
How To Come Up With Good Ideas | Mark Rober | TEDxYouth@ColumbiaSC
What this covers
This is an 18-minute TEDxYouth talk by Mark Rober, a former NASA JPL engineer turned YouTuber and inventor. He answers the question people ask him most, "How do you come up with your ideas?", by treating it as a question about process rather than inspiration. He builds the answer from historical examples: the Library of Alexandria, which took books off ships to copy them and drew thinkers like Euclid and Archimedes, and Percy Spencer, who noticed a chocolate bar melting near a radar tube and, unlike others who had seen the same thing, acted on it. He also draws on his own projects, including the two-iPad "hole in the body" Halloween costume that went viral, the cheaper Digital Duds shirt it led to, and a thermal-imaging microwave he has patented.
The middle of the talk is about iteration. The Marshmallow Challenge, as described by Tom Wujec, has kindergarteners beating CEOs and lawyers because they place the marshmallow several times and test as they build, instead of planning and adding it at the end. Thomas Edison's 10,000 light bulbs, James Dyson's 5,127 failed prototypes, and the 40-plus discarded devices behind each Apple product support the same point. He also argues that kids are naturally the most creative people, and that schooling beats this out of them.
The talk turns contentious on luck. Rober uses hindsight bias to argue that success stories are retrofitted onto random outcomes. His example is 1,024 people flipping coins, where one will land ten tails and be studied for "technique." He adds that two CEOs praised in Good to Great, at Circuit City and Fannie Mae, later failed badly. He ties this to the Roman idea of genius) as an external presence, which separates ego from the work. Accepting luck, he argues, makes persistence easier. A shorter detour covers his roadside experiment with rubber snakes and turtles.
Creativity is a learnable skill developed through three systematic steps—curiosity (observation), hard work (iterative testing), and luck—not an innate gift, and anyone can become more creative by following this process.
- The Library of Alexandria succeeded through curiosity and observation, as did scientific breakthroughs like the microwave invention
- The Marshmallow Challenge shows kindergarteners outperform CEOs because they test early and often, not because of innate creativity
- Successful creators like Edison (10,000 prototypes) and Dyson (5,127 failed prototypes) succeeded through iteration, and luck compounds with more attempts
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Two CEOs profiled as exemplars of sustainable success in 'Good to Great' (Circuit City and Fannie Mae) subsequently failed dramatically, demonstrating that the book's success narratives were constructed through hindsight bias and luck, not timeless principles.
“it's funny even returning on that point with Good to Great, of the 10 companies, two of the CEOs she profiled were the CEOs for Circuit City and Fannie Mae uh cuz the book was written like 10 years ago, right? Which we know, right? Didn't work out so well.”
The Library of Alexandria succeeded because they forcefully boarded ships and took books to copy them, building an unparalleled knowledge database that attracted geniuses like Euclid and Archimedes and led to incredible advancements through sustained curiosity about the world.
“For step one, we're going to go to the ancient city of Alexandria, 300 BC. They did something interesting here. Whenever a ship would enter their port, they would board it forcefully, but the soldiers weren't looking for gold or spices, they wanted their books. They would take the books in the library and they would copy them. And as a result, they got this amazing knowledge, this database. It's like, you know, Wikipedia of 300 BC of just all these experiences of people across the world and we had people like Euclid and Archimedes who studied there and they had incredible advancements because of this approach. They were really curious about the world around them, they observed it and they tried to solve these the you know, these problems.”
Percy Spencer invented the microwave by observing that a chocolate bar melted in his pocket while working near a radar tube, demonstrating that accidental observations combined with curiosity-driven investigation lead to major innovations.
“A great example of this is the microwave oven. Um this was first invented by a guy named Percy Spencer and he was working on a radar tube. He had a Mr. Goodbar in his pocket and all of a sudden the thing melted, which seems incredibly dangerous now that we know about microwaves, but he saw this thing melt and he's like, 'Well, that's weird. Like that's funny.' He had that one of those that's funny moments. And so he observed that and went back and did some research and figured out what was going on and from that we got the microwave.”
The Marshmallow Challenge demonstrates that kindergarteners consistently outperform CEOs, lawyers, and businessmen at building stable structures because they test early and often (placing the marshmallow 4-5 times) rather than adding it at the end, showing iteration beats planning.
