What this covers

Tyler Cowen interviews Rabbi David Wolpe on Jewish history, theology, leadership, and the structural challenges facing Jewish continuity in the modern world. Wolpe moves between biblical interpretation, medieval and modern Jewish philosophy, and contemporary politics, drawing on figures like Maimonides, Jacob Neusner, and Yehudah ha-Levi to argue that Judaism's distinctive strength lies in its tolerance for internal disputation and its refusal to sanitize its heroes. The conversation turns repeatedly on the distinction between flawed heroes versus whitewashed heroes—the case of King David illustrates how Jewish tradition judges leaders by pragmatic judgment of leaders by results rather than by claims of divine favor that cannot be verified.

Wolpe traces how Conservative Judaism declined because it could not articulate a compelling non-fundamentalist reason for demanding ritual observance once modern scholarship undermined the claim that God commanded it. He discusses the role of Jacob Neusner's scientific approach to the Talmud, the misuse of the term tikkun olam in contemporary Jewish social-action discourse, and how social media strips the contextual knowledge that a commentary culture requires. On politics, Wolpe argues that powerful Jewish cases exist on both Right and Left, rejects the equation of Jewish values with Democratic values, and offers a sharp analysis of why American Jews leave Judaism—not from rejection but from acceptance, when assimilation becomes frictionless. He also engages Israeli settlements, income inequality, and the corrosive political disaffection in contemporary Israel, while asserting that Jewish history has always been disputatious and that genuine love requires familial closeness rather than universal brotherhood.

Sharpest takeaway

Wolpe argues that Jewish tradition is best understood through flawed, charismatic, pragmatically-judged figures like David rather than sanitized ideals, and that its survival depends on sustaining a deep, demanding, disputatious culture against forces (assimilation, context-stripping media, submission-cultures) that flatten it.

  • David is judged a successful king by pragmatic results (survival, charisma, unification) rather than divine favor we cannot verify
  • Judaism's strength is its flawed-hero realism and disputatious legal culture, which Wolpe contrasts with sanitizing texts and submission-based traditions
  • Liberal/Conservative Judaism declines because it lacks a compelling non-fundamentalist rationale for demanding ritual observance

The argument · threads12 threads · 48 claims
0.51

Jewish heroes gain power through flawed humanity and pragmatic results, not divine sanction or whitewashing.

6 pointscentrality 4/5
  • David was a more successful king than Saul not because of divine favor (which is unverifiable) but on pragmatic human grounds: he died in his bed, which was rare among ancient and medieval kings and is itself a test of merit, and he possessed tremendous charisma, whereas Saul lost the confidence of the people.

    “The first test of a king in the ancient world is what David did that is remarkable, and that is, he died in his bed. That’s rare among ancient and medieval kings... survival in and of itself is a test of merit.”

  • Because we cannot verify whether God spoke to a leader—we cannot 'cut windows into people's souls'—the way to judge the success of a leader, then and now, is pragmatically by results: David unified the kingdom, subdued rebellion, established Jerusalem as the capital, installed his son who built the temple, and left a lasting legacy.

    “if you want to be a pragmatist about it and just look at results, I would say that’s how you judge the success of a leader then and now.”

  • Chronicles is 'Samuel made boring' not because it is a dry textbook but because it takes the humanness of David and tries to sanctify him in a way untrue to his character; it is, for example, the first text where Satan appears as an inciter so David is not blamed for his sin—a sanitizing of the real history of David.

    “it takes the very humanness of David and tries to sanctify him, in a way that I think is untrue to David’s character. It’s the first time, for example, that the character of the Satan appears as an inciter.”

  • David has the most complicated and detailed relationships with women of any character in the Hebrew Bible, and what draws him out of the charge of simple narcissism is that he genuinely listens to women and changes himself because of what they say—a self-effacement and receptivity that coexists with his hubris and charisma, and a trait uncommon in men of the ancient or modern world.

    “One of the things that draws David out of the charge of simple narcissism is that he really listens, he pays attention — he pays attention to women over and over again. He listens to what they say and changes himself because of it.”

