YouTube50m· Nov 2023· cataloged

The Infernal Logic of Jihad: A Conversation with Graeme Wood (Episode #339)


What this covers

This is a 51-minute conversation between Sam Harris and Graham Wood, the Atlantic correspondent who wrote a book on the Islamic State. Wood had been in Israel continuously from a few days after October 7th, and he reports on the mood there: mourning, fury, and a sense of betrayal toward a government whose central promise was security. He describes Israelis, especially on the left, who are now weighing emigration because the country's basic premise appears to have failed. He also notes that many victims were kibbutz residents, peace advocates, and elderly labor Zionists, not right-wing settlers.

Much of the conversation compares Hamas with Islamic State (ISIS)). Wood argues the violence differed in form and production quality but shared a jihadist foundation. He lays out why ISIS would regard Hamas as apostate: Hamas is nationalist, has compromised theologically, and works with Shia actors such as Hezbollah and Iran. He adds that ISIS's eschatology places the final conflict with the Jews very late, so it treats the Israeli-Palestinian struggle as a distraction. Years of governing Gaza made Hamas messier and more pragmatic. Harris pushes the opposite emphasis, that the different jihadist groups remain united in hostility to secular pluralism.

On the day itself, Wood describes a breach at multiple points, outposts overrun, and 12 to 24 hours of killing, hostage-taking, and looting. He argues this was improvised rather than the execution of a detailed plan, and that attackers did better than they expected. Many attackers spoke in jihadist terms, while ordinary Gazans who crossed over looted opportunistically. He also says the 9/11 comparison misleads, because Americans did not lose faith in their protection the way Israelis did.

The contentious stretch is Harris's moral argument. He holds that the perpetrators were mostly psychologically normal people moved by destructive ideas. He argues that casualty counts cannot equate the attack with Israel's response, contrasting Israeli warnings and targeting with Hamas's use of human shields. The two also separate hating Hamas as a government from celebrating October 7th as a military victory.

Sharpest takeaway

Sam Harris and Graham Wood argue that the October 7th attack on Israel was fundamentally a jihadist operation driven by religious ideology rather than purely nationalistic or political motivations, and that understanding this distinction is essential to making moral sense of both the attack and Israel's response, which cannot be morally equated through simple casualty counts.

  • October 7th was not a rational military operation but a deliberate act of maximalist violence designed to cause maximum suffering, suggesting jihadist ideological motivation rather than strategic calculation
  • The attackers exceeded their own expectations and encountered far less resistance than anticipated, indicating this was not a coordinated military plan but an eruption of jihadist fervor
  • Normal people committed these atrocities because of powerful destructive ideas (jihadist ideology), not because they were psychopaths—this ideological mechanism is what distinguishes this violence from ordinary criminality and makes it fundamentally different from Israel's military response designed to minimize civilian casualties

The claims · ranked38 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.79

Despite fragmentation between different jihadist groups on theological and strategic grounds, they remain essentially united in their hostility to secular pluralism and Western values, and their shared aspiration to spread Islam to the end of the Earth, making the differences primarily tactical rather than strategic.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“in their hatred of secular pluralistic I.E Western values I think they're United in their aspiration to you know triumphantly spread Islam whatever form they favor to the end of the Earth they're ultimately United”

0.75

ISIS has an extremely explicit eschatology where the final conflict with Jews is prophesied to occur very late in human history (around 11:59 p.m. in the timeline of humanity), and therefore views the Israeli-Palestinian conflict as a distraction from the more urgent task of purifying the faith and establishing a caliphate.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Graham Wood

“in isis's Timeline is way down the road Israel is not going to be vanquished the Jews are not going to be vanquished until pretty late like 1159 p.m. in the on the timeline of of humanity so they say if you're trying to do that right now you've got things out of order what you want want to do now is purify your faith mhm and then once that done then Jesus will come back the fight with the Jews will be won and so forth”

0.75

ISIS would view Hamas with extreme hostility (viewing them as apostates requiring death) because Hamas practices theological compromise, engages in nationalism, and collaborates with Shia actors like Iran and Hezbollah, violating ISIS's doctrine of uncompromising Islamic purity.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Graham Wood

“not just would never countenance but order number one of business for kill Isis would be whoever was doing that killed them kill the Shia as quickly as possible so they think that anybody who would collaborate with Shia including Hamas need to be killed”

