What this covers
Will Storr sits down with EconTalk host Russ Roberts to make the case that status is not a preference but a biological imperative—a subconscious operating system that has shaped human behavior since our ancestors lived in cooperative tribes. The conversation ranges across psychology, politics, economics, and culture, treating status as the hidden mechanism behind much of what we observe: workplace hierarchies, social media dynamics, moral outrage, tribalism, and even the stories we tell about ourselves. Storr argues that attempts to escape the Status Game entirely—whether through Buddhist monasticism, hikikomori isolation, or Communist ideology—have consistently failed and often produced the opposite of what was intended, with some ending in catastrophe.
The discussion unpacks how status operates differently from related forces. Status anxiety drives both civilization's greatest achievements and its worst atrocities, while power and status are distinct desires: power exhausts, but status hunger never stops. Storr traces a psychological shift in Western culture beginning in the early 1980s toward individualism and perfectionism, which he links to neoliberal economic reforms under Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher, though Roberts pushes back with evidence that deregulation's scope was narrower than Storr suggests. The pair examine how cancel culture and wokeism operate as status attacks, how group status matters as deeply as individual status, and how aging offers an escape route: abandoning youth's status games for different Reward Spaces where one can rank higher. A practical note emerges: Reduce Your Moral Sphere, stop surveilling others for moral failure, and life becomes less angry.
Storr argues that status is not a want but a biological need — an inescapable, subconscious driver of human behavior that shapes everything from prisons to politics — and that morality, justice, and tribalism are largely downstream expressions of the competition for individual and group status.
- The brain has an always-on 'status detection system' because cooperative human survival depended on being valued by the group
- Attempts to escape the status game (Buddhists, hikikomori, Communists) fail and often end catastrophically
- Truth and justice are 'local' and downstream from group status competition
Status concerns pervade human interaction, from narrative archetypes to academic conventions to expressions of indignation.
- The prevalence of orphans in children's underdog stories reflects status: an orphan loses not only parental guidance and income but any status the parents would have conferred, leaving the child with nothing to stand on, which intensifies the grievance and injustice we identify with.
“the kid who normally would be able to stand on the shoulders of the parent in some dimension, has nothing... that underdog is, you're right--they have a grievance.”
- Author ordering in academic papers is so charged with status that economists sometimes explicitly note in acknowledgments that order was random or alphabetical, lest readers infer the first author contributed more — illustrating that even tiny stakes provoke intense status competition.
“People will write that the order of the authors was chosen randomly, lest you think that the first author is the more important one”
- The angry cry 'Do you know who I am?' is, despite appearing as an assertion of importance, fundamentally a statement of insecurity — a plea that 'you are not giving me the status I am entitled to.'
“it's basically an incredible statement of insecurity because it's saying, 'You are not giving me the status I am entitled to.'”
We authentically desire to earn genuine respect and admiration, though we often deceive ourselves about whether we truly have.
- Echoing Adam Smith, man naturally desires not only to be loved but to be lovely — meaning we care about honestly earning the respect and admiration of others, though we sometimes fool ourselves about whether we have earned it.
“Man naturally desires, not only to be loved, but to be lovely.”
Neoliberal economic policies like deregulation were not inherently selfish and did not substantially dismantle the welfare state.
- Deregulation under Reagan (begun under Carter with Alfred Kahn) introduced competition into protected industries like trucking and airlines that had been profiting at consumers' expense, which is hard to characterize as an encouragement of selfishness; the welfare state was not substantially dismantled, so cultural change toward a transactional, brand-like sense of self has deeper causes than neoliberal economics alone.
“it introduced competition into industries that were making lots of money at consumers' expense because they were protected. And, I have trouble seeing that as an encouragement of self-interest or selfishness.”
Collective welfare provision through civil society, not state mandates, was the aim of some conservative cultural arguments.
- Reading the Thatcher 'change the soul' quote charitably, the aim was to devolve responsibility away from the collective state toward voluntary association through civil society where people care for each other — though in some cases, like a welfare state, voluntary provision is largely a myth.
“the redemption of the soul... was about devolving responsibility away from the collective, the state, toward, not the individual so much as the voluntary.”