hindsight bias
The cognitive tendency to over-estimate, after an event, how predictable or obvious that outcome was beforehand.
As defined in Bruce Schneier on Power, the Internet, and Security
Other definitions
The retrospective sense that past events were more predictable than they actually were before they happened.
Nassim Nicholas Taleb on Black SwansThe tendency to view past outcomes as predictable, overestimating what one could have known at the time.
Building a Modern Business
Where it comes up · 6
- How To Come Up With Good Ideas | Mark Rober | TEDxYouth@ColumbiaSC3 claims
- Philip Tetlock on Superforecasting2 claims
- 102 | Maria Konnikova on Poker, Psychology, and Reason2 claims
- #22 How To Turn Down A Billion Dollars: The Snapchat Story1 claim
- Bruce Schneier on Power, the Internet, and Security1 claim
- Nassim Nicholas Taleb on Black Swans1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 10Search all claims for “hindsight bias” →
- Two CEOs profiled as exemplars of sustainable success in 'Good to Great' (Circuit City and Fannie Mae) subsequently failed dramatically, demonstrating that the book's success narratives were constructed through hindsight bias and luck, not timeless principles.How To Come Up With Good Ideas | Mark Rober | TEDxYouth@ColumbiaSC
- The 'connect the dots' complaint after attacks is a flawed metaphor: in a connect-the-dots picture the dots are numbered and yield a duck, but real intelligence means sifting a million unnumbered pieces of information not knowing if any mean anything—it is finding a needle in a haystack, and hindsight bias makes us over-estimate how obvious the signal was after the fact.Bruce Schneier on Power, the Internet, and Security
- Experts exist in an 'outcome-irrelevant learning situation'—no matter what actually happened with the Soviet Union, people could always interpret the outcome as consistent with their prior worldview, appropriating credit or deflecting blame, so they never updated their views.Philip Tetlock on Superforecasting
- The narrative fallacy is our susceptibility to constructing ex-post stories and hindsight explanations because we are suckers for stories, which leads us to retrospectively impose coherent causes on events after the fact.Nassim Nicholas Taleb on Black Swans
- Successful risk-takers (people and companies) who happen to win then write books explaining their success with hindsight bias, and others imitate them while ignoring all the people and companies that did the same things and failed—selecting on the dependent variable—because we crave a narrative and certainty that, once success exists, are easy to retroactively supply.102 | Maria Konnikova on Poker, Psychology, and Reason
- To protect against hindsight bias, you should record your reasoning in the moment ('I'm raising here because X, Y, Z') so you can later check whether you made a decision for the right reasons; this forces reflective rather than reflexive decision-making and prevents you from rewriting history to claim you 'knew' an outcome after the fact.102 | Maria Konnikova on Poker, Psychology, and Reason
- The Stanford VCs who dismissed Spiegel's 2011 disappearing-photo pitch likely passed on a billion-dollar return, but such ideas look inevitable only with hindsight, when the Facebook-driven conditions that enabled Snapchat are visible.#22 How To Turn Down A Billion Dollars: The Snapchat Story
- People systematically misremember their prior probability estimates, pumping them up retrospectively—experts who assigned low probabilities to the Soviet Union's dissolution later recalled assigning higher than 50%—an effect psychologists call hindsight bias, which persists even when you know the other person knows the true prior.Philip Tetlock on Superforecasting
- Hindsight bias causes humans to construct false causal narratives around random events after they occur; if 1,024 people flip a coin 10 times, statistically one will get 10 tails, and media will then analyze that person's 'technique' despite the outcome being purely random.How To Come Up With Good Ideas | Mark Rober | TEDxYouth@ColumbiaSC
- Most successful companies experience luck as a significant factor in their success—CEOs in 'Good to Great' interviews acknowledged that luck played a major role alongside skill, yet humans use hindsight bias to construct false narratives of causation around random events.How To Come Up With Good Ideas | Mark Rober | TEDxYouth@ColumbiaSC