What this covers

Bryan Caplan conducts a wide-ranging argument against what he sees as widespread intellectual errors in contemporary progressive thought. Speaking with Dwarkesh Patel, he redefines feminism as the empirical claim that society treats women less fairly than men, then contests that claim on the data—noting that happiness gaps between men and women are small in magnitude and have reversed only marginally since the 1960s. He extends this mechanism-driven, comparative skepticism across four other major domains: the economics of education, immigration policy, the ethics of billionaire wealth, and the lessons of historical contingency. The throughline is his insistence on honest measurement, meritocracy over demographic representation, and what he calls the "Compared to What" framework—judging outcomes not against an imagined ideal but against realistic alternatives.

On feminism specifically, Caplan argues that fears around false accusations have made mentorship worse for women, a problem he says feminists worsen by confronting rather than persuading reluctant male managers. On education, he attacks credential inflation as socially wasteful—college signaling conformity rather than ability. On immigration, he invokes the place premium to argue that moving poor workers to rich countries generates enormous gains, and cites Poland's absorption of Ukrainian refugees as proof that large-scale immigration is absorbable where political will exists. On billionaire wealth, he applies tournament theory: outsized rewards for winners motivate all competitors, so praising rather than taxing billionaires would lower their earnings by encouraging entry. He also defends Jeff Bezos as genuinely irreplaceable to Amazon's success, and argues that unlike revolutions or wars, the Industrial Revolution's timing was not contingent—too many forces were converging. Throughout, he challenges the reflexive application of fairness language to situations where no human agent bears responsibility, and rejects slippery slope reasoning as unreliable.

Sharpest takeaway

Caplan argues that mainstream feminism is mostly wrong because, properly defined, it claims society treats women less fairly than men—a claim that fails on the objective measures and is overturned by the climate of exaggerated accusations against men; he extends a contrarian, mechanism-driven worldview to immigration, education, decolonization, and billionaire wealth.

  • Feminism is best defined as the view that society treats women less fairly than men, and on net the objective measures are close to a wash—tipped against feminism by false accusations men must endure.
  • Meritocracy and honest case-by-case reasoning outperform demographic-representation goals and lawyerly one-sided argumentation.
  • Where there's a political will (as in Poland with Ukrainian refugees) large-scale immigration is demonstrably absorbable; restrictions waste hundreds of trillions in potential wealth.

The claims · ranked55 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.78

The most powerful argument for immigration is the place premium: moving a poor worker from a poor country to a rich one multiplies their pay many times almost overnight because productivity is higher everywhere in rich countries; most of why Haitians are poor is that Haiti is broken, not Haitians, and this gain is scalable to hundreds of millions of people.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Bryan Caplan

“why can we make a Haitian suddenly earn 20 times as much money just by moving into Miami? He hasn't even learned English yet, but he's still making 20 times as much money as he was back in Haiti.”

0.75

The Stevenson and Wolfers finding that women became less happy relative to men is real but tiny in magnitude—roughly a swing from a 2-point happiness advantage in the 1960s to a 2-point deficit now—so media claims that 'women are miserable now' badly misrepresent the data.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“they find that in the sixties, women had about a two percentage point advantage relative to men in terms of their odds of saying they're very happy... Whereas now, it seems like women have a two percentage point deficit relative to men.”

0.73

Almost all major wars could be avoided by one side giving in, and most leaders—unlike Hitler—can be negotiated with because politics is built on demagoguery, so small symbolic concessions often satisfy them; the hawkish claim that conceding emboldens infinite escalation is right only about half the time and is unreliable.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“for almost anything involving major wars, I’d say almost all major wars could be avoided by one side giving in.”

0.73

The central problem with education is credential inflation: when everyone gets a degree, nobody does, because schooling mainly stamps people as better than competitors so their applications aren't tossed; adding credentials, like printing money, just raises the bar and causes social waste rather than creating value.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“When everyone has a college degree, nobody does, right? This analogy is very good. Can you make a country rich just by giving everybody a trillion dollars? You cannot.”

