human exceptionalism
The belief that humans are fundamentally separate from and superior to all other life on earth, occupying a uniquely privileged position.
As defined in Humans Are Overrated (with Christine Webb)
Where it comes up · 2
- Humans Are Overrated (with Christine Webb)4 claims
- Do All Creatures, Great and Small, and Made From Silicon, Have Rights? (with Jeff Sebo)1 claim
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “human exceptionalism” →
- Improving treatment of non-human animals and AI can be co-beneficial for humans because many co-beneficial solutions exist (food, infrastructure, AI safety reforms good for humans, animals, and environment simultaneously), and because much human prejudice and oppression is rooted in dehumanizing comparisons to 'lesser' animals, so defending animals can also undercut narratives used to oppress marginalized human populations.Do All Creatures, Great and Small, and Made From Silicon, Have Rights? (with Jeff Sebo)
- Comparative cognition studies that conclude humans are cognitively superior are unscientific because they compare deprived captive chimpanzees—raised in labs, separated from mothers, tested on human tasks—against comfortable, autonomous WEIRD humans tested with familiar materials, stacking the deck before the comparison begins.Humans Are Overrated (with Christine Webb)
- The hidden assumption that makes rigged human-animal comparisons seem valid—that deprived environments don't harm other beings' development and well-being as much as they harm humans'—is itself a problematic, human-centric premise.Humans Are Overrated (with Christine Webb)
- Human arrogance—specifically the belief that we are separate from and superior to the rest of life—is a major cause of the ecological crisis, because seeing ourselves as outside the living world lets us treat other beings and environments as mere resources to exploit without abandon.Humans Are Overrated (with Christine Webb)
- The 'arrogant ape' is not all humans, a particular culture, or an individual, but a character or mask—inspired by hubris in Greek tragedy—representing a worldview of arrogance that people may hold unawares and that they can change over their lifetime.Humans Are Overrated (with Christine Webb)