Upside Down Markets
What this covers
Patrick interviews Jesse Livermore in a conversation that runs from the plumbing of money to the history of crashes. A good part of it separates what the Fed does from what fiscal authorities do. Asset purchases do expand the broad money supply, since the Fed creates deposits and reserves. Livermore argues they add little spending power, because the seller simply swaps an asset for cash with a nearly identical yield. He also says M2 alone cannot show what quantitative easing does, because private flows offset it at times.
The range then widens. On inflation, he makes the contested claim that equities are real assets, and that their historical weakness under inflation runs through the rate hikes it provokes, not through inflation itself. The real inflation risk, he says, is fiscal expansion past productive capacity, a limit only discovered after the fact. Yet a heavily indebted, unequal economy carries deflationary forces, so he thinks the US can run more fiscal support than many expect. He applies Hyman P. Minsky's logic to policymakers, who may push fiscal policy until inflation finally appears. On valuation, he notes that a 40 or 50 times earnings multiple means the buyer is counting on resale rather than payback.
The history sections stand out. In the COVID crisis the Fed lent directly to corporations through legislated facilities, which it could not do in 2008, because a pandemic is a risk banks cannot diversify. For 1929, he lists extreme starting conditions, a hesitant Fed, bank runs, and a moralized economy wary of rewarding speculators.
Livermore argues that under fiscal-dominant policy, bad economic news can be good for stocks (an 'upside-down market') because fiscal injections add unencumbered spending power and shift portfolios toward equities, so conventional monetary-policy reasoning misreads market direction.
- Monetary easing is weak at stimulating spending because borrowing adds debt, whereas fiscal transfers directly raise private-sector spending power
- Deficits inject income that supports corporate profits, and fiscal support lets firms capture productivity gains without demand loss
- Fiscal injections become savings held as cash or bonds, which are effectively equivalent at zero rates and push investors back toward equities
Near-high equities suggest the fiscal response was smart, and investors must keep updating views on fiscal policy.
- The host argues the stock market is one of the best barometers of what a smart system expects, and since equities are near highs, the fast and large fiscal response appears to have been a smart decision.
“using the stock market as a barometer, and it's one of the best barometers we have”
- Investors need to continuously update their views on changing conditions, and fiscal policy is now a key variable that will matter going forward, so the piece is best used as a toolkit for updating beliefs about how markets work.
“in markets you have to update your views. You have to update your views for changing conditions”