What this covers

This is a university lecture, with a few student interjections, that continues a survey of Aristotle's metaphysics. The professor opens by defining metaphysics as the science of the most general principles of being, as opposed to the particular sciences that study particular kinds of things. He then works toward Book 12 of the Metaphysics, where Aristotle summarizes his account of reality before arguing for God, since a case for God has to proceed from knowledge of other things. Along the way the lecture sets out the law of non-contradiction, the distinction between essential and accidental properties (rationality for humans, blue eyes as an accident), and the four causes.

The middle of the lecture is the contrast with Plato. Particulars are primary substances, while forms are secondary substances that exist only in composition with matter, so form is drawn out of matter's potential rather than living in a separate realm. The professor ties this to a hierarchy of being running from rocks and prime matter, through vegetative and animal life, to rational humans. He also claims, in a contested aside, that this split divides Augustinian and Franciscan theology from the tradition of Thomas Aquinas and the Dominicans and Jesuits. A student raises Justice itself and Beauty itself, and the professor applies the contrast to the philosophy of art and of religion, where a view of what is real shapes what counts as knowing it.

The last stretch turns to cosmology. Aristotle needs a cause for the endless circular locomotion of the fixed stars, and he finds it in The Unmoved Mover beyond the cosmos, a being with no unactualized potential. The professor stresses that it works as a final cause rather than an efficient cause: the stars are moved by wonder and the wish to be like it. He notes that the Greeks lacked creation from nothing, so they needed no maker, only something to sustain the cosmos. He treats medieval angels riding the stars as an attempt to solve the problem of how a mind moves a body. God is also the one exception to the rule that forms never exist apart from matter.

Sharpest takeaway

Aristotle's metaphysics establishes being as fundamentally rational and comprehensible through the categories of substance, essence, and laws of thought, which ground his argument for God as an unmoved mover—a final cause that maintains eternal cosmic motion through the aspiration of all things to become like it.

  • The law of non-contradiction and rational structure of reality make being knowable to rational minds
  • Primary substances (particulars) are the fundamental realities, distinguished from secondary substances (forms) which only exist in composition with matter
  • God as unmoved mover explains eternal celestial motion through final causality rather than efficient causality, maintaining the cosmos as a cosmic magnet or upward gravitation

The claims · ranked26 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.80

God is not a body and is not subject to mind-body problems like the stars; the medieval scholars' talk of angels riding the stars was an attempt to address this conceptual problem, but Aristotle's actual meaning is that God must be final cause rather than efficient cause.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Professor of Philosophy

“you know when he says the fixed stars are their souls are moved what does he mean you know this is what incited some of the medievals to talk of angels riding the Stars uh doesn't he have a Mind Body problem in the stars that sort of thing all right well maybe this has a myth ological cast the way it's said but what he's trying to say is that God has to be final cause you see final cause in a sense he doesn't need an efficient cause”

0.75

For Aristotle, the distinction between particulars as primary substances and forms as secondary substances is not merely academic but theologically revolutionary—the Platonic tradition informed Augustinian and Franciscan theology, while the Aristotelian tradition informed Thomas Aquinas and Dominican and Jesuit theology, and this distinction persists to the present day.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Professor of Philosophy

“you can say that Aristotle is more down to earth right he's more of a physical realist Plato is more the idealist Aristotle is more the realist yeah and that terminology is used um some interpreters of Plato discarding his conception of God have said well Aristotle is is really a philosophical naturalist just talking about natural things particulars but um as these two Traditions the platonic and the Aristotelian are gradually transmitted onto the Middle Ages um you'll find that the theological ramifications that flow from these two alternatives are rather significant the platonic tradition informs the augustinian and Franciscan Traditions whereas the Aristotelian informs Thomas aquinus and also the Dominican tradition the Jesuits very significant and that incidentally is True to this day”

