What this covers
Audrey Tang, Taiwan's former Minister of Digital Affairs, sits down for a wide-ranging conversation about how lessons from software development and internet governance can reshape democratic practice. The discussion treats democracy as social technology—a system people can iteratively improve, much like contributing code to an open-source project. Tang draws on her own work in Taiwan's tech community and government to explore how open innovation, radical transparency, listening at scale, and rotation between viewpoints) can channel collective energy toward consensus rather than conflict. The core argument is that these practices don't require reinventing government from scratch; they scale empathy and cooperation through concrete institutional design, from e-petition platforms to crowdsourced fact-checking campaigns.
The conversation spans Taiwan's specific context—including its simultaneous arrival of democracy and information technology, the role of humor traveling faster than rumor in countering disinformation, and educational shifts from rote memorization toward competence-based learning—while also addressing broader questions about technology governance, encryption security, LGBTQ inclusion, and data sovereignty. Tang tackles contentious ground: how to regulate Chinese tech companies through systemic risk, what makes API design and AI accountability matter for society, whether blockchain has genuine use cases, and how platforms like TikTok should be evaluated through whole-of-society deliberation rather than top-down decree. She threads in observations on the I Ching, laziness as "lazy evaluation," and how transculturalism creates room for diverse norms to coexist. The interview moves between philosophy and infrastructure, personal practice and institutional experiment, without settling into abstraction.
Audrey Tang argues that democracy is itself a set of social technologies, and that open innovation, radical transparency, listening at scale, and 'rotation' between viewpoints can scale empathy and rough consensus the way software development scales collaboration.
- Democracy and constitutions are technologies people can contribute to like sending pull requests to the Linux kernel
- Open innovation brings technology to people rather than forcing people to adapt to technology
- Humor traveling faster than rumor and fast iteration channel outrage into co-creation rather than revenge
Democracy requires technology enabling listening at scale and co-presence so suffering voices amplify and diverse people build empathy across difference.
- Democracy is an ongoing process that requires software enabling listening at scale and co-presence, so that people closest to suffering can amplify their experiences and people of varied backgrounds can empathize with that experience.
“software that enables listening and feeling scale”
- Empathy is built not at the extremes of one death or a million deaths, but in the transitional zoom levels between them, where people can build context and connect their experiences with people who are slightly but not radically different, which is how common values form; a map that can only show the globe or a single block is useless.
“What’s useful is in the transitional zoom levels that makes sure that people can build a context in their head and connect their experiences with people who are slightly different but not all that different, and that builds common values.”
- Tang practices 'rotation' or taking all the sides: whenever she cannot argue from a particular community's viewpoint on an emerging topic like Uber, eSports, 5G, or self-driving cars, she spends days living ethnographically with that community until she can argue from their viewpoint, and she combines this with 'scaling' that uses technology so that local listening can be heard simultaneously by many ministries and municipalities.
“If I find that I cannot argue from any particular viewpoint, I will book a couple of days to spend time with that community on ethnographic — just hanging out until I rotate my worldview and until I can argue from their viewpoint. That’s called taking all the sides.”
- Elections are a kind of temporal rotation that loops every four years, but shortening the iteration to about 60 days, as in Taiwan's citizens' initiative e-petition platform, lets society iterate more; just as still pictures rotated quickly look like animation, rapid democratic iteration produces continuous responsiveness even though each generation acts only from its own point of view.
“If we shorten the iteration to not four years, but actually maybe 60 days, as is the standard iteration in Taiwanese citizens’ initiative, the e-petition platform, then we can iterate more.”
Radical transparency makes people performatively share agendas benefiting humanity and future generations rather than individual short-term gain.
- Under radical transparency, people show the better parts of themselves more visibly, sharing agendas that benefit humankind, the planet, or future generations because it is performative for people of the future to see, while the parts oriented only toward next-quarter linear individual or GDP growth at the expense of future generations tend not to show.
