Better for You, Better for the World
What this covers
This is a conversation between host Patrick and Craig Shapiro of Collaborative Fund about how the firm chooses early-stage companies. The main tool is the villain test, which Shapiro credits to Ben Goldhirsh of Good Magazine: a product with a do-good orientation must also serve the buyer's own interest, or returns suffer. Patrick adds a frame of Looks Good Versus Feels Good, meaning status signaling versus self-interested satisfaction. Examples include fair-trade cotton that no one wants to wear, Tesla resolving the Ferrari-versus-Prius tension, and Kickstarter, which has raised over $2 billion though backers get no equity.
The middle of the conversation turns to screening and timing. Shapiro's negative screen rejects founders who started from market-size statistics instead of a personal pain point, since they quit first. He also makes a contested claim that once a McKinsey report makes an area popular, the opportunity is already crowded, and he urges entrepreneurs to build passion before it goes mainstream. He forecasts a shift in CPG from industrial products to small craft brands, with large incumbents buying growth through M&A. He also recounts passing on Uber at its seed round, despite having once written a car-sharing business plan.
The last stretch covers the fund's mechanics and Shapiro's personal lessons. Limited partners, often entrepreneurs, use the fund as an outsourced early-stage scout, and portfolio alumni who start new companies feed deal flow. The firm's values-driven brand works as a self-selecting beacon. Shapiro also discusses an early investor who required him to disclose problems, what bootstrapping and Good Magazine taught him about burn, and a definition of meditation as whatever re-energizes you.
Shapiro argues the strongest venture investments sit at the intersection of what is better for the individual and what is better for the world, and that financial markets and metrics lag cultural change in valuing that intersection.
- Culture has moved from a nonprofit-versus-shareholder split toward hybrid organizations, but financial metrics still reward an older model
- Businesses that balance self-interest with social benefit should generate the greatest financial returns over the next decade
- Products must pass a 'villain test' where they satisfy both personal desire and broader good, and a 'pain point' origin predicts founder persistence
Balancing for-profit returns with for-good impact is the core investment thesis.
- The core of Collaborative Fund's investment thesis is that businesses that balance between the for-profit and for-good ends of the spectrum will generate the greatest financial returns over the next decade and beyond.
“the businesses that get that right, that balance right between those two, are the ones that are going to generate the greatest financial returns over the next decade and beyond.”
- The world has bifurcated into nonprofits focused on doing good and for-profits focused on shareholder returns, but culture has migrated toward hybrid organizations in between, while financial markets have not kept pace.
“ironically, our financial markets haven't really shifted alongside culture.”
- Because human beings are self-interested by nature, the balance between what is best for me and what is best for the world is where startups should be evaluated, and this tension can be transformative.
“because we're human beings, and by nature we're self-interested.”
- Collaborative Fund evaluates founders' business savvy, business model, market size, and competitive landscape like most venture capitalists, but adds a distinctive assessment of the tension between what is best for me and best for the world.
“We evaluate their business savvy, we evaluate the business model and the size of the market and the competitive landscape”
- Ben Goldhirsh of Good Magazine introduced the villain test, which checks whether a company's do-good orientation is combined with what is best for the individual, because if the doing-good sensibility is not balanced it can impair returns.
“He shared with me a term called the villain test”
- Collaborative Fund moved from a broad for-profit-for-good filter to thematic categories because nearly every startup now touts mission, making the original intersection too broad to be a useful filter.
“it was no longer a small subset of startups, but almost every startup we're seeing these days really touts that as being a key element.”
Independent consumer packaged goods brands offer a larger opportunity than technology.
- The consumer packaged goods space is orders of magnitude larger than the technology space.
“the CPG space is just orders of magnitude larger than even the technology space.”
- Consumer packaged goods are undergoing a shift from mega-corporation industrialized products toward smaller, independent craft, authentic brands that consumers are demanding, and this shift is still in its early stages.
“a shift from the mega-corporation, industrialized, produced goods to smaller, more independent craft, authentic brands and products, which consumers are demanding.”
- Independent consumer brands use existing technologies to target the younger consumer's specific desires, which allows them to take market share and change the dynamics of the consumer products industry.
“I like to use the term scratch and itch with the younger consumer, and start to take market share.”
- Coca-Cola acquired Honest Tea, and Unilever acquired Dollar Shave Club for a billion dollars, showing that acquisition sizes in consumer brands are increasing.
“Dollar Shave Club was acquired for a billion dollars by Unilever.”
- Big monolithic consumer organizations are struggling to grow organically and so use investing and mergers and acquisitions to fuel growth, making well-traction startups attractive acquisition targets.
“the big monolithic organizations are having a hard time growing. And so they're using investing, as well as mergers and acquisitions, to fuel their growth.”
- Collaborative Fund has invested heavily in consumer categories including Ripple Foods, Good Eggs, Simply Gum, Hampton Creek Foods, Sweetgreen, and Blue Bottle Coffee.