0.74

Since the Greeks did not have a conception of creation ex nihilo, they did not need an efficient cause to bring the world into being; they only needed a means to maintain and keep eternal forms and matter in their eternal existence.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Professor of Philosophy

“if form and matter are both Eternal none of the Greeks had a creation xneo all they needed was a means whereby the thing could be maintained see it's as if there is a cosmic magnet magnetism going on an upward gravitation you”

0.74

If reality is rational and we are rational, then our rationality provides us with an entree to reality—correct thinking gives us access to being itself.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Professor of Philosophy

“notice there's a correlation between the way in which the Mind functions thinks and the way in which reality is you see um if reality is rational and we are rational then our rationality provides us with an entree to reality get it if reality is rational and we are rational then our rationality gives us an entree to reality”

0.74

Aristotle understands Plato's conception of Justice itself and Beauty itself as transcendent forms that exist apart from material particulars, whereas Aristotle's own approach is grounded in embodied particulars and requires psychological understanding to fully address ethical questions about universal concepts.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Student

“I wonder how Aristotle would answer Plato's concepts of Justice or beauty or something it seems that from Plato's perspective that Aristotle is caught in a Cav yeah I wonder if we could hold on that question the question is how would Aristotle speak of things like justice and Beauty from PLO standpoint it seems as if Aristotle is staying around in the cave you say what is Justice itself ideally Beauty itself ideally let's hold on that could we until we get to his ethics because I think we need in addition to this aspect of metaphysic you you you have to get in something further about human psychology into the picture in order to answer that ethical question”

0.72

The unmoved mover is not an efficient cause that exerts power or force; rather, it is the final cause—the good for the sake of which everything else goes on—and the stars are moved by wonder and amazement to want to be like the unmoved mover.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Professor of Philosophy

“it is the good yes see and The Souls of the stars are moved by one to be like the unmoved Mover that is to say the unve Mover is not an efficient cause it's the final cause of the whole works that for the sake of which everything else goes on the Stars moved in wonderment amazement to want to be like you think says Aristotle in another place philosophy begins with Wonder that's what moves us to inquire philosophically because we we are moved by Wonder at truth and goodness Beauty you see and philosophy culminates in Wonder as we'll see the idea of the good but the whole Cosmos is moved by Wonder to try to be like the unmoved Mover Everlasting locomotion”

0.68

Metaphysics is the science of all sciences and deals with the most general principles of being—being qua being in general—rather than particular kinds of beings as dealt with by particular sciences.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Professor of Philosophy

“metaphysics is the science of all Sciences the most general principles therefore his development of his own theory of forms in response to what he sees as inadequacies in plos”

0.68

God is a grand exception to the rule that forms never exist as separate independent entities; in God, particular forms never change, resolving the problem of eternal unchanging forms in Aristotle's metaphysics.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Professor of Philosophy

“you're anticipating what comes in a very short while namely one grand exception to the rule that you never find forms as separate entities okay and it's by virtue of that in God that particular forms never change”

0.68

Beyond the perimeter of the universe exists an unmoved mover: an eternal, unchanging being that is totally unchanging and has no unactualized potential or capacity.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“out beyond the per of the universe he thinks of another being that is an unmoved mover and again Eternal the fixed Stars may be moved Eternal movers but there must be an unmoved totally unchanging mover an unmoved mover ah but you say how can the unmoved Mover move the fixed Stars except by exerting Force Power like an efficient cause which is a process of change in the unmoved Mover the unmoved Mover is not an efficient cause does not exert power does not exert a thing just is being pure fully actualized no un actualized potential capacity at all”

0.66

In philosophy of religion, the metaphysical question 'what is the reality with which religion is concerned?' is answered as 'God', which determines the epistemological question: 'what kind of knowing is involved in knowing about God or knowing God?'