“This guy named um Tom Wujec does this. He's done it over like 70 times and what he does is he gives people a challenge. He gives them some spaghetti, some tape and some string and a marshmallow and he says in 18 minutes, why don't you build the tallest tower you can with the marshmallow on top. And the fascinating thing about this, he's done it a bunch of times and there's one group that consistently beats CEOs, uh lawyers and businessmen. And that group is kindergarteners. Seriously. And the reason why, he explains, is because, you know, the adults look at the situation and first of all, the first 3 minutes is like a power struggle, who's going to be the leader, right? And then once they sort of figure that out, they start building something, but they don't actually put the marshmallow on until the very end at like minute 17 and marshmallows are deceptively heavy. And so then the whole structure buckles and now they have nothing with like a minute left. Uh whereas kindergarteners, by contrast, they just start building right away. There's no power struggle, right? And kindergarteners, instead of just putting marshmallow on once, on average, they put it on four to five times. So about 4 minutes into it, they're already putting the marshmallow on top and sort of testing it. And so because of that, because they're sort of testing early and often, they're able to get to a solution that actually works”
Percy Spencer was the first person to act on the observation that a chocolate bar melts near a radar tube, whereas others had experienced the same phenomenon but didn't investigate, showing that curiosity plus action—not mere observation—separates inventors from passive observers.
“it's interesting to note that the guy who invented the the the the microwave, you know, other people had actually had the the chocolate bar melt in their pocket, but he was the first person to actually do something about it and actually have that like kindergarteners approach of curiosity and trying to figure out what was going on there.”
The Romans believed genius was a troll living in your walls that sprinkled creative dust on your work at night, and this framing is valuable because it removes ego from the creative process—if your work is good, it's your good genius, and if it's bad, it's your bad genius, not a personal failure.
“Back in people have noted this, but with the Romans, we actually get the word genius from them. But to them, what a genius was was like a troll that lived in your walls. And at night, when you like had your piece of art you were working on, it would come out and like sprinkle like creative dust on your work of art. And this had an interesting impact because if you were really good, you were kind of humble about it cuz you're like, 'Well, I just got a really good genius, you know, that lives in my wall.' But if your work was kind of sucked, then, you know, it's like, 'Well, what can you do? My genius is kind of lame, right?'”
Apple's design philosophy succeeds because it maintains the mindset 'the difficulty lies not so much in developing new ideas as escaping from old ones,' allowing designers to step back and see entirely different solutions rather than optimizing within existing constraints.
“The difficulty lies not so much in developing new ideas as escaping from old ones. And a lot of times, you know, you picture it almost like there's a hill and everyone's trying to optimize and get to the top of this hill and Apple sometimes can step back and just be like, 'Oh, there's another hill over here that's really big, right?' And so the hallmark of good design is when people can look at it and be like, 'Wow, like how did how did nobody think of that before?' When the design in hindsight seems really obvious.”
Creativity is not about luck alone, but rather a combination of observation (curiosity), hard work (iterative testing), and luck (accepting forces outside your control), and understanding this process shows most people are far more creative than they give themselves credit for.
“I'm not saying, don't misinterpret it that being creative is just it's all luck. But my point is is as you are creative and you observe and you, you know, question your world, as you work hard and you you build early and often, you increase your chances of getting lucky.”
Accepting the role of luck in creativity enables persistence; if Thomas Edison had recognized after 9,999 failed light bulbs that the 10,000th might also fail, he might have given up—but trusting the process increases your odds, like giving yourself more coin flips to land 10 tails in a row.
“Because then if you're Thomas Edison and you've built 9,999, you know, light bulbs, you don't say I give up cuz you realize you just need to trust the process. If you're James Dyson, you built 5,000 vacuums, it's like trust the process and keep going. And I'm not saying, don't misinterpret it that being creative is just it's all luck. But my point is is as you are creative and you observe and you, you know, question your world, as you work hard and you you build early and often, you increase your chances of getting lucky. You're basically giving yourself more quarters to flip so you can get 10 tails in a row.”
Kids are naturally the most creative group of people because they maintain a curiosity-driven, questioning approach to the world; this capacity gets 'beaten out of us' through the school system, and the most creative adults are those who maintain this kid-like approach.
“if you think about the most like creative group of people on Earth, I think it's probably kids. Like my son could take a bucket and just play with it for like 3 hours. And that's amazing with kids is because they're always questioning and looking and observing and making connections about the world around them. I think that sort of gets beat out of us like in the school system somehow. And by the time we're your guys' age, a lot of people are like, 'Oh, I'm just not creative, right?' That's not what you said when you were in kindergarten.”
