closet indexer
A manager who claims to be active but actually just holds a benchmark portfolio; never takes bets, so never underperforms but also adds no value
As defined in Liz Ann Sonders, Cliff Asness, Mike Green and 40+ Others Share Their Most Important Lesson
Where it comes up · 4
- Lessons From the Founder of Morningstar2 claims
- A Conversation with Charlie Munger & John Collison - [Invest Like the Best, REPLAY]1 claim
- Warren Buffett Published His Whole Playbook | Robert Hagstrom on Why Only One Tenth of 1% Uses It1 claim
- Liz Ann Sonders, Cliff Asness, Mike Green and 40+ Others Share Their Most Important Lesson1 claim
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “closet indexer” →
- It is okay to be wrong in active management; the only way to avoid being wrong is to be a closet indexer (never taking a bet), which means you never add value; taking active risk means regularly being wrong, and this must be accepted as the cost of value creation.Liz Ann Sonders, Cliff Asness, Mike Green and 40+ Others Share Their Most Important Lesson
- Many fund managers became closet indexers who hugged their benchmarks while charging active fees, because clients wanted consistently good performance without the career risk of underperforming.Lessons From the Founder of Morningstar
- Active managers fall on a bell curve with poor managers on the left, a large mushy middle of average managers charging active fees, and true outperformers on the right, and passive growth is compressing the middle, which deserves to be washed out.Lessons From the Founder of Morningstar
- Large fund managers like Fidelity have almost no chance of beating an index with their common stock investments, so they force employees to be closet indexers because being a streak outlier on the losing side can destroy an investment management business.A Conversation with Charlie Munger & John Collison - [Invest Like the Best, REPLAY]
- If tracking error and benchmark deviation are the primary concerns of active managers, they must know what bets the benchmark is making and then make different bets; those with low active share become 'closet indexers' earning index-like returns while charging active fees.Warren Buffett Published His Whole Playbook | Robert Hagstrom on Why Only One Tenth of 1% Uses It