
What this covers
This episode of The Daily has host Rachel Abrams talking with Anton Troianovski, the Times's Moscow bureau chief, about a week of rapid moves on Ukraine. It begins with the release of Mark Fogle, an American teacher held in Russia, after Steve Witkoff flew to Moscow, the first visit there by a senior American official since before the invasion. It then covers a 90-minute call between Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin that was not coordinated with allies. Trump phoned Volodymyr Zelensky only afterward, which reverses Joe Biden's principle of Nothing About Ukraine Without Ukraine and his effort to show a united front that Putin could not divide and conquer.
The middle of the conversation is about what the administration has conceded publicly. Pete Hegseth, speaking in Brussels, called a return to pre-2014 borders unrealistic, ruled out NATO membership for Ukraine as a likely outcome, and said no American troops would join a peacekeeping mission. Troianovski sets this against Putin's pre-invasion ultimatum on NATO and Russia's sphere of influence, which the West once dismissed as absurd. He also describes the bind facing Europe, which has given more than $100 billion to Ukraine but cannot easily provide deterrence against Russia without American backing.
The episode turns most contentious around JD Vance's Munich Security Conference speech. Vance said the threat to Europe comes from within, from eroded democratic values and limits on speech, and he criticized the exclusion of populist lawmakers just before a German election in which the far-right AfD hoped to gain. Troianovski notes that this echoes Putin's own complaints about Europe. The closing material covers reactions: elation in Moscow, where the stock market rose more than 5%, and Zelensky's insistence that Ukraine will not accept a deal made without it. Troianovski frames the remaining difficulty as threading the needle between Putin's demands and Ukraine's need for security guarantees.
The Trump Administration has fundamentally shifted U.S. foreign policy away from its post-WWII alliance with Europe, embracing Russia and signaling abandonment of NATO commitments, which represents a stunning geopolitical victory for Vladimir Putin and potentially the collapse of the transatlantic order.
- Trump initiated direct, uncoordinated diplomacy with Putin before consulting allies, breaking Biden's isolation strategy and unified Western front
- JD Vance and Pete Hegseth publicly signaled withdrawal of U.S. security guarantees to Europe, effectively removing America as the guarantor of European security against Russian aggression
- The Trump administration is negotiating Ukraine's fate without Ukraine's meaningful participation, echoing Putin's pre-2022 demands for sphere of influence and weakening Ukraine's leverage
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The Trump Administration released Mark Fogle, an American school teacher imprisoned in Russia, as a diplomatic gesture when Trump's Middle East Envoy Steve Witkoff flew to Moscow and brought him home on his plane, marking the first time a senior American official had traveled to Russia since before the Ukraine invasion.
“when surprisingly the Russians released Mark Fogle an American school teacher who had been in jail in Russia to get him out Steve witkoff Trump's Middle East Envoy actually flew to Moscow and then later brought him home on his plane that was the first time that a senior American official had traveled to Russia since before the war”
Before Putin started his invasion, he presented an ultimatum demanding NATO withdraw from Eastern and Central Europe and give Russia back its European sphere of influence, which the West dismissed at the time, but Trump's approach to peace negotiations now incorporates many of those same demands.
“before Putin started his invasion I don't know if you remember he presented this ultimatum to the West saying NATO needed to withdraw from Eastern and Central Europe and really give Russia its European sphere of influence back at the time that seemed like a ludicrous demand the West dismissed it out of hand but here we are 3 years later and really kind of talking about many of the things that Putin demanded”
Hegseth's public concessions about Ukraine put Europe 'in an incredibly tough spot' because without U.S. military backing, Europe cannot deter Russian invasion on its own, given Russia's vastly larger military and nuclear arsenal.
“those concessions that hex Seth made that put Europe into an incredibly tough spot because how do you guarantee Ukraine's security and deter A Renewed Russian invasion at some point down the road if the US isn't involved you know Russia's military is huge compared to any European country and obviously their nuclear Arsenal is is far greater than anything that Europe has”
JD Vance criticized Europe at the Munich Security Conference for departing from democratic values, echoing Vladimir Putin's long-standing criticisms of Europe for being 'woke' and silencing speech.
