What this covers

Judge Glock joins Russ Roberts for a conversation that challenges the dominant narrative about zoning and American housing unaffordability. Rather than treating zoning as the root cause of high housing costs, Glock argues the problem lies elsewhere: in restrictions on outward growth, in LAFCOs that prevent new municipalities from forming, and in property-tax redistribution policies that severed local governments' incentive to encourage development. The discussion weaves economic theory, climate science, and comparative data into a defense of suburban growth and competitive local governance, grounded in concepts like the home-voter hypothesis and Tiebout Competition.

The conversation ranges across how cities actually price housing—showing that the most affordable American metros have extensive single-family zoning—and turns to California specifically, where Serrano v. Priest and Proposition 13 broke the link between local property taxes and local benefit, inadvertently crushing both housing supply and school funding. Glock and Roberts also contest the environmental case against sprawl, arguing that wood-frame suburban homes carry carbon advantages over concrete-heavy density, and that local air pollution from cars has already fallen 90 percent per mile driven. The conversation includes a defense of Nozick's Meta-Utopia as a framework for understanding competitive local governance, and closes with what Glock identifies as the highest-leverage policy change: removing Bay Area restrictions on outward development to restore real housing choice. Throughout, the positions are empirically grounded and contested, offering a sustained alternative to conventional pro-density planning arguments.

Sharpest takeaway

Glock argues that zoning's impact on housing affordability is small and often beneficial; America's real affordability crisis stems from restrictions on outward growth and from redistributive property-tax policies that broke local incentives to develop, while competitive local governments and even urban sprawl carry underappreciated benefits.

  • The most affordable U.S. cities have extensive single-family zoning, so zoning cannot be the overwhelming cause of unaffordability
  • Redistribution of property taxes (Serrano v. Priest, Prop 13) severed the link between local taxes and development incentives
  • Restrictions on forming new municipalities (LAFCOs) suppress Tiebout competition and outward growth

The argument · threads6 threads · 29 claims
0.85

Local competition and exit options discipline governments toward efficiency and allow diverse communities without imposing uniform national rules.

6 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Local zoning and control resemble Nozick's meta-utopia, where people choose to join communities that constrain them in agreed ways; as long as an exit option exists and new governments can be formed, allowing diverse local communities to set their own rules preserves an admirable diversity of lifestyles rather than collapsing choices into a single national rule.

    “even if you're a hardcore libertarian, a lot of what zoning and a lot of this local control is, is people who moved to these areas, and moved and made a choice to be constrained in some way. And, as long as they have the ability to go to other ones... we should really encourage that.”

  • The European/Catholic principle of subsidiarity holds that public goods should be provided at the lowest level of government possible but no lower; for many local public goods this means local governments, which can provide them more efficiently while competition among them constrains the Leviathan as Buchanan later recognized.

    “I mention the European/Catholic concept of subsidiarity: You want the lowest level of government possible, but no lower.”

  • Public choice problems look different at the level of competitive local governments because a strong exit option (people voting with their feet across one or two dozen nearby governments) tempers the deadweight losses of bad regulation and can even increase consumer surplus when people value a particular kind of local community character.

    “If you have a strong exit option for these local governments, how much do some of these broader public choice problems take place?... Does that temper the negative deadweight losses of a bad regulation? It might... even allow for a lot more consumer surplus.”

  • Per William Fischel's home-voter hypothesis, homeowners have most of their wealth tied up in a single illiquid, immovable asset (their home), which makes them rightfully attuned to their city manager's actions; combined with intercity competition for residents, this disciplines local government toward maximizing land value much like a corporation despite imperfect internal politics.

    “William Fischel--one of my favorite researchers over at Dartmouth--talks about the home-voter hypothesis. And, he makes the good argument that a lot of people have a lot of wealth tied in a single asset that's illiquid, immovable. And, that's why they're rightfully attuned to what their city manager does.”

  • Because exiting a local government is much harder than switching private suppliers, monopoly power (defined as difficulty of exit) can arise, so higher levels of government and especially courts should restrain the worst excesses--as 1950s-60s courts did by striking down one-acre minimum lot sizes as expropriating farmers' land--while still preserving local provision of public goods.

    “monopoly is maybe just another word for inability to exit easily or difficulty to exit. And so, one of the things I think we need to do is make sure courts, especially, and higher levels of government are restraining kind of the worst excesses of that.”

  • Small governments exhibit efficient behavior--when they receive a windfall in property taxes or grants they keep spending flat and cut taxes--whereas large cities exhibit the flypaper effect, where windfall money 'sticks' and gets used for interest-group spending and log-rolling, evidence that smaller local governments are more efficient.