0.75

The violence of October 7th was different from ISIS violence in its form and production quality, but similar in its jihadist ideological underpinning, making ISIS a useful historical comparison for understanding Hamas's motivation despite significant organizational differences.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Graham Wood

“for me it was like hearing the old Isis rhythms coming back... there's there's been a lot of discussion especially from the Israeli side saying Hamas is Isis and you know that's that's a really complicated thing for me given that if you look at Isis for as long as I did that you can start to see some Salient interesting differences there”

0.75

Hamas, unlike ISIS, spent years actually governing and managing basic services in Gaza, which required flexibility and pragmatism, leading to a messier, less ideologically pure organization that would accept nationalists and Shia allies like Iran and Hezbollah, while maintaining a relatively clear charter describing a future worldwide Muslim government.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Graham Wood

“the thing to remember about Hamas is that it's had years in power and the ideology that it stands for is rather well laid out it's it's in favor of an eventual worldwide Muslim government it is in favor of the Muslim brother Hood's view of of of of government and of how islamism should work it is not though Isis in Isis Isis operated with crystalline Clarity extreme Simplicity where you could describe the system of government that Isis wanted on the back of a 3x5 card whereas Hamas as a entity that actually has to you know pick up trash and do do a lot of of things for for years not not just briefly as Isis did is a pretty messy thing”

0.74

The attackers encountered people in unarmored vehicles who were largely unarmed or lightly armed with handguns against their assault rifles and RPGs, allowing for extended killing sprees, and many Israelis died in safe rooms designed for missile attacks rather than 24-hour sieges by armed terrorists who could set fires or use other methods to force occupants out.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Graham Wood

“Israeli houses now in order to be up to code they have to if you build a new house it has to have a safe room that's meant to withstand missile attacks or rocket attacks rather and so of course a lot of families went into these safe rooms the safe rooms are not meant to withstand 24 hours of diabolical terrorists surrounding you and deciding to do whatever they want such as just light your house on fire”

0.73

Many Israelis, particularly those of left-wing or peace-oriented ideology, are reconsidering their presence in Israel and considering emigration because the fundamental premise of Israel—providing security and preventing massacres of Jews—appears to have failed.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Graham Wood

“Jews in Israel saying things like you know I came to Israel because the whole point of Israel is to avoid having massacres of Jews which could have happened in anywhere else where you find Jews except for possibly the United States and you can't do that if that's the case I'm just going to go back to Morocco I'm just going to go back to to the lands of my grandparents or parents because if you can't provide that then what good are you”

0.73

Graham Wood was in Israel continuously from a few days after the October 7th attack and observed the atmosphere of mourning, fury, and deep betrayal among Israelis who felt their government had failed to protect them despite Netanyahu's core campaign promise of security.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Graham Wood

“I've been here almost continuously since a few days after the attack and I have seen things change. You know, on a—there was an atmosphere of mourning but more than anything else people were just stunned... this really did reach into the daily life of Israelis... there's an atmosphere of mourning also an atmosphere of fury... there was a sense that of a lot of Israelis that they were betrayed like deeply betrayed by their own government”

0.71

Understanding the October 7th attack requires recognition that it was fundamentally a jihadist operation driven by religious ideology rather than primarily a rational response to occupation or political grievance, though the two are not mutually exclusive.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Sam Harris

“the moral logic of what happened on October 7th and the logic of its support in the Muslim world to the degree that it is supported is quite a bit different than the logic of Israel's response”

0.71

The perpetrators of October 7th were psychologically normal people, not primarily psychopaths, meaning that powerful destructive religious ideas capable of justifying maximum sadistic violence can transform ordinary people into perpetrators of absolute evil without those people being intrinsically evil.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Sam Harris

“the kinds of people who would do what you just described are almost certainly I mean it's not to say there wasn't a a psychopath or two among them almost certainly these were psychologically normal people it's not like jihadism functions as a pure bug light for the world Psychopaths and you know these are people who would do horrible things anyway”

0.69

The attackers were not exclusively members of Hamas but included ordinary Gazans who crossed the border as looting occurred; these civilians participated in hostage-taking, theft of televisions and solar panels, and other opportunistic violence alongside the organized jihadist fighters.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Graham Wood

“it's not captured in the footage that I saw in the idf's screening so the IDF screening was truly raw footage... there's lots of other footage too I I've seen I I've seen lots of footage of people stealing you know TVs solar panels and ordinary Gins crossing over the board simply to loot so that that's that's a big part of what what what people have seen and also they also participated in taking of hostages”

