitative beings; imitation begins seconds after birth and is the mechanism by which we learn everything, including language—but the same imitation drives us into conflict because we reach for the same objects of desire.

    “We are imitative beings. Imitation is how it drives us forward. We begin imitating as soon as almost seconds after we're out of the womb. It's why we learn, it's how we learn. But it's also how we come to fight with each other, because we'll both reach for the same things”

  • Mimetic desire begins earlier than envy: we don't merely want to imitate others or acquire what they have, we long to be them, to occupy them—we crave to be something other than we are, which is why all desire is ultimately a desire for being.

    “the envy itself is beginning because we actually long to be someone else. We don't want to just imitate them. We want to occupy them. We want to be them. And that is why all desire is a desire for being. We crave something other than we are.”

0.71

Imitating Christ and Jewish religious tradition inventing interpersonal forgiveness offer the permanent solution to mimetic cycles and human violence.

6 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The only way out of the cycle of imitation is the Imitatio Christi, because every other kind of imitation leads back into the human community where rivalry and conflict arise, whereas imitating Christ—teaching us to imitate God in his forgiveness and more—takes us out of that cycle entirely.

    “the only way out of the circle of imitation... certainly a powerful way out is the Imitatio Christi, because every other kind of imitation will lead you back into the human community, which is where things screw up. But, Imitatio Christi suddenly takes you out of that cycle of imitation. It's basically teaching you to imitate God”

  • Girard argued that the permanent solution to the cycle of violence is forgiveness, and that the people who invented forgiveness were the Jews; other ancient religions contain debt forgiveness but not genuine interpersonal forgiveness, and the revelation of the scapegoat's innocence begins in the Old Testament with figures like the persecuted psalmist and Job.

    “René says that the permanent solution is forgiveness; and the people that invented forgiveness are the Jews.”

  • The Old Testament story of Joseph represents the fullest expression of forgiveness and a huge movement in human psychology and spirituality, exemplified by Joseph weeping audibly as he forgives the guilty brothers and by Judah—who originated monetizing his brother's enslavement—later offering himself as a slave, a dramatic human reversal with nothing comparable anywhere.

    “it finds its fullest expression in the Old Testament--in the story of Joseph--that is so incredible. There's nothing like that anywhere, with the forgiveness that Joseph offers... It's a huge movement in the psychology and the spirituality of the human people.”

  • Girard was not a conventional narrow-discipline scholar; though his Ph.D. was technically in history (on American and French opinion during and after the war, and on the history of Avignon), his thought crossed disciplinary boundaries after the war and Hiroshima prompted him to rethink his direction.

    “He kind of crossed boundaries, didn't he? Technically, his Ph.D. was in history. He did American and French opinion during the war and after the war.”

  • Girard overturned three conventional beliefs: first, that our desire is authentic and our own; second, that we fight from our differences rather than our sameness (when in fact conflict arises from sameness produced by mimesis); and third, that religion is the cause of violence, when archaically it was the solution for controlling violence.

    “it creates conflict because the other person fights to keep themselves from appropriation or what they may see as appropriation. Or where they both become so much alike--which is what typically happens, that two people reach for the same thing.”

  • Girard's maxim that the best way not to be crucified is to join in the crucifixion captures the temptation toward groupthink and self-exoneration: the only way to avoid being stoned is to join the stone throwers, and people bond by joining the persecutors because it is hard to stand alone as the outsider.

    “the only way to not be stoned is--he said this elsewhere--is to join the stone throwers.”

0.70

The scapegoat mechanism temporarily relieves mimetic tension by sacrificing a blamed third party, but the cycle inevitably returns unless broken by forgiveness.

3 pointscentrality 5/5
  • The scapegoat mechanism depends on believing the scapegoat is genuinely guilty—you cannot kill the scapegoat unless you truly believe he is the cause of all the problems—so revealing the scapegoat's innocence undermines and dismantles the whole sacrificial mechanism.

    “The scapegoat--it depends on you thinking the scapegoat is guilty. And the Christian revelation is the scapegoat is innocent. You can't kill the scapegoat unless you really believe he's the cause of all the problems.”

  • In archaic societies, when mimetic tension builds, the community offloads its quarreling onto a third party who is blamed and then sacrificed, expelled, or killed; this brings a tremendous but temporary sense of relief because the perceived problem is solved, after which the whole cycle inevitably begins again.

    “the obvious solution or the frequent solution is to find somebody that you can blame for your quarreling, somebody outside the situation that you can offload on him... This is the scapegoating process.”

  • Forgiveness as a form of reconciliation is the only way out of the cycle of violence; if suppressed or stuffed down it returns in a more powerful form, and Girard warned at the end of The Scapegoat that we must forgive one another while there is still time, or there will not be time enough.

    “forgiveness as a form of reconciliation is the only way out of the cycle. It's the only way to end the violence.”

0.56

Forgiveness must be continually renewed and practiced personally; it is the only escape from violence and requires recognizing oneself as a persecutor.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Forgiveness is not a once-and-for-all achievement; large-scale events can let people rise above grievance because the scale leaves no choice, but then ordinary life resumes ('it becomes Tuesday again') and the grievance returns, so forgiveness must be continually renewed rather than completed once.

    “Sometimes when there's something that huge, we can rise above it simply because the scale is so large. Simply because there's no choice. But then we go back to--then it becomes Tuesday again... We'd like to think it's once and for all, but we forgive one day and then the next day it's Tuesday again and they're in our face.”

  • Girard said the success of his theories would be seen when one recognizes oneself as a persecutor; the deeper claim is that we all habitually exonerate ourselves, rewrite our stories to favor our own innocence, and have perpetrated injustices large and small, and recognizing this in oneself enables forgiveness of others.

    “"You will see the success of my theories when you recognize yourself as a persecutor."”

  • Asked by theologians what to do about the world's problems, Girard answered 'We might begin with personal sanctity'—the recommendation that, rather than first trying to fix large external institutions, one should start by cleaning house internally, since changing deeply ingrained personal habits of hardness is where genuine reform begins.

    “he said, 'We might begin with personal sanctity.' And really, doesn't it start there?”