    “what you find is small governments do that, by and large... The larger cities are much less likely to do that. They're much more likely to have what's called the fly paper effect: it sticks to that city and they use it for interest group and log-rolling and all of the rest of it.”

0.80

Zoning and growth restrictions, not market fundamentals, artificially raise housing prices and prevent affordable development.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • If Glock could change one thing in the housing market, he would remove the Bay Area rules that prevent outward building--open-space reserves, slope-density ordinances, green belts, urban growth boundaries, and LAFCOs--to restore local competition and outward spread and move the region toward an efficient housing market.

    “a lot of those rules that just prevent you from building outwards: Get rid of those... Get rid of those LAFCOs that prevent the new abilities to form new governments, and you're going to get the Bay Area a lot closer to an efficient housing market.”

  • Houston, the only large unzoned U.S. city, has housing-price-to-income ratios only about 10% lower than nearby zoned Dallas/Fort Worth, indicating that zoning is not what holds up housing prices in those other cities; central cities are best left unzoned while suburban competition and homeowners' associations handle land use.

    “Houston has very low housing prices; but not relative to California and New York and some of the others. But, not very distinct relative to, say, Dallas or Fort Worth right next door. By some measures, their housing-price-to-income ratio is almost the same. Maybe about 10% higher in Dallas.”

  • California's Local Agency Formation Commissions (LAFCOs), created in the 1960s, function like cartels of existing municipalities that can block the formation of new cities, acting like a Certificate of Need regime that prevents the Tiebout competition through which new municipalities would pressure existing ones toward efficiency and lower prices.

    “in California, to me, it's a great kind of equivalent of a Certificate of Need [CON] stuff... these LAFCOs have all the existing cities and districts on their Boards, and they decide do we want a new one? And, they say, No, we don't want new competition.”

  • Restrictive zoning functions like a monopolist by limiting supply to raise prices, which reduces overall welfare including consumer welfare; most contemporary American zoning is too strict relative to the goal of maximizing land value, so allowing more density would benefit everyone.

    “you can think of zoning as something like a monopolist, to some extent. The way to increase the price of something is just to restrict the supply of it. And, on the whole that actually means less welfare overall.”

  • The most affordable growing American cities--Nashville, Atlanta, Oklahoma City, Dallas--have extensive single-family zoning and powerful local governments, while the real housing crisis is concentrated in a few areas like California, New York, and Massachusetts, implying zoning is not the overwhelming cause of unaffordability.

    “if zoning is not the overwhelming issue in a lot of these cities, and if zoning is near universal, but America's real housing crisis is located in a few areas, most importantly California, New York, and Massachusetts and some of the coast, then what's the real issue here? To me, it can't just be zoning.”

0.71

Single-family suburban development with outward sprawl is more affordable, environmentally sound, and reflects what most Americans actually want.

6 pointscentrality 4/5
  • By the median-house-price-to-median-income ratio, American housing is among the most affordable in the developed/anglophone world, with a ratio around four versus seven or eight in New Zealand, Australia, and Japan.

    “We have what's called a price-to-income ratio--the median house price to median income ratio--about four. Where, you see a lot of places like New Zealand or Australia, it's more like seven or eight.”

  • Although the San Francisco Bay Area is among the densest regions in the country, almost 40% of the nine-county Bay Area is grazing and pastureland, indicating the constraint is the inability to grow outward rather than insufficient density.

    “if you look at the kind of nine-county Bay Area, almost 40% of that is grazing and pastureland.”

  • Single-family homes are largely stick-built from wood--a renewable resource that acts as a carbon sink--whereas buildings above four or five floors require heavy CO2-emitting concrete and steel and use more energy per square foot for heating, cooling common areas, and elevators, giving sprawl underappreciated climate advantages.

    “a single family home, it's largely stick-built. It's largely wood, which means it's largely using a renewable resource that's a carbon sink. Especially when you get up above four or five floors--when you're using concrete, when you're using steel--these are very heavy CO2-emitting materials.”

  • Houston-area Municipal Utility Districts (MUDs) let developers and homeowners on the urban fringe tax themselves via bonds to build their own roads, pipes, sewers, and water, internalizing the cost of new infrastructure; there is good evidence this self-financing development pays for itself, refuting the claim that sprawl imposes uncompensated infrastructure costs.

    “These local MUDs, they build the roads out there, they build the pipes, the sewers, the water and the rest of it. And, that's all internalized... there's a lot of good evidence that this stuff, especially when properly internalized, does pay for itself.”