  • The Koran is very unwilling to allow any sinfulness in its heroes (such as Moses), whereas Judaism embraces flawed heroes and rejects whitewashing, which Wolpe prefers as truer to character.

    “the Koran is very unwilling to allow any sinfulness in its heroes... I like the idea of flawed heroes. I like the notion that there isn’t this whitewashing.”

  • Saul's failure to kill the Amalekite king and exterminate the Amalekites as commanded illustrates the Talmudic principle that 'somebody who is kind to the cruel will end up being cruel to the kind'; effectively subduing or dispatching enemies was a necessary trait Saul lacked the stomach for, which made him an unsuccessful king in the ancient world.

    “the way the Talmud puts it is that somebody who is kind to the cruel will end up being cruel to the kind. And the idea that your enemies have to be dispatched or at least effectively subdued was something that Saul didn’t have the stomach for.”

0.49

Jewish tradition institutionalizes argument and disputation as spiritual practice, producing democratic culture unlike submission-based religions.

5 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The Kuzari is foundational because Judaism generally did not engage in polemics against other religions, and this book—structured as religions making their case to the king of the Khazars who converted to Judaism—made the case for Judaism; Jewish philosophy, unlike the Christian tradition, was not native to Judaism but was born out of the golden age of Spain's encounter with other cultures and the need to explain ourselves.

    “philosophy wasn’t native to Judaism — it was born out of an encounter with other cultures and a need to explain ourselves.”

  • The one thing at the heart of Islam that is antidemocratic is the concept of submission (in the very name of the religion), because a population trained to submit will create authoritarians; by contrast Israel's founders, who came from non-democratic places, created a democracy because the disputatious culture of the Talmud trained them to argue with each other.

    “if I had to pick one thing that is at the heart of Islam that is antidemocratic, it is the concept that’s very deep — that is, in the very name of the religion — of submission. Because a population that is trained essentially to submit is a population that will create authoritarians.”

  • The Book of Samuel introduces an understood division between the political order and the religious order: Samuel as high priest and leader is upset when the people want a king, but a separate political order is needed—effectively a separation of synagogue and state.

    “You need separation effectively of synagogue and state to some degree.”

  • Jacob Neusner, the most prolific scholar of the 20th century, transformed Talmud studies by questioning the traditional attributions ('Rabbi So-and-So told Rabbi So-and-So this'), applying the scientific study of texts to the Talmud in a way that had not been done before, such that anyone studying Talmud today is indebted to him whether they acknowledge it or not.

    “he started to question the attributions. How do we know that Rabbi So-and-So said that? And he started to apply scientific study of texts in the 20th century to the Talmud in a way that had not been done before”

  • There is a debate in Jewish philosophy between Maimonides and Yehuda ha-Levi over whether prophecy is divinely gifted or achievable; ha-Levi takes the gifted side and represents the nonrationalist strain of Jewish philosophy (as Maimonides represents the rationalist strain), which is why The Kuzari nurtures the Hasidic tradition from afar and fittingly came from a poet.

    “ha-Levi, I want to say, represents the nonrationalist strain of Jewish philosophy, as Maimonides represents the rationalist strain. And that’s why that book nurtures the Hasidic tradition from afar”

0.46

Liberal and Conservative Judaism decline when ritual lacks compelling non-fundamentalist justification for demanding lifestyle.

3 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Conservative Judaism declined because it tried to hold serious Jewish observance together with modern scholarship that did not consistently say 'God told you to do this'; as the motivational piece weakened, so did the demanding observant lifestyle. Unless and until a compelling non-fundamentalist rationale is created for ritual behaviors (eating a certain way, not going out on Saturday) that maintain communal cohesion, Conservative Judaism—and liberal religion generally—faces a huge uphill battle, made worse because Judaism makes greater lifestyle demands than Christianity.

    “Unless and until there is a compelling nonfundamentalist rationale for why I should eat a certain way and why I shouldn’t go out on Saturday... Conservative Judaism is going to face a huge uphill battle.”