0.73

Mentorship is the main area that has genuinely gotten worse for women, and feminism caused it: male managers now openly admit reluctance to mentor female employees out of fear of accusations, and feminists who respond by yelling at scared men only worsen the problem, since mentorship is an informal favor that requires winning people over, not threatening them.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“it is totally standard now for male managers to admit that they are reluctant to mentor female employees because they're so worried.”

0.73

Much of what college signals is not intelligence or even work ethic but sheer conformity, which is why a Harvard admit who skips college to apply directly to Goldman Sachs would be viewed as a freak rather than a bargain, and why internships and elite jobs go to box-checkers rather than people doing weird things.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“A lot of what people are signaling is not just intelligence, it's not even work ethic; it's just sheer conformity.”

0.73

The dictionary definition of feminism as the view that women should be social/political/economic equals of men is wrong because the overwhelming majority of self-identified non-feminists also endorse equality; the distinguishing view of feminism is that society treats women less fairly than men, which actually fits ordinary usage.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“What I say is that the really distinguishing view of feminism is that society treats women less fairly than men.”

0.73

Foot binding in China was driven mainly by women binding their own daughters' feet while men cared less, which is an intra-female abuse; this exposes a weakness in the 'society treats women less fairly' definition of unfairness, since the standard definition isn't calibrated to count harms women inflict on women.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“From my understanding, the main drivers of foot binding in China were women. So women are binding feet, and they're also telling their daughters they have to have their feet bound. Men seemed to care less, actually, it was more of an intra-female abuse.”

0.73

The apparent rise in anxiety and neuroticism among young people is largely an artifact of the medicalization of society—easier access, de-stigmatizing psychiatry while stigmatizing traditional substitutes like religion—though suicide-rate data are genuinely complicated, falling 1970-2000 then rebounding to roughly 1950s levels, fitting no obvious single story.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“By modern measures, there was no neuroticism, and there were no psychiatric problems 200 years ago because there were no psychiatrists.”

0.73

Poland increased its population by roughly 10% in a month by welcoming Ukrainian refugees—and the country looked fine—demonstrating that where there's a will there's a way: large-scale refugee absorption is doable when people sympathize, whereas the same population freaks out over 10,000 refugees they dislike, proving complaints about capacity are phony.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“Poland increased its population by 10% in a month, and the country looked fine. No one there was complaining, and I could see why.”

0.73

Without Lenin the Bolshevik takeover had perhaps a 99% chance of not happening, because the rest of the party was planning to join the provisional government until Lenin's intellectual status alone overrode their unanimous opposition; the revolution rested on a tiny number of fanatics with ~2000 armed followers in a country where no one else was following orders, so a short delay would have left them hopeless.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“I’ll bet that there’s a 99% chance that without Lenin, even with all the other Bolsheviks, it wouldn't have happened.”

0.73

Tournament theory shows enormous rewards for billionaires are socially valuable because they incentivize not just the winner but all potential winners, fostering a whole culture of entrepreneurship; therefore heavily taxing or denigrating billionaires would dent that motivation, and the way to reduce their earnings is to praise them so more people enter and compete the rewards down.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“it can be extremely socially valuable to go and have seemingly unreasonably large rewards for people that do something useful because it doesn't just incentivize the winner, it incentivizes all the potential winners.”

0.73

Business history is less contingent than political history, but the quality of entrepreneurship and management varies greatly across countries, and Amazon's apparent natural monopoly (no comparable global rival, with Alibaba not even catering well to English speakers) suggests the second-best alternative might have been only a tenth as good—so it is dogmatic to assert Bezos wasn't counterfactually responsible for Amazon, since assembling a great team is itself the leader's irreplaceable contribution.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“is it possible that the second-best thing to Amazon would have been 1/10th as good? That actually is not crazy.”

0.72

Most interpersonal conflicts are caused by misunderstandings rather than deliberate wrongdoing, because each person, limited by the human mind's inability to get inside another's head, sees themselves as right and the other as wrong; recognizing this norm—and refusing to side automatically with the most hypersensitive person—is essential to keeping friends and to functioning workplaces.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Bryan Caplan

“Most conflicts are caused by misunderstandings, not by deliberate wrongdoing.”

