
Ruchir Sharma — What Went Wrong with Capitalism? | Prof G Conversations
What this covers
This is a 28-minute conversation in which Scott Galloway interviews Ruchir Sharma, an emerging-markets investor, about his book on capitalism. The first half stays mostly on the US. Sharma treats the 20% share of zombie companies as the sign of lost economic churn, defining them as firms that fail to cover interest payments for three straight years yet keep refinancing. He also takes up the productivity paradox. In his account the slowdown predates the 2010s and was interrupted only by the internet boom of the late 1990s. That boom, he says, shows mismeasurement cannot explain the decline. Demographics get partial credit for the slowdown, and the number of US startups had been falling for two to three decades before the pandemic.
The argument gets more contentious on regulation, tax, and deficits. Sharma says regulation favors incumbents, that Big Tech now dominates new lobbying spending, and that finance was deregulated while Main Street industries were not. He rejects the idea that low corporate tax rates drive reinvestment, pointing to Europe. On deficits he expects no imminent crisis, but he warns that reserve-currency complacency lets policymakers avoid discipline. He also argues that a recession at a 6% deficit would push it to 9-10%.
The second half moves abroad. Sharma is optimistic about India, noting its shift from the socialism of his birth era and its democratic resilience, though he cautions that its unevenness makes forecasts hard. He calls China's secular decline structural, citing shrinking population and exhausted debt capacity, and limits its growth to 2-3%. He praises Greece for reforming under crisis, and he argues that crisis is generally what unlocks reform. The immigration discussion concludes that it helps the economy but is too politically toxic for the economics to prevail. He also says the US and Australia have assimilated immigrants better than France. Finally, he suggests America's tech and AI sector cushions it against policy errors that would hurt peers.
Sharma argues that excessive government intervention in capitalism—through spending, regulation, and bailouts—has destroyed creative destruction, undermining productivity growth and creating zombie firms that prevent economic dynamism; the system must return to disciplined capitalism with real consequences for failure.
- Government spending has grown from 3% to 36% of GDP, with regulation increasing 3,000 rules annually, raising barriers for startups while protecting incumbents
- Creative destruction is broken because zombie companies (20% of firms) refinance despite unprofitability, crowding out productive firms and depressing productivity
- Productivity growth has declined for decades despite tech innovation because state intervention prevents the churn necessary for economic health
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
India is a heterogeneous, complex country unlike homogeneous China, and therefore its development is uneven across regions, making simple growth predictions difficult despite a generally positive long-term trajectory.
“this is a pretty complex country it's not a homogeneous country like China which Moves In One Direction it's very heterogeneous very diverse so you got different things and different You Know Places which play itself out”
Crisis is the only catalyst that forces governments to reform or change fundamentally entrenched systems; the silver lining of crises is that they remove political constraints on reform that otherwise persist.
“it is one uh Silver Lining of a crisis it said it's the only time when governments reform or change things is when you a crisis so Greece runs out of money it's on the verge of default and then you end up getting a lot of Reform”
No country in the world can grow rapidly (or even grow) when facing negative population growth; this demographic headwind is extremely difficult to overcome and represents a fundamental constraint on China's future growth trajectory.
“there is no country in the world which is able to grow rapidly or even grow when it has a negative population growth rate that headwind is just very hard to overcome”
Productivity growth has been slowing for decades despite significant tech innovations, and this slowdown predates the 2010s—apart from a brief surge in the late 1990s and early 2000s during the internet revolution, productivity growth has been generally declining everywhere.
“productivity growth has been slowing everywhere in the midst of what is otherwise such a powerful Tech boom and this is a trend that predates even the 2010 it's been like on a decline apart from a you know like a brief surge in the late 1990s and early 2000s when you had the internet Revolution productivity growth has been generally slowing everywhere”
Big Tech firms dominate new lobbying spending in Washington, becoming a major force in capturing regulations that benefit large tech companies, similar to how existing regulated industries have historically used lobbying to entrench themselves.