  • American Jews leave Judaism largely because acceptance replaced persecution (Irving Kristol's quip that non-Jews used to want to kill Jews and now want to marry them); coherent stable neighborhoods once produced inmarriage and continuity, but in an age of mobility, dispersed families, high intermarriage, and cultural sharing, a countercultural tradition demanding knowledge and a sacred language (Hebrew, which Americans won't learn) struggles to retain members—more so than in Canada where there is less mobility.

    “When you say to a child, “I want you to go to the best schools, live in the best neighborhoods, work in the best firms, but don’t fall in love,” that’s too nuanced a message.”

  • Judaism, like any thick civilization, faces the problem that social media strips away context and shortens attention, undermining a commentary culture that depends on recognizing references; the optimistic outcome is that easy access to vast Jewish libraries creates a more conversant community, while the pessimistic outcome is that Jewish culture grows thinner and thinner.

    “a lot of Jewish commentary is based on your recognizing the reference that I make. Who recognizes references anymore? Because people don’t spend years studying books.”

0.44

Israel's settlement policy ignores security calculus of neighbor perception and Palestinian enfranchisement contradictions.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The Israeli-nationalist case for settlements fails to account for two parts of the calculus: that allowing your neighbors to feel a certain way about their neighbors is itself an element of security (building in total disregard breeds ill will, and world opinion matters), and that the endgame assumption—that Palestinians will eventually be reconciled or absorbed if their standard of living is high enough—does not work, since enfranchising them makes a Jewish state hard to imagine.

    “it is an element of security to allow your neighbors to feel a certain way about their neighbors. And therefore, if you build in total disregard of the people in the neighborhood, that’s not going to encourage goodwill.”

  • The word 'settlements' is far too broad: some 'settlements' are universally understood, with a nod and a wink, as places that will always be Israel in any negotiation and are not really settlements, while others are remote outposts in the middle of nowhere with 'six guys and a goat'—and both are called settlements, obscuring a mixed and complicated issue where both sides have powerful arguments (like Kashmir or Nagorno-Karabakh).

    “there are settlements that everybody knows with a nod and a wink, they’re always going to be Israel... And then there are outposts in the middle of yenevelt... where there are six guys and a goat and that’s also called a settlement.”

0.44

Contemporary Israeli politics faces dangerous disaffection across left and right, paralyzing governance.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • The underobserved trend in contemporary Israel is an increasing dissatisfaction and disaffection with all political life, dangerous because the left wing is virtually declawed and the religious right negates the political legitimacy of the country even while supporting right-wing policies, driven by an endless, worsening struggle over the same unchanging issues.

    “there is an increasing dissatisfaction and disaffection with all political life and activity that is dangerous for the country because the left wing is virtually declawed.”

  • Income inequality is a huge issue in Israel, especially because small countries have a sense of national solidarity—someone in my country who's like me shouldn't be poor—in a way Americans do not feel (a New Yorker does not quite feel that way about Appalachia), so a Jerusalemite feels solidarity with someone in Netanya.

    “in Israel, unlike in the United States... there’s a sense of national solidarity in a different way, as there is in small countries. Small countries feel like, someone in my country who’s like me shouldn’t be poor.”

0.44

Jewish community sustains itself through familial love and crisis mobilization despite constant internal historical division.

19 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Belief in God is not definitional to being a Jew; one does not have to believe in God to be a Jew.

    “You don’t have to believe in God to be a Jew. That’s not definitional. It’s not definitional.”

  • All real love stories require an obstacle (Lionel Trilling argued Lolita was the modern novel of love because, when all barriers like adultery have been leveled, the only remaining obstacle is that an adult may not touch a child); in a ruleless society love stories lose erotic tension, but religious settings with rules preserve the barriers that create dramatic tension.

    “all real love stories require an obstacle. And usually, it was adultery or something like that... In a ruleless society, love stories have no erotic tension, no barrier, nothing to vault over.”

  • Tikkun olam is a kabbalistic (mystical) term meaning the performance of mitzvot to fix breaks in creation and in God; it is not a synonym for social action and has nothing to do with saving the whales—every mitzvah, from wrapping tefillin to keeping kosher to giving charity, equally constitutes tikkun olam.

