What this covers
Maeve Cohen, co-director of Rethinking Economics, speaks with host Russ Roberts about the state of economics education and why its current form produces uncritical graduates and opaque policy. The conversation turns on a central complaint: undergraduate economics is taught as a single, value-free science through standardized textbooks with no competing schools of thought, unlike philosophy or politics. Because most economics students never pursue graduate study, their simplified worldview shapes decisions in business, media, voting, and policy-making. Cohen and Roberts explore how this narrow pedagogy disconnects economics from actual people and society, and why that matters for democracy and human wellbeing.
The discussion ranges across the pedagogical roots of the problem—professors trained in ideas but not in teaching—to its downstream effects. Standard economics cannot measure externalities like community texture or environmental harm, so it misses large portions of human wellbeing. Homo Economicus, the rational agent model, strips actual humans from the picture and mistakes the blackboard for reality. Yet both speakers acknowledge the genuine power of economic thinking: incentives matter, and emergent order arises from individual actions in ways policy-makers must respect. The pair spar over whether the solution is to abandon markets in favor of democratic control, or to make economics teaching far more honest about its assumptions and limitations. Cohen contends that studying competing schools—Austrian economics, feminist, Marxist—builds critical thinking even if no school has a monopoly on truth. Roberts worries that concentration of political power poses dangers equal to or greater than market failures. Throughout, they return to a single problem: economics confidently presents itself as physics applied to humans, when it is a contested social science whose complexity resists reduction to equations.
Cohen argues that economics is taught as a single value-free 'science' rather than as a plural, contested social science, and that this narrow, dehumanized pedagogy produces uncritical citizens, opaque policy, and unmeasured social and ecological harms.
- Undergraduate economics is taught as fact via a single textbook with no reading lists or competing schools of thought, unlike politics or philosophy
- Most economics students never go beyond undergrad, so their simplified worldview shapes business, media, voting and policy
- Standard economics cannot price or measure things like community texture and the environment, so it misses large parts of human wellbeing and harm
Economic education teaches memorized results and mechanical models instead of transforming how students see the world.
- The Financial Crisis did not change anything fundamental about how economics is taught; textbooks responded by adding a chapter rather than rethinking the curriculum, and US teaching is essentially the same as the UK's.
“I think most textbooks have responded to it by, say, adding a chapter. They certainly haven't re-thought anything fundamental about the way the curriculum is approached.”
- Economics professors are trained in the ideas of economics but not in how to teach, so they reproduce their own graduate-school notes in dumbed-down form, perpetuating the discipline's narrow pedagogy.
“when you become a professor of economics, as I was for 30 years, you aren't trained in how to teach. You are trained in the ideas of economics.”
- Just as undergraduate astronomy delivers a dumbed-down set of graduate results instead of the wonder of the night sky, economics teaches memorizable results rather than a way of seeing the world through a new lens, when the life-changing classes in any field are the ones that change how you see the world.
“in astronomy you have this unbelievable, magical, awesome, wondrous poetry of the nighttime sky. But that's not what you learn... the life-changing classes in any field... are the ones that get you to see the world through a different lens--and that's what I think economics should be and often isn't.”
Supply and demand and rational-agent models are powerful tools but economists mistake them for reality, ignoring actual complexity and non-material human values.
- Supply and demand is a powerful simplifying tool but only a tool; many economists mistakenly treat the blackboard model as the actual real world, which is a terrible error because it doesn't capture the richness of how interactions actually work.
“that stark, blackboard model--which I love... But it is only a tool. It is only a simplification... But I think most economists think, 'Well, that is how--that's actually the real world.' And that's a terrible error.”
- The deeper danger of the rational-agent model is not occasional human error but that, once you treat people as programmable robots who just need the right incentives, you start believing you can make society better by adding up everyone's utility — a materialistic misunderstanding that ignores belonging, connection, and how we experience life.
“we talk about individual agents maximizing utility, in a market. And there's no people in that. So, we look at the rational agent. And I'm certainly not rational.”
- Most economists like to think of themselves as physicists applying tools to humans instead of atoms, and assume the discipline advances like physics through empirical testing and rejection of falsified ideas (so Adam Smith need not be read), but economics is a social science whose complexity cannot be stripped to a linear equation.
“most economists like to think of themselves as like physicists, but applying their tools to human beings instead of, say, atoms... As if economics advances like physics does, through empirical testing and rejection of things that don't match the data. But... that's really not what economics is doing.”
Economists present detached authority while benefiting from the status quo, and claims of one true model are dangerous when scholars lack awareness of their own evangelism.
- No single person or model has a monopoly on economic truth; people who claim one correct model of the world are dangerous evangelists, and evangelism only has value when the evangelist is aware they are evangelizing.
“there's no one model that's exactly right. And people who are going to around saying... they are also a little bit dangerous, because... they are evangelists. And evangelism has value, as long as you are aware that you are evangelist.”
- Roberts justifies his tolerance of market outcomes by his worry about the concentration of political power: he doesn't want firms focused on influencing government, because government tends to help its friends rather than do what reformers intend, while conceding this rationale may be a post-hoc justification colored by his doing well in the current system.
“I'm very worried about the concentration of political power... I don't want firms to be focused on influencing that. And I worry that government will only help its friends and not do what you and I would like it to do.”
- Economists present themselves as detached observers who heal the economy like doctors, but many benefit explicitly or implicitly from the status quo (hoping to work at the Fed or consult on Wall Street), so their policy advice is compromised by self-interest and imperfect knowledge.
“many economics benefit either explicitly or implicitly from the status quo. They either hope to work for the Federal Reserve; they maybe consult on Wall Street. And so, they are somewhat compromised.”
Market outcomes involve genuine tradeoffs between benefits like convenience and costs like community damage that the price mechanism cannot fully capture.
- Rather than artificially penalizing Amazon, society could adopt a social norm of sacrificing some standard of living to shop at the local bookstore, because if everyone follows only the narrowest self-interest the institutions they value (like the corner bookstore) won't survive.
“we could have a social norm that says, 'If you value that bookstore on the corner, you might want to sacrifice some of your standard of living to shop there, because if you only follow the narrowest of self-interest, it won't be there any more.'”
- Big-box stores and Amazon deliver genuine benefits (cheap goods, vast selection, convenience), but that cheap stuff is not free: it changes the texture of daily life and damages communities, costs the price mechanism cannot capture, so the full picture of these trades is not obvious even when people freely choose them.
“it's not free, that cheap stuff. It changes the texture of daily life. And that, we don't measure... I'm just saying that the full picture isn't obvious.”
People respond to incentives and individual actions create emergent complexity, which are foundational insights across all economic schools.
- Across all schools (Marxist, neo-Keynesian, Austrian), two cornerstones are undeniable: people respond to incentives (implying every action has a foregone-opportunity cost), and when people act together, emergent complexity arises that is not merely the sum of individual actions, which makes policy design genuinely challenging.
“People respond to incentives. Which also implies that there is cost to action. There is foregone opportunities... And then that--when we act, together, things happen that aren't just the sum of our individual actions.”
Lord Byron wrote the 'She Walks in Beauty' lines quoted in a prior episode.
- The 'She Walks in Beauty' lines quoted in a prior episode were written by Lord Byron, not Shelley, contrary to the host's earlier attribution.
“I pointed out incorrectly that that poet of those lines was Shelley. In fact, it's Lord Byron.”