“if they have an agenda that benefits humankind or the planet or the cosmos, they are much more likely to share it because it’s also performative. They understand that people from the future will see it.”
- Decisions about platforms like TikTok should not be made top-down but through whole-of-society deliberation in the style of Taiwan's 2014 Sunflower movement, so a country collectively forms a 'data norm' about whether it is acceptable for facial recognition and self-filmed data to be aggregated into a single state with no jurisdictional accountability.
“all of society deliberation, the style of the 2014 Sunflower, needs to happen for the society to come to a common value about these sort of things, and this is what we call data norm”
- Taiwan's pandemic success benefited from a clearly-spelled-out privacy perimeter and a strong civil-rights movement with fresh memories of repression, so any attempt to encroach on basic freedoms is immediately met with arguments like 'Do you want to go back to martial law or the White Terror,' which makes pro-surveillance arguments nonstarters and conserves societal energy to use already-collected data creatively rather than inventing new collection with uncertain privacy properties.
“anything that tried to encroach on the basic freedoms is immediately met with the counterargument, “Do you want to go back to the martial law?” or “Do we want to go back to the White Terror?””
Outrage becomes constructive when directed toward co-creating institutions that prevent recurring problems rather than seeking revenge or discrimination.
- Outrage is the beginning of social movement, and what matters is where it is directed: toward revenge or discrimination, which are destructive, or toward co-creation of new institutions so that the problems that provoked the rage do not recur, which is how democracy grows.
“outrage is the beginning of social movement. The thing is, where do you direct the outrage to?”
- Drawing on Manuel Castells and prior movements like Occupy Wall Street and 15-M, Tang found that the faster humor travels than rumor and the more you draw people in through a fun, night-market atmosphere, the less likely the divisive, revenge-seeking part of an occupy movement grows, allowing the conservative-anarchist element to thrive and people to reach rough consensus and running legal code; her role in the 2014 occupation was setting up communication infrastructure with the g0v community so people could witness events directly and participate in journalism without being derailed by disinformation.
“the more that you can make humor travel faster than rumor, the more you can get people interested in night market, fun-ish way, the less likely that the more divisive and the more revenge-seeking part of an occupy movement will grow”
- Civic tech differs from ordinary private software because it is open for anyone to fork to a new direction; even when Taiwan's original mask-availability model was not open-source, its open API let open-source clones from communities like OpenStreetMap rapidly sprout into more than 140 versions, and working in the open eventually drew even corporations like Google to develop pandemic tools openly.
“while it’s true that original mask availability model wasn’t open-source, the API was open, and open-source clones and derivatives from the OpenStreetMap community, from various other communities, very quickly sprouted”
Taiwan's transcultural coexistence of multiple traditions, indigenous wisdom, and gender diversity creates space for innovation and breaks binary thinking.
- When the touch screen is the primary interaction method rather than a fallback used alongside a stylus and keyboard, it builds addiction; terminal-based platforms like Taiwan's PTT bulletin board lead to better discourse quality.
“if the touch screen is the primary interaction button, then, of course, it builds addiction”
- GDPR can be understood through two competing lenses: as a data norm extending from a framework of human rights that travels with the EU individual rather than the territorial jurisdiction, and as data localization or sovereignty based on where data is collected and used; real cases like a Singaporean app serving Filipino workers in Taiwan inherently span three overlapping jurisdictions, so GDPR's extraterritorial reach reflects this multi-jurisdictional reality.
“For the EU citizens, it extends by the framework of human rights, and therefore, of course, travels with the individual, not within the territorial jurisdiction.”
- Even as factory farming has increased, greater public understanding of how animals suffer has driven animal welfare and rights movements and innovations like the Impossible Burger, which are superior in nearly every regard except cost and avoid industrial-farming side effects including carbon emissions.
