self-defense
The legal right of a nation to use force to protect itself against attack or threats; in international law, this right is qualified—it must be proportional, necessary, and cannot violate other international norms like the prohibition on targeting civilians; often used as a justification for conduct that may violate international humanitarian law.
As defined in Is Israel Committing Genocide in Gaza? | The Ezra Klein Show
Where it comes up · 1
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “self-defense” →
- Courts have adopted the principle that to infer genocidal intent from a pattern of conduct, the pattern must be such that it 'could only point to the existence of such intent'—meaning the only reasonable inference from the acts must be intent to destroy the group, not other motivations like self-defense.Is Israel Committing Genocide in Gaza? | The Ezra Klein Show
- In genocide trials across history, including Nazi Germany, perpetrators claim self-defense and argue that the targeted group posed a threat that justified destruction, which Sands identifies as a timeless argument.Is Israel Committing Genocide in Gaza? | The Ezra Klein Show
- Sands responds that even if Israel's self-defense arguments are true, under international law this kind of treatment is not justifiable, and that while Israel is entitled to use force in self-defense, 'the right to use force is not unlimited and it is constrained by the requirements of international law and it may not go beyond those requirements'Is Israel Committing Genocide in Gaza? | The Ezra Klein Show
- Netanyahu has effectively become the prosecutor of his own case—his published and broadcast genocidal rhetoric makes it easier for South Africa to prove genocidal intent even though his statements make Israel's legal position more difficult.Is Israel Committing Genocide in Gaza? | The Ezra Klein Show
- If a state's claim of self-defense can justify any level of destruction, then 'when you find yourself under attack in such conditions you need to say this is not permissible,' creating a reciprocal risk that others will later use the same justification against that state.Is Israel Committing Genocide in Gaza? | The Ezra Klein Show
- The Nazi governor of occupied Krakow once rejected a request to protect a Jewish child on grounds that laws concerning the threat posed by Jews meant 'we have no other way of proceeding than to apply the full force of the law to them in order to protect ourselves'—showing genocide is justified by perpetrators using self-defense arguments.Is Israel Committing Genocide in Gaza? | The Ezra Klein Show
- Klein initially opposed South Africa's genocide accusation as wrong because Israel had been attacked and self-defense was legitimate; but over time, as human rights organizations, Holocaust scholars, and genocide experts came to the same conclusion, his view evolved.Is Israel Committing Genocide in Gaza? | The Ezra Klein Show
- Israel will argue in its defense that it is acting in self-defense against an existential threat from Hamas, and that its intention is self-protection rather than the extermination of Palestinians as a group.Is Israel Committing Genocide in Gaza? | The Ezra Klein Show
- Sands is currently counsel for the Gambia in a genocide case against Myanmar alleging genocide against the Rohingya, which will come before the International Court of Justice before the Israel case, and this case faces the same legal issues as the Israel case about whether self-defense or national security justifications defeat genocide chargesIs Israel Committing Genocide in Gaza? | The Ezra Klein Show
- South Africa will argue that there is no military justification for the continued starvation, and therefore the only inference is intent to destroy the group. Israel will argue it is acting in self-defense against further attacks. The International Court of Justice judges will assess which interpretation of intent to apply.Is Israel Committing Genocide in Gaza? | The Ezra Klein Show