Talmud
The central text of Rabbinic Judaism, a record of rabbinic discussions of law, ethics, and tradition; here cited for its teaching about a covenant in which Jews would await divine return to Zion.
As defined in Daniel Gordis on Israel and Impossible Takes Longer
Where it comes up · 4
- Rabbi David Wolpe5 claims
- Daniel Gordis on Israel and Impossible Takes Longer1 claim
- Iain McGilchrist: The Coincidence of Opposites1 claim
- National DISINTEGRATION and How to Stop It feat. Peter Zeihan1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “Talmud” →
- Maimonides' Mishneh Torah aggregated messy Talmudic tradition into simple law but omitted footnotes (a choice he later regretted), so scholars have spent generations trying to reconstruct his sources, and fixed law rigidifies community practice ('it's not in the book, so you can't do it')—yet on balance more was gained than lost, and Maimonides is the single most important post-Talmudic figure in Judaism, making Jewish rationalists comfortable while forcing non-rationalists to argue their case.Rabbi David Wolpe
- The early Zionist revolution was, semi-figuratively, a revolt against God: traditional Talmudic Judaism held that God made a deal that the nations would not oppress Jews too much in exchange for Jews not 'hurrying the hands of time' to return to Zion; Zionism rejected this, declaring the nations had broken the deal—which is why many religious Jews considered Zionism a fundamental sin and some ultra-Orthodox remain anti-Zionist today.Daniel Gordis on Israel and Impossible Takes Longer
- Jacob Neusner, the most prolific scholar of the 20th century, transformed Talmud studies by questioning the traditional attributions ('Rabbi So-and-So told Rabbi So-and-So this'), applying the scientific study of texts to the Talmud in a way that had not been done before, such that anyone studying Talmud today is indebted to him whether they acknowledge it or not.Rabbi David Wolpe
- Judaism, like any thick civilization, faces the problem that social media strips away context and shortens attention, undermining a commentary culture that depends on recognizing references; the optimistic outcome is that easy access to vast Jewish libraries creates a more conversant community, while the pessimistic outcome is that Jewish culture grows thinner and thinner.Rabbi David Wolpe
- Saul's failure to kill the Amalekite king and exterminate the Amalekites as commanded illustrates the Talmudic principle that 'somebody who is kind to the cruel will end up being cruel to the kind'; effectively subduing or dispatching enemies was a necessary trait Saul lacked the stomach for, which made him an unsuccessful king in the ancient world.Rabbi David Wolpe
- The one thing at the heart of Islam that is antidemocratic is the concept of submission (in the very name of the religion), because a population trained to submit will create authoritarians; by contrast Israel's founders, who came from non-democratic places, created a democracy because the disputatious culture of the Talmud trained them to argue with each other.Rabbi David Wolpe
- Rabbi Jonathan Sax told a story: a holy man reads that Rabbi X says a certain thing is the case, then reads that another equally revered rabbi says the opposite. In spiritual turmoil, he prays to God which is right. God answers 'both are right,' and when the man protests they can't both be right, God replies 'all three of you are right.'Iain McGilchrist: The Coincidence of Opposites
- Ultra-Orthodox Jewish groups in Israel (like Lubavitch) follow rabbinical authority without question through the Talmud rather than the Old Testament, voting as unified blocks under rabbi leadership; Netanyahu aligned with these groups despite their biblical fundamentalism not grounded in fact, similar to how Osama Bin Laden, Scientology, or certain Christian sects operate through blind obedience to leadership.National DISINTEGRATION and How to Stop It feat. Peter Zeihan