What this covers

Diane Ravitch, a historian and education scholar, talks with Russ Roberts on EconTalk about her book Slaying Goliath and her critique of the charter school movement. Ravitch argues that charter schools, despite being publicly funded, function as a step toward privatization of education and have failed to deliver on their promise to lift up disadvantaged students. The conversation ranges across thirty years of charter expansion, the role of billionaire-backed advocacy in promoting school choice, and the mechanisms by which some charter schools appear to succeed while actually narrowing their student bodies.

Central to Ravitch's case is the distinction between apparent and genuine achievement gains. She argues that successful charter schools largely succeed through selection bias—by cherry-picking motivated students, excluding children with disabilities, and pushing out struggling learners—rather than through superior pedagogy. She documents specific examples: Success Academy's attrition from 78 kindergarteners to 16 graduates, Ohio's Electronic Classroom of Tomorrow taking a billion dollars while accumulating "ghost students" and filing for bankruptcy, and San Diego's $50 million embezzlement scandal. On standardized testing, she contends that the US uniquely tests every child annually while the data yields little diagnostic value and merely predicts family income. Ravitch identifies poverty as the primary driver of test scores, arguing that anti-poverty investment would help more than school choice. She also examines how charter waiting lists are inflated, how certification and training matter for teaching quality, and how high teacher turnover at some charters reflects unsustainable working conditions. A recurring theme is the role of political actors like Betsy DeVos in using charters as a vehicle toward voucher systems that would direct public funds to religious schools.

Sharpest takeaway

Ravitch argues the charter school movement is a failed, billionaire-funded privatization effort that drains resources from public schools without closing achievement gaps, and that the real driver of low test scores is poverty, which schools alone cannot fix.

  • Charter schools succeed mainly by selecting motivated students and excluding the neediest, not by improving education
  • The biggest predictor of test scores is family income, so anti-poverty investment would help more than school choice
  • Charters lack the oversight of public schools, producing large-scale financial corruption

The argument · threads9 threads · 37 claims
0.85

Charter schools deviated from their original collaborative purpose to become competitive market-driven entities seeking to replace public schools.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Charter schools were originally meant to be R&D centers collaborating with public schools to test new approaches that could improve the public system, but over time they became competitors seeking market share and in some cases sought to drive public schools out of business, as in New Orleans where no public schools remain.

    “the charter idea was originally going to be a collaboration between public schools and experimental schools--charter schools, that were meant to be like R&D centers for the public sector”

  • There is no genuine charter 'movement'; what exists is a large amount of money from billionaires used to promote the privatization of public education, which after 30 years has failed to deliver on its original promise of saving poor kids from failing schools.

    “I think what there is, is just a lot of money provided by a long list of billionaires to promote the privatization of public education.”

  • There has long been a determined right-wing effort to defund public education, and charter schools function as a step toward vouchers, which are the ultimate goal of advocates like Betsy DeVos who want children to attend mainly religious schools, evidenced by DeVos sponsoring a Michigan voucher referendum in 2000 that was overwhelmingly defeated.

    “they are a step towards vouchers, and that the people who advocate the most avidly, like Betsy DeVos, see them as a step towards vouchers, and vouchers are the ultimate goal.”

  • Many studies show charter schools spend more on administration and overhead than public schools, while in public schools more of the money actually reaches classroom instruction, meaning charters are not more efficient.

    “there have been many studies showing that charters spend more on administration and overhead than public schools do. In public schools, more of the money actually gets to classroom instruction.”

  • Public school costs have risen partly because they now serve special-education students who require very expensive support, including children in diapers and wheelchairs, whom charters avoid; the federal government promised to pay 40% of special-education costs when it mandated it in the 1970s but never has, leaving an expensive burden on public schools.

    “the Federal Government, when it mandated special education back in the 1970s, promised that the Federal Government would pay 40% of the cost; and then it has never [inaudible]. It's a very, very expensive burden on public education that it must bear.”

0.85

Charter schools demonstrate no superior academic outcomes compared to public schools across multiple jurisdictions.

5 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Citing a doubling of proficiency in New Orleans is misleading because if proficiency starts very low, doubling it still leaves a low-performing district, and New Orleans dominates the scores of Louisiana, one of the lowest-performing states.

    “you can double proficiency if proficiency is very low and you still have a low-performing district.”

  • In the all-charter district of New Orleans, half of the open-enrollment charter schools are rated D or F by the State of Louisiana and are all-black, while the high-rated charters use selection processes; Louisiana is itself among the lowest-performing states.

    “half of the charter schools in New Orleans are failing schools. They were ranked by the state as either D- or F-rated schools, and they're all black.”

  • Milwaukee, which has full charter and voucher sectors plus a stripped public sector, sees all three sectors perform terribly with black students on par with peers in Mississippi, and Detroit, where charters enroll half the kids, remains the lowest-performing city in the country, demonstrating that choice has not produced success.