“he launches into this extensive criticism of Europe the threat that I worry the most about Visa Europe is not Russia it's not China it's not any other external actor and what I worry about is the threat from within the retreat of Europe from some of its most fundamental values values shared with the United States of America you know a Europe that in his telling has departed from its Democratic roots”
Vance criticized Europe for banning populist party lawmakers from participating in the Munich Security Conference, making this critique while in Germany just before elections where the far-right Alternative for Germany party hopes to gain seats.
“he was doing this in Germany with the big National German election less than two weeks away and where the German farri party is hoping to make big gains and of course the German farri party the alternative for Germany has been very much ostracized across the political Spectrum in Germany for its links to Neo-Nazi ideology and its attempts to whitewash the Nazi past”
Trump spoke to Putin in a 90-minute phone call on Wednesday, the first known conversation between an American president and the Russian leader since Russia invaded Ukraine three years ago, which was not pre-coordinated with American allies.
“then on Wednesday Trump speaks to Putin on the phone it was a 90-minute call according to the Russians and just the mere fact of this call was really remarkable it was the first time that we know of that an American president spoke to the Russian leader since Russia invaded Ukraine three years ago”
Vice President JD Vance, speaking at the Munich Security Conference, did not clarify the Trump administration's foreign policy; instead, he delivered an extensive criticism of Europe, claiming that the threat Europe faces is not from Russia or China but from 'within,' specifically from Europe's departure from Democratic values and its restrictions on free speech.
“you know Vance gives this speech at the Munich security conference it's like this massive event probably the most high-profile security Forum globally where you have tons of heads of state Prime Ministers defense ministers foreign ministers in the audience we're happy to be here and you know one of the things that I wanted to to talk about today is of course our shared values and but instead of talking about Trump's foreign policy he launches into this extensive criticism of Europe the threat that I worry the most about Visa Europe is not Russia it's not China it's not any other external actor”
In his post about the Trump-Putin call, Trump invoked shared history between the U.S. and Russia from World War II, claimed both he and Putin agreed they want to stop the war in Ukraine, attributed the phrase 'Common Sense' to Putin, and stated he would then call Zelinski to inform him of the conversation with Putin.
“Trump wrote that in this call he and Putin both reflected on the great history of our Nations and the fact that we fought so successfully together in World War II and then Trump added that he and Putin had both agreed that they want to stop the war in Ukraine and that President Putin even used Trump's quote very strong campaign motto of Common Sense and Trump writes on social media after that call that he will then call President vadir zalinski the Ukrainian leader to inform him of that conversation with Putin”
The central challenge in ending the Ukraine war is threading the needle between Putin's demands (to keep territory already conquered, gain influence over Ukraine, and limit Ukraine's military) and Ukraine's requirements (security guarantees and deterrence against future Russian invasion).
“the big question if these negotiations get more serious is going to be how do you thread the needle between Putin's demands and what Ukraine would need you know Putin is demanding not just to keep the territory he already has but he also wants influence over Ukraine he wants Ukraine's military to be limited and then on the other hand zalinsky and the ukrainians are saying they need security guarantees they need assurance says that there will be a response if Putin were to try to invade again down the road they need deterrence against Russia”
Trump called Putin and then called Zelinski to inform him of the conversation, reversing the Biden administration's approach of coordinating with Ukraine before making decisions about its future.
“so first he calls Putin and then he calls zalinski to let him know how it went and what they discussed”
Zelinski stated that Ukraine will not accept a peace deal that Ukraine was not part of negotiating, giving Ukraine veto power over any U.S.-Russia agreement.
“zalinski has said very clearly that Ukraine will not accept a deal that they were not a part of in negotiating”
Before the Ukraine invasion, Putin presented an ultimatum to the West demanding that NATO withdraw from Eastern and Central Europe and restore Russia's European sphere of influence; this demand seemed ludicrous at the time, but three years later the West is discussing many of the things Putin demanded.