    “tikkun olam has nothing to do with saving the whales; it doesn’t. Tikkun olam is actually not a synonym for social action even though everybody uses it that way. Tikkun olam is a kabbalistic term... in which you do mitzvoth in the world to fix breaks in creation and in God”

  • A weakness of Hasidic philosophy, woven through Yehudah ha-Levi, the Tanya, and Hasidism, is the question of whether Jews have essentially different souls from non-Jews—a belief that Harold Schulweis called 'metaphysical racism' and which Wolpe rejects.

    “is the question of whether Jews have different souls from non-Jews in some essential way... It’s what a great American rabbi who passed away not so long away, Harold Schulweis, used to call metaphysical racism.”

  • Genesis resolves fraternal conflict through the figures of Ephraim and Manasseh, where the older Manasseh silently accepts the younger receiving the better blessing; this teaches acceptance of an unequal distribution of God's gifts, talents, and goods, and that interpersonal acceptance is how brothers succeed in not killing each other.

    “there is a degree of acceptance that is taught, an unequal distribution of goods... the acceptance of that, that is the acceptance of God’s gifts at unequal levels, is the way interpersonally brothers succeed in not killing each other.”

  • The canonical winnowing of texts (where only a small fraction of commentaries survive) is a normal historical process, but 'history's final judge' never delivers a final verdict because authors and books are continually revived and rediscovered; as long as works remain accessible—and here the Internet is invaluable—a book thought gone forever may, in 500 years, live again.

    “when they say history’s the final judge, the final judgment is never written because authors are being revived, they’re being rediscovered.”

  • As Joseph Telushkin says, polygamy does exist in the Bible but is never successful; David's simultaneous (not sequential) multiple wives were normative by the standards of the time yet produced strained and complex relationships.

    “as my friend Joseph Telushkin says, “Polygamy does exist in the Bible, it’s just never successful.””

  • Islam shares more with Judaism than Christianity does—both are religions of the transcendence of God and of law and commentary—and the reason is that Christianity grew up in the Roman Empire where laws were already taken care of, whereas Moses and Muhammad had to create a people in the desert, requiring civil as well as criminal law.

    “it’s because Christianity grew up in the Roman Empire, so the laws were taken care of. But Moses and Muhammad had to create a people in the desert. So you needed civil law as well as criminal law.”

  • The Iran nuclear deal is way overrated and likely a bad mistake; knowing Iranian culture (from his largely Iranian congregation), Wolpe holds that any deal where the American side never left the negotiating table even once is by definition a bad deal.

    “any deal where the American side didn’t leave the table even once is to me, by definition, a bad deal. By definition.”

  • Hasidism, from the Baal Shem Tov, sought to restore the sense of God's immanence and joy in the world and expanded religious ecstasy through dance, song, and especially religious stories—the Hasidic stories, particularly those of Rebbe Nachman of Breslov, are an immeasurable contribution to the world treasury of spirit.

    “Hasidic stories are an immeasurable contribution to the world treasury of spirit.”

  • Not everything happens for a reason—there is much randomness, and insisting everything happens for a reason leads to moral obscenities; the real question is not why something happened but what you will do with it. The world's unfairness is necessary because if good things always happened to good people and bad to bad, everyone would be good all the time for the reward; the only way genuine goodness is possible is if you can be good without knowing the consequences, so outcomes must be random for goodness to be real.

    “The only way it is possible to be good in this world is if you can be good without knowing the consequences. It has to be random or there’s no goodness.”

  • Los Angeles is overrated as a dream factory or cloud city but underrated in its tremendous natural beauty (mountains in the middle of the city) and in its intellectual and cultural depth; dismissing one in ten Americans as 'fruits, nuts, and flakes' is silly.

    “one out of every ten people in America lives in California; to dismiss them all as fruits, nuts, and flakes is silly.”

  • There is so much sex in the Zohar because the most powerful metaphors for human intimacy are sexual metaphors, so when speaking of intimacy with God it is very hard to avoid terms like zivug (coupling); the talk of devils, by contrast, reflects medieval folk belief in a world lit only by fire rather than the biblical tradition.

