Humans Are Overrated (with Christine Webb)
What this covers
Christine Webb, a primatologist and author of The Arrogant Ape, speaks with Russ Roberts on EconTalk about how the myth of human exceptionalism shapes both science and our ecological trajectory. Webb argues that the belief in human uniqueness and superiority has distorted research on animal cognition while simultaneously driving environmental destruction. The conversation ranges across how animals demonstrate capacities long thought exclusively human—theory of mind, teaching, planning, and emotional depth—and why comparing animals to humans on human-designed tasks produces systematically misleading conclusions about intelligence across species.
The pair examine specific cases of methodological bias in comparative cognition research, where deprived captive animals are tested against comfortable humans in familiar settings, stacking the deck before the comparison begins. They explore how scientific literature itself reveals bias: a 2020 analysis of ecology journals found competition mentioned nearly two-thirds of the time versus cooperation less than 2 percent, despite both being equally abundant in nature. Webb proposes redefining evolutionary success through Evolutionary Success as Sustainability—the ability to sustain thriving communities over time—which reverses the verdict on human superiority. Roberts pushes back on several points, including Webb's claim that humans fail Intelligence as novel problem-solving, instead attributing climate inaction to a Collective Action Problem. The conversation also touches Awe, Hope vs Optimism, and how recognizing ourselves as Multi-Species Collective might reshape how we relate to death and the living world.
Webb argues that human exceptionalism—the belief that humans are uniquely superior to and separate from other life—is a myth that both drives the ecological crisis and systematically distorts science's ability to understand animal minds and capabilities.
- Comparative cognition studies are rigged by testing deprived captive animals against comfortable WEIRD humans on human-designed tasks
- Animals demonstrate capacities once thought uniquely human, like theory of mind, teaching, and planning
- Defining intelligence as living sustainably within nature reverses the human-superiority verdict
Human arrogance and false superiority, not humans as a species, drive ecological destruction.
- The humans most at risk of the worst consequences of the ecological crisis are often the ones least responsible for causing it, which is part of why the 'arrogant ape' should not be equated with all of humankind.
“those humans who are the most at risk of the worst consequences of the ecological crisis are often the ones who are the least responsible for causing it in the first place.”
- Human arrogance—specifically the belief that we are separate from and superior to the rest of life—is a major cause of the ecological crisis, because seeing ourselves as outside the living world lets us treat other beings and environments as mere resources to exploit without abandon.
“I think that when we believe that we are separate from and superior to the rest of life on earth, it leads us to treat other beings and their environments as mere resources or objects to be exploited.”
- The 'arrogant ape' is not all humans, a particular culture, or an individual, but a character or mask—inspired by hubris in Greek tragedy—representing a worldview of arrogance that people may hold unawares and that they can change over their lifetime.
“the arrogant ape represents a character, and I was inspired by the concept of hubris in Greek tragedy, this sort of arrogance that leads protagonists to their downfall, but they're often unaware that they even hold this arrogant worldview.”
Scientific studies systematically overstate human cognitive uniqueness through biased methods and flawed comparisons.
- Evolutionary biology tends to conflate evolutionary success with ecological dominance, but success can instead be defined as the ability to sustain thriving interspecies communities over time—by which measure mosses, around for hundreds of millions of years versus humans' 200,000, far outperform us.
“There's a tendency in evolutionary biology to confound evolutionary success with ecological dominance.”
- The hidden assumption that makes rigged human-animal comparisons seem valid—that deprived environments don't harm other beings' development and well-being as much as they harm humans'—is itself a problematic, human-centric premise.
“And, I think that assumption, that environments don't matter as much for other beings as they do for our own development and well-being, is a problematic one, right? And, it's a very human-centric one.”
- Comparative cognition studies that conclude humans are cognitively superior are unscientific because they compare deprived captive chimpanzees—raised in labs, separated from mothers, tested on human tasks—against comfortable, autonomous WEIRD humans tested with familiar materials, stacking the deck before the comparison begins.
“they're typically comparing the abilities of chimpanzees who live in highly restricted man-made environments like labs or zoos. These chimpanzees have often been separated from their biological mothers at birth.”
Animals possess rich emotional and cognitive lives—theory of mind, teaching, planning—demonstrable through relationship-based observation.
- The scientific norm of detaching from study animals can introduce more noise into the data, because an animal terrified of the researcher reveals little of its emotional and cognitive world; forming trusting relationships and using empathy—as Barbara Smuts and Len Howard did—is how one comes to understand rich mental lives, just as humans come to know each other through relationship.
“that lack of relationship I think can actually introduce more noise into the data. Right? If you are studying an individual who is terrified of you, how much are you really going to learn about their emotional and cognitive worlds? Not very much.”
- Through Len Howard's careful observation of birds as trusting individuals, she documented mother birds teaching fledglings about the danger of glass by placing food on alternating sides until the young birds learn the glass barrier exists—demonstrating teaching, another supposed cognitive rubicon thought to separate humans from animals.
“how mothers will teach their fledglings about glass by taking a worm or a bit of food on one side of the glass so that the fledglings will peck on it, and then moving to the other side”
- A juvenile baboon named Bear approached the researcher the day after a frightening troop aggression and gave a bared-teeth pacifying gesture, which is most parsimoniously explained as Bear knowing the researcher had witnessed the prior incident and trying to reassure her—demonstrating theory of mind, and doing so across species, contradicting the teaching that humans alone possess this capacity.
“And not only did Bear show that ability, but he showed it for a member of another species, which was astounding to me.”