“before Putin started his invasion I don't know if you remember he presented this ultimatum to the West saying NATO needed to withdraw from Eastern and Central Europe and really give Russia its European sphere of influence back at the time that seemed like a ludicrous demand the West dismissed it out of hand but here we are 3 years later and really kind of talking about many of the things that Putin demanded”
When Zelinski spoke with Trump after the Putin call on Wednesday, Zelinski told Trump that Putin was a liar, could not be trusted, and did not actually want peace, while also saying publicly that a strong America and Trump could pressure Putin into a sustainable peace deal.
“he later said that he in his call with Trump that same day on Wednesday he told Trump that Putin was a liar someone you couldn't trust someone who did not actually want peace and someone who could deploy Russian troops beyond Ukraine at the same time zalinski was saying publicly that a strong America a strong Trump could pressure Putin to make the kind of peace deal that Ukraine believes would be sustainable”
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, speaking to NATO and European defense ministers in Brussels on Wednesday, stated that Ukraine's return to pre-2014 borders was an 'unrealistic objective,' that Ukraine joining NATO is not a realistic outcome of negotiation, and that the U.S. will not deploy troops to Ukraine as part of any peacekeeping mission.
“We want like you a sovereign and prosperous Ukraine but we must start by recognizing that return to Ukraine's borders from before Putin annexed Crimea in 2014 was quote unrealistic objective a durable peace for Ukraine must include robust security guarantees to ensure that the war will not begin again that said the United States does not believe that NATO membership for Ukraine is a realistic outcome of a negotiated settlement he also said it was unrealistic that Ukraine would join NATO and he said that there will not be US troops deployed to Ukraine if there were to be a peace deal American troops would not be part of any peacekeeping mission”
In Moscow, the response to Trump's call with Putin and Hegseth's speech was elation: the Russian stock market rose more than 5%, the ruble strengthened, and pro-Putin politicians posted on social media celebrating it as a major win for Russia and evidence of Putin's status as a brilliant foreign policy strategist.
“well I think it's fair to say that in Moscow there was was quite a bit of elation in response the Russian stock market was up more than 5% the ruble the Russian currency strengthened you had all these protin politicians posting on social media about how like this was such a big win for Russia and it showed Putin's status as a brilliant foreign policy strategist”
Europe has contributed more than $100 billion to Ukraine over the past three years by some counts, more than the United States has contributed, giving Europe a major stake in the outcome of the war.
“European countries have contributed more than hundred billion doar by some counts more than the US has in total to Ukraine over the last three years so they clearly have a huge stake in this too”
Vance gave his Munich Security Conference speech just before a major German national election scheduled for less than two weeks later, where the German far-right Alternative for Germany party was hoping to make significant gains, creating the appearance that the U.S. Vice President was supporting populist parties opposed by the mainstream political spectrum.
“and you know and even more remarkable was the fact that he was doing this in Germany with the big National German election less than two weeks away and where the German farri party is hoping to make big gains and of course the German farri party the alternative for Germany has been very much ostracized across the political Spectrum in Germany for its links to Neo-Nazi ideology and its attempts to whitewash the Nazi past”
The Munich Security Conference organizers banned lawmakers representing populist parties on both the left and right from participating in the conference discussions.
“and you know and even more remarkable was the fact that he was doing this in Germany with the big National German election less than two weeks away and where the German farri party is hoping to make big gains and of course the German farri party the alternative for Germany has been very much ostracized across the political Spectrum in Germany for its links to Neo-Nazi ideology and its attempts to whitewash the Nazi past if you're running in fear of your own voters there is nothing America can do for you nor for that matter is there basically the vice president of the United States is saying to his European allies long-standing European allies that Russia isn't the problem here you are now again and you know and even more remarkable was the fact that he was doing this in Germany with the big National German election less than two weeks away and where the German farri party is hoping to make big gains and of course the German farri party the alternative for Germany has been very much ostracized across the political Spectrum in Germany for its links to Neo-Nazi ideology and its attempts to whitewash the Nazi past if you're running in fear of your own voters there is nothing America can do for you nor for that matter is there basically the vice president of the United States is saying to his European allies long-standing European allies that Russia isn't the problem here you are even more remarkable was the fact that he was doing this in Germany with the big National German election less than two weeks away and where the German farri party is hoping to make big gains and of course the German farri party the alternative for Germany has been very much ostracized across the political Spectrum in Germany for its links to Neo-Nazi ideology and its attempts to whitewash the Nazi past”
Steve Witcoff, Trump's Middle East Envoy, flew to Moscow to negotiate the release of Mark Fogle, an American school teacher, and then brought him home on his plane—the first time a senior American official had traveled to Russia since before the war.