“We've invested pretty heavily in it, with Ripple Foods, invested in Good Eggs, invested in Simply Gum, invested in Hampton Creek Foods”
- The market of consumers willing to sacrifice for the right thing is very small, while the market of people who want to do the right thing without sacrificing their self-interest is massive and growing.
“The market size for people that are willing to be sacrificial to do the right thing... is very small. But the market size of people who want to do the right thing, but not at the sacrifice of what's better for them... is massive and growing.”
- A product with strong better-for-the-world metrics, such as fair-trade cotton, fails if consumers would be embarrassed to wear it, because good intentions cannot compensate for lack of personal desirability.
“I wouldn't be caught dead in that thing. I'd be embarrassed to wear it. Then it doesn't work.”
A values-driven brand and mission-aligned network supply deal flow and partners.
- Collaborative Fund's limited partners, who are often entrepreneurs, are a rich source of deal flow because they deploy larger sums into later-stage businesses and cannot evaluate every early opportunity, so the fund effectively serves as an outsourced early-stage scout for them.
“Collaborative Fund actually serves as a wonderful... almost like an outsource for a lot of that early-stage deal flow.”
- Ron Gonen, founder of Recyclebank and later New York City's recycling czar under Mayor Bloomberg, is well connected in waste management and recycling and shares deal flow with Collaborative Fund that he cannot evaluate himself.
“a lot of times, he's seeing deal flow that he's not able to parse or evaluate himself and, in some cases, will share that with us.”
- Collaborative Fund's portfolio companies continuously spawn new startups when co-founders or engineering leads leave to start their own businesses, creating a self-refreshing talent pool that has become the richest source of deal flow as the fund ages.
“those companies themselves spawn companies when one of the co-founders decides it's time to move on and start something new”
- Collaborative Fund's values-driven brand is self-selecting, acting as a beacon that attracts investors, entrepreneurs, partners, and media who can add value to the efforts it pursues.
“our brand and our values are somewhat self-selecting.”
- Many financial managers name firms after themselves or innocuous places like Ridge Crest or Mountain Summit Partners, which fails to signal a mission and so misses the beacon effect of a values-driven name.
“they choose either their own name... Right, so it's Smith and Associates. Or they choose just an innocuous Ridge Crest, Mountain Summit Partners”
- Craig's background as an entrepreneur, including deals in which he worked on opposing sides, built mutual respect that later became the basis for relationships with future limited partners, rather than relationships built inside the investment world.
“through business, I was able to build relationships with some of these folks... In some cases, working on opposing sides, but building mutual respect.”
- Collaborative Fund's thesis is that collective action and shared resources will be a competitive edge in the for-profit venture world, and this way of thinking applies to entrepreneurs, partners, and media as well as to capital sources.
“We believe that, essentially, collective action and resources are going to be a competitive edge in the for-profit venture world.”
Hybrid for-good models like Kiva and Kickstarter succeed despite investor skepticism.
- Kiva, a nonprofit micro-lending organization started by a former PayPal employee and a Stanford business student, is run in many ways like a for-profit business, which would surprise people visiting its board room.
“it's run almost like a for-profit business, in a lot of ways.”
- Kickstarter, which Collaborative Fund invested in early around 2010, opened a funding path beyond National Endowment for the Arts grants or friends and family, and has since seen over $2 billion raised, even though backers receive no equity.
“Over $2 billion has gone on Kickstarter”
- Kickstarter succeeded even though backers receive no equity or financial return, because it satisfies both the individual's desire to fulfill potential and the community's desire to lift up creative projects, with over $2 billion raised.
“Over $2 billion has gone on Kickstarter... So it clearly scratches an itch, both from what's best for me as an individual”
- Tesla shows that the apparent conflict between the Ferrari-style desire for speed and beauty and the Prius-style desire to do good can be resolved, because an electric car can be every bit as fast and beautiful while also caring for the world.
“until an entrepreneur like Elon Musk comes along and creates something like Tesla, which kind of allows for both of those emotions to exist”
- Ripple Foods makes a pea-protein milk alternative that uses a fraction of the water and resources dairy milk requires, uses less than other dairy-free alternatives like almond and cashew milk, and has more protein than almond milk.
“Ripple uses a fraction of the water and resources that dairy milk uses.”
- Even some of Collaborative Fund's own investors doubted that anyone would give money to projects with no tangible reward or equity, seeing it as crazy, which shows the model was counterintuitive to financial professionals.
“Who in their right mind would give money to a project to get nothing, no tangible reward, right?”
Seed-stage investing offers attractive risk-reward because young companies are formative.
- Venture is the only asset class Shapiro is aware of where the underlying assets do not yet exist, so raising a venture fund means convincing investors to fund things that have not been built.
“Venture's interesting in that it's the only asset class that I'm aware of where the underlying assets don't yet exist.”
- Early-stage venture investing has an attractive risk-reward profile because if a fund gets it right by investing in businesses very early, it can produce tremendous rewards, and the entrepreneurial spirit has been a driving force of the US economy.