0.69

Netanyahu's government promised security as its central legitimating proposition, making the October 7th attack a catastrophic failure of that core promise and ensuring deep political anger from across the Israeli political spectrum.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Graham Wood

“The main proposition that Netanyahu who offered Israelis was I will keep you safe we the right built a wall we have kept there from being another inata we've had the Iron Dome intercepting Rockets coming in and now they've presided over the worst massacre of Jews since the holocost”

0.69

Most Hamas attackers seemed to have jihad explicitly on their minds, using familiar jihadist slogans and phrasing their actions in religious terms, while other attackers involved in looting appeared motivated by dehumanization and opportunism rather than explicit religious ideology.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Graham Wood

“most of them seemed to have Jihad on the brain they go in and they use particular really they just slogans that are familiar from from from jihadism elsewhere uh that indicate they're thinking about this and they're phrasing what they're doing in in those terms”

0.69

ISIS maintained ideological purity through extreme enforcement mechanisms and educational projects to ensure all participants believed the same doctrine, while Hamas attackers showed varying levels of explicit jihadist commitment, suggesting Hamas is less doctrinally rigorous than ISIS.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Graham Wood

“Isis worked very hard to make sure that everybody was on the same page ideologically a lot of their project was an educational project it was you have to believe the following things in fact that's how we know that you're with us is that you believe the following things and you don't deviate at all because if you do deviate then we're coming after you”

0.69

The Israeli communities attacked on October 7th remain largely evacuated and their future repopulation is unclear, with many homes destroyed or damaged beyond immediate repair.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Graham Wood

“I've been to a few of them since and they're totally evacuated uh it's unclear whether they'll they'll ever be repopulated the the former residents or in other cities in Israel no but you you see some houses that are completely intact and then others that are piles of of rubble and Cinders and then others that are just completely bullet riddled”

0.69

Hamas is relatively more popular in the West Bank (where it is not in power) and less popular in Gaza (where it has governed for years), while the inverse is true for the Palestinian Authority, showing that governed populations consistently grow hostile to their actual governing jihadist organizations.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Graham Wood

“in the West Bank which is governed by the Palestinian Authority on the Palestinian side Hamas is relatively popular and then in Gaza which is governed by Hamas and where the Palestinian Authority was kicked out the Palestinian Authority is more popular so in in both cases they're misgoverned I mean these are terribly misgoverned stat lits”

0.68

The comparison between October 7th and 9/11 is misleading because while the scale was similar, the American response did not involve a wholesale loss of faith in government protection on the part of ordinary citizens as happened in Israel.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Graham Wood

“there's an atmosphere of Fury that I I don't think really pertained in the time immediately after September 11 in the United States that there was the sense I think that of a lot of Israelis that they were betrayed like deeply betrayed by their own government”

0.68

On October 7th, Hamas and other armed groups breached the border wall at multiple points, overwhelmed military outposts with little resistance, then expanded their perimeter into adjacent civilian communities where they massacred inhabitants, took hostages, and looted for 12-24 hours largely unopposed.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Graham Wood

“there were multiple breaches of this wall between Gaza and Israeli communities... there were multiple breaches of this wall... Hamas and others breached the border wall attacked a number of military outposts and were just wildly successful... they just massacred a large number of soldiers”

0.68

The October 7th attack was not a coordinated military operation following a preconceived plan; rather, Hamas and other attackers exceeded their own expectations of success, encountered less resistance than anticipated, and improvised an extended campaign of killing and looting that they had time to prolong because the IDF response was delayed.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Graham Wood

“they succeeded it seems at least that they may have succeeded beyond their wildest imaginings and they encountered much less resistance than they were imagining so they just they had this kind of embarrassment of sadistic riches where they they had all the Time in the World to kill people and torture people and desecrate their bodies”

0.66

The victims of October 7th included many leftist kibbutz residents, peace advocates, and elderly people—described as '60s Throwbacks' and labor Zionists—rather than right-wing settlers, which adds an additional layer of irony given their ideological opposition to the settlers whose policies contributed to the vulnerability.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Graham Wood

“these were peace nicks these were 60s Throwbacks these were labor zionists the kibutz movement goes back you know before I was born you know into a period when when people were they had a kind of utopian peace oriented view of the world and and a lot of these people who were like 85 years old who were who were taking hostage they came from from that”

0.66

It is conceptually coherent for Palestinians to hate Hamas as a governing entity while simultaneously viewing October 7th as a great military victory, since these are separate judgments about governance competence versus military success.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Sam Harris