“the Russians released Mark Fogle an American school teacher who had been in jail in Russia to get him out Steve witkoff Trump's Middle East Envoy actually flew to Moscow and then later brought him home on his plane that was the first time that a senior American official had traveled to Russia since before the war”
Putin is demanding to keep the territory he already has, wants influence over Ukraine, and wants Ukraine's military to be limited, while Zelensky and Ukraine demand security guarantees and deterrence assurance against future Russian invasion.
“Putin is demanding not just to keep the territory he already has but he also wants influence over Ukraine he wants Ukraine's military to be limited and then on the other hand zalinsky and the ukrainians are saying they need security guarantees they need assurance says that there will be a response if Putin were to try to invade again down the road they need deterrence against Russia”
Trump called Ukraine's President Zelensky after calling Putin to inform him of their conversation, rather than coordinating with Ukraine beforehand—reversing Biden's 'nothing about Ukraine without Ukraine' approach.
“Trump writes on social media after that call that he will then call President Zelinski the Ukrainian leader to inform him of that conversation with Putin so first he calls Putin and then he calls zalinski to let him know how it went and what they discussed”
Zelensky told Trump that Putin was a liar who could not be trusted and did not want peace, while publicly trying to remain positive by saying a strong Trump could pressure Putin into a sustainable peace deal.
“he later said that he in his call with Trump that same day on Wednesday he told Trump that Putin was a liar someone you couldn't trust someone who did not actually want peace and someone who could deploy Russian troops Beyond Ukraine at the same time zalinski was saying publicly that a strong America a strong Trump could pressure Putin to make the kind of peace deal that Ukraine believes would be sustainable”
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth publicly stated that returning Ukraine's borders to pre-2014 status was 'an unrealistic objective,' that NATO membership for Ukraine is not a 'realistic outcome' of peace talks, and that the U.S. will not deploy troops to Ukraine for peacekeeping.
“return to Ukraine's borders from before Putin annexed Crimea in 2014 was quote anistic objective a durable peace for Ukraine must include robust security guarantees to ensure that the war will not begin again that said the United States does not believe that NATO membership for Ukraine is a realistic outcome of a negotiated settlement he also said it was unrealistic that Ukraine would join NATO and he said that there will not be US troops deployed to Ukraine if there were to be a peace deal American troops would not be part of any peacekeeping mission”
Vance told European allies, 'if you're running in fear of your own voters there is nothing America can do for you,' signaling that the U.S. will no longer support Western Europe as it has since the end of World War II.
“if you're running in fear of your own voters there is nothing America can do for you nor for that matter is there basically the vice president of the United States is saying to his European allies long-standing European allies that Russia isn't the problem here you are”
Zelensky insisted on Meet the Press that Ukraine must be involved in negotiations, and said that if the U.S. were to pull its aid, it would be very difficult for Ukraine to survive as an independent country.
“when valdimir zalinski was on Meet the Press on Sunday morning he was insisting that Ukraine did need to be involved okay but just to ask a really basic question how do you end a war in Ukraine without Ukraine at the table”
For Russia and the U.S. to reach a deal on Ukraine, Ukraine would still need to agree to stop fighting, and Zelensky has said Ukraine will not accept a deal negotiated without Ukraine's participation.
