cherry-picking
The practice of selectively admitting the most able or motivated students while excluding harder-to-educate ones.
As defined in Diane Ravitch on Slaying Goliath
Where it comes up · 5
- Diane Ravitch on Slaying Goliath2 claims
- Finding Undiscovered Talent1 claim
- John Taylor on Rules, Discretion, and First Principles1 claim
- Jerry Muller on the Tyranny of Metrics1 claim
- 144 - Conquering Hate1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “cherry-picking” →
- Khan argues that people deeply committed to an ideology like Spencer and Taylor have a barrage of argumentative tactics, a worldview built over a long period by cherry-picking arguments and reading biased material, and are seeking power—making them much harder to reach—whereas emotion-driven followers can connect to her humanity and thereby their own.144 - Conquering Hate
- Success Academy cherry-picks the best students and shows high attrition: its first graduating class began with 78 children in kindergarten but only 16 remained at graduation, and after fourth grade it accepts no new students, so kids who leave in fifth or sixth grade return to public schools rather than another charter.Diane Ravitch on Slaying Goliath
- The most successful charter schools achieve their results by screening parents to get the best kids, excluding children with disabilities, and pushing out troublemakers; they have become selective schools, while non-selective charters tend to be very low-performing.Diane Ravitch on Slaying Goliath
- When surgical report cards publicized surgeons' success and failure rates, some surgeons responded with 'creaming' or cherry-picking—taking easier cases and turning down high-risk patients with co-morbidities—so that the people who suffer are those who don't get operated on, a harm that never appears in the metrics.Jerry Muller on the Tyranny of Metrics
- GPT-3's public website let people experiment, and because it succeeds only about 4 times in 10, users cherry-pick the good outputs and post them on Twitter, creating tremendous hype.Finding Undiscovered Talent
- Across the last three and a half decades there have been a striking number of temporary interventions (tax rebates, home-buying programs, cash-for-clunkers) that, when evaluated individually with more precision than broad trends allow, have remarkably little academic support from either left or right—yet they keep happening, suggesting something beyond economic research drives them.John Taylor on Rules, Discretion, and First Principles