Daron Acemoglu on Shared Prosperity and Good Jobs
What this covers
Daron Acemoglu and Russ Roberts discuss the sources of shared prosperity and the policy levers required to restore inclusive economic growth. Acemoglu rejects the premise that redistribution alone can sustain broad-based living standards, arguing instead that durable prosperity must flow from labor-generating work across skill levels. The conversation traces why market forces do not automatically produce such outcomes, examining the Race Between Automation and New Tasks—the empirical pattern in which technological change can destroy more jobs than it creates unless deliberate choices steer innovation toward labor-complementary directions.
The episode ranges across history, institutions, and policy. Historical case studies include the British Industrial Revolution's wage stagnation (the "Engels' Pause") and its eventual recovery through democratization and institutional reform, alongside contrasts between German and American responses to robotization and the postwar Nordic model's success in balancing worker, business, and state interests. On current conditions, Acemoglu presents data on stagnant real wages across multiple education levels and argues that the decline involves three distinct mechanisms: globalization, automation, and institutional deterioration including monopsony power and shifting corporate norms. The conversation moves into policy territory—where Directed Technological Change through government funding, minimum-wage floors, union power, and reformed education all appear as intentional corrections to market failures. Throughout, Acemoglu emphasizes that democratic self-correction, not technocratic design, must drive such choices, and he registers skepticism about both a future of welfare transfers and complacency about current institutional breakdown.
Acemoglu argues that shared prosperity must come from a market economy that actively generates good jobs across all skill levels rather than from redistribution, and that achieving this requires steering technological change and institutions (via a functioning democracy) toward labor-complementary innovation rather than pure automation.
- Redistribution-based 'live off transfers' models are neither psychologically satisfying nor politically/economically sustainable
- Whether automation/globalization yield shared prosperity depends on institutional and technological choices, not automatic market forces
- Good-jobs creation requires institutions (minimum wage, unions, education/training, government-directed innovation) plus a self-correcting democracy
Education policy treats college as universal path despite flawed spending-outcome relationship and changing graduate-wage dynamics.
- Apparent stagnation in college-graduate wages is partly explained by the dramatically increased proportion of the population going to college, especially over the last 20 years, which brings in people of different ability levels, so you would expect at least the rate of wage growth to slow.
“the proportion of the population going into college has grown dramatically, especially in the last 20 years. So, it's not the same people.”
- There is disturbing evidence of little relationship between per-student spending and measured educational outcomes, so the default position to be explained is that simply spending more money has not proven helpful, even allowing that outcome measures may be flawed.
“there doesn't seem to be much of a relationship between per-student spending and various measures of outcomes... the idea of 'spending more money' has not proven to be very helpful”
- The current emphasis on K-12 as merely the entry port into a college experience is a mistake because not everyone can or should go to college, and we need alternative ways to enrich the skillsets of those not going—but the German vocational model is too scripted and fails to offer the second chances and social mobility that the fabric of US society requires.
“the current emphasis on K-12 [Kindergarten through 12th grade] as the entry port into a college experience is a mistake. Not everyone can go to college. Not everyone should go to college.”
Dignity and social belonging matter as much as material living standards and drive legitimate political resentment.
- Beyond the material side of the standard of living, the dignity component is equally or more important: too many people in America today do not feel they matter and struggle to feel self-respect, and these are the people most worth worrying about; their feeling of being neglected and ignored fueled rightly-felt resentment in the heartland and in Britain.
“there are too many people in America today who don't feel like they matter, and who are struggling to feel self-respect. And those are the folks that I'm most worried about.”
Corporate and political norms have eroded, permitting behavior once considered unacceptable and reducing system competitiveness.
- Just as corporate norms generally have changed, pharmaceutical pricing behavior that would have been considered unacceptable 25-60 years ago is now treated as acceptable simply because firms can do it, reflecting a broader erosion of norms in corporate and political behavior.
“I see that in, say, the pharmaceutical industry where pricing, I think, would have been unacceptable 25, 50, 60 years ago, is now considered like, 'Well, why not?'”
- A troubling agreed-upon reality is that the US two-party political system is less competitive than it used to be and parties' ability to control their members is stronger, which is a bad thing, even though the exact causes are not well understood.
“the two-party political system is not very competitive. It's less competitive than it used to be... their ability to control their members is stronger; and I think that's a bad thing.”
Unions and wage floors restrict job access while helping incumbent workers, creating tradeoffs without clear resolution.
- Unions are a mixed bag whose role as a counterbalance is unclear, and they generally raise wages by restricting access to jobs—similar in this respect to the minimum wage, which helps the workers who keep their jobs while raising concerns about those who lose them.
“unions generally raise wages by restricting access to those jobs. It's such a mixed bag.”