“even if Russia and the US were to make a deal here you know you would still need Ukraine to agree to it you would need Ukraine to agree to stop fighting and zalinski has said very clearly that Ukraine will not accept a deal that they were not a part of in negotiating”
The cost to Russia of the war has been extraordinary—100,000 or more Russians dead, a million fled the country, and the economy stretched to the breaking point—but if Putin settles on his terms, he will present it as a big victory and an even bigger victory if the U.S. walks away from Europe.
“the cost of all this to Russia has been just extraordinary maybe a 100,000 or more Russians have died something like a million have fled the country the economy has been stretched to its Breaking Point obviously just the moral cost of having started Europe's biggest war of aggression since World War II is hard to Fathom but if Putin through these peace talks is able to settle the war more or less on his terms that'll be something he presents as a big victory and an even bigger Victory will be if at the end of all this he gets the US to walk away from Europe”
The U.S., under Biden, coordinated all its steps with European allies to show Putin a united Western front that he could not divide and conquer.
“in addition it was all about showing a United Western Front the US under President Biden was very very careful to coordinate all of its steps with the Europeans just to show Putin that he wasn't going to be able to divide and conquer when dealing with the west”
Trump's 90-minute phone call with Putin was the first time an American president had spoken to the Russian leader since Russia invaded Ukraine three years ago, breaking Biden's strategy to isolate Putin diplomatically.
“on Wednesday Trump speaks to Putin on the phone it was a 90-minute call according to the Russians and just the mere fact of this call was really remarkable it was the first time that we know of that an American president spoke to the Russian leader since Russia invaded Ukraine three years ago”
Biden's core principle for Ukraine negotiations was 'nothing about Ukraine without Ukraine,' meaning Ukraine would be directly involved in any peace discussions affecting its territory and future.
“the Biden administration's philosophy that they repeated over and over was nothing about Ukraine without Ukraine and here Trump threw that completely out the window”
Vance signaled to his European allies that Russia is not the problem for Europe; rather, Europe itself is the problem, fundamentally reversing post-World War II American foreign policy of maintaining a committed alliance with Western Europe.
“and Vance here is signaling the possibility that America will no longer be that key Ally of Western Europe and the European Union that it was for all those decades after the end of World War II”
Even if Russia and the U.S. reach a deal to end the war, Ukraine would still need to agree to stop fighting, and Zelinski has made clear that Ukraine will not accept any deal that Ukraine was not part of negotiating.
“you would still need Ukraine to agree to it you would need Ukraine to agree to stop fighting and zalinski has said very clearly that Ukraine will not accept a deal that they were not a part of in negotiating”
Hegseth's concessions put Europe in a difficult position because without U.S. military involvement, Europe must find a way to guarantee Ukraine's security and deter renewed Russian invasion using only European military capacity, which is significantly smaller than Russia's military and has no nuclear arsenal comparable to Russia's.
“so those concessions that hex Seth made that put Europe into an incredibly tough spot because how do you guarantee Ukraine's security and deter A Renewed Russian invasion at some point down the road if the US isn't involved you know Russia's military is huge compared to any European country and obviously their nuclear Arsenal is is far greater than anything that Europe has so that speech really put into Stark relief how much of a problem Europe was going to have in finding a way to face down Russia and Putin without the us at its back”
In Europe, the response to Trump's statements and Hegseth's speech was shock and confusion; Hegseth attempted to walk back parts of his speech the next day, Trump said Ukraine would be involved in talks, but overall there was uncertainty about the administration's approach to Europe, NATO, and the Russia-Ukraine conflict.
“in Europe there was both shock and confusion you know Pete Heth tried to walk back parts of his speech the next day Trump said that Ukraine would be involved in the talks so on top of just the shock you also just had people not really understanding what exactly the approach of the administration was going to be to Europe to Nato and to Russia and Ukraine”
Vladimir Zelinski appeared on Meet the Press on Sunday morning insisting that Ukraine must be involved in peace negotiations, indicating that the Trump administration was not guaranteeing Ukraine's participation.
