natural resource curse
The paradox that regions rich in a single valuable resource often develop poorly because that resource crowds out other economic activity; Glaeser uses it as an analogy for how Detroit's productive auto machines squeezed out other invention.
As defined in Edward Glaeser on Cities
Where it comes up · 3
- Paul Collier on the Bottom Billion 01/28/20084 claims
- Edward Glaeser on Cities1 claim
- Bruce Bueno de Mesquita on Democracies and Dictatorships 2/12/20071 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “natural resource curse” →
- Foreign aid has the same effect as the natural-resource curse because, like oil in the ground, it is money the leader can tap without raising taxes on labor — a 'free good' that sustains bad leaders in office and oppresses the public.Bruce Bueno de Mesquita on Democracies and Dictatorships 2/12/2007
- Having valuable natural resources such as oil, diamonds, or other high-value extractables should be an opportunity, but in practice it corrodes and corrupts politics, producing a dysfunctional polity in which leaders compete to control the public purse instead of providing public goods.Paul Collier on the Bottom Billion 01/28/2008
- Botswana used its diamond wealth relatively well, Norway thrives with oil, and the decisive difference is governance: good institutions established before the resource windfall lead to good outcomes, while resource revenues arriving before good institutions corrode governance and rarely allow it to improve.Paul Collier on the Bottom Billion 01/28/2008
- Dictatorships are a familiar problem in resource-rich countries, but democracies in very poor countries can also fail: resource revenues corrupt democracy so that electoral competition becomes a race to the bottom, with politicians buying votes through corruption, patronage, and violence rather than adopting good policies.Paul Collier on the Bottom Billion 01/28/2008
- Detroit's decline was seeded by its central innovation—the vast vertically-integrated factory—which is great for short-run productivity but bad for long-run reinvention, because such plants don't need or give to the city, can be relocated to lower-cost areas, and crowd out small entrepreneurs in favor of middle managers who can't pivot to new industries.Edward Glaeser on Cities
- Aid and natural resource revenues are analogous only in that both give governments income not raised through taxation of citizens; aid is purposively directed, comes with advice and conditions, while oil and diamonds simply bubble out of the ground, and the evidence suggests aid is more effective than resource revenues.Paul Collier on the Bottom Billion 01/28/2008