    “the most powerful metaphors for human intimacy are sexual metaphors. And so when you’re talking about intimacy with God, it’s very hard to avoid, like, zivug, which means coupling”

  • Jonathan Sacks's claim that the entire burden of the Torah from Exodus to Deuteronomy is about creating a free society as opposed to slavery is too sweeping; it is defensible that a large swath of the Torah is about this, but not the entire burden, since there are many other things the Torah is about.

    “If you take out “The entire burden of the Torah,” I might agree... So I think that it’s too sweeping a statement.”

  • Of all the characters in the Book of Samuel, Jonathan is the one (besides David) imaginable as a king because of his capacity for self-sacrifice and because people were drawn to him, though he probably would have gotten killed in the kingship, lacking David's too-strong personality and craftiness.

    “He probably would’ve gotten killed in the kingship in a way that David was too strong a personality and too crafty an operator to allow himself to be killed.”

  • Michelangelo's David statue portrays the Hebrew David, but the very idea of having such a magnificent David statue is a Christian idea.

    “He’s portraying the Hebrew David, but the idea of having such a magnificent David statue is a Christian idea.”

  • The Supreme Court being composed only of Catholics and Jews reflects that Catholicism has a natural law tradition and Judaism a strong legal tradition, while Protestantism is essentially antinomian (anti-law); so those trained in deep legal traditions are Catholics and Jews, even though individual Protestants can also excel.

    “Catholicism has a natural law tradition, Judaism has a strong legal tradition, and Protestantism is antinomian: it’s anti-law. That’s the essence of Protestantism”

  • Echoing Rebbe Chaim Halberstam's story of two men lost in a forest, our situation is that even the one who arrives cannot show the way out but knows the paths already tried are not the way, so the wisdom is to hold hands and find the way together.

    ““But one thing I do know, is the way we have gone is not the way. Now, let’s hold hands and find the way together.””

  • Jews have never been united—history is full of mutual excommunications (Hasidim and Mitnagdim) and constant internal fights—so worries about lost cohesion reflect ignorance of Jewish history; the community can still mobilize around moments of crisis (such as a wave of anti-Semitism), and what ultimately sustains it is not universal love (which dilutes love to meaninglessness) but a familial sense of love and closeness, since fear is more immediately effective but love is more enduring.

    “The good news is, Jews have never been united. Never... We used to be excommunicating each other all the time, the Hasidim, the Mitnagdim”

0.32

Jewish theology holds God as intangible yet intimate, transcendent and immanent simultaneously, beyond human comprehension.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Jewish faith rises or falls not on whether creation is eternal (Maimonides' Book Two question) but on whether God is; whether creation is eternal is not a question for Jewish dogma—as long as God is, we're good.

    “Jewish faith rises or falls, not on whether creation is eternal, but whether God is.”

  • When discussing God, one must recognize that just as a two-year-old cannot imagine what an adult is—and cannot even imagine what they cannot imagine—the distance between God and human beings is infinitely greater than the distance between a two-year-old and a twenty-year-old, so all talk of God's immanence or transcendence is caught in a net of metaphors about something we cannot comprehend.

    “the distance between God and human beings is infinitely greater than the distance between a two-year-old and a twenty-year-old. So as soon as we say God’s immanence or God’s transcendence, realize that we’re caught in this net of metaphors about something we can’t comprehend.”

  • In Jewish tradition God is not invisible (which would imply a body you cannot see) but intangible like love or justice—having no physical being—which makes God simultaneously transcendent and distant yet as close as your mouth to your ear; Judaism holds both immanence and transcendence at once, unlike Christianity which bridges the gap through the personhood of God.

    “God is intangible like love, like justice. That is, God doesn’t have a physical being, and that makes God transcendent and in some ways incredibly distant.”

0.31

Jewish political thought contains powerful arguments on both Left and Right, rejecting false ideological monopoly.

2 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Jewish intellectual opinion has historically leaned Left because Eastern European immigrants saw socialism/Bundism as the humanistic face of economics with no living capitalist alternative; but capitalism is profoundly Jewish in two ways—George Gilder's insight that a real capitalist must have empathy (you cannot succeed without understanding what others want or need) and that capitalism is the great engine of wealth lifting people out of poverty—so a Jewish thinker today would have to be a capitalist of some stripe, though one that addresses the inequalities and underclass it inevitably creates (a 'capitalist socialism').