“in that sense it's not a surprise that when valdimir zalinski was on Meet the Press on Sunday morning he was insisting that Ukraine did need to be involved”
The Ukraine war has lasted nearly three years, with tens of thousands of Ukrainian soldiers and civilians dead, and recent polls show increased Ukrainian willingness over the past year to make compromise with Russia due to intense war fatigue.
“the war has lasted almost 3 years now which would have been just so unimaginable if we think back to the beginning of 2022 obviously tens of thousands of ukrainians both soldiers and civilians have died and so what you've also been seeing over the last year or so in Ukraine is a higher Readiness according to the polls to make some kind of compromise with Russia”
Trump Administration officials (Marco Rubio as Secretary of State, Mike Waltz as National Security Advisor, and Steve Witkoff as Middle East Envoy) were scheduled to meet with Russian officials in Saudi Arabia to discuss the war in Ukraine, with the possibility that Ukraine would not be included in those talks.
“in fact we're actually continuing to see signs that Ukraine's involvement is in question just this weekend we learned that uh three top us officials Marco Rubio the Secretary of State Mike Waltz The National Security advisor Steve witkoff the Middle East Envoy are all going to be in Saudi Arabia to meet with Russian officials about the war in Ukraine and for all we know Ukraine won't be there”
Reporting from Ukraine shows there is deep skepticism among average Ukrainians that Putin can be seen as a good-faith negotiator.
“we know from our colleagues in Ukraine that there's extremely deep skepticism across Ukraine that Putin can be seen as a goodfaith negotiator”
Russia's stock market rose more than 5% and the ruble strengthened in response to Trump's engagement with Putin, with Russian politicians celebrating Trump's approach as demonstrating Putin's status as a brilliant strategist.
“in Moscow there was was quite a bit of elation in response the Russian stock market was up more than 5% the ruble the Russian currency strengthened you had all these protin politicians posting on social media about how like this was such a big win for Russia and it showed Putin's status as a brilliant foreign policy strategist”
Keith Kellogg, Trump's Envoy to Ukraine, stated that the Trump Administration expects only Russia and Ukraine to be at the negotiation table with the U.S. as mediator, but not European countries, despite Europe contributing over $100 billion in aid to Ukraine.
“we also learned during the Munich security conference last weekend that the Trump Administration does not expect Europe to be at the table when peace talks around Ukraine finally take place we heard from Keith Kellog Trump's Envoy to Ukraine say that the Trump Administration expects Russia and Ukraine to be at the table they expect the United States to act as a mediator but that the Europeans probably won't be there”
Three top U.S. officials—Marco Rubio (Secretary of State), Mike Waltz (National Security Advisor), and Steve Witcoff (Middle East Envoy)—are scheduled to meet with Russian officials in Saudi Arabia to discuss the war in Ukraine, with uncertainty about whether Ukraine will participate.
“just this weekend we learned that uh three top us officials Marco Rubio the Secretary of State Mike Waltz The National Security advisor Steve witkoff the Middle East Envoy are all going to be in Saudi Arabia to meet with Russian officials about the war in Ukraine and for all we know Ukraine won't be there”
Reporting from Ukraine shows extremely deep skepticism that Putin can be a good-faith negotiator, and there is intense war fatigue with tens of thousands of deaths, but recent polling also shows increasing Ukrainian willingness to make compromise with Russia.
“we know from our colleagues in Ukraine that there's extremely deep skepticism across Ukraine that Putin can be seen as a goodfaith negotiator at the same time you know if you look at our colleagues reporting from Ukraine you see there's intense fatigue with the war there the war has lasted almost 3 years now which would have been just so unimaginable if we think back to the beginning of 2022 obviously tens of thousands of ukrainians both soldiers and civilians have died and so what you've also been seeing over the last year or so in Ukraine is a higher Readiness according to the polls to make some kind of compromise with Russia”
The Trump Administration began blowing up America's existing approach to ending the war between Russia and Ukraine by embracing Russia and snubbing Ukraine, shifting away from Biden's policy of isolating Putin both diplomatically and economically.