“people understand how animals suffer more. That leads to more people understanding the animal welfare and animal right angles. It also leads to innovations, such as the Impossible Burger”
- America's deeper character is a grand experiment of continually making mistakes and correcting them in the open and sharing the results with the world; this is also embodied in the internet and IETF, which encode 1970s-80s American values of free speech, free assembly, end-to-end and permissionless innovation, values whose claimed universality is now challenged but not lost.
“Isn’t America this grand experiment to keep making mistakes and correcting them in the open and share it with the world? That’s the American experiment.”
- Drawing on the Tao Te Ching, Tang holds that we are merely spaces through which thoughts pass; we do not own the thoughts, rather the thoughts own us briefly.
“we are merely spaces of which thoughts may pass through us, but we don’t own the thoughts; the thoughts own us briefly”
- Tang reinterprets Taiwan's official name Zhonghua Minguo as a 'transcultural republic of citizens,' a globally applicable view in which anyone can be part of a transcultural republic, reflecting her aim to synthesize the cultures she has encountered into a transcultural way of living and thinking.
“Taiwan — the name of the country is officially Zhōnghuá Mínguó, which I translate as a transcultural republic of citizens.”
- Tang identifies primarily as homo sapiens descended from a common East African ancestor rather than through Chinese dynastic identity, finding the question of whether a dynasty is 'Chinese' beside the point; her real interest is how cultures transfer and learn from each other to make cultural innovations like Zen, a transcultural conversation between Buddhist and Daoist traditions.
“I identify mostly as homo sapiens. I mean, we’re all descendants of some East African common ancestor.”
- Tang frames her role as working with the government rather than for the government, which she sees as protecting her from being corrupted by it.
“I’m working with the government; I’m not working for the government.”
- Not being educated in the United States did not separate Tang from American values; working with internet technologies and the IETF, with their implicit assumptions of free speech, free assembly, free press, end-to-end and permissionless innovation, imbued her with American internet values more than a traditional US education would have, and the core internet still reflects 1970s-80s US values even as ASCII's American assumptions are challenged.
“I’m more imbued in the internet scene, more imbued American value in the internet than a traditional education in the States would, I think.”
- Taiwan became a nice country quickly partly because the food is good and bubble tea helps.
“maybe the food is good, and bubble tea helps too”
- The reason there are few people like Tang in other governments may be that people are limited by imagining the government as a single thing; the internet community deliberately says 'governance' not 'government,' and had the IETF or ICANN called themselves a government, the multi-stakeholder approach would have been far more constrained.
“We said internet governance; we didn’t say internet government.”
- Tang reinterprets Larry Wall's programmer virtue of laziness as a 'lazy evaluation' that avoids over-scaring oneself by evaluating parameters and inputs only as the situation calls for them, which enables a more balanced work-life balance; she has accomplished much by designing spaces for people who care to make things happen rather than doing things personally.
“laziness also means that you do not over-scare yourself. You evaluate — this quite lazy evaluation — evaluate the parameters, the input, and so on, as the situation calls it.”
- Daoism is not opposed to anything; it makes space so that opposition can grow into common values and innovation, and unlike a Confucian approach that codifies rights, norms, and best-practice norms, for a Daoist there is no best practice, only practices, and the best practice is to share and let go of one's practices and be humble.
“We’re always making space so that opposition can grow into common values and innovation.”
- Taiwan's openness to LGBTQ rights grew from transculturalism and multiple coexisting norms across Holo, Hakka, and indigenous traditions, so that more individual-to-individual marriage norms eventually prevailed; combined with feminist movements and 12 years of gender mainstreaming and impact assessment, marriage equality law was designed to 'hyperlink' only the individual bylaws while preserving family-to-family in-law relationships, building a more liberal culture out of the existing family-based one rather than disrupting it.
“It only hyperlinks to the individual parts, the bylaws but not the in-law relationships, the family-between-family relationships.”
- An important remnant of Japanese colonial influence in Taiwan is the emphasis on public health and the view of medical and public-health professions as a high and noble calling, partly because the Japanese discouraged Taiwanese from entering politics or law, channeling talent into medicine.
