Reinhart-Rogoff Debt-Growth Finding and the Excel Error
Reinhart and Rogoff assembled datasets showing that GDP growth tends to be lower the higher a country's public debt — a correlation, not a demonstrated causal claim. A U. Mass. Amherst graduate student found an Excel error in which they averaged growth over 15 countries instead of 20, plus other debatable judgment calls. Paradoxically, the more egregious the error (the Excel mistake) the less it changed the bottom line, while the defensible judgment calls mattered more to the result; even after all corrections, high-debt periods still show slower growth.