“the Trump Administration began blowing up America's existing approach to ending the war between Russia and Ukraine by embracing Russia and snubbing Ukraine”
Biden's strategy toward Russia was to isolate Putin both diplomatically and economically through sanctions and to maintain a unified Western front, explicitly avoiding any bilateral engagement with Putin while coordinating carefully with European allies.
“Because Biden's strategy was to isolate Putin both diplomatically and economically to put pressure on him yeah exactly it was about sanctions it was about don't talk to Putin show Russia that the fact that it launched Europe's biggest war of aggression since World War II was absolutely unacceptable and made Moscow a capital that was just not to be dealt with diplomatically and in addition it was all about showing a United Western Front the US under President Biden was very very careful to coordinate all of its steps with the Europeans just to show Putin that he wasn't going to be able to divide and conquer when dealing with the west”
The German Alternative for Germany party has been ostracized across the German political spectrum for its links to Neo-Nazi ideology and attempts to whitewash the Nazi past.
“the German farri party the alternative for Germany has been very much ostracized across the political Spectrum in Germany for its links to Neo-Nazi ideology and its attempts to whitewash the Nazi past”
The United States is Ukraine's biggest ally, and Zelinski has stated that if the U.S. withdrew its aid, Ukraine would find it very difficult to survive as an independent country.
“it it is true Rachel that the US is Ukraine's biggest Ally and zalinsky himself has said that if the US were to pull its Aid it would be very difficult for Ukraine to survive as an independent country”
Putin has made clear that he wants to talk to the United States rather than Ukraine directly, because he sees Zelinski's government as a puppet of Washington, creating space for U.S.-Russia conversations to happen without Ukraine's participation.
“on the flip side Putin has also made it very clear that he wants to be talking to the US you know he sees zelinsky's government as a puppet of Washington so there is clearly space here for conversations between the US and Russia to happen it would just be pretty shocking for those conversations to happen without Ukraine being a part of them”
The Trump administration expects Russia and Ukraine to be at the negotiating table with the United States acting as a mediator, but does not expect Europe to be there.
“the Trump Administration expects Russia and Ukraine to be at the table they expect the United States to act as a mediator but that the Europeans probably won't be there”
In his social media post about the Putin call, Trump claimed that he and Putin 'reflected on the great history of our Nations and the fact that we fought so successfully together in World War II' and that Putin agreed to stop the war in Ukraine using Trump's campaign motto of 'Common Sense.'
“Trump wrote that in this call he and Putin both reflected on the great history of our Nations and the fact that we fought so successfully together in World War II and then Trump added that he and Putin had both agreed that they want to stop the war in Ukraine and that President Putin even used Trump's quote very strong campaign motto of Common Sense”
The cost to Russia of the Ukraine war has been extraordinary: approximately 100,000 or more Russians have died, about one million have fled the country, and the economy has been stretched to the breaking point, alongside the moral cost of having initiated Europe's biggest war of aggression since World War II.
“the cost of all this to Russia has been just extraordinary maybe a 100,000 or more Russians have died something like a million have fled the country the economy has been stretched to its Breaking Point obviously just the moral cost of having started Europe's biggest war of aggression since World War II is hard to Fathom”
The Munich Security Conference, a major annual gathering of security officials, was scheduled to occur on Friday with expectations that Vice President JD Vance would clarify the Trump administration's position on Ukraine, NATO, and Europe.
“and all of this was happening just before the Munich security conference this big annual Gathering of security officials started on Friday in Germany and JD Vance the vice president was scheduled to give a big speech so there was a lot of Hope or at least expectation among Europeans that Vance when he stepped up to that Podium was going to clarify where exactly the administration stood on these issues”
Vance's criticism of European restrictions on speech echoes rhetoric that Vladimir Putin has been using for years, where Putin criticizes Europe for becoming 'too woke' and for silencing speech, creating alignment between Trump administration rhetoric and Russian talking points.
“it's actually a picture of Europe that very much Echoes what we've been hearing from Vladimir Putin over the last few years you know he's long been criticizing Europe for becoming to woke for silencing speech and I really do believe that allowing our citizens to speak their mind will make them stronger still”
If Putin is able to settle the war through peace talks more or less on his terms, he will present it as a big victory, and an even bigger victory would be if he gets the U.S. to walk away from Europe.