“the emphasis on public health, the fact that people see that working in the medical and public health professions as the high and noble cause of calling. I think that was introduced by the Japanese colonial rule.”
- Having a heart problem until age 12 made Tang less interested in outdoor sports and less prone to anger or strong passion, unable to feel very joyful, leaving her more calm and collected, and led her to learn Daoist breathing exercises that remain with her like a survival instinct.
“It also made me less prone to anger or really any passion. I can’t feel very joyful either because of the heart condition. I’m more calm and collected.”
- Taiwan does have very successful software companies such as Appier and Trend Micro, but because they are business-to-business rather than consumer-facing, they are less visible, and the Taiwanese psyche is comfortable with that lack of recognition, expressed in the '#TaiwanIsHelping' ethos of wanting the world to be better without demanding thanks.
“There are very successful Taiwanese software companies. They are new in the software world. Trend Micro is another one. But because these are less directly to users, to customers, and so maybe they are less well known”
Empathy and transcultural understanding grow from lived experience rotating through multiple communities and scaling that local listening widely.
- Translation is very important for becoming a better thinker, along with the related skills of rotation and scaling.
“I think it’s very, very important. Also important is the skills of rotation and scaling.”
- Being transgender makes it easier to empathize with people because having gone through parts of puberty regardless of gender, Tang does not feel half the population is different from her but rather feels part of one large homo sapiens community; she frames becoming 'a little more transgender' as a practice like translation and transculturalism, exemplified by Minister Chen wearing a pink mask in solidarity with a bullied boy.
“I think it makes it easier to empathize with people because I’ve gone through some parts of your puberty, no matter the gender of you, so I wouldn’t feel that half a population is different from me.”
- Living with the Atayal indigenous community liberated Tang from written culture into an orally preserved culture that views mountains and rivers as long-lived spirits with humans as transient stewards, making her politics less human-centric; the Amis matriarchy and Taiwan's 20-plus national languages create many gender stereotypes that form a 'rainbow' helping people break out of binary thinking about gender and other categories.
“this orally preserved culture really takes me out of this human-centric point of view, in the view that the mountains and rivers are long-lived spirits and we’re just transient stewards that work with them”
- The core teaching of the I Ching, the original binary thinking, is that the only thing that does not change is change itself, and the discipline is learning how to work with change: to face, accept, and deal with it, and then let go of it.
“the only thing that is immobile, that would not change, is change itself, and how to work with the change, to face, to accept, to deal with it, and let go of it”
Open innovation co-creates technology with people rather than asking people to adapt to technology, building empathy and shared social reality.
- Virtual reality experiences only become socially and democratically meaningful when they are shared as an extended reality containing multiple people; a private VR experience may have therapeutic or overview effects and be pro-social, but it is not democratic because it does not create a shared social reality.
“this is pro-social but not necessarily democratic”
- The innovation that would most boost empathy is open innovation, which means innovation co-created to bring technology to people rather than asking people to adapt to technology.
“Definitely open innovation — that is to say, innovation that is co-created to bring technology to people rather than asking people to adapt to technology.”
- Remote work does not eliminate face-to-face meeting but transcends spatial boundaries; when opt-in it can improve work quality, but when mandatory for unsuitable work it hurts quality. It should be seen as an augmentation that scales empathy and rough consensus to remote places, not a replacement for in-person contact, and disliked tools can simply be improved through open innovation.
“It’s about expanding the idea of face-to-face meetings and the empathy and rough consensus that we can form and scale it to the more remote places. It’s not a replacement. It is an augmentation to the face-to-face form.”
Taiwan's democratic culture treats democracy and constitution as social technologies people can contribute to like open-source code, enabling rapid civic innovation.
- Because democracy and information technology arrived in Taiwan at the same time, Taiwanese see democracy as a set of social technologies; even the constitution, the kernel of democracy, is technology that people can contribute to just like sending pull requests to the Linux kernel, as shown by ongoing constitutional amendments.