“the number of lobbyist in Washington the uh have been captured by all the big Tech firmm the big Tech firms dominate the number of new lobbyists in Washington or just total uh spend on Lobby”
India was a truly socialist economy in the mid-1970s when Sharma was born there, but has progressively moved toward greater economic freedom and improved on indices of economic freedom, supporting optimism about its long-term economic trajectory.
“India was a truly social economy when I was born in in the 19 uh in the mid 1970s and so I saw what socialism could do but fortunately for India after especially it faced an economic crisis in 1991 it's progressively been getting Freer progressively been moving up the indices of economic freedom and so therefore you know like I I've been much more optimistic about the economy as that's happened”
The creative destructive fiber of the economy has been undermined by keeping alive so much 'dead wood'—approximately 20% of companies today are 'zombie companies' defined as firms unable to earn enough profits to cover their interest payments for three consecutive years but continuing to refinance themselves in the market.
“the capitalist creative destructive fiber of the economy has been undermined because we're keeping alive so much dead wood I mean today the number of zombie companies as I say that we have in the economy today by some measures is close to 20% what do I mean by that these are companies that are defined as uh firms that have not uh or not earning enough profits to even cover their interest payments for three years in a row but keep going back to the market to refinance themselves”
The primary problem with government spending and deficits is not that a crisis is imminent, but that complacency and arrogance about America's position as the world's reserve currency enable policymakers to avoid necessary discipline, creating a false sense of security that will eventually lead to serious consequences.
“the argument that debt and deficits will cause a crisis seems very stale now because nothing has happened for despite these crisis warnings for so long and there is this uh real confidence which almost B um borders on arrogance that because we are America you know the world will keep funding it we have the world's main currency which people use so they keep buying dollars and we'll never have a problem you know it's that kind of complacency and arrogance about you know where else will the money go it has to come here which sort of bothers me”
The productivity growth decline is partly attributable to demographic headwinds and population growth slowdown across the world, which has limited economic expansion independent of policy choices.
“I think that the reason economic growth has been slowing a lot has to partly do with demographics that yes population growth across the world has slowed down that there's not much we can do about that but as far as far as productivity growth is concerned that too has slowed down significantly despite some tech innovations”
A recession at full employment with a 6% budget deficit would likely produce a 9-10% deficit, demonstrating the procyclical fiscal policy that worsens downturns rather than moderating them.
“We are at full employment in the economy and we have a 6% budget deficit uh already imagine if you have a downturn it'll be 9 or 10%”
The number of startups in America declined over the two to three decades preceding the pandemic, indicating a long-term deterioration in entrepreneurial dynamism.
“so therefore it's one of the reasons I think that the number of startups in America has been declining right up until the pandemic we saw a big decrease in the number of startups in America over the preceding two or three decades”
Financial sector deregulation has allowed financial markets to explode, but most other industries (hospitality, restaurants, etc.) have experienced increasing regulations, and this differential deregulation has concentrated wealth in finance while suppressing growth in Main Street industries.
“there's been financial sector deregulation which is why financial markets have exploded a lot but I'd say for most Industries in things like hospitality and things like restaurants and stuff the number of regulations that any small business has to deal with has gone up a lot”
America is introducing 3,000 new regulations per year, and this regulatory increase has grown over time; regulations tend to be pro-incumbent and pro-big business because existing large companies can game the system better and capture favorable regulations, while new regulations make it much more expensive for new companies to enter markets.
“America is introducing 3,000 new regulations a year and that's gone up over time and I argue in the book that in fact regulation tends to be Pro incumbent and pro big business because when you introduce new regulations the existing people are able to gain the system much better get the regulations they want and also it makes it that much more expensive uh for new companies to come up”
Government spending as a share of the US economy has increased from approximately 3% a century ago to about 36% today, alongside massive increases in regulatory intervention, bailouts, and business cycle management, collectively destroying the creative destructive fiber of the economy.
