scapegoating
The process by which a community discharges its internal tensions and quarrels by blaming, expelling, or sacrificing a third party deemed responsible, producing temporary relief and unity.
As defined in René Girard, Mimesis, and Conflict (with Cynthia Haven)
Where it comes up · 3
- René Girard, Mimesis, and Conflict (with Cynthia Haven)7 claims
- Peter Thiel on Political Theology | Conversations with Tyler6 claims
- Pete Buttigieg on 2024 and the ‘Crank Realignment’3 claims
Most important claims · 10 of 16Search all claims for “scapegoating” →
- Girard overturned three conventional beliefs: first, that our desire is authentic and our own; second, that we fight from our differences rather than our sameness (when in fact conflict arises from sameness produced by mimesis); and third, that religion is the cause of violence, when archaically it was the solution for controlling violence.René Girard, Mimesis, and Conflict (with Cynthia Haven)
- Girard's maxim that the best way not to be crucified is to join in the crucifixion captures the temptation toward groupthink and self-exoneration: the only way to avoid being stoned is to join the stone throwers, and people bond by joining the persecutors because it is hard to stand alone as the outsider.René Girard, Mimesis, and Conflict (with Cynthia Haven)
- Girard argued that the permanent solution to the cycle of violence is forgiveness, and that the people who invented forgiveness were the Jews; other ancient religions contain debt forgiveness but not genuine interpersonal forgiveness, and the revelation of the scapegoat's innocence begins in the Old Testament with figures like the persecuted psalmist and Job.René Girard, Mimesis, and Conflict (with Cynthia Haven)
- Girard said the success of his theories would be seen when one recognizes oneself as a persecutor; the deeper claim is that we all habitually exonerate ourselves, rewrite our stories to favor our own innocence, and have perpetrated injustices large and small, and recognizing this in oneself enables forgiveness of others.René Girard, Mimesis, and Conflict (with Cynthia Haven)
- In archaic societies, when mimetic tension builds, the community offloads its quarreling onto a third party who is blamed and then sacrificed, expelled, or killed; this brings a tremendous but temporary sense of relief because the perceived problem is solved, after which the whole cycle inevitably begins again.René Girard, Mimesis, and Conflict (with Cynthia Haven)
- The scapegoat mechanism depends on believing the scapegoat is genuinely guilty—you cannot kill the scapegoat unless you truly believe he is the cause of all the problems—so revealing the scapegoat's innocence undermines and dismantles the whole sacrificial mechanism.René Girard, Mimesis, and Conflict (with Cynthia Haven)
- Joseph McCarthy was eventually discredited not through argument but when he appeared 'sputtering about Communists everywhere' and someone asked 'Have you no decency?'—suggesting that the current scapegoating of immigrants will similarly break through public decency appeals.Pete Buttigieg on 2024 and the ‘Crank Realignment’
- Girard says 'I see Satan fall like lightning' meaning to see Satan is to see Satan fall; the only time Satan appears in the Bible is at the very end of the world, never earlier, because to see Satan (the scapegoating mechanism) is to see it fall.Peter Thiel on Political Theology | Conversations with Tyler
- A common external enemy or attack functions like a scapegoat by discharging internal social tensions and producing temporary unity, as seen in the social relief and feeling of oneness after 9/11 and the unification of Israel after October 7th, but the effect fades and internal divisions re-emerge over time.René Girard, Mimesis, and Conflict (with Cynthia Haven)
- Springfield Ohio residents have responded to migration influx with dignity—acknowledging the economic benefits and population recovery while also noting real pressures on hospitals and schools—demonstrating grace that contrasts with political figures like JD Vance who use Springfield's situation for scapegoating without offering solutions.Pete Buttigieg on 2024 and the ‘Crank Realignment’