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Professor of Philosophy

“seems true in philosophy of religion uh what is the reality with which religion is concerned God so then religious epistemology has to do with the kind of knowing that's involved in knowing about God or knowing god do you follow”

0.66

Eternal things which are not generable but are movable in space have matter—not matter for generation but for motion, indicating that matter is not exclusively the principle of change in generation and corruption but also enables spatial motion.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Professor of Philosophy

“notice at the end of that paragraph all things that change have matter of eternal things those which are not generable but are movable in space oh he's back to that Eternal physical thing you see that Eternal thing it's not generable it's Eternal but it's movable in space has matter okay not matter for Generation but for motion yeah so he's including that in his thinking”

0.66

In Book 12 of the Metaphysics, Aristotle begins with a summary of his metaphysics as the foundation for arguing for the existence of God, because in order to argue for God's existence one must argue from knowledge of other realities.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Professor of Philosophy

“in book 12 now as you start reading book 12 you're likely to say to yourself this isn't about God it's about metaphysics again sure for the reason I've just indicated you see if you want an argument for the existence of God you have to argue from your knowledge of other realities so what other the realities and so he needs another summary statement of his metaphysics as a starting point for his argument”

0.66

The final cause (telos) of a growing thing is identified by the potential inherent in its form; for a human infant, the form gives it the potential to become a well-developed, fully-functioning adult, and the ideal is not to become a disembodied adult (as Plato might imagine) but rather a fully incarnate, fully-functioning physical adult.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Professor of Philosophy

“the form which um gives the particular its nature also gives it its potential okay so in the case for instance of an infant the body is growing the matter expanding the form of that infant you see the form of that infant gives it potential for becoming a human adult so the Telos then is um identified by the potential of the form get it so that the final cause is to become a well what you might call a flourishing adult but depends um the ideal is not to become a disembodied adult you see um it is for Plato it's not for Aristotle the ideal is to become a full grown fully functioning adult”

0.61

In philosophy of art, if art is understood as Plato did—imitation of forms—then the knowledge required to be a good artist is knowledge of forms, but if art is understood as self-expression and self-understanding, then it involves a different kind of reality and knowing.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Professor of Philosophy

“if you think as Plato did of Art's imitation you see art is imitation ideally imitation of forms then the kind of knowledge you need to be a good artist is knowledge of forms underlying epistemology if art is not about um forms but is rather a kind of self-expression um seeking a self- understanding through self-expression then obviously you've got a different kind of reality and a different kind of knowing that's involved that accounts for that kind of art”

0.60

The fundamental problem Aristotle must solve is how to explain the everlasting locomotion of the fixed stars, given that all change and motion require a cause.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Professor of Philosophy

“Now The $64,000 Question how do you explain that Everlasting Locomotion of the fixed Stars that's all there is to the cosmos all right Everlasting Locomotion must have an unchanging cause you couldn't get Everlasting Locomotion unless there were a cause that is unchanging in every regard”

0.60

In Aristotle's philosophy, particulars are primary substances—individual things like this marker, this desk, this hand, or a person—which can exist as separate entities, whereas secondary substances (forms or essences) only exist in composition with matter.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Professor of Philosophy

“in one sense it is particulars that are substances particulars or parts of or contents of particulars that are substances so this um marker is a substance this desk is a substance this hand is a substance I'm a substance”

0.60

Aristotle distinguishes four kinds of causal factors that must be appealed to in explaining what anything is and any kind of change: efficient cause, material cause, formal cause, and final cause.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Professor of Philosophy

“his distinction of four kinds of causal factors that have to be uh appealed to in explaining what anything is and explaining any kind of change uh the four kinds of cause being efficient cause material cause formal cause final cause you ought to know those till they just come out in your dreams and you're talking about them in your sleep”

0.60

The law of non-contradiction states that a being cannot both be and not be something at the same time and in the same respect; equivalently, one cannot both affirm and deny something at the same time and in the same respect, symbolized as 'A is not non-A'.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Professor of Philosophy

