Lessons From the Founder of Morningstar
What this covers
Patrick interviews Joe Mansueto about how Morningstar was built and how he runs it and invests. The story starts with the first product, which was sold through advertising and prepaid subscriptions before the book was printed. Customer money covered production, which mattered because Joe had little capital. From there the talk turns to product choices: classifying funds by what they actually held rather than by prospectus language, which produced the style box, and an open architecture that puts Morningstar data on Google, Yahoo, Schwab, and Fidelity, in contrast to Bloomberg's closed terminal.
The middle of the conversation covers industry opinion and capital allocation. Joe argues that competitors serve institutions and only praise, while Morningstar criticizes. He calls many managers closet indexers and describes a bell curve whose "mushy middle" passive investing is squeezing. He expects passive to gain roughly 100 basis points of share a year without taking over, and both claims are contested. As a value investor he holds good businesses for long periods, and he admits he has sold too early, as with Apple and Dell. He ranks organic growth first, prefers buybacks to dividends when shares trade at or below fair value, and says dividends persist out of inertia. Patrick brings his own research on large buybacks beating the S&P 500.
The last stretch is about management. Joe hires bright liberal arts graduates, is coding resumes to score persistence, and runs 30 to 40 agile squads. He delegates, gives up minor decisions the way a chess player gives up pawns, and treats saying no as a skill, since each board seat or talk can cost about two weeks a year. Patrick adds a framing of good businesses as reducing others' transaction costs, illustrated by a dorm soda service.
Mansueto argues Morningstar's durable advantage came from float-funded growth, critical independent research that earns trust, and ubiquitous open distribution, and that investors and leaders win by holding good businesses long-term, delegating, and saying no.
- Customer prepayment (float) funded Morningstar's launch and growth without outside capital
- Willingness to criticize funds, not just praise them, builds the trust that anchors the brand
- Holding high-quality businesses long-term beats trading around macro views
Long-term holding of great businesses compounds wealth better than diversifying or selling along the way.
- If a manager builds a massively diversified portfolio covering every square of the style box, the result is effectively an index fund, so such a portfolio does not need active management.
“if you're going to have a massively diversified portfolio covering every square of the style box, I'm not sure you need active management.”
- Mansueto has held Morningstar stock for 32 years, it is the best investment he has made and his largest source of wealth, and selling at any point along the way, such as before a feared 1987 crash, would have been a mistake.
“the best investment I ever made has been Morningstar stock. ... Any period, any point along the way to sell it would have been a mistake.”
- Mansueto joined the Giving Pledge because he expected to give away most of his assets while his children would be well provided for, and Buffett framed it as being on the good side of the ledger if you were going to give anyway.
“if you're going to do this anyway, you might as well be on the good side of the ledger in life”
- When Mansueto covered Berkshire Hathaway at Harris Associates, its A shares traded around 1,200 dollars, and they now trade near 240,000 dollars, a reminder of long-term compounding in a great business.
“Berkshire at the time was $1,200 a share and these were the A shares. Today it's $240,000.”
- Mansueto says he sent Buffett an analyst report on Berkshire that said hold rather than sell, saying he didn't say sell.
“I think I sent those to Warren Buffett at one point. At least I didn't say sell. I said hold.”
Leaders should delegate execution and push innovation down, fighting only for the critical decisions.
- A leader should give up the minor decisions, like brochure color, and fight only for the critical ones, like a seriously flawed brochure's copy, just as in chess you give up pawns but fight for kings and queens.
“So I think of it like chess. You give up the pawns but you fight for the kings and queens.”
- Morningstar's innovation is not owned by one department; analysts generate new metrics such as ESG ratings and product teams run independent innovation sprints off the roadmap, so innovation is pushed down throughout the organization.
“Innovation is not any one department's responsibility. ... they'll have what's called an innovation sprint.”
- Product managers set milestones on a roughly two-year roadmap, and then 30 to 40 cross-disciplinary squads of about 10 to 15 people figure out how to reach them, allowing bounded direction with discovery inside it.
“We have product managers who will set a roadmap over a couple years. These are the milestones that we want to accomplish. Then it's up to the squads to figure out how to get there.”
- A leader who starts out doing everything must step out of execution and build a team to build a major enterprise, because personal ambition is limited by one person's capacity.
“But I quickly realized that my ambitions are built to build a major enterprise, and to do that, I've got to build a team.”
Conservative, self-funded growth and disciplined capital use keep Morningstar away from make-or-break crises.