Behind every successful Apple design, there are 40+ prototype devices that never reach market, and prolific innovators like Thomas Edison (10,000 light bulbs before success) and James Dyson (5,127 failed prototypes) demonstrate that iteration is the path to breakthrough.
“And for every like design you see from Apple, right? Behind the scenes, there's like 40 devices, prototypes that you never seen. Thomas Edison said he came up with, you know, 10,000 light bulbs before he found one that worked. Um uh James Dyson, the inventor of like the cyclone thing, said he had 500 uh 5,127 failed prototypes before he had a mic you know, a vacuum that actually sucked. Like sucked like in the sense that like it sucked. It was good, right?”
Creativity is a learnable skill like a muscle you develop, not an innate gift bestowed from birth that you either have or don't have.
“there's this myth and I like it because it tackles this myth head-on that, you know, people are either creative or you're not. Like it's some gift bestowed from on high. Either you have good ideas or you don't. And that's not true. In my opinion, curiosity or creativity is sort of like a muscle you develop.”
Hindsight bias causes humans to construct false causal narratives around random events after they occur; if 1,024 people flip a coin 10 times, statistically one will get 10 tails, and media will then analyze that person's 'technique' despite the outcome being purely random.
“There's a there's a fancy term called hindsight bias, which is when we look back at points that are actually random, we try to connect them and create a narrative. Um as an example, like if there was 1,024 of us in this room and I gave each one of you a quarter, I said flip that 10 times. Statistically, one of you would get 10 tails in a row. And what happens usually is the media swoops in and then, you know, it's like, 'Oh, let's look at Kevin. Like, you know, he got 10 tails in a row. Look at his flip technique, you know, and his fingers and the way his wrist was and how his elbow and his posture.' Um like that's what we do.”
Most people believe they are 'just not creative,' but this is often false; the speaker believes most people are far more creative than they give themselves credit for, and understanding the three-step process is key to unlocking that latent creativity.
“So, my punchline today is that I believe we are all more like way more creative than we give ourselves credit for. It's just about understanding the process.”
Most successful companies experience luck as a significant factor in their success—CEOs in 'Good to Great' interviews acknowledged that luck played a major role alongside skill, yet humans use hindsight bias to construct false narratives of causation around random events.
“There's an interesting book called Good to Great and this author interviewed a bunch of CEOs and 10 of them of like supposedly these companies that will never fail, awesome ones. And she tried to find or he tried to find the common like thread, thing that connected all of them. And what I appreciated is all 10 of them mentioned that, you know, a lot of what happened they just got a couple lucky breaks. Like they got some they got lucky. Getting Certainly there was some skill involved, but a lot of it had to do with luck.”
People who ask 'How do you come up with your ideas?' are fundamentally asking 'How can I come up with more good ideas?' or 'How do I be more creative?'—this reframes the question as being about process rather than inspiration.
“So going back full circle, how do you come up with your ideas? Um I think what people are really asking when they ask this is, 'How can I come up with more good ideas?' Like, 'How do I be more creative?'”
The first step to developing creativity is curiosity—observing the world around you and asking 'Why is it that way?' rather than accepting things as given, which is the foundation of the scientific method.
“The most exciting phrase to hear in science, the one that heralds new discoveries, is not Eureka, but that's funny. And and the key to all good inventions, if you think about it, even the scientific method, the first step is observation. It starts with observing the world around you.”
The speaker's Halloween costume featuring iPads on front and back to create a 'hole through the body' visual effect went viral with 3 million views overnight and appeared on the front page of CNN, demonstrating the power of novel visual ideas.
“3 and 1/2 years ago this was my Halloween costume and I had an iPad on the front and back and if you do a FaceTime chat, it looks like you have a hole in your body. Um which is cool, right? Um So as we kind of had this like uh so basically put that video out um it went sort of viral, 3 million views overnight, front page of CNN.”
The speaker designed a thermal-imaging microwave by recognizing that humans rely primarily on sight, so adding infrared heat mapping to show when food is done solves a 40-year stagnation in microwave design, and he obtained a patent and is commercializing this with major retailers.
“I was cooking a frozen burrito in my kitchen and I'm like, 'Microwaves have not changed, it felt like, for 40 years.' I'm like like, 'What could we do differently?' As humans rely primarily on our sense of sight and so I figured since infrared my infrared lenses are pretty cheap now, it'd be awesome if you could put your burrito in the microwave and you could see it cooking, right? So you get a heat map on the front of the microwave, you could visually tell when it was done. But it gets better cuz you could like put your bowl of soup in the microwave and then you could like go upstairs and be working and then after like add 30 seconds. Um So it's like a different approach, right? And this one actually has a happy ending because I got a patent on this and I'm working with like a couple of the big guys to get it into a Walmart near you.”
