human shields
The practice of placing civilians in or near military targets to deter attacks or to exploit an enemy's reluctance to harm non-combatants.
As defined in et_956
Other definitions
The use of one's own civilian population to deter or morally complicate enemy attacks; Harris attributes this tactic to Hamas.
465 - More From Sam Iran Jihadism Conspiracism Ai Disruption The Manosphere And More
Where it comes up · 25
- 373 - Anti-zionism Is Antisemitism4 claims
- 338 - The Sin Of Moral Equivalence3 claims
- The Infernal Logic of Jihad: A Conversation with Graeme Wood (Episode #339)2 claims
- Is America Overstretched? A Conversation With General David Petraeus2 claims
- 437 - Two Years Since 1072 claims
- 48 - What Is Moral Progress2 claims
- 340 - The Bright Line Between Good And Evil2 claims
- 410 - The Whole Catastrophe2 claims
and 17 more
Most important claims · 10 of 39Search all claims for “human shields” →
- With their communications compromised after the pager attacks, Ibrahim Aqil and other Hezbollah commanders decided to hold an in-person meeting beneath a residential building in Beirut, apparently believing that gathering underground while using civilians as human shields would protect them, but Israeli forces struck the parking lot and second underground floor with four missiles, causing building collapse and killing approximately 20 Radwan Force commanders including five out of six leading battalion commanders present.Hezbollah's Nightmare - Israeli Strikes Overwhelm Top Iranian Proxy
- The use of human shields exposes the greatest ethical disparity in war: cynically calculating that the enemy will be deterred, one side fights behind children and places missiles by hospitals, while the other side is in fact deterred — a tactic that would be both morally unthinkable and useless against an enemy like ISIS who does not care about collateral damage.26 - The Logic Of Violence
- Jihadists strategically place their own noncombatants in the line of fire to exploit the more civilized moral code of their enemies, while Israel is deterred by civilian presence and warns people to evacuate before bombing — a concrete behavior occurring on only one side that reveals a deep ethical asymmetry.338 - The Sin Of Moral Equivalence
- When an enemy has no moral scruples, one's own moral scruples become a weapon in his hand — through tactics like human shields, lopsided prisoner swaps, and cynical complaints of torture — meaning certain conflicts may become harder to fight precisely because of the moral progress a society has made.48 - What Is Moral Progress
- When critics point to Gaza's death and destruction with no equivalent dead bodies pulled from rubble in Tel Aviv and conclude Israel is in the wrong, they ignore that the asymmetry exists because Israel invested in missile defense and bomb shelters for its civilians while Hamas, Hezbollah, the Houthis and Iran intended to produce maximal carnage; judging Israel by this asymmetry rewards Hamas for using its own non-combatants as human shields and demeans Israel for successfully protecting its population.437 - Two Years Since 107
- Israel should adopt a barbell strategy: on one hand recognize the PR war is unwinnable in certain camps and at the UN and defend itself unapologetically, since its real enemies respect only strength and not empathy or conformity to Western human-rights norms; on the other hand it should have marshaled immense resources into a war of ideas, deploying an English-language spokesman to walk through, on television and online, every moral asymmetry between the IDF and Hamas and between Israeli and Palestinian culture.437 - Two Years Since 107
- Reversing the human-shield logic exposes the asymmetry: it is unthinkable not only that Israelis would use their own women and children as shields, but that they could expect jihadist groups like Hamas, Hezbollah, Al Qaeda, or ISIS to be deterred by such a tactic, which shows how deep the ethical difference runs.338 - The Sin Of Moral Equivalence
- Yahya Sinwar's open strategy was to use Palestinian civilians as sacrificial lambs to break Israel's will and invite global condemnation, and treating Hamas like a government rather than a prison gang with a death-cult patina (one that steals construction materials for bunkers and uses civilians as human shields) leaves Israel in the impossible position of being expected to care more about Palestinian lives than Hamas does; this strategy is starting to pay off as European countries demand Israel feed Gaza while asking little of Hamas, so despite the structural antisemitism Israel should end the war for now on prudential grounds.428 - Political Extremism
- When jihadists believe that life in this world has no value apart from determining who goes to hell and who goes to paradise, it becomes possible for them to feel perfectly at ease killing non-combatants and using their own women and children as human shields, because they believe Muslims killed will go straight to paradise.The Bright Line Between Good and Evil (Episode #340)
- The bright ethical line between Israel and her enemies can be seen on the question of human shields: there are people who use them (Hamas, putting its headquarters under a hospital and physically preventing Gazans from leaving so they'll be killed) and people who are deterred by them, however imperfectly (Israel) — so however horrible the images from Gaza, Hamas should be blamed for the loss of life there.340 - The Bright Line Between Good And Evil