    “He said, “A real capitalist has to have empathy.” Because if you’re building a business or a product and you don’t know what other people want, you’ll fail.”

  • Because the most learned and observant Jews (the Orthodox) tend to be Republican, it is shortsighted to claim Jewish and Democratic values are identical; equally one cannot deny the prophetic values for the poor and the stranger. A powerful Jewish case can be made on both Right and Left, and the only thing to be uneasy about is believing the other side has no good Jewish values, because that is wrong.

    “if the most learned and most observant Jews, that is the Orthodox community, tends to be Republican, then it’s a little shortsighted to say, obviously Jewish values and Democratic values are identical.”

0.29

Anti-Israel sentiment has become respectable cover for resurging anti-Semitism, which is virulent globally.

1 pointcentrality 3/5
  • Not all anti-Israel sentiment is anti-Semitism, but anti-Israel sentiment is now the respectable guise for anti-Semitism: very few will openly call themselves anti-Semites, but one can say 'I'm anti-Israel' and be an anti-Semite respectably; tests comparing how people criticize Israel versus other places reveal what is behind it. Anti-Semitism, repressed underground after the Holocaust, has erupted again as a viral strain, with frightening virulence in both Islam and Europe.

    “not all anti-Israel sentiment is anti-Semitism, but anti-Israel sentiment is now the respectable guise for anti-Semitism.”

0.29

Israel represents astonishing Jewish self-determination and peoplehood revival impossible elsewhere.

1 pointcentrality 3/5
  • The best non-theological case for choosing Israel is being part of an astonishing experiment—the revival of a people in its land after thousands of years, creating something lasting that involves tradition without being enslaved to it—since Israel is the only place where the Jewish people determines its own destiny across a full range of areas, in a world that too often determined that destiny for it.

    “the only place where that is happening in a full range of areas is in Israel.”

0.18

Rabbinic communication and literary beauty matter tremendously to Jewish spiritual life and learning.

3 pointscentrality 2/5
  • The single most valuable commodity a rabbi has is their voice, because most people encounter a rabbi through public speaking—more will attend services than will sit at deathbeds—yet the ability to communicate (what words and examples to use, how to train your voice) is woefully underrepresented in rabbinic training, which is very much to the community's detriment.

    “the single most valuable commodity you have as a rabbi... your voice. Most people are going to come in contact with you when you speak to them.”

  • Abraham Joshua Heschel's importance lies less in the content of his thought than in his breathtaking, poetic prose, which can move the reader; in works like The Sabbath the beauty of the language is itself an illustration of its subject—it touches your soul as it talks about the necessity for your soul to be touched—even though he sometimes was over-flowery and could have used an editor.

    “The reason that Heschel is so important is less for the content of his thought... than the frequently breathtaking prose in which he put it”

  • Primo Levi was a rare scientific mind who was also a brilliant literary writer; on Auschwitz he writes careful, crystalline, detailed prose that does not appeal to the heart but simply states what happened, and the reader's knowledge that he will not exaggerate or distort makes the testimony far more painful—exemplified by his bricklayer who could not bring himself to build a wall badly.

    “he’s a scientific mind that is a brilliant literary writer. So when you read him on Auschwitz, you’re reading very careful, detailed prose that is heartbreaking. He doesn’t appeal to your heart. Instead he just tells you in a crystalline way what happened.”

0.15

Maimonides' legal codification rigidified practice but enabled Jewish rationalism and remains foundationally important.

1 pointcentrality 2/5
  • Maimonides' Mishneh Torah aggregated messy Talmudic tradition into simple law but omitted footnotes (a choice he later regretted), so scholars have spent generations trying to reconstruct his sources, and fixed law rigidifies community practice ('it's not in the book, so you can't do it')—yet on balance more was gained than lost, and Maimonides is the single most important post-Talmudic figure in Judaism, making Jewish rationalists comfortable while forcing non-rationalists to argue their case.

    “he didn’t add footnotes. So we don’t know. Scholars have spent generations trying to reconstruct the sources of Maimonides. That’s a lot that was lost”