“the fact that if you look at what's been happening in America pretty much a lot of the western world over the last few decades is that we have progressively seen greater and greater government intervention in the economy the suite of habits extends to just more than government spending government spending of the share of the economy has gone up from a century ago at just 3% when the government would do little more than deliver your mail uh to about 36% today”
China is experiencing secular decline on a fundamental basis due to loss of two key growth engines: favorable demographics (now negative population growth) and debt accumulation capacity, limiting future growth to 2-3% for the foreseeable future.
“I've been parish and China for a while now because I you know in terms of what's been happening to its both uh the two pillars of growth really which is that it's been relying a lot on you know like when China boomed it had great demographics and of course when the boom slow down it could still rely on on taking on more and more debt to keep going those engines are now down uh so I feel that China is in a secular decline on a fundamental basis I don't see China growing at a rate of more than 2 or 3% for the foreseeable future”
The recent Indian election result showing a strong democratic affirmation is hopeful, and India's belief in its democratic tradition will help it over the long term better than authoritarian regimes, because research shows democracies compound growth better than authoritarian regimes without accountability.
“it's a country you know which believes in its democratic tradition and I think that that's something which also helps in the long term because this is a lot of research that I've done that you know like under Modi there was a real fear that India was moving towards an authoritarian uh Direction now you'll argue maybe that's good for its economy because you're moving in an authoritarian direction and you can take tougher decisions but the research I've done on this is the fact that uh authoritarian regimes you end up get either getting very good economic outcomes for a while or you end up getting disastrous economic outcomes because there's no one to tell you you know when you go wrong”
Immigration policy is economically beneficial (helped avoid recession and reduce inflation last year) but has become so politically toxic that what is good economics will not translate into good politics, and a crackdown is likely regardless of economic evidence.
“what is good economics is not always you know what's with politics which is that even last year like I was I pointed out that immigration is what really helped uh countries like America avoid a recession and bring inflation down much uh more than in other countries did uh uh last year but the problem is the fact that it's become such a political issue about tearing apart the social Fabric and stuff that what is good economics in obvious terms is not good politics”
The US is protected from economic deterioration more than peer nations because of its AI and tech sector, which creates substantial economic value and attracts global capital, providing a cushion for fiscal and policy mistakes that would devastate other economies.
“the US has Ai and a tech sector that just creates so much economic value and draws capital from the rest of the world that at least props up or wallpapers over our problems more so than those other three nations”
The claim that lower corporate tax rates incentivize reinvestment in capital and growth is not supported by evidence; Europe has maintained higher corporate tax rates yet has not achieved higher productivity growth, disproving the correlation.
“the evidence again doesn't really back it up right because if you look at what's happened in Europe you know whatever you know like the corporate tax rates have been higher they haven't been able to sort of get higher productivity growth either uh so I just don't see the evidence of that”
America has assimilated immigrants better than European countries like France, and Australia has also done well at immigrant assimilation, suggesting that Anglo-Saxon countries have a comparative advantage in integration despite recent political backlash against immigration.
“America's at least been better at uh assimilating immigrants than a lot of European countries uh in that regard and I think that countries like you know a Australia and all you know have been you know like pretty good in terms of as well so I'd say that generally here the Anglo Saxon world has been better than Europe in terms of assimilation of immigrants”
The argument that mismeasurement explains the productivity paradox is false; the late 1990s and early 2000s internet boom did produce a temporary productivity surge, proving that mismeasurement cannot explain away the current productivity decline.
“I deal with this productivity Paradox in the book extensively saying that what could be causing this uh you know the all these arguments that it's because of mismeasurement and all but that's not true because when you know like in the late 90s on the back of the internet boom you did see a temporary surch”
China's property sector and overall debt have become problematic because the country took on so much debt to maintain growth ambitions, and now faces pressure to pay back that debt, which constrains future borrowing and growth capacity.
“China has you know took on so much debt over the last decade because it ambitiously wanted to keep its growth rate up uh but now it you know it's been forced to pay back that debt in a way uh you know with the property sector and all which took a lot of that debt in the dogghouse”
The US budget deficit has more than doubled from a historical 3% of GDP to 6% of GDP in recent years, making it the highest among developed nations and putting the country on a trajectory to exceed even Italy's debt levels within the decade.
