Amor Towles on A Gentleman in Moscow and the Writer's Craft
What this covers
Amor Towles and Russ Roberts discuss the architecture of fiction and the conditions under which writers produce their best work. Towles walks through the construction of A Gentleman in Moscow—its setting, constraints, and narrative machinery—while reflecting on his own creative process across twenty years of work in investment management and literature. The conversation centers on a central claim: that disciplined design unlocks rather than suppresses the subconscious mind. Outlining to Free the Subconscious allows the writer to shift from left-brain mechanics to right-brain poetry at the sentence level; Constraint as Generative Device forces artists outside their habitual instincts, producing word choices and emotional resonances they would never otherwise reach.
The discussion moves through several distinct territories. Towles explains how confining the Count to the hotel functions as a microcosm—allowing the outside world to enter through changing guests and Soviet policy rather than requiring the author to depict thirty years of all Moscow. He describes the accordion structure that expands and contracts time across the novel, the use of dual narrative voices to integrate brutality without drowning the Count's sensibility, and how wine labels stripped by decree become a metaphor for the erasure of individuality. More broadly, he argues that a well-crafted novel operates as a Novel as a Machine for Meaning—thousands of elements held loosely enough that readers of different ages and backgrounds genuinely extract different truths from the same pages. The conversation also touches on Inconvenience as a Source of Meaning, the role of The Mentor's Covenant in sustaining young artists, and Towles's decades-long practice of reading seriously with friends through the Survivorship Filter of Classics rather than pursuing research-driven projects.
Towles argues that disciplined design—extensive outlining and deliberate constraint—is what frees the creative, subconscious mind to produce literature's most resonant moments, and that great novels function as 'machines for meaning' that yield different truths to different readers.
- Detailed advance outlining lets the right-brain take over sentence-level creation rather than the left-brain solving mechanics mid-scene
- Constraints (the hotel, the accordion time structure, the sonnet form) are generative devices that unlock the unconscious
- A well-crafted novel assembles thousands of craft elements loosely enough that readers from different backgrounds extract different meanings
Outlining and constraint free the creative mind by handling mechanical problems before writing begins.
- Towles outlines and designs novels in great detail precisely because doing so frees the creative, right-brain side to take over the writing of sentences, imagery, and word choice; if he didn't know what happens in a chapter, the analytical left-brain would have to handle mechanical inventions (names, settings, plot) during the scene, displacing the poetry.
“the reason I'm an outliner, a designer, a planner is because by being careful about outlining, when I am writing a chapter, it allows the right side of my brain--the creative, imaginative, dreamlike side of the brain--to take over and influence the writing of the sentences and the paragraphs, the imagery, the language, the word choice”
- Constraint is an extremely valuable, underrated starting point for most art: painters start with a fixed canvas size, and the sonnet's rigid rules (14 lines, iambic pentameter, set rhyme schemes) endure across languages and centuries because the constraint forces the artist outside their normal instincts, triggering word choices and emotions they wouldn't otherwise reach and thereby unleashing the unconscious.
“the rules of assignment are what we would call a generative device. It's a rule that forces you to move a little bit outside your normal instincts and to adapt in a way that, again, unleashes potentially the power of your unconscious”
- A Gentleman in Moscow uses an 'accordion' time structure: from the sentencing it reports events at doubling intervals (one day, two, five, ten days... up to 16 years later in 1938), then reverses and contracts back down to the conclusion—a generative device that delivers granular daily detail when readers crave it at the start and end while allowing large leaps through the middle, and which works invisibly to most readers.
“The book then tells you what happens to the Count in the hotel one day later, two days later, five days later... one year later to the day. Then it tells you what happens two years later... eight years, 16 years later to the day--from 1922 to 1938. And, then it reverses itself.”
Characters and immersion generate insights the author would never consciously invent or foresee.
- Even for a committed outliner, a character's established personality can override the planned plot mid-writing; in Rules of Civility, the character Eve was supposed to return home to her parents, but Towles realized while writing that she would never do that, so she stayed on the train to Hollywood instead.
“Eve would never go home to her parents. She might say she's coming. And so, what ends up happening is that she just stayed on the train and goes all the way to Hollywood, in 1938.”
- When a writer creates a character with a background and personality unlike their own and places them in unfamiliar situations, the character can produce insights the author would never arrive at in their own life; 99% of the passages readers cite as most meaningful are things Towles says he never would have thought of himself.
“Ninety-nine percent of the time when someone says that, the passage that they're describing that affected them, that was insightful, is something that I never would've said in the course of my own life”
- Towles is not a research-driven writer who picks a topic and then researches it; instead he chooses topics grounded in something he already has deep familiarity with, having spent decades immersed in Russian literature and culture before deciding to set a novel in Russia.
“I'm not a research-driven writer. So, I don't pick a topic, research, and write it. What I do is I pick a topic that is grounded in something I have a deep familiarity with.”
Belief sustained by genuine admiration, constraint as metaphor for loss of identity, and decades of immersion inform artistic choice.
- A young artist does not need frequent or widespread validation; a single serious endorsement from someone they genuinely admire—as Peter Matthiessen gave Towles at Yale—can sustain belief and persistence for a decade, functioning as a covenant the artist returns to mentally to keep going.
“You don't need a lot of people and you don't need it all time. You need, like, one really good person, and you can live off of that for a decade.”