“if you get it right, if you're able to invest in some businesses very early on in their evolution, it can pay tremendous rewards.”
- Collaborative Fund focuses around the seed stage because it is the most creative, messiest, and most formative time in a company's life, though it is not dogmatic about investing beyond seed.
“our favorite is kind of right when it's getting started. It's the most creative, it's the messiest, and it's the most formative.”
- The job of a venture capitalist is first and foremost to serve the entrepreneur, and doing that well generates fantastic returns for investors, as Shapiro has seen across the firm's more than 70 investments.
“I do think the job of a venture capitalist is to serve an entrepreneur, and so first and foremost.”
- By the time of the interview Collaborative Fund had invested in over 50 companies and later reported 70-plus investments, with its portfolio expanding continuously.
“So we've now invested in over 50 companies”
Shapiro's entrepreneurial experience and family values shaped the firm's mission to support entrepreneurs.
- Shapiro's immigrant grandfather passed down a belief in working together, and capital, though not the most important resource, is the most universally needed resource for starting a business, which inspired the firm's mission to support entrepreneurs.
“capital is in essence, it is the most universal resource. Certainly not the only, and maybe not even the most important, but it's universally needed when starting a business.”
- Craig's grandfather, an immigrant who started with a pushcart, passed down a belief in working together, and this value of collective action became the basis for Collaborative Fund's mission to support people trying to do something positive.
“one of the things that he passed down to myself and to the rest of our family was just the belief in working together, that you can't go it alone.”
- Shapiro's first startup, Prodius, built early mobile applications such as live TV voting, and became an exclusive mobile partner for HBO shows before being acquired at the end of 2005.
“that business ended up getting acquired at the end of 2005.”
- Shapiro's experience at a bootstrapped mobile startup and at Good Magazine, which was funded by Ben Goldhirsh's family resources, taught him to manage unit economics and burn while knowing when to use outside capital ahead of the balance sheet.
“knowing when to focus on your unit economics and how to build a budget, and where to cut burn”
- Collaborative Fund closed its first fund in November 2010, and Shapiro considers the day the most memorable milestone, as the firm had no traditional finance background and was an underdog.
“the day that we closed our first fund, which was actually in November of 2010”
Founders should pursue unpopular passions and personal pain points rather than trends.
- Successful people usually pursued something and became great at it before it became mainstream, so aspiring entrepreneurs should find passion areas that are not yet popular or hot.
“they pursued something and became great at it before it was mainstream.”
- A young musician who devotes years to the trombone while others chase jazz saxophone will be well positioned when the world's attention shifts to trombones, illustrating that deep investment in unfashionable passions creates an advantage.
“it's the trombone player who just loved it and went so deep into the trombone”
- A key negative screen is whether a startup originated from a personal pain point rather than opportunism, because founders driven by market size statistics are the first to quit when the business gets hard.
“the negative screen for me is when it doesn't come from a pain point.”
- Once a McKinsey report or similar publication makes an area popular, an entrepreneur's opportunity set is smaller rather than larger, because the best opportunities are already crowded.
“Your opportunity set is actually somewhat smaller.”
The firm's missed deals and commitment to candor shaped its investing approach.
- Shapiro passed on Uber at its seed round after David Shen showed it to him, despite having written a car-sharing business plan years earlier, because the round was closing quickly and he had not met the founders.
“I had written a business plan for a car-sharing business years earlier, and the round was closing relatively quickly, and I hadn't met the founders yet.”
- After missing Uber, Collaborative Fund became an early investor in Lyft and has been a big supporter of the company.
“So we then became an early investor in Lyft, and have been a big supporter of theirs.”
- An early investor made his investment conditional on Shapiro promising to disclose when something goes wrong, because hiding problems with white gloves will eventually fail, and this permission to share downsides was the most generous gift the firm received.
“Don't shine the turd.”
Exercise and meditation support mental health and clear decision-making.
- Shapiro's wife encouraged him to read about and practice meditation and holds him accountable, while meditation apps such as Headspace provide frameworks, though breathing is the only universal element.
“One actually is my wife... she holds me accountable.”
- Meditation is different for each person and is best defined as whatever activities re-energize you rather than drain you, so people must learn to listen to themselves.
“what are the things that are going to enable you to recharge your battery?”
- Shapiro believes exercise every day is critical to mental health and every other facet of life, reflecting a strong body, strong mind philosophy.
“I just think it's critical to mental health and every other facet of life.”
- Shapiro first felt the benefits of meditation during exercise, specifically running, where he could decompress and think about the business and team goals.
“ironically, where I first felt the benefits of it was during exercise.”
- Craig's daily routine centers on exercise, which he views as critical to mental health and every other facet of life, plus meditation, which he first experienced as a benefit during running by giving his brain time to decompress and plan.
“I try to find time to exercise every single day. I just think it's critical to mental health and every other facet of life.”