“America used to run a budget deficit of around 3% of GDP for the last couple of decades it was in line with other developed countries today we're running that at 6% of GDP way higher than any developed country in the world and our public debt as a share of the overall economy has crossed 100% And is uh only behind that of Japan and Italy and at this pace we'll be higher than Italy by the end of the decade”
Greece is the best-performing economy in Europe recently, having recovered dramatically from near-default 10 years ago by being forced to undergo structural reforms during its crisis.
“the economies that are you know have been sort of good again which is the economy that's doing the best in Europe these days it's Greece right which is that this is a country which till 10 years ago was like an example of a complete yeah if I can say so a basket case uh in terms of that but just look at how well Greece has come back it's booming now”
Near 70% of Americans want big economic change or want the current economic system to be torn down, reflecting widespread disillusionment with the capitalist system.
“near 70% of Americans want big economic change or want the current economic system to be Tor down”
Young Americans, particularly Democrats, increasingly prefer socialism to capitalism according to survey data, representing a historically significant rejection of capitalism as a system.
“the surveys show that most Young Americans particularly Democrats say they would rather have socialism than capitalism that's a really big statement uh for a country that was the founder of uh for all practical purposes a capitalist system”
Sharma affirms the tech advantage hypothesis and notes that the value creation is becoming dangerously concentrated in just a few select companies, representing a real problem even as it props up overall US performance.
“America has the success of the tech engine in there but again it's slightly concerning to me that the like in America the domination is getting so concentrated that the value is being created but it's been created in just very few select companies you know and I think that that is a real problem”
AI is being positioned as the next hope to boost productivity, but the underlying structural problem remains: government intervention and zombie firms will continue to suppress productivity gains even if AI delivers technological improvements.
“now we are hanging her hat on AI boosting productivity but I think that the as I said that the capitalist creative destructive fiber of the economy has been undermined because we're keeping alive so much dead wood”
While China may not experience a dramatic economic blow-up or crisis, the more likely outcome is that growth rates continue slipping and sliding downward toward 2-3%, representing a slow secular decline from its previous miracle growth trajectory.
“yeah for now it seems that the risk of a blow up in China has you know sort of been papered over because they've again done what it takes to keep the economy afloat but the problem in China is the fact that they can't get away from the basic notion that there is no country in the world which is able to grow rapidly or even grow when it has a negative population growth rate that headwind is just very hard to overcome and then second obviously is the debt issue in China where China has you know took on so much debt over the last decade because it ambitiously wanted to keep its growth rate up uh but now it you know it's been forced to pay back that debt in a way uh you know with the property sector and all which took a lot of that debt in the dogghouse so I feel that yeah the China may not have a blow up or a crisis but it's sort of going the way where the growth rate keeps slipping and sliding and you know 2 or 3% is the growth rate for China which is a far cry from where it was a decade ago”
Peripheral eurozone countries (Greece, Portugal, Ireland, etc.) have been performing better than core European countries like France and Germany in recent years, reversing the hierarchy established during the 2008 crisis.
“in general the clubm countries of late have been doing better than their Continental uh payers but Greece is an example of that”
Poland has done well by maintaining a competitive manufacturing sector, avoiding the trap of excessive billionaire-creation, and having strong EU institutions supporting it; its recent democratic election result improved political risk.
“it feel a while since a major Nation joined the ranks of the developed countries I think the next one to do so could be Poland uh which is on the brink of you know getting a per capita income of you know $20,000 or so which makes it like a developed country again a lot it's done right from having a very competitive manufacturing sector not too many flashy billionaires and in general I'd say that the election result in Poland last year sort of also took away some political risk because it's a much more Cooperative government uh that you have in place Visa uh the EU and the European Union helped it give it uh some pretty strong institutions”
America, despite problems, remains 'the beacon for the world' as the largest economy that other nations look to for direction, making the decline of the American capitalist model deeply concerning globally, not just domestically.