0.72

Contrary to the cliché that you must be dishonest to get things done, the credibility literature shows leaders most need ironclad honesty so that long-horizon commitments are believed; the apparent exception, 'underpromise and overdeliver,' is not dishonesty but exceeding stated commitments, and Tyler Cowen's ultra-honest leadership style exemplifies this.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Bryan Caplan

“there's this whole literature on credibility saying, “No, what you really want is to be honest and in a very credible way such that when you say I'm going to do something in 20 years, people believe you.””

0.72

Unfairness requires a human agent who does it; when no human being is responsible, the correct term is 'unfortunate' rather than 'unfair,' so claims that 'the cosmos mistreats women' are conceptual errors rather than genuine unfairness.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Bryan Caplan

“unfairness, where there's no human being that does it, seems like a very strange idea to me... the correct term there is unfortunate, not unfair.”

0.70

The successful US occupations of Germany and Japan worked because they completely crushed the prior regime and then prioritized human rights (denazification) over democracy—allowing elections only for those committed to denazification and devolving power slowly—rather than rushing to full democracy, which is the model decolonization should have followed.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“in those occupations, there were two things that they were pushing: democracy and human rights. They pushed for human rights a lot more than democracy.”

0.70

The idea that talent can be reliably spotted with a 1500-word essay and a Zoom call is ludicrous because essays can be forged and even work product is a poor predictor (a candidate can produce five great pages then stall for years); the realistic method is hiring and watching people for months, but that is incredibly expensive and most employers don't actually fire disappointing hires due to inertia, social, emotional, and legal costs.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“the idea that you can spot talent with a Zoom call and a 1500-word essay is ludicrous. The essay can be forged, obviously.”

0.70

Contrary to Mancur Olson, public opinion is far more important for policy than interest groups: interest groups work in the fine print (a sentence on page 1037 of the tax code), not broad changes, and most policies—even seemingly captured ones like farm subsidies—are actually supported by the general public for pro-social reasons they haven't examined.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“Public opinion is much more important for policy than interest groups. Contrary to what Mancer Olson said, if you really look at what interest groups do normally, they're trying to work in the fine print.”

0.68

Unlike major wars and revolutions, the onset of sustained economic growth around 1800 was not very contingent because too many forces converged—multiple scientific breakthroughs with obvious economic applications and many countries with profit-seeking business classes willing to try them—so if it hadn't happened in Britain it would have happened elsewhere.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“Were things like economic growth going to happen one way or another starting in 1800? That, I think, was not so contingent if it didn't happen in Britain, because there were just too many things going on.”

0.68

Female infanticide makes the treatment of women in India and China very likely more unfair than that of men, and almost certainly so in Saudi Arabia, yet American feminists devote less than 1% of their rhetoric to it; the distraction onto small or reversed first-world problems causes neglect of these serious problems abroad.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“The amount of time that American feminists spend on female infanticide in China and India… I don’t think it would even be 1% of the rhetoric. It's just not something that they care about.”

0.68

The citizen-versus-noncitizen distinction is one of the strongest focal points available for keyhole immigration solutions and has real stability, but keyhole solutions would probably fail multi-generationally because denying citizenship to immigrants' grandchildren is hard to maintain—though the underlying worries also dilute over time.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“That's one where I would just say that the focal point of citizen versus noncitizen is one of the strongest ones. So I think that it actually is one that has a lot of stability.”

0.68

The observation that men endure roughly 90% of workplace deaths is not clear evidence of unfairness to men because they receive monetary compensation (combat pay broadly construed) for taking those dangerous jobs, so all things considered it shouldn't be treated as unfair.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

““Hey, wait a second, how come men are the ones that are enduring 90 percent of the workplace deaths” and say, “Well, because they're getting 90 percent of the combat pay.””

0.68

The right policy reform is education austerity—spending less and making education less accessible—because that would reverse credential inflation, letting people get the same jobs while spending fewer years learning useless material; but it is politically unlikely because the prestige of state universities (and their football teams) deters even right-wing governments from cutting budgets.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“the big policy reform that I push in The Case Against Education is education austerity, which means spending less on education and making education less accessible.”

0.68

Water shortages can be solved by raising water prices well short of the level where anyone dies of thirst—multiplying the price by 10 or 100 would still leave everyone drinking all they want, since drinking is a tiny fraction of water use; people would simply take quicker showers and shift farming, so the political-will objection overstates the harm.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“we don't have to go and raise the price of water up to the level where a few people die of thirst. You could go and multiply the price by a factor of 10 or 100, and people will still be drinking all the water that they want.”