  • California and Massachusetts have the densest housing in America with extensive multi-family and infill housing encouraged by state mandates, yet remain the least affordable, suggesting that encouraging apartment development does not improve affordability and may go the opposite direction; affordability instead comes from greenfield single-family development.

    “if you look at places like California and Massachusetts--California especially--they have by most measures the densest housing in America. They have lots of multi-family housing... And, that doesn't seem to make those areas significantly more affordable. If anything, it seems to go in the opposite direction.”

  • The overwhelming majority of Americans, including about 90% of millennials in surveys, say they want a single-family home with a car at some point in their lives, so policy should focus on making suburban living green rather than cramming people into apartments.

    “the overwhelming majority of Americans, the survey was, I think 90% of millennials even said they want a single family home with a car at some point in their lives.”

0.56

Breaking the link between local property taxes and local schools destroyed incentives for voters to fund quality education and support development.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • After Serrano v. Priest and Prop 13, school spending dropped substantially across California, and the state turned from a leader in K-12 education into a laggard near the bottom on quality metrics, partly because detaching property taxes from local schools reduced voters' incentive to fund and care about them.

    “everyone agrees that California turned from in many ways a leader in local education in K-12 [kindergarten through 12th grade] into an obvious laggard, near the bottom of a lot of quality and other metrics.”

  • State efforts to equalize property taxes across school districts (notably California's Serrano v. Priest) broke the link between local property taxes and local benefit, which both triggered Prop 13's tax cap and removed the incentive for local voters to favor development, contributing to the post-1980 explosion in California housing prices.

    “A lot of these redistribute things broke the link between property taxes which could provide a lot of local gains for these local taxpayers and development. And, it was really post-1980 you saw this incredible explosion in California housing prices.”

  • One of the strongest findings in the historical literature, going back to Wallace Oates's 1969 piece, is that areas with better school districts have higher housing values everything else held constant, which gives homeowners a strong incentive (via the home-voter hypothesis) to care about and fund their local schools.

    “one of the strongest connections in the historical literature going back to 1969, a Wallace Oates piece, is that areas with better school districts tend to have higher values. Everything else held constant.”

0.43

Cities flourish when they maintain order and cleanliness in public space while allowing property owners control over their neighborhoods.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The re-flourishing of American cities after about 50 years of population loss, starting in the 1990s-2000s, depended heavily on restoring a basic sense of order and daily quality of life on the streets--not just prosecuting violent crime but keeping public space clean and comfortable; cities are over-regulated in private space but under-regulate public space, which is backwards.

    “a large part of that was people wanted to feel safe and they wanted to feel like they were living in a clean, open city... if you want to do whatever you want in public--throw out trash, whatever--you do anything. Which is 180 degrees the opposite of what government should do.”

  • Zoning, combined with property taxes commensurate with allowed development, solves the free-rider problem in the Tiebout model by making a local government function like a business: homogeneous owners with equity invested control entry and have incentive to fund good public goods, preventing redistribution away from the median voter that would otherwise cause everyone to underfund public goods.

    “some economists like Bruce Hamilton and others realized, well, zoning solves that problem. That, if you have zoning that determines how much property people could afford or should afford in these kind of competitive local suburban environments, and you had property taxes that were commiserate[commensurate?] with the amount of zoning... you basically had something that looked... a little bit, maybe like a business.”

  • When a neighborhood like Chelsea is its own city whose goal is to maximize land value, residents internalize both the amenity costs and gains of development; if told development would quadruple their land value, many would vote for it despite aesthetic concerns, so competitive municipalities incorporate the negative externalities of density that YIMBYs tend to dismiss.

    “If you tell everybody, 'Well, you can develop more and this is going to make all of your land worth four times as much,' I do imagine a lot of the people would vote for that even if they had aesthetic or character concerns.”

0.24

Environmental regulations solved local air pollution from cars, undermining anti-sprawl arguments that once rested on urban choking concerns.

2 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Thanks largely to environmental regulations, local air pollution from cars is down more than 90% per mile driven, so the 1980s argument that cars choke cities is no longer a live local political issue and many anti-sprawl arguments are solutions in search of a problem.

    “Thanks largely to environmental regulations, the local air pollution by cars are down by more than 90% per mile driven. It's not a local political issue like it once was.”

  • Even though each person may emit slightly less individually in dense areas, packing more people together raises local concentrations of pollutants like nitrous oxide and sulfur dioxide, so density carries real local air-pollution costs that the pro-density environmental narrative overlooks.

    “there's more local air pollution. If you have more people crammed together, you're more likely to suck down more nitrous oxide, more sulfur dioxide, all these things. Simply because: even if every person emits a little less individually, it's all crammed more together in that one small space.”