The speaker's experience producing the iPad costume video made him realize he enjoyed 'putting something out there and having people see it and getting that feedback' and feeling his creative efforts were appreciated, which motivated him to commit to creating one YouTube video per month.
“the thing that I learned basically from this experience is that I liked this feeling of putting something out there and having people see it and sort of getting that feedback and making it feel like, you know, your creative efforts were appreciated. So I decided every month I would try and put out a YouTube video about a creative idea.”
Creativity is partly determined by luck, and the speaker conducted an experiment placing rubber snakes and turtles by roadsides to observe driver behavior, expecting snakes to be safer but finding drivers actually swerve more to hit snakes while some drivers try to avoid turtles—illustrating unpredictability in human behavior.
“I remember reading as a kid that if, you know, people will swerve more on the road to hit turtles than they would snakes, which always seemed interesting to me. So, I actually ran an experiment. So, I had the curiosity and I went out and I placed by the side of the road um alternating like snakes and turtles, right? Um and then I collected data in a lab coat so it looked official. Um and it turns out my hypothesis was wrong. So, like actually uh people did swerve to hit snakes more than turtles”
The main complaint about the iPad Halloween costume was cost—'I don't have $1,200 for a Halloween costume'—which prompted the speaker to develop Digital Duds, a cheaper alternative using a $20 shirt and a free app with a video played through it.
“The main complaint though was like, 'Cool idea, bro, but I don't have $1,200 for Halloween costume.' So basically my challenge was to come up with like a cooler Halloween costume that wasn't quite as expensive, right? And so while working my day job as a NASA engineer on the Curiosity rover, that was like 3 months before we sent it to Mars, um at night I was working on uh this this this concept, right? And so I called the company Digital Duds and so this is kind of how it works. So you play a video on your phone and you slide it into like a shirt and it's a really cheap Yeah, sorry, it's kind of big. Uh it's really inexpensive implementation of this concept, right? You buy $20 shirt and it's a free app.”
The speaker's YouTube channel has accumulated 42 million views and 190,000 subscribers by publishing one creative idea per month, demonstrating the scalability of a consistent creative practice.
“I decided every month I would try and put out a YouTube video about a creative idea. Um and so we started YouTube channel and now it has like uh it's way more than we first thought. I think it's like 42 million views on the site and like 190,000 subscribers, which is super cool. Certainly no PewDiePie, um but it's but it's an exciting opportunity.”
Using the front-facing camera of a smartphone at a zoo pointed at monkeys results in fascinating footage as monkeys become interested in the camera, and the speaker tested this observation on 'higher-order primates' as well.
“Finally this idea, if you use the front-facing camera on your phone and then take it to the zoo and put it like in front of the monkey exhibit. The monkeys see it and they're really interested, so you get this really cool footage with this is a dumb phone, right? Um and before you get all smug and laugh at the monkeys, I actually repeated this experiment on higher-order primates as well.”
A GoPro mounted upside down on a spinning ceiling fan creates a 'ghetto bullet time' effect similar to the Matrix, demonstrating a cheap, creative way to achieve high-end visual effects.
“So this is like you put a GoPro on a ceiling fan upside down. It's like ghetto bullet time from like the Matrix, right? So this is just a GoPro that's spinning around and you play the footage back, it has this really cool-looking effect.”
An infrared thermal camera mounted on an iPhone can reveal thermal signatures left behind on keypads by human touch, revealing which keys were pressed, and the simple solution is to rub your hand across all keys when done to obscure the thermal signature.
“Or this is if you put the FLIR, like an infrared, on on the front of an iPhone, I'm actually stealing this woman's pin here because I figured out that certain keypads, if you touch the keypad, it leaves behind a thermal signature, so you could see where they touched, right? And so I put this video out saying like, 'Dude, bad guys can use this. Simple solution is just rub your hand across all the keys when you're done and then it leaves like a meaningless thermal signature.'”
Using a coat hanger and a drill on a watermelon creates a 'no mess watermelon smoothie' that is refreshing and 'slightly creepy,' representing a creative repurposing of common tools.
“Um another idea uh is uh uh no mess watermelon smoothie, right? So you just get a coat hanger and a drill. Uh it's really refreshing and slightly creepy. I just stumbled upon that one.”