- Buffett uses float in insurance companies, and understanding that float means not laying out large sums before being paid later is a powerful concept shared across business models.
“Buffett uses it obviously with insurance companies.”
- Morningstar never reached a make-or-break moment because the company grew steadily and financed things conservatively, which kept it away from the edge of disaster.
“There was never a kind of make-or-break moment in our history, thank goodness... we've grown pretty strongly and tried to finance things pretty conservatively”
- Morningstar has laid off people only twice, and both experiences were unpleasant enough that Mansueto never wanted to face layoffs again.
“we've only had to lay off people twice in our history here and both of them were pretty unpalatable”
- Mansueto's capital allocation hierarchy puts organic growth first, because internally generated growth creates the best long-term value with no integration issues, and then uses balance-sheet cash for acquisitions, dividends, or repurchases.
“to me that's the best source of long-term value creation is organic growth. Businesses that can grow on their own without having to resort to say acquisitions, just a much healthier growth.”
- Morningstar considers acquisitions only when a target furthers its strategic direction and it is quicker than building, as with PitchBook, a private equity and venture database it bought at the end of the prior year.
“typically it's a build or buy decision. We know how to build databases”
Early self-reliance and entrepreneurial experience shaped his routines, reading, and business instincts.
- Mansueto and his roommate ran a 24-hour honor-system soda business from their dorm, stocking refrigerators with Coke and Pepsi each week and paying themselves from a change jar, which met a real need and let them meet everyone in the dorm.
“it was just the honor system. ... we'd each make like 500 bucks a quarter”
- After graduating with a roommate, Mansueto started a radio research business and worked on it for a year to learn what building a business required, without caring about radio itself.
“to really see what putting a business together was all about, not that I wanted to be in the radio business.”
- Thoreau's Walden, with its theme of independence, thrift, self-reliance, and simplification, was the book that most influenced Mansueto, who gives it to Morningstar employees after their three-year anniversary and would recommend it to a graduating 22-year-old.
“everybody at Morningstar after their three-year anniversary, we give them a copy of Walden, and it's part of our culture here.”
- At about age 11, Mansueto borrowed $100 to buy a Drake 2B receiver that was worth at least $250, then resold it for about $250 after recognizing it was priced far below value, which he sees as an early arbitrage instinct.
“I knew that this thing was worth 250 bucks at least, and he just wanted to get out of the business, was selling it for 100 bucks.”
- Routines reduce daily decisions, so Mansueto follows a fixed schedule of waking at 5:15, running four miles, and eating the same lunch, following Peter Lynch's point that he did not want to think about breakfast cereal every morning.
“I don't want to think of what breakfast cereal to eat every morning because I've got other things to think about.”
- Walden is a book to give every 22-year-old graduate because it builds confidence to think for oneself, follow a different drumbeat, and build castles in the sky before putting foundations under them.
“And giving you confidence to dream, build your castles in the sky and then put the foundations under them.”
Hiring bright, persistent, developmental talent is how Morningstar builds its workforce.
- Persistence, shown by sticking with activities over multiple years, predicts success, so Morningstar is coding resumes to score repeated commitment, such as one point for two years in a row and another for holding a leadership role, alongside GPA and school quality.
“maybe you've gone out for something, you get zero points, but if you've done it two years in a row, you get one point.”
- Mansueto favors bright people who can reason, build arguments, question, and analyze data, and he prefers liberal arts graduates because they like to learn and investing skills can be taught in-house.
“I favor liberal arts grads, people who just like to learn because the world is constantly changing. We can teach them the investing side.”
- Morningstar hired 150 recent graduates last year into a two-year rotational development program, growing talent from within as part of its culture.
“We hired last year 150 kids right out of school, college, business school, put them through a two-year rotational program.”
Morningstar's history and critical stance set it apart from its institution-serving competitors.
- Morningstar's first product, the Mutual Fund Sourcebook, was a 400-page quarterly covering all US equity funds, with a single copy priced at $32.50 or a yearly subscription of four copies for $110, promoted through a Barron's ad.
“you could buy one copy for $32.50, subscribe for a year, four copies for $110.”
- Morningstar was founded in 1984 and Mansueto has run it for 32 years, going public in 2005, with the company's history traced from the Mutual Fund Sourcebook through international expansion.
“'84. ... We went public 2005.”
- Morningstar's competitors mainly serve institutions, do not want to offend those institutions, mostly provide data, and when they comment, only praise, which makes Morningstar unusual in the industry for being critical.
“They don't want to offend the institution. They're primarily giving data.”