- After spending seven years on a first novel he disliked, Towles drew on decades of accumulated investment and validation to persist rather than quit, learning the key lesson that he should outline; he reasoned about what his mentor and his older future self would think of quitting.
“I began writing fiction on the weekends in my 1930s, and I spent seven years writing a book I didn't like and set that aside. And then--but I learned a lot from that. One of the things I learned from that was that I am an outliner.”
- Towles was not an investment banker but worked in investment management, joining a friend's firm as its first employee and managing money for high-net-worth individuals, endowments, and foundations across asset classes for 21 years before retiring after Rules of Civility became a bestseller.
“I was not an investment banker, although it was often reported that. We were in the investment management business. So, we managed money.”
- Confining the Count to the hotel is an advantageous constraint because it relieves Towles of having to depict all of Moscow over 30 years; instead he can show the changing world through a microcosm—shabbier furniture, changing guests, and the in-fiction example of the Soviet government opening hotels to citizens who pay in foreign currency to capture hard currency hidden in the black market.
“It brings a lot of advantage to me as the writer, because I don't have to write about all of Moscow over 30 years. I can focus on how the world is changing through the microcosm as the furniture gets shabby, or as the type of guests change”
- Luxury can be understood as a lack of constraint and poverty as constraint, yet in retrospect it is the inconveniences—not the conveniences like arriving late, postponing marriage, or not having children—that matter most; some challenge is almost always an essential element rather than an impediment to fulfillment, with children being the prime example.
“some challenge is almost always essential to feeling a greater sense of fulfillment... some challenge is not an impediment to the realization of those things. It's almost an essential element to the realization of those things.”
- At the time of WWI, Russia was the most backward of the great European nations—still effectively a 19th-century society with over 90% peasantry and over 90% illiteracy—and the Revolution flipped a switch overnight, with the new leadership vowing rapid industrialization, equal rights for women, and forced literacy to leap into the 20th century.
“at the time of the First World War, Russia was the most backward of the great European nations. They were a 19th century nation at that point.”
- The Soviet decree stripping all wine labels from the Metropol's cellar—reducing every bottle to merely 'red' or 'white'—functions as a metaphor for the Soviet stripping of individuality; just as a wine's character expresses the specific acre, slope, soil minerality, and year that produced it, human individuality arises from the particular 'acre' and 'weather' of one's upbringing, and erasing that distinctiveness is the deepest loss of the Soviet experiment.
“This is the whole Soviet mess: the stripping down of individuality that makes human nature so extraordinary. And, where in human nature it is this combination of the acre where we're growing up in and the weather that we're going through, that turns us into very specific individuals”
- For nearly 20 years Towles has read seriously with three friends on a monthly basis, working through projects—an author's five to seven novels, or a region, time period, or theme—chronologically, and focusing on classic literature time has already filtered as excellent, which yields a very high hit rate of rewarding books.
“we will take an author and read five, six, seven of their novels chronologically, or we'll take a region or a time period or a theme... we're tending to read classic literature. We're not sifting through the contemporary pile. And so the hit rate is very high.”
Sustained daily practice and momentum sustained by reworking prior material drive novels forward.
- Hemingway's practice of stopping writing when you know what happens next—and Towles's variant of starting the morning by transcribing and refashioning handwritten notes from the prior day—provides propulsive momentum, because the act of reworking existing material launches you forward and surfaces what should come next.
“the transfer of material I wrote yesterday by hand into a Word document first thing in the morning is a way of getting started... that sends you propulsively forward.”
- Towles's productive writing regimen is based on consistent hours rather than word counts or chapter targets—being at his desk roughly 8:00 to noon daily—because the worst experience for an artist is sitting down to write without knowing what to do, which can rapidly turn into depression.
“It's not about a word count. It's not about chapter targets... basically it's really about punching the clock.”
- Writers who produce a book a year retain only a fleeting impression of each, much as a reader of many mystery novels can no longer recall which book had which culprit, whereas Towles—taking five years per book and rereading constantly while editing—develops a deep, lasting narrative memory of his own work and the novels he reads.
“it takes me five years to write a book and I've only written three... I have a very good narrative memory... And so, 10 years goes by and they've written 10 books; and that's very hard. And, that book has made a very different impression on them”
A novel is a machine for meaning: thousands of craft elements in harmony yield layered interpretation across readers and time.
- A novel at its best is a 'machine for meaning': an assembly of thousands of craft elements (plot, setting, characterization, dialogue, allusion, word choice, point of view, cadence) held in harmony loosely enough that readers of different backgrounds, ages, and personalities consciously or unconsciously select different components and walk away with genuinely different interpretations—which is why great books survive centuries and why the same person can reread one at 20, 40, and 60 and find new meaning each time.
“the novel at its best is in essence a machine for meaning. If you think about the composition of a novel, what it is, is it's literally a thousand elements of craft that are being brought together.”
- To integrate Soviet brutality without flooding out the Count's sensibility, Towles used two narrative voices: 90% is third-person in the Count's tone and ideals, while about 10% comes from a more cynical, cutting voice—appearing first as footnotes, then chapter addendums, then major chapter introductions—that reports what was happening to ordinary citizens outside the hotel.
“90% of the book is told in the third person, which is an extension of the Count's reality... However, there's about 10% of the book, which is told by somebody very different. And, originally the voice shows up in footnotes.”