Simultaneity problem
A situation where two variables cause each other, making it impossible to disentangle which is cause and which is effect—here, whether a paper's Op Ed page causes its readership's slant or reflects it.
As defined in David Leonhardt on the Media
Other definitions
The difficulty in causal inference when the supposed cause and effect influence each other, so observed correlations may reflect causation running in the opposite direction.
Ian Ayres on Super Crunchers and the Power of Data 10/22/2007
Where it comes up · 3
- Russ Roberts (and Robin Hanson) on Truth and Economics 01/26/20092 claims
- Valerie Ramey on Stimulus and Multipliers 10/24/20111 claim
- David Leonhardt on the Media1 claim
Most important claims · 4 of 4Search all claims for “Simultaneity problem” →
- Economists should be cautious about the minimum wage evidence, because a single study like Card and Krueger's showing employment gains does not outweigh dozens of studies showing harm, but the bigger problem is that any one study is an attempt to isolate a single policy from many simultaneous changes.Russ Roberts (and Robin Hanson) on Truth and Economics 01/26/2009
- Government spending decisions are simultaneous with monetary policy, tax policy, and regulation, and causation runs in both directions (a weak economy can prompt stimulus, and stimulus can be mistaken for the cause of a weak economy), so correlation between spending and output cannot be read as causation.Valerie Ramey on Stimulus and Multipliers 10/24/2011
- Because the New York Times is located in New York City, its readers skew more liberal than the country as a whole, which is intertwined with the character of its Op Ed page in a simultaneity problem where it is hard to tell cause from effect.David Leonhardt on the Media
- States with high minimum wages having low unemployment does not refute the minimum wage view, because of simultaneity: states with low unemployment may be the ones able to afford higher minimum wages, and many other state differences also exist.Russ Roberts (and Robin Hanson) on Truth and Economics 01/26/2009