    “Milwaukee has a full-blown charter sector... All three sectors do terribly. No one has been saved.”

  • Apparent New Orleans test score gains are confounded by the post-Katrina disappearance of roughly 25% of students, mostly the poorest who fled to Houston and never returned, and by a significant funding increase from the federal government and philanthropists, so the gains cannot be validly attributed to the switch to charters.

    “about 25% of the kids disappeared after the storm... Those were the poorest kids who fled to Houston and other places and never came back.”

  • After 30 years of the charter experiment, only about 6% of children are enrolled in charter schools, which Ravitch considers a small return for the enormous investment.

    “after 30 years 6%[?] of kids are in charters. Well, that doesn't seem to me a huge return.”

0.73

School choice policies inherently intensify racial, social, and religious segregation across districts and schools.

3 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Any kind of school choice intensifies racial, social, and religious segregation, a finding supported by studies from the UCLA Center on Civil Rights and other groups and observed internationally, and the term 'school choice' originated as the favored slogan of Southern segregationists seeking to maintain segregation.

    “any kind of choice intensifies segregation--racial segregation, social segregation, religious segregation. And that's true internationally, not just here.”

  • The highest-performing charter schools in the country, the BASIS charters in Arizona, are composed primarily of white students and do not reflect the population served by Arizona public schools, having very few Latino and African-American children.

    “the highest performing charter schools in the country are the BASIS charter schools in Arizona and they are composed primarily--their highest-performing schools in Arizona are white nations.”

  • Whenever charters or vouchers are put to a public vote they are voted down, as vouchers were in Utah in 2007, Florida, Michigan in 2000, and as charter expansion was in Massachusetts in 2016, where minority communities voted against it and only wealthy white communities supported it.

    “It's interesting that whenever charters or vouchers are put to a vote, they're voted down. And, vouchers have always been voted down.”

0.65

Charter schools lack the oversight, accountability, and transparency of public schools, enabling widespread corruption and fraud.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Charter schools are publicly funded but Ravitch declines to call them public schools because in court their own defense is that they are not public schools; they accept the status of public schools for funding purposes but reject it when accountability is demanded.

    “they're public schools for getting the money; but when it comes to accountability, they're not public schools.”

  • Florida's voucher system takes a billion dollars a year out of public schools, yet voucher-school students do not take the same tests as public school students and there are no standards or accountability whatsoever for the voucher schools.

    “What we know about the voucher system in Florida is it takes a billion dollars a year out of the public schools.”

  • Because charter schools lack the oversight, accountability, and transparency of public schools, they are in a crisis of corruption, with the single biggest scandal being an online charter in San Diego where 11 people were indicted for embezzling $50 million, a scale of theft no public school has matched.

    “the single biggest scandal in the history of charter schools occurred just a year ago when 11 people were indicted in San Diego and it had to do with an online charter school that had embezzled $50 million dollars.”

  • The Supreme Court is likely to support vouchers in Espinoza v. Montana, which Ravitch finds scary because society would then fund not just Catholic schools but evangelical, yeshiva, and Muslim schools, including yeshivas that proudly do not teach English or modern science, with no standards or accountability comparable to public schools.

    “vouchers to me are probably going to be supported by the Supreme Court in this Espinoza versus Montana case, and I think that's really scary”

0.65

Poverty and family income are the primary drivers of academic outcomes, making poverty interventions more effective than charter schools.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The biggest predictor of test scores is family income; poverty, not school quality, is the primary driver of academic outcomes, so investments addressing poverty (health clinics, prenatal and family services) would do more good than charter schools.

    “Because, the biggest predictor of test scores is family income.”

  • About 20% of US children live in poverty, compared with around 5% or less in Scandinavian nations, and US schools reflect a failing society with serious social problems including homelessness and lack of medical care for children.

    “We have right now about 20% of our kids living in poverty. That's not the case in any Scandinavian nation to which we compare ourselves to, where the poverty rate is somewhere around 5% and sometimes less.”

  • Billionaires should look at the evidence showing charter investment hasn't produced desired results and instead fund things actually needed, such as health clinics offering prenatal and family services in neighborhoods where children lack health care, and should lobby to pay higher taxes that fund education.

    “What I will do instead is open health clinics in neighborhoods where kids don't have health care.”

  • The right intervention for poor, struggling schools is to reduce class size for children overwhelmed by poverty, special needs and language barriers, and to restore the arts and other reasons to come to school that have been stripped away in favor of relentless test preparation.

    “I think what we should be doing for those kids is reducing their class size.”

0.59

High-performing charters achieve results through selective admissions and exclusionary practices rather than superior instruction.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The most successful charter schools achieve their results by screening parents to get the best kids, excluding children with disabilities, and pushing out troublemakers; they have become selective schools, while non-selective charters tend to be very low-performing.