- Contrary to the long-running scientific claim that humans are the only animal with a sense of the future, there is good evidence animals plan—such as birds caching food in thousands of separate locations they can later access—and scientists who assert humans alone hold a given trait are often later proven wrong.
“When you look at birds who are caching food for the winter coming--and they're making plans, they're storing them in thousands of separate locations that they know that they'll be able to access.”
Humans are unique but not superior; questioning mortality awareness and consciousness hierarchies undermines claims of singular human distinction.
- The presumption that we can never know what's in an animal's mind ignores that the same uncertainty applies to other humans; language is just another behavior and not as reliable as assumed, while body language, pupil dilation, and shared history are arguably more reliable indicators of another's interior world.
“while that might be true, that's equally true of us right now. I can't know with certainty what's going on in your mind, even though you have human language to describe your interior states.”
- Under the standard animal-cognition definition of intelligence as the capacity to solve novel problems in one's environment, humans fail the test at the current ecological moment, because we have solutions to the climate crisis but are not enacting them and in many cases are making it worse—undermining the claim that humans are the most intelligent species.
“the definition of intelligence that many scientists in animal cognition and related fields use is the capacity to solve novel problems in one's environment.”
- It is a mistake to assume that everything humans do other species can also do; humans are genuinely unique, but so is every species, and that uniqueness—not equivalence—is what makes each worthy of moral concern in its own right.
“I am not going to argue that a gorilla is out there contemplating what book he's going to write about and then doing it. Right? I think that humans are unique, and I think that all species are unique, and I think we should honor that uniqueness.”
- The idea that we are discrete biological individuals is a myth, because much of the body is composed of viruses and bacteria—members of other species—so humans are multi-species collectives; recognizing this means that when we die part of that collective lives on, and seeing oneself as part of a grander earthly narrative can make death less frightening.
“This idea that we are somehow these biological individuals, when most of our body actually is composed of viruses and bacteria, members of other species.”
- Humans do not have a unified or solid grasp of death—beliefs range from afterlife to oblivion—so the supposed uniquely human awareness of mortality is itself confused, making it unwarranted to deny other animals a comparable orientation toward survival, which they clearly demonstrate by avoiding predators and acting with a will to live.
“I don't think humans have a unified understanding of death... Some people think that they're going to an afterlife, so is that actually dying?”
- Even granting that other animals might be less conscious than humans, that could equally mean their subconscious is more limited—so they may live more fully in their conscious present while humans, with most activity happening beneath conscious awareness, are merely the tip of an iceberg, which itself undercuts claims of human superiority.
“maybe they're living actually more in their conscious, and we're the ones who are just tip of the iceberg, and then everything's beneath the surface.”
- Whereas Roberts hears 'instinct' as a humble admission of ignorance, Webb hears it as implying automata—creatures with no choice, behavior reduced to pre-programmed genetics—which is a shame because any behavior can be explained at multiple levels of analysis, and a genetic or molecular explanation does not preclude consciousness, will, intention, or planning as additional valid layers.
“When I hear the word 'instinct,' I think of automata. I think of: they have no choice in the matter... it's not more complicated than pre-programmed genetics.”
Journal bias and theoretical frameworks emphasize dominance hierarchies while minimizing cooperation and mutual thriving in nature.
- A 2020 lexical analysis of major ecology journals found that despite competition, cooperation, predation, and mutualism being equally abundant in nature, the journal Ecology mentioned competition almost two-thirds of the time and cooperation less than 2% of the time, revealing a research bias toward dominance and hierarchy narratives.
“almost two-thirds of the time competition was mentioned, and less than 2% of the time the word cooperation, or the theme of cooperation, was mentioned.”
- Dominance hierarchies in chimpanzees and baboons function as a way of preventing conflict rather than causing it, because they predictably allocate resource distribution—everyone knows who gets first dibs—so individuals avoid fighting over every resource.
“when I learned about dominance hierarchies in chimpanzees and baboons, I learned that they were a way of preventing conflicts because they help allocate the distribution of resources.”
- Conflict and cooperation in nature are not two separate stories but part of the same one: socially tense moments often facilitate cooperative acts like resource sharing and reassurance, and individuals who form tolerant, reciprocal relationships are thereby able to out-compete others.
“it's often the most socially tense moments that facilitate cooperative acts. So, it's those tense moments that necessitate cooperative acts like resource sharing and reassuring one another.”
Awe and hope cultivate humility and pro-social behavior; we have lost ecological knowledge Western societies once held.
- In gaining technological knowledge—building cars, airplanes, rockets—Western societies have lost another sophisticated form of knowledge, illustrated by people recognizing hundreds of corporate logos but unable to name ten local species, a different but no less valuable form of knowing the natural world.
“there's these stats about how kids and adults can recognize hundreds of corporate logos, but they can't tell you 10 species living in their local community?”
- Awe—an emotional experience of vastness requiring accommodation—leads to a diminishment of the self and self-concept that produces greater humility and pro-social behavior; this researched effect, mostly studied human-to-human, plausibly extends to how we treat and perceive the rest of nature, making awe an antidote to the arrogance the arrogant ape doesn't recognize.
“awe is described as this emotional experience of vastness that requires accommodation to understand this vastness.”
- Optimism and pessimism are probabilistic—they estimate the odds of a better or worse future—whereas hope is not about knowing the odds but about recognizing we don't know everything and that a chance always exists; one can be pessimistic about the path forward yet still hopeful, and hope is more aligned with awe and humility than optimism is.
“I think of optimism as more probabilistic Like pessimism: It sort of seems to know the odds. It predicts a better future is likely.”