suitcase words
Marvin Minsky's term for words or slogans into which people pack many different meanings, so the same term means different things to different speakers.
As defined in A Lively Debate on the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict (with Robert Wright)
Where it comes up · 4
- A.J. Jacobs on Solving Life's Puzzles2 claims
- Melanie Mitchell on Artificial Intelligence1 claim
- Michael Munger on Constitutions1 claim
- A Lively Debate on the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict (with Robert Wright)1 claim
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “suitcase words” →
- Almost all language is a form of translation, because words like 'freedom' or 'virtue' carry different meanings for different people, so communication requires recognizing that what one person 'stuffs' into a word is not the same as another person's meaning.A.J. Jacobs on Solving Life's Puzzles
- Slogans like 'intifada,' 'free Palestine,' and 'from the river to the sea' are suitcase words into which different people pack very different meanings, so most chanters do not hold the violent associations Israelis attach to them, and meaning is not fixed but varies by the chanter's conception.A Lively Debate on the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict (with Robert Wright)
- Intelligence is a 'suitcase word' and a placeholder for phenomena we don't yet understand—it is not a single thing nor a yes/no property, and because our understanding of the brain and human psychology remains limited, the term awaits scientific advances to replace it with something more precise.Melanie Mitchell on Artificial Intelligence
- Even an imperfect shared vocabulary matters because language is fundamentally imperfect and gets harder to share as numbers grow; the phrase 'all men are created equal,' though not enforced and contested in meaning, was a constant drumbeat that, like drops on a rock, eventually wore down the defense of slavery by letting people charge defenders with hypocrisy.Michael Munger on Constitutions
- Engaging in crossword wordplay trains the mind to recognize the multiple meanings of words, which sensitizes a person to how slippery language is and changes how they read the news, becoming more aware that big words like 'freedom' or 'virtue' can be interpreted in many different ways.A.J. Jacobs on Solving Life's Puzzles