“even the constitution, the kernel of democracy, is technology — that people can contribute to it just like sending pull requests to the Linux kernel”
- Blockchain is just one implementation of distributed ledger technology and not necessarily the market-preferred solution; Git is effectively a blockchain and the killer app of decentralized open-source work. Cryptocurrency will not overtake a trusted central bank in Taiwan anytime soon and only has value where trust in fiat is very low, whereas ledgers enabling cross-jurisdiction accountability, multi-writer environmental science, and labor smart contracts for migrant workers are the genuinely useful applications.
“Blockchain is just one implementation of a broad swath of technology known as distributed ledgers or DLTs”
- Taiwan's curriculum shift from literacy-based, standardized-answer, rote-memory, standardized-test education toward competence-based education, where people are producers of data, media, and narratives, really helps; early signs include cram schools pivoting from memorization to hiking, kayaking, and overseas humanitarian aid, with more emphasis on social responsibility from a tender age rather than individualistic competition.
“the shift from a literacy-based, standardized answer, rote memory, standardized test, “the teachers know the best” into a competence-based education, which is, the people are producers of data and media and narratives — that really helps”
Humor that is self-directed or shared, distinct from toxic attacks, travels virally and shapes positive long-term associations with pro-social behaviors.
- Taiwan counters disinformation with crowdsourced fact-checking plus rapid, funny dog-meme responses from ministry participation officers, so that before people sleep they encounter humor alongside the conspiracy theory; because the humor travels virally, the long-term associations people form with keywords like masks or social distancing become fun, which promotes pro-social behavior.
“By the time that they go to sleep and form long-term associations in their minds with the keywords such as masks or social distancing, they think of something fun. And that enables more pro-social behavior.”
- Humor specifically means making fun of oneself or making fun with someone, never aggression; it is distinct from sarcasm or toxic attacks that make fun of someone, and certain comedic styles do not work and will quickly reinforce conspiracy-theory thinking.
“A humorist makes fun of oneself or makes fun with someone, but it’s never a kind of aggression.”
Secure anti-authoritarian communication requires quantum-resistant cryptography offering physical rather than merely mathematical guarantee against interception.
- Current public key cryptography rests only on a mathematical property, not a physical one, which means it carries a real danger of being broken within one to two decades by quantum computers; a quantum-resistant cryptographic channel that reveals interception immediately is needed for truly secure anti-authoritarian communication.
“the public key cryptography in mathematics has added a very real danger of being broken within a decade or so, or two decades if you’re optimistic, by the quantum computer themselves”
- A quantum-resistant cryptographic channel would enable truly secure conversation because any attempt to intercept it would be detected immediately, providing a physical rather than merely mathematical guarantee.
“a quantum-resistant cryptographic channel will really help to enable true secure conversation, that once someone tries to intercept it, you will know immediately”
AI systems raise value-alignment and accountability problems whose solutions depend on participatory access to source code, APIs, and training data.
- An AI that gives factually good answers raises two distinct problems: value alignment, meaning the degree it agrees with a society's epistemic norms, and accountability, meaning who gets to correct its mistakes and overcome its biases, which depends on whether the source code, API, and data are participatory or known only to a few.
“that’s the value-alignment part. What you’re saying is that it more or less agrees with the epistemic norms”
Regulating Chinese tech companies requires systemic-risk approach recognizing state-party control blurs private-sector boundaries and inflates total cost of ownership.
- Regulating major Chinese tech companies should use a systemic-risk approach grounded in the deliberated recognition that there are no purely private-sector companies in the PRC, because the party and state, effectively the same thing, can replace or swap leadership through party branches; thus PRC infrastructure components, though cheap due to state subsidy, carry a higher amortized total cost of ownership because each upgrade requires reassessing whether the state has taken over the supposedly private firm.
“there’s no pure private-sector companies in the PRC, and party or the state — really the same thing — can replace and swap leadership as they like through the party branches”