“it's conceptually coherent to me to believe that there's some people who thought October 7th was a great victory and even knowing the details they would fully support it but they also think Hamas is a terrible governing organization and and they've ruined Gaza right those are not incoherent”

0.65

The moral logic of October 7th cannot be evaluated purely through casualty counts; equating it to Israel's response by comparing body counts misses fundamental distinctions between deliberately sadistic violence intending maximum suffering versus military operations designed to minimize civilian casualties while degrading military capability.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Sam Harris

“there is a difference between a group of people that would intend to murder non-combatants up close and personal in totally inefficient and and painful ways and make a kind of sacrament of that violence... and people who would take fairly great pains to avoid killing non-combatants all the while knowing that if they're going to wage any kind of War non-combatants will be killed”

0.65

If Israel could kill only members of Hamas without killing any civilians, that is precisely what the IDF would do, which reveals that all non-combatants killed by Israel are at worst inadvertent rather than intentional, whereas Hamas's use of human shields is deliberate and structural.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Sam Harris

“if Israel wanted to kill non-combatants by the tens of and hundreds of thousands they could do that the fact that they don't do that reveals that all the non-combatants they kill are at worst inadvertent right this is not if they could kill only members of Hamas and not kill a single woman or child in Gaza that's what the IDF would do”

0.65

Israel's deliberate minimization of civilian casualties through leaflet warnings, cell phone calls, and targeting precision stands in moral contrast to Hamas's deliberate use of non-combatants as human shields, and reversing the logic (imagining IDF use of Jewish human shields) reveals the asymmetry as intuitively absurd.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Sam Harris

“they'll drop leaflets telling people to get out of buildings they intend to destroy uh they'll call cell phones to try to get people to leave those buildings and uh you know Hamas is consciously using those non-combatants as human shields in a way that would be completely Unthinkable and just ridiculous if you reverse the logic I mean they just imagine these you imagine I IDF soldiers using those non-combatants on those kutas as human Shields against the on-rushing forces of Hamas”

0.64

Evidence of specific atrocities including decapitation has been documented on video, with attackers hacking at victims' necks with garden hoes when knives were unavailable, and U.S. Secretary of State Antony Blinken reported being shown imagery of families bound and dismembered with fingers and feet taken off and eyes gouged out.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Graham Wood

“I know there was decapitation because the video showed a Thai worker who was clearly already dying he had been gutshot I think and was lying on the floor and you can hear the terrorists around him yelling give me a knife give me a knife presumably to decapitate him because that's what they eventually tried to do and not having a knife they used a garden ho so I had seen part of this video where they hack it at his neck with a garden hoe”

0.64

One piece of video footage showed a father with two young sons being woken by an attack, going to their backyard seeking shelter, having a grenade thrown at them killing the father, and the surviving children then discussing their impending death in their kitchen while terrorists remained on the property, with one attacker entering the house asking for water.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Graham Wood

“there was one in particular cap in a nanny cam uh where there's a father with two young sons who are clearly woken up surprised but aware that they're being attacked and they tentatively leave their house and then go to a little area in their backyard I think thinking they they might be able to hide there and pretty quickly the terrorists toss a a grenade in and there's an explosion... at least unconscious and certainly never gets up again uh and then the kids covered in blood one of them's lost an eye and then you hear them as they they run back into their house sit in their kitchen and hear them talk about the fact that their lives are about to end”

0.64

Video evidence from GoPros and security cameras showed attackers entering communities at gates, waiting in bushes, shooting people arriving in vehicles, hunting families in homes, torturing occupants, and deliberately desecrating bodies—a form of violence that was disorganized, improvisational, and aimed at maximum sadism rather than military efficiency.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Graham Wood

“you can see in the videos that they show up at the at the gates of the communities these Gates they're closed you have to like have a code to open them up not that much more complicated than like a garage door opener and so in some of the videos you see them just waiting there like hiding almost like in the bushes next to the gates waiting for someone to drive up and shooting them”

0.63

Israel faces potential threats from Hezbollah in the north with approximately 150,000 rockets and a large battle-hardened force, which could change the strategic situation entirely if opened as a second front while Israel is dealing with Gaza.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Graham Wood

“Hezbollah currently constitutes a kind of existential threat and just it needs to be preemptively destroyed right I don't see how they just sit with Hezbollah on their northern border with 150,000 Rockets as has been reported and a much larger Force than they just encountered coming from Gaza”

