reality-based community
Rauch's term for the global professional network of truth-seekers (scientists, journalists, scholars) who check ideas empirically and interoperate across disciplines.
As defined in Jonathan Rauch on the Constitution of Knowledge
Where it comes up · 4
- Jonathan Rauch on the Constitution of Knowledge5 claims
- 350 - Sharing Reality2 claims
- Donald Trump and Elon Musk Broke The Media and We Have To Adjust (w/ Semafor's Ben Smith)2 claims
- 103 - American Fantasies1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “reality-based community” →
- The second foundational rule is 'no personal authority': no one gets to determine truth based on who they are (God's revelation, being dictator or president), so you must persuade others unlike you through empirical checks—replicable experiments and arguments that convince any reasonable person—creating a global, interoperable network of truth-seekers from many disciplines focused on one reality.Jonathan Rauch on the Constitution of Knowledge
- The reality-based community—the spheres that actually do the daily work of producing objective knowledge—consists of four domains: academia/science/research, mainstream reality-based media, law (which originated the concept of a 'fact' through adversarial courts before science did), and government, whose liberal institutions are shot through with fact-tethering rules; when government stops being fact-based it becomes tyrannical.350 - Sharing Reality
- There is only one reality-based community: a single unified system spanning all disciplines that points toward one reality, implying the unity of knowledge and the possibility of conciliation between disparate fields; truth is not a destination but a direction, like north on a compass—you never arrive, you only navigate.350 - Sharing Reality
- The COVID response demonstrates how the knowledge system spontaneously coordinates without central control: within weeks of a new virus's discovery in late 2019, hundreds of thousands of expert minds and thousands of institutions worldwide pivoted to the problem, sequenced the virus, designed a vaccine within days, and delivered it within a year.Jonathan Rauch on the Constitution of Knowledge
- No society can function without institutions that shape us as people; journalism's newsrooms inculcated norms of accuracy, double-sourcing, checking, and running corrections, and these unwritten professional norms—rather than just free speech—are what produce reliable knowledge.Jonathan Rauch on the Constitution of Knowledge
- The knowledge system works like a giant funnel of pumps and filters: free speech provides cheap, mostly-wrong raw input; most ideas are too screwball to be acquired; a small fraction are divided into refutable units, peer-reviewed, checked across many decentralized nodes, and a tiny precious fraction emerges as new knowledge—converting cheap information into expensive, durable knowledge while settling disputes peacefully.Jonathan Rauch on the Constitution of Knowledge
- The Constitution of Knowledge rests on four institutional branches—research (academia/science), journalism, law, and government—each fact-based, decentralized, and operating through rules and many institutions, with the concept of a 'fact' originating in law before science.Jonathan Rauch on the Constitution of Knowledge
- Media credibility is ultimately based on revealing true things that voters and citizens have to react to, not on media's self-perception of importance or power—this 'reality-based community' function is the actual power of journalism.Donald Trump and Elon Musk Broke The Media and We Have To Adjust (w/ Semafor's Ben Smith)
- Unlike past episodes of American unreason that gave way to cleansing corrective reactions, today's disruptive internet technology lets every tribe of the empirically untrue immerse itself permanently in its own version of reality, supported by a powerful telecommunications complex (Fox News, talk radio, the internet); this is not a left-right pendulum that will swing back but a 'toothpaste out of the tube' problem that makes a cyclical return to a shared, establishment-anchored reality much harder to imagine.103 - American Fantasies
- The power of journalism ultimately derives from revealing truths that citizens must react to, not from media's ability to set agenda or shape reality; the 'reality-based community' is grounded in revealing facts, and power comes from citizens' response to those facts when disclosed.Donald Trump and Elon Musk Broke The Media and We Have To Adjust (w/ Semafor's Ben Smith)