0.65

Anarcho-capitalism—competing police, legal, and court systems—is the best system for the long term if people realize it's a doable equilibrium, because it once-and-for-all dissolves international war and nationalism, dethrones demagogues by removing any government to seize, and leaves would-be tyrants confined to cults, religion, and punditry rather than mass murder.

normativehigh valuefringenovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“what I think is that there is another equilibrium that is totally doable if people realize that it's totally doable. This equilibrium is one where we actually have competing police, competing legal systems, and competing court systems.”

0.65

Gandhi, while not a mass murderer and admirably nonviolent, was so dominated by wishful thinking and pie-in-the-sky denial of foreseeable pogroms that he should have been nowhere near important decisions—a caring, touchy-feely person who was not a reasonable one.

normativehigh valuefringenovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“Gandhi was an apostle of nonviolence. Good for him, but he was also someone who was so dominated by wishful thinking and just trying to pretend like a pogrom shouldn’t be expected after the transition”

0.64

Public opinion matters greatly even in dictatorships because dictators demagogue and generally want to be liked—being liked makes ruling easier, so they only need to terrify perhaps 10% of the population into obedience rather than 90%—and weaponize their monopoly on demagoguery once rivals are dead, imprisoned, or terrified.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“even dictators generally want to be liked by their population. It makes ruling easier. Then you only have to terrify 10% of the population into obedience instead of 90%.”

0.64

Poland's policy of letting Ukrainians work the day they arrive is excellent and a path to productive membership in society, in contrast to the normal approach of keeping refugees as semi-prisoners on welfare while forbidding them from working—treating production and contribution as if they were bad things.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“Poland was doing the best thing where the day you show up, you can get a job there. You're totally legal to work. So this is a path toward having them become productive members of society.”

0.63

The main way women have come to be treated less fairly over time is declining paternal support for children: in 1940 the odds a biological father would help raise his children was around 90%, whereas now it is closer to 60-70%, and this unfairness has worsened over time.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Bryan Caplan

“In 1940, the odds that you could count on the biological father of your children to help you to raise them was maybe 90%. Now it's probably more like 60%, 70%.”

0.62

When the goal is producing correct answers, making things run effectively, and generating knowledge, the right focus is identifying the top-quality people rather than trying to achieve demographic representation; targeting representation is the wrong approach and starts a slippery slope to bad outcomes.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“Just looking at a group and saying, “We need to get more members of Group X,” is the wrong way to approach it. Rather, you need to be focusing on, “Let's try to figure out the best way of getting the top quality people here.””

0.62

Student loan forgiveness is a regressive transfer that shifts the cost of debt run up by the educated elite onto the general population, including non-college-goers; it doesn't increase education since people already got it, and by signaling future forgiveness it may raise willingness to borrow and thus push tuition higher.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“the forgiveness really means, “We're going to go and transfer the cost of this debt from the elites that actually ran up the bill to the general population.””

0.61

Even if men and women are equally good in every way, an illusion of one's own gender being superior can arise because people handpick same-gender close friends (whom they think well of) but encounter the opposite gender mainly as their friends' partners (whom they merely tolerate), producing a two-filter bias against the opposite gender.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 4/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“Basically, there are two filters there: I like you because you're my friend, and I put up with your partner because that person is your partner.”

0.61

When all objective measures are weighed, the fairness of treatment between men and women is close to a wash; what tips the balance against feminism today is that one gender (men) must endure grossly exaggerated, hyperbolic false accusations of unfairness while the other gender (women) gets to make them, creating a climate of intimidation.

causalhigh valuefringenovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Bryan Caplan

“When we go over all the objective measures, then you say, well, it's close to a wash in terms of which gender is treated more or less fairly overall. But then you realize, “Yes, but there's one gender that has to endure a whole lot of grossly exaggerated hyperbolic accusations and unfairness and another gender that gets to make those accusations.””

