villain test
Thought experiment asking what a purely profit-maximizing actor indifferent to climate would build, used to identify where commercial incentives align with removal.
As defined in Jonathan Goldberg - Capturing Carbon - [Founder’s Field Guide, EP. 25]
Where it comes up · 2
- Better for You, Better for the World5 claims
- Jonathan Goldberg - Capturing Carbon - [Founder’s Field Guide, EP. 25]1 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “villain test” →
- The market of consumers willing to sacrifice for the right thing is very small, while the market of people who want to do the right thing without sacrificing their self-interest is massive and growing.Better for You, Better for the World
- Because human beings are self-interested by nature, the balance between what is best for me and what is best for the world is where startups should be evaluated, and this tension can be transformative.Better for You, Better for the World
- A product with strong better-for-the-world metrics, such as fair-trade cotton, fails if consumers would be embarrassed to wear it, because good intentions cannot compensate for lack of personal desirability.Better for You, Better for the World
- Even a purely profit-seeking actor should build CO2 infrastructure such as pipelines, storage, and transport from point sources or air capture, because existing supply is far too limited and the commercial opportunity is large.Jonathan Goldberg - Capturing Carbon - [Founder’s Field Guide, EP. 25]
- Collaborative Fund evaluates founders' business savvy, business model, market size, and competitive landscape like most venture capitalists, but adds a distinctive assessment of the tension between what is best for me and best for the world.Better for You, Better for the World
- Patrick suggests a humorous rule that profit margins rise as one moves down the body from head to heart to groin, which parallels the risk of profit overriding values.Better for You, Better for the World