“the law of noncontradiction that a being cannot both be and not be something at the same time and in the same respect and by that same token you cannot both affirm and deny something at the same time and in the same respect and we um symbolize that law of non-contradiction typically by simply saying that a is not non a a is not non a it cannot both be and not be it cannot be this and not be this at the same time and in the same respect”

0.60

The essential property of a human being is rationality (the capacity for rational thought), whereas accidental properties like having blue eyes are not essential to the nature of what it is to be human.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Professor of Philosophy

“an essential property of a human being is rationality that capacity at least an accidental prop property that isn't essential to the nature of human beings is that I have blue eyes at least so I'm told now that's that's accidental in the sense that it's not essential to the nature of a human being”

0.60

The motion of planets orbiting the Earth is an endless locomotion through space that does not stop; linear motion stops at the end of a line, and motion along the sides of a square or rectangle stops momentarily at corners, but circular motion does not require stopping at any point.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Professor of Philosophy

“notice the key to the argument is the fourth kind of change locomotion notice that the motion of the planets as they orbit is an endless Locomotion they don't stop you see linear Locomotion along a straight line from A to B stops at the end of the line rectal linear Locomotion from a back to a by the four sides of a square or a rectangle stops momentarily at the corners yeah he talks about different kinds of locomotion but there is a third kind of locomotion which does not stop circular Locomotion don't have to stop at Corners no stop signs yes endless Locomotion”

0.60

Inanimate objects (like rocks) are at the bottom of the hierarchy, describable only in terms of elemental matter with a particular spatial form (like granite), with bare, hypothetical matter (prime matter) as the ultimate substrate.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“inanimate objects obvious L down here so that if you're talking of a a rock you'll say you'd have to talk there of Elemental matter with this particular uh what um thre spatial form that it has but it do or having the form of granite or something of that sort”

0.60

In Aristotle's hierarchy of being, vegetative life has functions of nutrition and reproduction; animal life adds sensation and locomotion; and human life adds rational functions, so that humans possess all the capacities of lower forms of life plus rationality.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Professor of Philosophy

“vegetable life vegetative life has functions of nutrition and reproduction okay animal life has functions of sensation and locomotion uh but in addition to um that human beings have functions of uh rationality rational functions so humans have rational functions plus sensation and Locomotion and nutrition and reproduction other animals have sensation Locomotion nutrition and reproduction vegetative things have only nutrition and reproduction”

0.60

Forms do not exist in any independent realm separate from matter; rather, form is drawn out of the potential of the matter itself in the process of change.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Philosophy Professor

“they don't exist um in any independent realm um there is no world of forms separate from matter um where does the form come from well it seems as if it's drawn out of the potential of the matter itself”

0.57

The orbiting planets produce changes in the Earth's atmosphere, and these atmospheric changes produce the changes on the surface of the Earth—a causal chain from celestial to terrestrial phenomena.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Professor of Philosophy

“it's the orbiting planets which produce changes in the Earth's atmosphere which produce the changes on the surface of the Earth don't you know oh yeah that's what lay behind the astrology and the so forth of those days”

0.50

At the outer perimeter of the universe are fixed stars (approximately 50 of them by Aristotle's count, though some ancients debated this), which are not rotating around the Earth but spinning on their own axes in everlasting circular locomotion.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Philosophy Professor

“on the Outer Perimeter of the universe are fixed stars um 50 odd of them as he counts them though there was some contention among the Ancients as to whether that's the exact number or more uh these fixed stars are not rotating around the Earth but are spinning on their own axes spinning in Everlasting circular Locomotion they are Everlasting physical bodies everlastingly moving by their own nature and Locomotion”

0.29

Among ancient philosophers, discussions of Zeno's paradoxes concerning motion showed that some thinkers attempted to work with concepts of intermediate alternatives, but Aristotle's law of excluded middle rules out such third alternatives.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Professor of Philosophy

“there's some subtlety in the third one that um is that what Aris was talking about when he was going on about about how like xenos paradoxes and such how people try there's something in the middle”