cancel culture
The practice of withdrawing support for or removing public figures over objectionable statements or actions.
As defined in Barkha Dutt
Other definitions
Social phenomenon where individuals are publicly shamed, disinvited, or have their opportunities withdrawn due to perceived offensive statements or positions, often without due process
“The Treason of the Intellectuals,” with Niall Ferguson | Uncommon Knowledge
Where it comes up · 22
- Dave Collum (Profit From Central Planning And “Money Printing!”)?4 claims
- 189 - Wealth Happiness3 claims
- 172 - Among The Deplorables3 claims
- Greg Lukianoff3 claims
- 368 - Freedom Censorship2 claims
- 160 - The Revenge Of History2 claims
- Tim Urban - Idea Labs and High-Rung Thinking - [Invest Like the Best, EP.317]2 claims
- What's shame got to do with it? - Dr. Eve Ekman & Tenzin Chogkyi.2 claims
and 14 more
Most important claims · 10 of 35Search all claims for “cancel culture” →
- Where Chomsky described mass media as manufacturing consent, we are now in the age of manufactured dissent: platforms like Twitter amplify disagreements even when those disagreements don't exist offline, and de-platforming figures like Trump was wrong because cancel culture should not extend to removing people rather than specific harmful content.Barkha Dutt
- The current cancel culture has fired roughly 200 professors—about twice the under-100 fired during the entire McCarthy period (1947-1957)—and professor self-censorship has risen from McCarthyism's ~9% toning down writing to about 35% toning down writing and ~91% self-censoring in some aspect of life, making it larger in scale, especially since it occurs after academic-freedom law was firmly established.368 - Freedom Censorship
- What is commonly called 'shaming' in public discourse about cancel culture is actually the expression of contempt or disgust rather than shame itself, creating semantic confusion about what is being weaponized.What's shame got to do with it? - Dr. Eve Ekman & Tenzin Chogkyi.
- Because attraction to religion and tribalism is baked into human nature, the liberal/cosmopolitan project of overcoming them does not produce an open secular world but instead summons an ersatz religion and tribalism—cancel culture and woke phenomena—that, having been assembled over a few years rather than evolved over millennia, is more oppressive and frightening than the old-fashioned religion it replaced.Moshe Koppel on Norms, Tradition, and Resilient Societies
- The quest for moral purity in human beings is fruitless and dangerous because everything we value was created by flawed people—T.S. Eliot was an anti-Semite, Ezra Pound a fascist, Byron a pedophile—so a culture that erases creators for their sins would have nothing of value left; punishing Louis C.K. professionally may be merited, but expunging his entire body of work from the cultural record is disturbing.160 - The Revenge Of History
- Social impropriety—reputational punishment for declaring support for now-despicable ideas—is an important and legitimate tool alongside legal equality for moving bad ideas into the past, but it must be applied correctly because too blunt a tool stops working and merely creates new grievances that require more opprobrium.172 - Among The Deplorables
- Cancel culture is the most repugnant social invention of the younger generation because it attempts to destroy people's livelihoods and existences over disagreements; the person doing the canceling may be protected but vulnerable people (teachers, professors, low-level employees) are destroyed.Dave Collum (Profit From Central Planning And “Money Printing!”)?
- Because the modern right has no serious policy platform (reduced to 'build the wall' and isolationism), all political debate has been ejected in favor of culture-war issues, and because reasonable conservatives have disengaged from arenas like college campuses, there is no sane right-of-center counterweight to ground out and check far-left ideas, leaving only a hateful framing versus a misguided-but-empathetic one.381 - Delusions Right And Left
- A completely rational and compassionate attempt to mitigate violent crime could have produced stop-and-frisk: the data show perpetrators and victims of violent crime are disproportionately young minority males, and these communities suffer not from too much policing but the wrong type, so castigating Bloomberg as a racist monster reflects the miscalibrations of the woke left.189 - Wealth Happiness
- Cancel culture is defined as the uptick (beginning around 2014) of campaigns to get people fired, deplatformed, expelled, or otherwise punished for speech that would be protected under the First Amendment, plus the resulting culture of fear, with nuance imported by analogy to public-employee law.368 - Freedom Censorship