0.61

Much of cancel culture and feminism's rhetorical dominance stems from 'women's tears'—complaints mingling sadness with implied intimidation—because men dislike arguing with angry or upset women and seek to end such conflicts quickly, making the conversation one-sided where women complain and men listen in silence.

causalhigh valuefringenovelty 3/4durability 2/4· Bryan Caplan

“no guy feels this way about an argument with his wife. “What do I need to do in order for this argument to end as soon as possible” would be a more normal reaction.”

0.60

If you judge leaders only by how caring they are, the most caring people make bad leaders; but from an effective-altruism viewpoint—combining caring emotions with rigorous, clear thinking about how to get good results—those who are both very caring and very logical fit the right profile for genuinely good leadership.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Bryan Caplan

“If you have an effective altruism point of view, however, where it's not just feeling a lot of caring emotions, but being very committed to thinking clearly about the best way to get good results, then I'll say those people are more heroic people in my view.”

0.60

The apparent decline in college attendance is driven by community college (whose signal is barely better than nothing outside fields like nursing), while attendance at traditional four-year brick-and-mortar colleges continues to rise—supporting bets that such attendance will fall no more than 10% over a decade.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Bryan Caplan

“It's community college that has fallen a bit... But for four-year college attendance, it's actually continuing to rise.”

0.57

Feminism likely reduces happiness for feminist elites who take it seriously and think about it constantly, but for the vast majority who say 'yeah, I'm a feminist, moving on,' it probably doesn't affect their lives much, because most people are not intellectual and rarely dwell on their ideas.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“feminism is very likely to reduce the happiness of people who are feminist elites and take it really seriously, where they're talking about it all the time... for the vast majority of people who say, “Yeah, I am a feminist. Moving on…” I don't think it's too likely to be messing up their lives.”

0.57

Education makes people more pro-free-market mainly through peer effects rather than coursework, but peer effects are a double-edged sword: because college physically and socially segregates pro-market people together, it makes them more pro-market while removing their influence on non-college classes—so whether education makes society overall more pro-market is unclear.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“I think that the best story is about peer effects. When you go to college, you're around other peers who though not pro-market, are less anti-market than the general population.”

0.57

Corporations endorsing affirmative action are engaging in a species of corporate philanthropy—a public-relations and internal-status play—not self-interest, since they would press a button to immunize themselves from employment lawsuits; like corporate philanthropy generally, they spend far more marketing the gesture than the gesture actually costs.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“If those individual corporations could press a button that would immunize them from all employment lawsuits, I think they would press it.”

0.57

People generally confuse being radical with being unfriendly, and most of the harm done to radical causes comes from the unfriendliness rather than the radicalism; feminism has a definite friendliness problem because its elite emotional tenor is 'we are totally right and anyone who disagrees had better watch out,' which discredits the movement and undermines Overton-window shifting.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“people generally confuse being radical with being unfriendly. And most of the harm that is done to radical causes is due to the unfriendliness rather than the radicalism.”

0.57

Stage fright arises because public speaking is a bid for status: in the ancestral environment of small bands, standing up to speak claimed importance, and if the group judged you unworthy you risked being pushed off the cliff, so the fear is an evolved response to making an unsupported status claim.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“In the ancestral environment, we're in small groups of 20-40 people. If you go and want to speak, you're saying, “I'm one of the most important people in this band here.””

0.57

Successful decolonization would have required a high-credibility, pre-committed, gradual transition—a fixed multi-decade timetable, willingness to lose soldiers, and refusal to be forced out by terror—handing power slowly to reasonable people while crushing those inciting pogroms; the partition of India failed precisely because the British 'never going to leave until they did (really quickly),' causing millions of deaths.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“you've got to pre-commit stating your goal: Our goal is going to be a peaceful, free rich India. We have a plan for how we're going to do this, and we're going to stick to it, and we are ready to lose a whole lot of our soldiers in order to do this”

0.57

Reforms like decolonization should be enacted from a position of strength during peace, jumping the gun before fanatics gain the upper hand, so that bloodthirsty actors never get their status raised by appearing to force your hand—they should look like losers and crazy people while you transition power to reasonable partners.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“You don't wait before the fanatics have the upper hand and there's blood in the streets and then say, Oh gee, what do we do now? You want to jump the gun when things are peaceful.”