    “Those that are the most successful screen the--either as Robert Pondiscio says, they screen the parents in order to get the best kids, or they don't want kids with disabilities, or they exclude the kids who are troublemakers. They have become selective schools.”

  • Success Academy cherry-picks the best students and shows high attrition: its first graduating class began with 78 children in kindergarten but only 16 remained at graduation, and after fourth grade it accepts no new students, so kids who leave in fifth or sixth grade return to public schools rather than another charter.

    “Their first graduating class began with 78 children in kindergarten. By the time they graduated, there were only 16 left.”

  • Charter school waiting lists are unaudited and vastly inflated marketing ploys; a Boston audit by public radio found duplications and students already accepted still listed as waiting, and most charters have no real lotteries because demand is low, with 80% of Los Angeles charters and several Detroit and Washington State charters having vacancies or closing for lack of demand.

    “The talk about waiting lists is ridiculous because no one has ever audited them.”

0.52

Charter schools impose unsustainable working conditions on teachers, causing rapid turnover and staff instability.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Charter schools have tremendous teacher turnover, with Success Academy experiencing roughly 50% turnover every year, because working teachers 60 to 80 hours a week is unsustainable as a career, forcing near-complete staff replacement within two years.

    “Success Academy, which you mention, has a 50% turnover rate every single year. They are constantly advertising for new teachers.”

  • The US has a national teacher shortage, not a surplus, caused by low pay relative to other careers and by 20-30 years of demonizing teachers through think tanks, journalists, and films like Waiting for Superman, so removing certification would not solve a shortage rooted in disrespect and compensation.

    “we have a teacher shortage because we have so demonized teachers over the past 20 to 30 years that we have a national shortage of teachers.”

  • Amateur teachers are not good teachers; classroom management and pedagogical training are essential, so teachers should hold a bachelor's degree in a discipline plus certification, and models like Teach for America with only five weeks of preparation used as a stepping stone are inadequate.

    “I don't think that amateur teachers are good teachers. I don't think that Teach for America is a good model for teaching because it's only five weeks of preparation”

  • Public school principals can readily fire bad teachers, who do not receive tenure until after three to four years of repeated observation, and tenure grants only a right to a hearing when accused, not lifetime job protection like university professors; if bad teachers are getting tenured, that is an administrative failure.

    “This is not lifetime tenure. It's not the kind of lifetime tenure that professors have at a university. Teachers have a right to a hearing and that's all they have a right to.”

0.52

Standardized testing wastes billions on invalid assessment that produces no diagnostic value and misleads policymakers about school quality.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • The theory that schools should fire the bottom 5% of teachers each year based on test-score gains never worked and is self-defeating, because it simply identifies teachers working with the lowest-performing students, who show the smallest gains; wherever value-added by test scores has been tried, the best teachers turn out to be those in the best schools with the wealthiest kids.

    “There was this theory, which Rick Hanushek helped to propound, that you should fire the lowest-performing teachers every year, the bottom 5%.”

  • The US is the only advanced country that tests every child every year, wasting billions, yet the tests yield no diagnostic value: questions are often poorly written with multiple defensible answers, results arrive months later when the child has a new teacher, and they produce only rankings that stigmatize schools rather than information that could guide help.

    “we're the only advanced country in the world that tests every child every year and waste billions of dollars on it.”

  • By the nature of standardized tests, children from poverty will always be classified in the bottom half because tests are great predictors of family income, and most kids do not move out of the bottom half.

    “the kids who come from poverty are going to always be classified in the bottom half because tests are great predictors of family income”

  • The 2010 documentary Waiting for Superman was propaganda with no evidence at the time that charters would save any child, contained factually inaccurate use of national test data by treating anyone below 'Proficient' as failing, was produced by right-wing evangelical anti-gay billionaire Philip Anschutz, and featured staged scenes.

    “that was sheer propaganda. In 2010 when that film was released, there was absolutely zero evidence that charter schools would save any kid; but it helped to propagandize the movement.”

0.26

Many charter schools close shortly after opening, disrupting families and demonstrating the instability of the sector.

2 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Many charter schools close almost as soon as they open—in Florida and other states roughly one closes for every one that opens—so a family may enroll a child only to have the school shut mid-year, leaving them stranded.

    “many charters close almost as soon as they open. Right now in Florida and some other states... for every charter school that opens, another one is closing.”

  • Ohio's Electronic Classroom of Tomorrow, the largest online charter in the country, took a billion dollars over 20 years with high dropout and low graduation rates, and when audited was found to have many 'ghost students,' owed the state $60 million, and chose bankruptcy over repayment.

    “It took a billion dollars over 20 years and had high dropout rates, low graduation rates... we find you have a lot of ghost students. You owe the state $60 million dollars.”