0.62

Israel is prioritizing obliterating Hamas as an operational entity in Gaza before addressing the Hezbollah threat, because eliminating Hamas is more feasible than preventing a war with Hezbollah that Israel believes would be much harder to win.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Graham Wood

“Israel thinks that it can obliterate Hamas as an operational entity and Hezbollah to do that would initiate a war that is not nearly so obviously winnable so they would much prefer to take care of what they can now now and then figure out how to deal with with Hezbollah from there”

0.61

Some specific atrocity claims such as decapitated babies and fetuses ripped from mothers' wombs have been reported but Wood cannot personally confirm the video evidence for these claims, though he notes that the confirmed atrocities are already sufficient to establish the nature of the violence.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Graham Wood

“at the margins there are particular atrocities that have been described that you know I as a reporter I can't claim to have seen the videos of this so I I can't confirm them but you know the dozens of decapitated babies uh the fetuses ripped from the mother's wombs these these these have been these are on the list of things that that have have been claimed”

0.61

Secular people who have never encountered absolute religious certainty find it extremely difficult to understand how normal people can be transformed into perpetrators of maximum sadistic violence through commitment to jihadist ideology, and this difficulty is a form of epistemic vulnerability in democratic societies.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“for secular people people who have never met anyone who has met anyone who has been certain to Paradise I think that's very hard to understand and so anyway feel free to disagree with anything that I just said there but that I think that is something that you know I'm eager to um disabuse our audience of”

0.61

Significant Israeli government resources were diverted from Gaza security to support West Bank settler projects over the past year, leaving Gaza communities more vulnerable to attack, and Israeli analysts connect this resource diversion to the security failures of October 7th.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Graham Wood

“over the last year settlers have been pushing Palestinians off of land in the West Bank and they've had to do that with the help of the IDF so you find that there's a growing number of resources that were devoted to the settler project... if that happens more and more there's only finite resources and those resources were probably taken away from Gaza and that probably meant that Gaza was more vulnerable”

0.57

Netanyahu and most of his government face political extinction as a result of October 7th, but they remain in power during the current military response, likely to exit after the immediate security crisis is resolved.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Graham Wood

“Netanyahu personally is toast his political future is sealed so is the political future of most of the people in his government but not yet there's a belief that the the heads of the IDF and the political leadership they stay until the moment is right for them to to move”

0.37

The IDF invited journalists to a screening where they showed raw footage from security cameras, GoPros, nanny cams, and dash cams documenting the October 7th attacks without commentary or identifying which faction was perpetrating which act.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Graham Wood

“the IDF screening was truly raw footage I mean it was it was just images that were captured as you say by Nanny cams by security camps by GoPros but there was no indication of of which faction from Gaza was was doing what”

0.34

Ordinary Israeli civilians and soldiers on October 7th were lightly armed or unarmed relative to the attacking force, making resistance ineffective and leading to extremely high casualty rates and extended torture.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Graham Wood

“the people in these kutzas were not right-wing settlers... these were peace nicks... most of these people have been described as left-wing idealists... and precisely the kinds of people who would volunteer to drive gazin across the border to get medical treatment in Israel”

0.32

Intelligence failures may have resulted from hacking of monitoring systems, but the full story of how attackers breached the heavily monitored border remains unclear and will require official investigation.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Graham Wood

“the actual tactics that they used we don't know the full story and I guarantee there's going to be a commission that the Israelis have to discover exactly what happened but you know on other parts of the Border I've had people tell me that a bird cannot fly across that border without the Israelis knowing”

0.29

Graham Wood has been reporting on the Islamic State for years, has been in Israel since days after October 7th, is a staff writer for the Atlantic, member of the Council on Foreign Relations, teaches at Yale, and has reported from every continent except Antarctica on a wide variety of topics.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“the Atlantic writer Graham wood Graham has been in Israel since a few days after the October 7th attacks he is a staff writer for the Atlantic and the author of the way of the strangers encounters with the Islamic State which is well worth reading he joined the Atlantic in 2006 and has since reported from every continent except Antarctica and on a very wide variety of topics he's also a member of the Council on Foreign Relations and he teaches at y University”

0.28

There is no evidence of Israeli plans for preemptive attack on Hezbollah absent Hezbollah opening a second front, despite speculation about such possibilities.

factualestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Graham Wood

“what I think you're not hearing anyone speculate that Israel would actually preemptively attack Hezbollah like in the absence of that front opening up from”