“it just pains me that in terms of the fact that I don't even compare America to these other countries because America is still the beacon for the world right it's still the largest economy that everyone looks up to to see as to what is American doing and the American brand of capitalism unfortunately has been dented”
The question of whether America assimilates immigrants better or attracts a different (higher-quality) type of immigrant is important but risks becoming a culturally charged discussion that is difficult to navigate analytically.
“well it could be both I think a combination of both right which is that in terms of what's happening but I just look at it more from a similation but then you start getting into Cal issues in terms of who's coming and what's happening and that just gets a very slippery slope in terms of looking at immigration in that regard”
The cost of setting up a new investment fund has increased 10 times over the last 20 years, making it much more difficult for new fund managers to achieve profitability compared to established large funds that already have legal compliance departments and resources to manage regulatory costs.
“I know it from personal experience that the cost of let's say setting up a new uh fund uh is up 10 times over the last 20 years so that makes it very difficult for someone looking to set up a new funding breaking even compared to some large fund which is already there has the resources has the legal compliance departments to deal with all this”
The number of lawyers in America per capita is approximately the largest in the world, and this growth has exploded in the last 20 years, indicating increasing legal and regulatory complexity that consumes resources without generating productivity.
“America's always had a very large uh legal population the number of lawers per capita is about the largest in the world uh but again that uh that this growth has exploded in the last 20 years or so”
The spike in new business applications and permits filed recently was largely due to pandemic-related shutdowns forcing businesses to restart, not a genuine long-term reversal of the declining startup trend over the preceding 30 to 40 years.
“you're correct that we did see like a spike up in new businesses or so over the last couple of years but a lot of that was because during the pandemic many had to shut down so that's a bit of a which is going on that's not been the true Trend over the last 30 to 40 years uh so I think we have to keep that in perspective”
The three critical policy changes needed are: (1) pause new regulations and evaluate which help vs. harm economic dynamism, (2) implement tougher antitrust regulation while scaling back the vast majority of regulations that hurt small and mid-sized businesses, and (3) establish a clear commitment not to bail out companies, eliminating moral hazard expectations.
“in terms of I know that nobody listens un until they have a crisis so I doubt I'm going to get that call but still I think that you know let's think about it i'd say that in terms of once you know like stuff is that think about every time you do a new regulation who's it hurting and who's it benefiting uh I mean I put a freeze on that”
Poland is on the brink of becoming the next developed nation—only ~40 of 200+ nations are classified as developed, and Poland is approaching the $20,000 per capita income threshold that defines developed status, making it a standout success in post-communist Europe.
“I think is next classified to becoming a developed country remember that in the world today there are more than 200 Nations only 40 or so are classified as developed countries everybody is else is classified as emerging and many of them uh from Brazil to Mexico have been emerging forever right so but I'd say that is uh it feel a while since a major Nation joined the ranks of the developed countries I think the next one to do so could be Poland uh which is on the brink of you know getting a per capita income of you know $20,000 or so which makes it like a developed country”
Canada is the worst-performing Anglo-Saxon economy over the last 10-15 years, followed by the UK and Australia, while the US has performed relatively better despite acknowledged problems—an irony given that all face similar issues of government overspending, capitalist-on-the-way-up socialism-on-the-way-down dysfunction.
“in the Anglo-Saxon world of course the the country that has been doing the worst which I think you know a bit of a surprise and I wrote about that is Canada that's been the worst really of the last you know 10 15 years and then next comes UK then Australia and the US compared to these countries has been doing relatively better”
India will likely grow at a 6-7% rate at best for the foreseeable future, not the 9-10% that characterized China's miracle, setting realistic expectations for its economic development.
“the only thing I'll keep in check is expectation that this is no next China which is going to grow at 9 or 10% it's going to be more like a 6 7% Tye growth rate at best that we in India for the foreseeable future”
The UK ranks worse than America on most metrics including deficits, zombie company prevalence, and regulatory burden, despite being a developed economy, demonstrating how severe policy mistakes can affect even established nations.
“in terms of you know what it's been doing with its deficits although America now has overtaken it in terms of you know what it's been doing uh in the number of zombie companies so I'd say that in that regard UK in fact ranks even worse than America on most metrics”