0.57

Because building things has almost no demagogic appeal (no one tears up at a new skyscraper) while NIMBYs generate endless emotionally resonant complaints, almost nothing would be built in America without self-interested developer lobbying—making this a case where concentrated interest groups have strongly positive social effects, contrary to the usual economist framing of interest groups as harmful.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“if we're not from lobbying from developers, basically zero things would be built in America because building things has almost no demagogic appeal.”

0.52

It is unreasonable for someone newly arriving in a male-dominated field to demand the entire discipline change its norms to feel more welcoming; the reasonable course is to become simpatico with the existing culture and push at the margin, since no symmetric pressure exists for men to remake female-dominated fields.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“maybe you could say that it's unfair for someone who's just shown up to demand that an entire discipline change its way of doing things to make you feel better about it.”

0.52

Business leaders who claim they hire only on demonstrable skills rather than credentials are usually repeating atypical newspaper stories rather than firsthand experience; when pressed, almost none have personally hired uncredentialed people for high-skilled jobs, because the press writes about the rare platypus, not the familiar norm.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“Then I always ask the same question: how many uncredentialed people have you personally hired for high-skilled jobs? “Well, we haven't done any, but I read in the Wall Street Journal,””

0.52

Society may sympathize more with women's suffering while admiring men's success, but since suffering is the universal human condition and notable success affects only a small share of people, the sympathy advantage is more valuable in daily life than the admiration advantage.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“everybody's got suffering, and only a small share of people have any notable success... to have admiration for your success is something where it just affects a much smaller number of people.”

0.52

Free, peaceful, prosperous societies are the historical exception, and one reason they sustain it is that their electorates are less crazy—few people endorse mass murder of out-groups, whereas in many other societies such bloodthirsty fanaticism is common; better-functioning societies are ones where people suppress atavistic desires for a bloodbath.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“The norm is not peaceful and prosperous societies throughout human history. The norm is impoverished and war-prone societies.”

0.50

By demonstrated preference, if people could costlessly and perfectly switch their gender by a mere wish, a large majority would still stay with their birth gender because it is part of their identity—an endowment effect or status-quo bias—which is distinct from transgenderism.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“If you could change your gender just with a wish, costlessly, perfectly, I think a very large majority of people would still want to stay with whatever gender they have because it's part of their identity. It's some kind of endowment effect, status quo bias, or whatever.”

0.49

Stand-up comedy differs from ordinary public speaking in that it depends heavily on exact word choice—a synonymous sentence produced by translating and back-translating can be entirely unfunny—and successful comedians effectively A/B test material across many audiences before a polished special.

factualestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Bryan Caplan

“The thing with comedy is it depends so heavily upon exact word choice. You could go and put the same sentence into Google Translate and then back-translate it and get another sentence that is synonymous but isn't funny at all.”

0.36

Employers are much more willing to fire men for defects and insubordination, and men are more likely to be dinged for dress-code violations because male dress codes are definite while judging women's attire feels presumptuous—indicating men are held to harsher workplace standards in these respects.

factualcontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Bryan Caplan

“I think employers are much more willing to fire men. For defects and for insubordination.”

0.35

Caplan has a public betting record of 23 wins and 0 losses on resolved bets, which he attributes to aggressively seeking out bets that hardly anyone wants to make, with his most likely future loss being a global-warming bet where his opponent gave him 3:1 odds because Caplan was betting against others' overconfidence rather than a personal conviction.

factualestablishednovelty 2/4durability 1/4· Bryan Caplan

“I do have a record of 23 wins for 23 bets that have resolved.”

0.33

While both men and women influence family size, the data suggest women's traits have a much larger effect: men more often say 'fine, whatever' while women have more pronounced preferences that they tend to get realized.

factualcontestednovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Bryan Caplan

“While both men and women seem to have a say on family size, it just looks like women's traits have a much larger effect. Men are more likely to say, “OK, fine, whatever. We'll do what you want to do on family size.””

0.14

Caplan's books are priced at only $12 (eBook $9.99) and he has not raised the price despite inflation, which he notes he's been thinking about from an economic-theory perspective.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 0/4· Bryan Caplan

“They're really cheap, only 12 bucks, and I have not raised the price despite inflation!”