“but if Putin through these peace talks is able to settle the war more or less on his terms that'll be something he presents as a big victory and an even bigger Victory will be if at the end of all this he gets the US to walk away from Europe”
It would be striking for Europe to be excluded from peace talks about Ukraine given their contributions of over $100 billion to the war effort.
“it would be pretty striking for Europe to be excluded like this you know they uh European countries have contributed more than hundred billion doar by some counts more than the US has in total to Ukraine over the last three years so they clearly have a huge stake in this too”
The Trump administration's approach has been to embrace Russia while sidelining Europe, fundamentally shaking the foundations of the transatlantic alliance that has been a given in global politics for most people's lifetimes.
“we've basically seen seen the United States Embrace Russia over its longstanding allies yeah I mean it's it's still early but you're right it really feels like a moment where that world order that we were all used to has has started to crumble right most people listening to this show have grown up in a world where it's a given that the United States is aligned with Europe”
Pete Hegseth tried to walk back parts of his speech the day after his Brussels speech, and Trump said Ukraine would be involved in talks, indicating confusion about the administration's actual approach.
“You had all these protin politicians posting on social media about how like this was such a big win for Russia and it showed Putin's status as a brilliant foreign policy strategist in Europe there was both shock and confusion you know Pete Heth tried to walk back parts of his speech the next day Trump said that Ukraine would be involved in the talks so on top of just the shock you also just had people not really understanding what exactly the approach of the administration was going to be”
Vance characterized Europe as having retreated from Democratic values by restricting free speech, specifically mentioning Europe's intention to shut down social media during times of civil unrest and removing content deemed hateful, framing this as a departure from shared American and European values.
“a Europe that in his telling has departed from its Democratic roots that they intend to shut down social media during times of civil unrest the moment they spot what they've just judg to be quote hateful content it's actually a picture of Europe that very much Echoes what we've been hearing from Vladimir Putin over the last few years you know he's long been criticizing Europe for becoming to woke for silencing speech”
Vance, speaking to German political leaders and media at Munich, stated that if Germany was running in fear of its own voters (implicitly referring to voters supporting the far-right AfD), 'there is nothing America can do for you,' signaling that U.S. support for European allies is conditional on accepting populist parties.
“if you're running in fear of your own voters there is nothing America can do for you nor for that matter is there basically the vice president of the United States is saying to his European allies long-standing European allies that Russia isn't the problem here you are”
Vance stated that 'allowing our citizens to speak their mind will make them stronger still,' implying criticism of European speech restrictions and alignment with the right to political speech even when controversial.
“I really do believe that allowing our citizens to speak their mind will make them stronger still”
While there were significant bumps along the way in U.S.-Europe relations, it is difficult to remember a week like the one just described where Trump, Hegseth, and Vance simultaneously shook the foundations of the transatlantic alliance so intensely.
“you know there were clearly pretty major bumps along the way that we can remember but I struggle to remember a week like the one that we just saw where JD Vance Pete Heth and Donald Trump himself just shook the foundations of that transatlantic Alliance so intensely”
There has been a week where Trump, Pete Hegseth, and JD Vance 'shook the foundations of that transatlantic Alliance so intensely' in a way that is hard to remember precedent for.
“I struggle to remember a week like the one that we just saw where JD Vance Pete Heth and Donald Trump himself just shook the foundations of that transatlantic Alliance so intensely”
The past week has felt like a moment when 'the world order that we were all used to has started to crumble,' with the U.S. embracing Russia over its longstanding European allies.
“I mean it's it's still early but you're right it really feels like a moment where that world order that we were all used to has has started to crumble right most people listening to this show have grown up in a world where it's a given that the United States is aligned with Europe”
The Moscow bureau chief is uncertain whether Ukraine will participate in planned talks between U.S. and Russian officials in Saudi Arabia, indicating ongoing exclusion or ambiguity about Ukraine's involvement.
“for all we know Ukraine won't be there”